Cancel
Open app
Search
Sign Up
Log In
Nearby
Bookmarks
Start a Project
Add a Business on Yelp
It's easier on the Yelp app
Continue
Stay on browser
Add Review
Call
Directions
Website
Culver's
$
Bianca G. said: I went in yesterday and they seemed to be very understaffed. The girl… read more
DQ Grill & Chill Restaurant
Maria A. said: We ordered online and got a double cheese burger meal with onion rings… read more
Taco Bell
April A. said: They've gotten better!!!! I stopped going here months ago bc service… read more
Start your review...
Get app
14 days ago
My Taco Pizza on original crust was awesome! The people who work there are the nicest people! I find their pizza to be better than all other pizza in town. It's amazing to get such well prepared, delicious pizza at a gas station! read more
342 Whitewater Ave
Fort Atkinson, WI 53538
(920) 568-9025
Call Now
Visit Website
https://www.caseys.com
Full menu
Hours
What time does Casey's open?
Casey's opens at 5:00 AM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.
What time does Casey's close?
Casey's closes at 10:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday and Sunday.
Mon-Sun 5:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Does Casey's take credit cards?
Yes, Casey's takes credit cards.
Does Casey's have catering options?
No, Casey's does not have catering options.
Does Casey's serve alcohol?
Yes, Casey's serves alcohol.
Does Casey's have outdoor seating?
No, Casey's does not have outdoor seating options.
Does Casey's have parking?
Yes, Casey's has parking options.
Does Casey's have free WiFi?
Yes, Casey's has free WiFi.
Water Street Brewery Lake Country
$$
Brewing award-winning beer since 1987, Water Street Brewery serves Wisconsin fish… read more
People searched for Pizza 377 times last month within 15 miles of this business.
It doesn't look like much from the outside, but inside was nicely decorated with Italian pizza…read moredecor with Italian crooner music for ambience. Friendly server took our orders and the drinks and food came out timely. Our loaded nachos were good, though the nacho cheese was a bit runny and pooled in the bottom. My grandsons loved their pepperoni calzone and Mac and cheese. My personal pan Meathead pizza was very good; tasty with a nice crisp crust. My wife enjoyed her chicken Tuscany pizza. Both personal pizzas were bigger than expected and very filling. Would definitely stop in again if in the area.
Had lunch today i had supreme personal pizza and wife had cream of mushroom soup. Both were very…read moregood and reasonably priced. Waitress did a nice job for our table of 6.
Loaded nachos
See all
Awesome pizza. Best pepperoni I have ever had…read more Has some quirky hours around the holidays, but that is to give employees time off to spend time with family. Very understandable. By far my favorite pizza in Jefferson county.
Pizza tastes like it did 30 years ago, amazing flavors and quality. And the owner Kim, is fantastic…read moretoo. Love this gem
Sausage and pepperoni pizza and cheese squares (cheese garlic bread)
Pepperoni and sausage pizza
The best place to eat in fort Atkinson ! Always a pleasure to pull up and eat some real comfort…read morefood in a town with not much to do this food is true!
Just ordered a stuffed pizza last night. Sausage and mushrooms. Very disappointed. Hardly any…read moretomato sauce. Pizza was dry, and lacking salt. Not very flavorful. Sausage bland and canned mushrooms didn't add much flavor. I would not recommend this over standard thin crust pizza. Won't order it again
The spot!
Cheese pizza
Sausage, pepperoni & mushroom pizza
The worst prime rib I have ever had no flavor and the onions and mushrooms tasted like dog food…read more How can these people serve humans this crap!!
Was tooling around on the Harley, and came across this place on a Sunday. Well, what a pleasant…read moresurprise! Wife and I both ordered a Bloody Mary. They had Shiner Bock on tap (that was my chaser) and the Bloody's were delish! Pickle, mushrooms, beef stick and all the rest hit the spot. Looked at the menu and decided on a mushroom swiss burger. We didn't order a split, but the server was nice enough to bring us both a plate, and it was all divided up already! The burger was hot and fresh and the swiss cheese pull was on point. Fries were sour cream and onion wedges, split on our two plates as well. It's a neat little place with good/friendly service. Check it out on a road trip! Bonus- There are some nice deer heads in this place as well. As a hunter and WIsconsinite, I appreciate that. :)
OUTSIDE SEATING
Good thin crust pizza with excellent sausage but a little short on the sauce. Cheese is excellent…read morebut hey Gus' is in Wisconsin! Potato slabs are very good. Staffing is a problem if you want to eat in as a waitress is harder to find than a Minnesota Vikings Super bowl trophy.
Toppings on the pizza were very scarce. Not worth 2.60$ each topping. The wine was of very low…read morequality. Greek salad was a joke, come on!! Probably would not return. Sorry.
Pizza is still the best! I waitressed there when Gus owned it. That was 1967. We went this weekend to celebrate our 55th anniversary.
Delivered Pizzas
Ordered our first Pizza last night. My Wife & I both agreed. Last nights Pizza was the Best we…read morehave had in Whitewater . And we have tried them all ! Highly recommend!
This was an absolute treat! The pizza was wonderful, probably the best I have ever had. Looking…read moreforward to going back many times and cost was very reasonable. All the ingredients were fresh and no other pizza place in town can compete with these lovely pies!
Fantastic! This Dominos ALWAYS has my food on time for carry out! The staff are friendly and good…read moreat what they do! I've never had any trouble or bad experiences here! If you've ever had a bad experience here it's probably because you're a Karen who doesn't know how to read or do basic math.
I give them 2 stars because their managers are rude!!!! I have been promised refunds but they have…read morenever came through with these promises!! I had a pizza ce in with it have turned over. The manager respond "oh" then silence,,, I thought she hung up on me ,, when I called back that is when the rudeness began. Not ordering there for some time.
Pizza was made perfect to order. Crispy, saucy, and delicious. Counter service was super polite and…read morefast. We ordered carry out and decided to dine in. Service was very accommodating of the last minute change. The dining room was clean and the lunch buffet was well-stocked. The only criticism is that the plates were dirty. But otherwise, we had a really good experience.
I ordered a pizza for delivery online. I waited three hours and the pizza never came. I went to the…read morestore to see what was wrong and the owner said "We're not doing delivery because we don't have any drivers." I told him that wasn't my fault and he said it wasn't his either. When I asked for a refund he got very upset and said it would come out of his own pocket. I told him I needed a refund because he refused to deliver what I ordered and then he screamed and took my pizza from the warmer and threw it at the wall. The owner is a sociopath, do not come here. I feel threatened that this lunatic has my address. I'm scared.
The delivery driver and customer service was amazing oh my god I love violet!!!!! I live it…read moreMukwonago I will drive 27 extra minutes to her to avoid the terrible service of a garbage toppers by me they turned the delivery driver around to bring me the first thing forgotten sauce who was also an absolute legend I love you guys I hope yall have an incredible night
Not the best pizza but topper sticks are pretty nice and u get 3 dip sauce Chipotle ranch is my favread more
My order.... Maui Topper Pizza & Loaded Tots Mac N Cheese!!
The spot
New Owners & this place is now amazing !!! Love their food specials & awesome events!read more
One of the best places on the lake for sure hands-down for Pizza. If you're lucky enough to get…read morehere in the winter time, they have a salad bar that is also pretty incredible. The ambience is definitely one of the best on the lake with great views and the Sandy Beach.
BEST of Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin Desserts near Casey's
BEST of Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin Restaurants near Casey's
BEST of Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin Coffee near Casey's
BEST of Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin Things to Do near Casey's
BEST of Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin Parking near Casey's
BEST of Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin Thrift Stores near Casey's
BEST of Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin Breakfast near Casey's
BEST of Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin Dinner near Casey's
BEST of Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin Burgers near Casey's
BEST of Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin Shopping near Casey's
Best Bar and Grill Experiences in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Best Fish Tacos Served in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Best Places for Brunch in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Best Places for Poke in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Best Smoothie Spots and Cafes in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Best Soul Food Dishes in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Best Vegan Restaurants to Try in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Best Wood Fired Pizza Available in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Delicious Ice Cream Treats in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Delicious Soup Spots to Try in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Delicious Vegan Breakfast Served in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Discover Authentic Indian Food in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Discover Authentic Italian in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Discover Popular Sunday Brunch Places in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Discover Top Asian Food Options in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Discover the Best Boba Drinks in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Discover the Best Breweries in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin Today
Discover the Best Romantic Restaurant Options in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Discover the Best Sushi Spots in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Enjoy Casual Dining Options in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Enjoy Classic Hamburger Options in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Enjoy Delicious Hot Dogs in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Enjoy Fast Food Favorites Across Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Enjoy the Best Cocktails in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Explore BBQ Restaurants Near Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Explore Delicious Sandwiches in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Explore Delicious Vegetarian Food in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Explore Popular Cocktail Bars in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Explore Popular Foodie Restaurants in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Fast and Reliable Pizza Delivery in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Find Family Friendly Restaurants in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin for All Ages
Fresh Oysters Served in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Great Diners to Visit in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Have Fun Bowling in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Highly Rated Japanese Restaurant Locations in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Highly Rated Steakhouses Around Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Order Fresh and Tasty Salad Options in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Order the Best Chicken Wings in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin Today
Order the Best Deep Dish Pizza in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Savor the Best Burrito Flavors in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Taste Delicious Korean Food Options in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Taste the Best American Food in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Taste the Finest Gelato Available in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Top Breakfast Sandwich Places in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Top Gluten Free Pizza Spots in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Top Gluten Free Restaurants in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Top Outdoor Dining Spots to Try in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Top Rated Seafood Dishes in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Top-Rated Spaghetti Dishes to Try in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Try Pizza by the Slice Near Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
Apple Cider Donuts near Casey's
Calzone near Casey's
Chicken Pot Pie near Casey's
Chinese Buffet near Casey's
French Onion Soup near Casey's
German Restaurants near Casey's
Halloween Bar near Casey's
Korean Restaurant near Casey's
Lasagna near Casey's
Late Night Coffee Shops near Casey's
Pie Bakery near Casey's
Restaurants That Deliver near Casey's
Restaurants With Private Party Rooms near Casey's
Sports Bar With Tv near Casey's
Study Spots near Casey's
Subs near Casey's
Thanksgiving Buffet near Casey's
Turkey Dinner near Casey's
Things to do in Fort Atkinson
Casey's General Store
Articles by date
Nice location, shopping is close by. Pretty clean, I didn't check out the restrooms. We like to get…read morethe family pizza since there is 6 of us. We always have quite a bit left over. My favorite thing to get is the cookie dough haha!
I live in Delavan, but because I was in Janesville on errands, I stopped at this Papa Murphy's…read moreinstead. NO COMPARISON!! For my husband and I, Friday is pizza night, so we've ordered almost every Friday night for two years from the Delavan location. This time I ordered the exact same pizza from Janesville and it was crazy skimpy on the cheese. Our Delavan location measures everything that goes on it, cheese, sauce, & various ingredients. In Janesville, the girl was just picking up a handfull, no measuring, and then trying to spread it around to make it look like more. They must skimping on ingredients to make a bigger profit, but they aren't doing their franchise any favors. I won't go back there. DON'T WASTE YOUR MONEY AT THIS LOCATION. I LOVE PAPA MURPHY'S PIZZA, BUT GO WHERE THEY'VE GOT QUALITY CONTROL.
Imagine a pizza place that is subway style. Go down the line, choose all your toppings and no extra…read moreprice for added extra- literally add all toppings and extra for the same price! The staff was also very friendly!
I've been to a few other MOD Pizzas, but this one was not my favorite…read more On the plus side, the staff were engaging and greeted me- then thanked me for coming, there were two types of lemonade at the soda station, plus Diet Coke, and the dining room was clean. But I didn't enjoy my pizza this time. The crust was flat and the toppings slid off, hasn't melted together into the crust. It tasted more like a frozen pizza, but I saw it being prepared. Not sure what happened? One bathroom was "out of order" and the one remaining bathroom needed to be cleaned. The utensils needed to be stocked, but I was able to get a knife and napkins. Staff super casually dressed, wearing crocs, maybe that's the vibe. But it felt too casual. $3.50 for the smallest fountain soda seems high to me. I got it, but that seems steep, was $2.99 plus tax, plus coins into the tip jar. So $4.00 for a 16-ounce fountain drink. My 6-inch pizza came to just over $10.00. Adequate experience, but I don't think I'll try this location again.
The young employees were both friendly and professional. The food was great! We were impressed by…read morethe special order gluten free veggie pizza.
Our first time ever eating at a Pizza Ranch anywhere happened today…read more WOW, were we impressed!!! This location was SUPER clean and all the food stations were kept being stocked up with all the foods!! The fried chicken was very juicy with NO pink on the inside and the outside coating was perfectly cooked...not too hard...not too soft...just right!! The stuffing on the hot station was fabulously moist and not dry. The gravy was delicious and we used it with the dressing and the mashed potatoes.. so YUMMMMY!!! The biscuits were fluffy, not dry and wonderfully hot to melt all the butter pats you can top them with like I did. The salad bar offerings were FRESH and replenished consistently. ALL of the Pizza choices were fresh and we were asked when we were paying as we started if there was a particular Pizza we were interested in trying and when I said "The Texan "taco pizza" the cashier said she would have one made right away and gave us a number to put on our table so they could bring us freshly made slices TO OUR TABLE BEFORE THE REST OF THE PIZZA WAS PUT ON THE BUFFET!!!!! The dessert pizzas included chocolate chip cookie pizza, a cinnamony/icing pizza and the Cherry/w icing dessert pizza I had was sweet decadence and the soft serve vanilla ICE CREAM not ice milk was the perfect end to our first time at a Pizza Ranch. Will be back...YESSSSSSS!! Aaaaaaaand the cashier gave us a punch card for every visit which ends up with you receiving a free buffet and she also gave us a coupon for our next visit of a good reduction of cost with a buy one get one. ALL of the employees were so courteous and kind!!!! Hard to impress us as I was a manager in food service in my younger years for a couple of decades and look at EVERYTHING with a "particular" eye including food "temperatures" and THIS Pizza Ranch gets a big BRAVO from my Husband and I!!!!!!
Best pizza hut ever. Best experience ever, excellent guest experience. Love this hutread more
this place is pretty much the only pizza place that I like in my town. they have other stuff like…read morewings and desert pizza that I love too. overall great place. great prices too.
Ordered take out at the location, was told it will be ready in 30 min. Went out to the store near…read moreby and came back. When I came back, my pizza should have been ready but wasn't so I sat back down to wait. After 15 min I asked about my order and was told I had to wait another 30 min. I asked why and I saw they were barely making my order. The pizza was ok but needed more cheese. For having to wait that long, I would assume they would give something for their mistake. I doubt I'll be returning
Tried to call in a order. After going through 2 different people, (1) you could barely understand…read more He said you have to order online to get the price on the coupon. It was in Valuepak in the mail. Dont send it out if you cant call the number listed. I do not have unlimited internet & went elsewhere. Higher English speaking people!
Best pizza and gyros in Watertown. Everything on the Phil's menu is delicious I bring my family…read moreto Phil's often.
I went to college in Watertown, and eating off campus was a treat. I tried Phil's after getting an…read moreEntertainment Book coupon for BOGO. I quickly used the rest of my coupons and any others I could find. I never had a bad meal at Phil's. Whether pizza, gyros, burgers, salads, or sandwiches...it was all delicious and served with care. Yes, the restaurant's small, but that just means the servers can pay better attention to the few tables there. I assume it gets packed on weekends, so check it out for a weeknight dinner. You won't be sorry.
I no longer go to Chipotle because they're awful. Qdoba is…read morejust okay. Burrachos is solid every time.
We had Burrachos catered for a 40th birthday party. The food arrived on time and they set…read moreeverything up for us. The tacos were a hit! The salsa tased fresh and the chicken had great seasoning.
I love that they use real strawberries in the strawberry shakes…read more I don't usually eat at Culver's because my tummy doesn't tolerate the sugar in the custard. But recently I ordered a cheeseburger (I don't usually eat burgers with buns, more tummy issues), they gave me a double. It was so good! Well worth the risk of digestive pain. The service is generally better than most other fast food joints. I don't know how they do their hiring and managing but McDonalds, Burger King, Firehouse subs, etc could definitely use a course in their methods.
Nice store off the freeway in the quaint town of Summit. Clean and friendly with good fresh food…read moreand service.
The best sandwich and best quality bread you could ask for. Highly recommend Milio's sandwiches.read more
We had just arrived in Stoughton, and checked into our hotel. We wanted to grab something to eat…read moreand saw Milio's across the street. The parking is very convenient as it is located in a small strip mall between the Walmart and Tru by Hilton. We went inside and checked out the menu board above the counter. There was no one at the counter and it was a few minutes before someone came from the back. They proceeded to take orders. We let someone else go in front of us as we checked out the menu. We each made our choices and proceeded to the counter. I decided to get the American Favorite, smoked ham, provolone cheese and lettuce without tomato and Hellman's Mayo on a wheat roll. We waited until our orders were called, we picked them up and decided to sit inside and eat there. I was very surprised to see when I opened my sandwich. It was obviously not a wheat roll and the ham and cheese did not appear anything like I saw in the menu image. I will let you be the judge. I chalked it up as another experience and ate the sandwich. The rest of the group was satisfied with their meals but not impressed. Fortunate for us we will not likely be in the area again anytime soon. We should have stopped somewhere else.