We have frequented this restaurant many times over the years. We have always enjoyed the food, the quick service and definitely the drinks :) We dined about a month ago and had multiple hiccups i.e. we waited 10+min to be welcomed and they came only after I asked the hostess as well as cold food. It was a busy night, so we chalked it up to it being an off-night. Not a problem. We decided to dine again tonight. Arrived before 5pm and sat outside. There were maybe 5 tables occupied at the time we arrived - inside and out. We waited 15+min to be welcomed. After I asked the hostess, it took an additional 5min for someone to come to the table. We were packing up our 4yr old to leave, but decided to stay once she arrived because he was starving. We ordered drinks (Margarita rocks and tequila rocks) as well as waters. After 10min, I went up to the bar with the intention of picking up our drinks, but the waitress was standing next to them. I gave her the benefit of the doubt and went back to my table. It still took 3-4min for drinks to be served. Food came 30 seconds after food arrived and my husbands meal was ice cold. We didn't see the waitress for at least 20min, asked for the bill, which arrived 10min later and bill was incorrect. It was quickly revised, so I will give her credit for that. Never did we receive an apology for any of the delays. The table next to us arrived 30min after us and had similar issues. I told them it would be quickest to go up to the bar and get their drinks themselves and they did. Entire visit/experience was beyond frustrating. Unfortunately, I believe tonight was our last time dining at Casa Tequila. read more

I love this place for Mexican! And they are open late, they serve food til 11pm during the week. I stopped in late on a Thursday and had a combo platter with Two Tacos and a Chimichango with rice. It included beans, but I just had the rice. The food was very food! Some of the best Mexica I have had. The drinks are great too! A "Medium" is like the biggest drink I have ever seen! I cant even imagine what large would be! Overall, this was a great mexican dining experience and I will def be back! read more

Casa Tequila - Mexican Near Me - Pewaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Good wasn't good and ordered a soda gave me the smallest portion with no gas. Food was cold when given yet they took long to take it out.

Excellent service and tasty foods. Nice menu, nice atmosphere. Daily special drinks and food menu. Our server Alex and busier Santiago made for a wonder dining experience. Definitely will be visiting here again. read more

Casa Tequila - Shrimp fajitas and two for one Margaritas, both delicious! You have to try it! - Mexican Near Me - Pewaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Very friendly service, very good. My husband had Chicken tacos Al Gusto. He said chicken was juicy and delicious. It was a Friday afternoon, and having eaten Mexican food earlier in the week, I decided to go non-traditional for a Mexican lunch, but traditional for Wisconsin, an all-you can eat Friday Fish Fry. Amazing! The fish was crispy, flaky and not super greasy. There was coke slaw and a choice of fries or potato pancakes. The potato pancakes were heart-shaped and crispy, but with creamy mashed potatoes inside. Our server was sweet and very cheerful! read more

My husband and I were looking to get some Mexican food for lunch on a lazy Sunday and we decided to try this place as we are sort of new to the area. It's a little difficult to find as it's tucked away in a shopping center but once you find it, it's a good spot for some less than basic Mexican food. We started off with the Cheese Dip (Queso Blanco) which was good. I asked for a side of hotter salsa to mix in and the waiter brought out some habanero and arbol salsas which gave us the kick we were looking for. I wish the chips tasted better. For my entree I had the Chipotle Shrimp Enchiladas which were really good and my husband ordered a combo platter which he really liked as well. We finished off our lunch with the Fried Ice Cream. I can see ourselves going back again on days we want something casual to eat. read more

Love this place! Was visiting from out of town and a friend suggested we order take-out. We stopped in to look at the menu and the bartender was SO engaging we ended up staying for a drink while looking over the selections to order later that evening. Every dish was a home run. I'll go back in a minute next time I'm in the area, probably to dine in this next time. Loved it! read more

The Margaritas are big, food was great and Christopher A, was a fabulous waiter! Polite, attentive and speedy.

Our favorite Mexican restaurant in the area. Wait staff is always great, friendly and happy to please. Food is also very good, lots of meat in the entrees, lots of cheese. My favorite is chilies relenoes. Two large chilis, fried just right with lots of meat and cheese. read more

We went last night with a group of friends. The service was great; prompt and helpful. The food; bland. I got the fajitas and you would expect a Mexican restaurant to do them better than a chain store like Applebee's. No such luck. Even the guacamole was mediocre. It seemed like a total lack of care in food preparation. Two stars is due to the good service otherwise it would've been one star. read more

If I could give more stars to this restaurant I would! We bag a large group of people (14) and some how the reservation some how got mix d up. The owner was very accommodating and seated all 14 of us together, our waitress was amazing (Kayla) she allowed us to group our checks together which never happens with a large group! The food was excellent You were able to taste all of the flavors of the dish. Kayla was on top of everyone's needs always asking if we needed anything else . This is a fantastic place with fantastic service also the food is fantastic. read more

I have been here a few times and the food has always been great. However this is the first time we have had such poor customer service and just complete lack of effort by the staff. My fiance and I arrived on Saturday at 9:52 for simply a cocktail and an appitizer. The restaurant closes at 11 pm according to the site even thought on the doors they do not list any closing times.. The first thing out of the Hostess mouth was we stop taking orders at 10:30. I responded so I have 37 minutes to place an order, she responded " oh yeah". So we sit and order a large Margarita on the rocks and a small Margarita frozen, what was brought to us was a large frozen Margarita and a small one on the rocks. We place our ordered of guacamole and the sample platter. We never received our sample platter and the waitress says oops they forgot to put in the order, but the kitchen is closed now... We get no acknowledgement that they messed up the drinks even though we told the waitress and she hesitated to take it back to correct it. We had such crap service since we arrived and they just watched over us waiting for us to leave. Then we were the last customers waiting for our check as the staff spoke in Spanish complaining. I am Hispanic so I understood their comments, which were pretty rude. So needless to say don't ever come in here an hour to closing or they treat you poorly instead of like a paying customer. read more

Casa Tequila - Mexican Near Me - Pewaukee, Wisconsin

This place has great food, fast and courteous service AND they make an excellent Mojito!!

This place was OK.. I met up with an old co-worker. We sat down right away and our waitress was over to take our drink order. We both ordered medium blended margaritas, which was huge! The drink menu is long and offers something for just about anyone. I got a mixture of two flavors. We also immediately ordered guacamole, it was absolutely delicious! They had someone come over and actually make the guacamole in front of you, a great experience. I ordered a chicken enchilada with a flour tortilla and unfortunately it came out in a corn tortilla. My old co-worker got three tacos, which she seemed to enjoy. We sat and talked for awhile and actually ended up ordering another margarita. Overall, I think Casa Tequila was not my favorite Mexican restaurant but it was just OK. I'd probably go back because the drinks and service was great. read more

Worst place ever. Only white people seem to like their unseasoned but overly advertised "with a hint of" food.. please save your time and money. A long wait with an empty store would have been fine if the food was the least bit of good... the only thing that looked good (I didn't have) was the alcoholic drinks... read more

Terrible experience. Very poor service for food and drinks. Server and manager got in an argument with a customer and then had the audacity to threaten to call the cops on the customer. Quite disturbing! Bathrooms were not clean with chunks of hair in the sink. Very reflective of poor management and service. Definitely won't be coming back and suggest you do the same! read more

Excellent meal for lunch with a yummy margarita. Service was slow. Very puzzling as it was not busy at all. But all in all a very nice experience. Will definitely go back for the food. Maybe we will get a faster server next time. read more

I have been going to this place for over 10 years, and they have never disappointed me. Their chips and salsa are always fresh and their service is great! Everyone is always kind there and every single meal is tasty and fresh. I even went here for my homecoming dinner of 25 people and they took care of us very well. I totally recommend going to this restaurant! read more

steak quesadilla was just ok. Steak was dry and didnt have any flavor. Like the meat was cooked in advance and reheated

OK...so I eat here...like once a week. Sometimes more. I drink here. I'm a lightweight, so one drink goes a LONG way. I love the margaritas. Just enough sweetness to go down easy. Strong enough to give you a wicked headache if you drink too much. If you weigh less than 120 pounds, don't go larger than the medium size. You will pass out. Wednesday nights are BOGO margaritas, so all my co-workers head there after the office closes. I admit, I haven't tried all the food there. I like the specialty items on the menu. Carne asada a la mexicana, tapequiena (sp?). But, once I tried the camarones a la diabla, I was HOOKED. I have not tried anything else there for the last year. The chicken enchiladas are great if you want something simple. I did not care for the fajitas. They were cooked in a sauce that had a smoky BBQ flavor. The wait staff is fantastic. My 3 year old spilled an entire cup of soda and the bus boy was there in a flash to help clean it up. The waiter brought us a new soda almost immediately. The place is PACKED between 6pm and 7pm on Friday and Saturday nights, so don't expect to be seated right away. I hear that kids eat free on Sundays, but I have not confirmed it. I'd take family and friends there any day. Anyone else wanna come?? read more

I went here Saturday with a friend. You get a decent amount of food for the price and it's tasty! I got a chimichanga dinner, with which you get: 3 chimichangas (I picked chicken), rice and refried beans. I also got a drink and my entire meal cost about &15.00 (not including tip). I had plenty to take home. It was pretty busy, of course it was a Saturday, but we did get seated right away. There appeared to be some room in the bar to sit as well. The service was really good this night as well! read more

I'm VERY picky about my Mexican, having grown up near so many of the best Mexican restaurants in Milwaukee and having worked in one for four years. At first when my husband suggested we try it out, I wasn't sold. The strip mall location and the typical Mexican restaurant decor threw me off. By the time we left, I was full and super satisfied!! Firstly, the parking lot was PACKED when we showed up. There was one high top bar table available, which we took in lieu of the 20 minute wait. Immediately we were given homemade chips and two salsas. Both were delicious! Our server was super sweet and attentive. When my husband ordered a whiskey old fashioned and she didn't know what that was, she made sure to get his drink correct. He said it was the best old fashioned he'd ever had!! I stuck to wine that night. I ordered the spinach enchiladas with the verde sauce with black beans. Everything was to perfection! The beans had good flavor, the enchiladas had enough sauce, and I could have eaten the whole plate if I wanted to sit there with my pants unbuttoned. I took the rest home for a snack later and it was just as good the second time. My husband ordered the beef tacos with refried beans. He swears by them. We've gone back a couple of times since and although we want to venture out, we can't help but always get what we know we'll love! It's always packed with a wait when we go (sign of a good place, right?), but we don't mind the wait. I've also tried their martinis for their $5 special. I got a raspberry one that was so good I could have had 10! Definitely worth the visit and always worth the wait! read more

I normally receive top quality food when ordering carryout from the good folks at Casa Tequila, but for some reason their steak taco dinner left a lot to be desired. The steak was tough and not very moist, maybe they should look at a better cut of meat or another tenderizing technique. read more

Casa Tequila is a favorite spot for my fiancee and myself, especially on Tuesdays after we get out of the movie at the Majestic for one dollar tacos! All you can eat as long as you order any kind of a beverage from the bar. We favor the soft shell, which is loaded with lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, chicken or beef along with chips and two bowls of mild and chunky salsa. We use the salsa to spice up our tacos. Get a good meal deal for under ten bucks for two! Phillip read more

Casa Tequila - Mexican Near Me - Pewaukee, Wisconsin

See all

We love Casa Tequila. Such a warm and family friendly atmosphere. My children love it there. So much so, my son is learning Spanish thanks to the great staff there. Food is fantastic and the prices are phenomenal. One of our go-to spots with the kids. read more

What can I say, 3 stars. Let me say this is not a negative review. Everything is average, service, food and atmosphere. Nothing bad just nothing that I see as truly exceptional. If your looking for the standard Mexican meal by all means stop in. I don't have a favorite meal but I regularly have chimichangas, taco salad and burritos.(typically pork) All of which are satisfying. The drinks are also just fine, but be warned the "Large Margarita" is enormous. :) read more

Had a great experience. Good food, clean surroundings and the service was great. A great place to go for Mexican. read more

The food is good, not anything exceptional. Good Mexican food. The place appears clean. Server was not overly friendly, buy good. The food was a little slow getting out to the table, but not too bad. I would recommend this place. Good eats. read more

Maria (the one with the pretty makeup) was our server and she was fantastic! Absolutely prompt and friendly. She went above & beyond. Our food was all very fresh and flavorful. Taco: Homemade tortilla shell Garlic shrimp: Freshly minced garlic, fresh big shrimp. REALLY veggies, not from a can or bag but freshly cut and cooked perfectly. Substituted white rice for Spanish rice & it was a little dry/old (we ate at 830pm). So she brought me Ranchero sauce that I asked for. Enchiladas: Real cheese! Great taste! Guacemole: Made right in front of you, custom to how you like it. Very tasty and fresh! Margaritas: Great value! 5.50 & buy 1 get 1. Good taste. Pomegranate was ok, strawberry was better. Chimichanga: Best I've had. Got the steak, and it was mouth watering! Other staff was also helpful and checked in a lot. Atmosphere: Not too noisy, cozy lights and clean. I'd highly recommend this place! Guacemole read more

It's a close place to get OK Mexican food. I love the chips and salsa, and they are generous with both! The Margaritas are HUGE! You can get them blended or traditional. They are not too vegetarian friendly. They put re-fried beans in my burrito. The menu said beans, so I didn't think to ask if they were re-fried. But they do have black beans available. The hostess was welcoming, and the buser was super friendly. The server was not as friendly as she could have been. When I asked for suggestions on the menu, there really wasn't anything she seems to really like. read more

Have been here several times and always have good food. The margaritas are huge and very tasty, lots of flavors to choose from. We were there this past Saturday to celebrate our son's birthday. Alejandro was a superb and attentive waiter, making sure everything was right. He even arranged for a free fried ice cream with a candle in it, and a birthday serenade while my son wore a HUGE sombrero. read more

Drinks were good, but could've used a splash more alcohol for the size. The food (fajita chicken quesadilla) was just ok.

Great place for Mexican. Get over the fact it's between Pick N Save and Wal-Mart - the food is good and the place is cute inside. Has a nice little bar area and they advertise a lot of drink specials. Margaritas are yummy and I'm partial to the Burrito Verde. It's a lot of food and a good price! read more

Whenever we come here, we are thrilled with the incredibly friendly service. The food is great and we certainly enjoy it, but the staff are just plain nice. Every time! Thanks Casa Tequila for the great service! read more

Absolutely Disqusting! My daughter ordered fish tacos and spent the night throwing up, and I ordered the quesadilla fajitas and it was deplorable! Pressed chicken meat, plain, no seasoning, bbq sauce, raw peppers and onions. The chicken and rice tasted rancid!!!! I had to give 1 star to leave the review, but this place is the absolute worst Mexican food ever. You cannot make this up! read more

Last Sunday my family picked me up a shrimp burrito from Casa Tequila. When I opened up the box it was pretty large. I ate about half the burrito and had to save the rest for later. Although, my appetite is kind of small so I'm sure in some cases it's fine. But anyway, the burrito itself was pretty adequate. It was almost kind of soggy, which made me a little stand offish at first. The burrito itself didn't taste bad, though. It came with rice and beans, and the rice was good but the beans were liquid-ish. They were very mashed. I mean, the meal was overall pretty tasty but I avoided the beans. read more

I am not a big Mexican person, I get chicken tenders at Mexican restaurants. But my family all got tacos, all good there. Waitress was nice and attentive. read more

I've been here 5 times now and every single visit the customer service is excellent and the food delicious. They have the best table side guacamole around. Each day of the week they have great drink specials and $1 tacos on Tuesdays. The staff thrust goes out of their way to make you feel valued here. Highly recommend! read more

The food was just ok. The service was awful. Too much staff hanging around the back wall goofing around. They were way too attentive. Taking stuff away before we were done, checking if we needed anything else multiple times. A male & female waitstaff in back we're getting pretty "friendly " with each other. When we finished our full meals, (almost a $60 bill) the hostess came to our table and told us we had either stay and go to a table in the bar area, or leave. She told us that other people are waiting to eat. We were shocked. We will not be back. read more

I was excited to try the food at this restaurant. Chips were stale, salsa was not great, The chicken and pork tacos were bland and the retried beans were awful! If that wasn't bad enough, I was charged $2 twice for two cups of hot water! Wish we had not visited this establishment. read more