Cancel
Open app
Search
Sign Up
Log In
Nearby
Bookmarks
Start a Project
Add a Business on Yelp
It's easier on the Yelp app
Continue
Stay on browser
Add Review
Call
Directions
Website
McAlister's Deli
J R. said: Wow! This place is a hidden gem!! Ate there for the first time last week… read more
Applebee's Grill + Bar
$$
Lisa N. said: I can't say anything about their food, but the rating is mainly for… read more
Dairy Queen Grill & Chill
Alonso B. said: This wasn't the most SANITARY Dairy Queen I've been to, but the food… read more
More like Casey's
Pizza Delivery
Breakfast & Brunch
Breakfast
Donuts
Start your review...
Get app
3 years ago
I love my Casey's pizza! They are the best cheesy pizza in town. I love the crust thickness, between a pan and a thin.
5 years ago
Awesome selection of deli and the pizza is delicious and fresh! I also started using their app. read more
525 E Morton Ave
Jacksonville, IL 62650
(217) 559-2709
Call Now
Visit Website
https://www.caseys.com
Full menu
Hours
What time does Casey's open?
Casey's is open 24 hours on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.
What time does Casey's close?
Mon-Sun Open 24 hours
Does Casey's take credit cards?
Yes, Casey's takes credit cards.
Does Casey's serve alcohol?
Yes, Casey's serves alcohol.
Does Casey's have parking?
Yes, Casey's has parking options.
Does Casey's have free WiFi?
Yes, Casey's has free WiFi.
Blue Margarita's Mexican Bar & Grill
James H. said: I see several bad reviews and I guess maybe they had an off night or… read more
Pizza Hut
Aaron And Hattie L. said: The place is consistently great, when you go to pick up… read more
Taco Bell
$
Makayla M. said: My order was wrong and I didn't notice it until I got home so I… read more
Get access to customer & competitor insights.
My go-to is the mushroom Swiss burger with chips, but honestly, you can't go wrong with anything on…read morethe menu. The sauce game is seriously on point, and the pizza is ridiculously good. Everything is packed with flavor and clearly made with care. One of those spots where picking just one favorite is nearly impossible! Staff our welcoming. Indoors or outdoors? Does not matter it's comfy.
Good food and atmosphere. A lot of choices on the menu…read more The help is good and very friendly.
Omelette & Hashbrowns
See all
I'm trying out the calzone as a friend of mine says it's his favorite. My wife is trying the…read moreBosco stixs as couldn't decide what to have. It's Friday night. The place is getting packed up easily at 5:25p
We ordered a pizza tonight. When we picked it up, the cashier noticed the cook didn't prepare it…read morethe way we had requested. It was suppose to have 3 toppings - not 2. She reduced the price to a 2 topping and then proceeded to tell me we could have gotten a large for less money. I feel that we should have received a discount for the error made by them especially when she told me we could get a large for $6 less. We are faithful customers so I hope the next time we receive better service.
Filie in the kitchen!
Front side menu
Excellent service. Great pizza at a great price. I like my pizza thin and crispy and was not…read moredisappointed
We love Barney's. Their pizza, Philly, tenderloin, specials, etc are awesome. Your bartenders and…read moreservers are awesome, they get to know you.
Sweep the kitchen Really good pizza.
January 2018
While the inside is very charming, the wait time and staff are not…read more My wife, my son, and I ordered a pizza that took nearly an hour to get to our table. No communication from the wait staff about the wait, no apologies; nothing. We had to go up twice to the counter to check on our order. They acted nonplussed, as if this was how things are supposed to be run and that we were the crazy ones. No one came to check on us after we got our drinks. Clearly, they were disorganized. When we finally got our pizza, and cut it ourselves, the pizza flopped down, causing all the toppings to slide off. That's not how a pizza is supposed to act if it's fully cooked. Save yourself some time and just go to La Piazza in Springfield instead.
The little stove is an unbelievable little gem in town that really doesn't offer much in terms of…read morefood but it is hands down one of the best wood fire oven establishments you will visit. The chef clearly knows what he's doing, eveything is fresh, the foccacia is to die for and the staff and ownership are always friendly. The hours can stink if you are driving from Springfield but it's worth it.
Dish of the day, fresh pasta with bolognese sauce
Old fashioned
There Crazy Puffs are delicious. Every time I've been there staff are very friendly and food is…read morealways hot & fresh. Highly recommend!!
Papa Murphy's is pretty consistent pizza. I like being able to bake my own occasional. I ordered…read moreonline. Very easy. It was ready in under 30 minutes. The young lady working was super nice. It was clean. Can't get much better than that.
Every pizza we have gotten from Papa Murphy's has been delicious. We usually get a family size…read morepizza, and we always redeem the $3-off coupon that we get for filling out the online survey for the previous visit. With the coupon, our order of 1 family-size pizza and 1 cheesy bread is only about $13. That's almost 2 meals for our family. The pizza we like currently is the Mediterranean DeLite, which has chicken, feta cheese, spinach and sun-dried tomatoes. It doesn't even taste like traditional pizza -- no tomato sauce, and the feta has more flavor than mozzarella -- but it is really good.
Clean and bright
Just as good as Papa Murphy's-saving on electricity
The first order was wayyyyy too saucy and burned took it back and waited and now it's just burned…read more Two tries and still didn't get it right. emailed corporate. I won't be back.
The amount of sauce they put on their food makes you think they're rationing during wartime.read more
Does this look like a pizza you would serve? It wasn't busy I was the only one picking up. I'm beyond mad
Two medium pizzas
Mess
My family and I are traveling through Jacksonville for an event. We wanted BBQ, that is not what we…read morereceived. I was unable to eat any of the brisket because it was entirely fat, and when I brought it up to the waitress she said that "brisket is a fatty piece of meat, what do you want me to do about it?" She did take a couple of dollars off of the bill, but it wasn't enough to make up for the poor food quality that we were served.
We were there for a ballgame so stopped by for dinner. It was delicious. My teenagers each had a…read morelarge sandwich and I ordered 1lb pork that was wonderful. The price wasn't too high either. I wish we lived closer because we would certainly go again!
Brisket- delicious.
it's just every location gets worse and the person who answered the phone says they'll give me a…read morecredit? How is that gonna fix the fact that the person that ordered it now has 12 French fries as a meal Good job I'll take my money elsewhere moving forward as I don't think a simple lunch that costs 40 dollars should be messed up at all get it together it's just a disappointment
The place is consistently great, when you go to pick up your pizza, you can see back into the…read morekitchen and it's always clean and well-maintained. The food is always hot and delicious.
Tried to order online, didn't work, called to order and got directed to a call center in India and…read morecouldnt understand what they were saying to get the order placed. Will never order from here in the future. Get ur phones connect directly to the store for crying out loud!
Ordered the special because everything is always so overpriced. Used to be really good but today…read morethe dough was bland and didn't have the pillow fluff it usually has. I won't be back. It was not good. :(
BEST of Jacksonville, Illinois Restaurants near Casey's
BEST of Jacksonville, Illinois Dinner near Casey's
BEST of Jacksonville, Illinois Desserts near Casey's
BEST of Jacksonville, Illinois Shopping near Casey's
BEST of Jacksonville, Illinois Things to Do near Casey's
BEST of Jacksonville, Illinois Coffee near Casey's
BEST of Jacksonville, Illinois Parking near Casey's
BEST of Jacksonville, Illinois Breakfast near Casey's
BEST of Jacksonville, Illinois Burgers near Casey's
BEST of Jacksonville, Illinois Movie Theatre near Casey's
Restaurants in Jacksonville, IL
Donuts in Jacksonville, IL
Breakfast & Brunch in Jacksonville, IL
New Restaurants in Jacksonville, IL
Ice Cream in Jacksonville, IL
Breakfast in Jacksonville, IL
Burgers in Jacksonville, IL
Barbeque in Jacksonville, IL
Restaurants Open Now in Jacksonville, IL
24 Hour Restaurant in Jacksonville, IL
Lunch in Jacksonville, IL
Pizza Delivery in Jacksonville, IL
Late Night Food in Jacksonville, IL
Sandwiches in Jacksonville, IL
Pork Tenderloin Sandwich in Jacksonville, IL
Dinner in Jacksonville, IL
Delivery in Jacksonville, IL
Deep Dish Pizza in Jacksonville, IL
Salad in Jacksonville, IL
Takeout in Jacksonville, IL
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt in Jacksonville, IL
Tacos in Jacksonville, IL
BBQ Chicken Pizza in Jacksonville, IL
Curbside Pick Up in Jacksonville, IL
Best Bagels Available in Jacksonville, Illinois
Best Bar and Grill Experiences in Jacksonville, Illinois
Best Places for Brunch in Jacksonville, Illinois
Best Smoothie Spots and Cafes in Jacksonville, Illinois
Best Soul Food Dishes in Jacksonville, Illinois
Best Vegan Restaurants to Try in Jacksonville, Illinois
Best Wood Fired Pizza Available in Jacksonville, Illinois
Breakfast and Brunch Restaurants in Jacksonville, Illinois
Dance Clubs
Delicious Soup Spots to Try in Jacksonville, Illinois
Discover Authentic Indian Food in Jacksonville, Illinois
Discover Authentic Italian in Jacksonville, Illinois
Discover Coffee & Tea Options in Jacksonville, Illinois
Discover Popular Sunday Brunch Places in Jacksonville, Illinois
Discover Top Asian Food Options in Jacksonville, Illinois
Discover the Best Boba Drinks in Jacksonville, Illinois
Discover the Best Breweries in Jacksonville, Illinois Today
Discover the Best Romantic Restaurant Options in Jacksonville, Illinois
Discover the Best Sushi Spots in Jacksonville, Illinois
Enjoy Delicious Food Trucks All Over Jacksonville, Illinois
Enjoy Delicious Hot Dogs in Jacksonville, Illinois
Enjoy Fast Food Favorites Across Jacksonville, Illinois
Explore BBQ Restaurants Near Jacksonville, Illinois
Explore Popular Cocktail Bars in Jacksonville, Illinois
Explore Popular Wine Bars Throughout Jacksonville, Illinois
Explore Top Buffet Options in Jacksonville, Illinois
Find Popular Pubs to Visit in Jacksonville, Illinois
Find the Best Cheap Eats Options in Jacksonville, Illinois
Find the Best Cupcakes Near Jacksonville, Illinois
Great Diners to Visit in Jacksonville, Illinois
Have Fun Bowling in Jacksonville, Illinois
Highly Rated Japanese Restaurant Locations in Jacksonville, Illinois
Highly Rated Steakhouses Around Jacksonville, Illinois
Order the Best Chicken Wings in Jacksonville, Illinois Today
Popular Drive Thru Locations to Try in Jacksonville, Illinois
Refreshing Shaved Ice Treats in Jacksonville, Illinois
Taste Authentic Mexican Food in Jacksonville, Illinois
Top Gluten Free Pizza Spots in Jacksonville, Illinois
Top Gluten Free Restaurants in Jacksonville, Illinois
Top Karaoke Spots to Visit in Jacksonville, Illinois
Top Outdoor Dining Spots to Try in Jacksonville, Illinois
Top Rated Seafood Dishes in Jacksonville, Illinois
Try Pizza by the Slice Near Jacksonville, Illinois
Dive Bars near Casey's
Korean Restaurant near Casey's
Steak near Casey's
Vietnamese near Casey's
Things to do in Jacksonville
Casey's General Store
Articles by date
Service was top notch ! Packed for the Wednesday night buffet . Will probably order a pizza or two…read moreon our next visit . One of the top pizza places I've found visiting Illinois.
Used to love this place growing up. But recently had a small pizza with pepperoni, mushroom, and…read moregreen peppers. Not impressed. Everything tasted like it came from a can and the sauce was way too sweet.
Ordered once right at the time of COVID-19 or early 2020, hungry for something new and delivery…read moreservice but cold sauce hardly no cheese even when I order extra cheese on a thin burnt cracker will never be considered as pizza to me
Great food convenient right of the interstate ! Stopped here while traveling for some quick food …read more Food was great , fast and good price . $8 gets you a personal pizza and regular drink!
Best pizza place we have found in Springfield IL. We love a thin crust and a non tomato based pizza…read moresauce so we were in heaven. The service is always good and the vibe is pleasant and comfortable. The prices are quite good especially if you take advantage of the coupons that they mail to nearby areas. we get either the individuals pizzas or the 14" thin crust. We have returned several times and it is now our favorite pizza by far.
Food Service…read more Ambiance This place was recommended by the UPS staff across the street, so I gave it a try. If you're a fan of thin crust, then you will love this pizza!!!! It's a nice, medium size restaurant, with a pizza that has a XL flavor! My only problem was the time it took for the pizza. The restaurant wasn't that busy, so I was surprised it took almost 25 min for a small pizza. But it was delicious.
Had been wanting to try the pizza after hearing great reviews. We have since been there three times…read moreand picked up pizzas. I know we'd like to try dining in, but the pick up option has been awesome. You do have to call and order, as they don't have online capabilities, and sometimes it can take a few tries to get a call through. It's worth it! We love the pizza, it's the perfect crust and toppings are delicious!
My pizza order was totally wrong and the pizza was burned on the crust making it inedible. So…read moredisappointed. I told the server twice what I wanted and they still got it wrong. No excuse, only a half dozen people in the whole place so it wasn't really busy.
OK...we tried it again. We eat out often and wanted to give the place a chance. After all,…read moremistakes happen. We didn't have the 2 hour wait (it was hot when we picked up). However, there was excessive sauce and the toppings were wrong (sausage but no pepperoni)! We are trying the new Pizza Hut tonight! Check out that review soon...
I can't describe this restaurant. I feel like sometimes it's great and sometimes it's not. What I…read moremean is that only three out of ten times in the past two months it was FANTASTIC. The other seven times there was a TON of sauce or a lack of it. But on special occasions do I order a cinnamon wheel which can be a bit crummy, but it's still GREAT! Their service isn't the best, but it's okay....
Now this is one real sandwich place. This pastrami was great. Fresh bread! And unlike the chain…read moresub shops, who will remain nameless, there's way more meat and fixings than bread. And believe it or not the staff here actually look you in the eye and smile. Great job to whoever runs this establishment.
I absolutely love a good sandwich and Head West offers some of the best. I love their menu, period,…read morethe sandwiches, the soups and the chips...every time, hands down without a doubt, I've never had a bad experience and some of the soups they will serve as a blend 1/2 and 1/2. I didn't think it would work so I secretly took home two different soups and mixed them...I was humming and singing. That soup was delicious. So be on the look out for their recommended soup blends. You'll be pleasantly surprised.
Expect straight trash. For a $15 meal you'll get a half ass ham sandwich and 6 curly fries. Don't…read morego here . Ever.
Oh my goodness, this place is so FAST!!! They have some of the sweetest employees. There is this…read morelittle blonde boy there and every time I see him he is so nice!!! 10/10 Recommend this for a quick, yummy meal!!
My order was wrong and I didn't notice it until I got home so I called and I spoke to a manager…read morenamed Hunter. He was polite, efficient and remade my food and it was delicious so thank you Hunter. I appreciate you and your kindness.
Great affordable food , spotlessly clean always and nice workers especially a wonderful hard worker…read morenamed" PAT", she is the best ! Thank you Pat for going out of your way to make sure everyone is taken care of . The manager Julie does a great job too ! The food is always good and hot and very affordable. You can get your moneys worth here. Thank you guys for great food and great service ,we appreciate you all !