Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casa Rustica

    3.7 (3 reviews)
    Open 5:30 am - 10:00 pm

    Casa Rustica Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casa Rustica

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    11 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Service. We waited over 2 hours for our meals. We even told the wait staff we had tickets for a show.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casa Rustica

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Steakhouses 902 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Indian Masala - Garlic Naan

    Indian Masala

    4.6(85 reviews)
    0.1 mi

    New to the area, my wife and I looked for our next go-to Indian restaurant. FOUND IT…read more The ambience is amazing. From stepping inside, you're given the allure of entering someone's home but greeted with a minimalistic, modern restaurant atmosphere. Service was A+ and the food even better! We ordered the garlic naan, chicken tikka masala (spicy) and lamb vindaloo (spicy) - all were stellar! The masala almost tasted like vodka sauce which was a first for me and I'm NOT complaining. Some of the best I've ever had, to be honest. Will be going back, for sure.

    ***2 1/2 stars*** As…read morea native of the Kingdom of Hunterdon, I tend to grade on a curve/appreciate when an ethnic restaurant, or really any establishment that's not just selling pizza by the slice, sets up shop in a pretty rural area. The tradeoff though is that sometimes these places just aren't very good. Indian Masala has a ton of great reviews so maybe I DID just come on an off day, but in my experience, these restaurants often get inflated positive feedback because the patrons just don't have perspective/experience to compare it to (the Hunterdon comp is Bamboo House in Frenchtown, which is very average but is literally the only sushi place must residents have ever been to). I genuinely don't know what the case is here. I stopped by for lunch yesterday with one of my top-tier chums, herself a native of the Kingdom of Sussex. She's a pretty big fan of this place and has mentioned it several times before. We both had pretty big appetites and were ready for a hearty meal. Comparatively speaking, the interior is a little on the bougie side especially for downtown Newton - high-class chairs, sleek tables, etc. I don't think there were any other customers in there when we showed up so we got our pick of the seating and I happily chose the table in the window for potential people watching outside. The highlight for me was the Gobi Manchurian app, which was fried cauliflower florets in a garlic sauce. I thought a few of the florets were overcooked/soggy but overall it was pretty decent - it tasted to me almost like healthy Chinese food, if that makes sense. If we didn't have legit entrees looming on the horizon, I would have had a lot more of that. The Chicken Tikka Masala was literally the worst I've ever had, and probably the only negative experience I've had with the dish. I'm by no means an Indian cuisine expert, but this to me is one of the more mainstream "Americanized" dishes and thus rare to mess up. The chicken was rubbery and dry and definitely wasn't helped by the accompanying curry. I got mild, but this was so mild to render it almost tasteless; it should have at least a little nip to it, but this was so rough that I chose to eat my accompanying naan bread naked without dipping it. Just a gigantic miss in my book and I'd recommend to any future customers that you opt for at least medium spice here. The service was hard to describe and ultimately a wash for me. In many ways it was technically a positive. Our waitress was very attentive but our interactions were a little awkward/odd, much of which can likely be chalked up to cultural barriers so I don't see a need to ding them for it. But as an example, any time my water glass was 80% full, she'd swoop in to fill it all the way to the top - literally the water level would hover right at the edge of the glass so I had to be careful not to spill when I took the next few sips. And once or twice she came by to fill up my chum's glass while I literally was drinking from mine, and she just stood there like a vulture until I placed the glass back on the table so she could swoop in. Especially given that my water was never close to even halfway empty, it was just too aggressive. But it came from a good place so your mileage may vary. Little odd all the way around. As much as I love to highlight restaurants in this area, this one is a pass for me. Much better options for Indian food closer to the city.

    Photos
    Indian Masala - Indoor

    Indoor

    Indian Masala - Fish Fry

    Fish Fry

    Indian Masala - Indoor

    See all

    Indoor

    Thai Na Khon - Drunken Noodle (Pad Kee Mow)

    Thai Na Khon

    4.2(29 reviews)
    0.5 mi

    Love this place. Service is always great, and the Thai food is a winner. Tom Kai soup is a favorite…read moreand musssman curry I really enjoy as well

    I've been here a few times now and it seems an establishment for the Newton area. Located in a…read morestrip mall, there's plenty of parking, making it a great place to bring families or pick up to-go orders. The standout appetizer for us are the curry puffs. They're just so tasty! The filling is a flavorful curry mixture of potato and chicken. Although I didn't taste the chicken, it didn't detract from the dish. The pastry was fork tender. Soo good! For dinner I like the pad se ew. It's more on the savory side than other restaurants I've tried but is consistently good. Speaking of savory, I've noticed Thai can be either savory or sweet depending on where you go. This place balances flavors on the savory/umami side. My boyfriend always gets the drunken noodles and bc I don't like spicy but he does, he asks for chili on the side. They bring out a tray containing 4 different spicy pepper based accoutrements. He loves this! The servers definitely never rush us, which I also appreciate bc we tend to come here on date nights. I like to get a bit dressy (dark denim and nicer top) and I don't look out of place here but jeans and a tshirt works too. We recently got the mango coconut sticky rice for dessert and enjoyed it. They served the rice warm, which was great and the mango was perfectly ripe and sweet. We'll get that again for sure! Also, they tend to stay open even in inclement weather, which is great. The dining area is separated a bit from the cash register so those picking up takeout orders don't detract from your meal.

    Photos
    Thai Na Khon - Shrimp musssmen curry

    Shrimp musssmen curry

    Thai Na Khon
    Thai Na Khon - Side soup served with any entree

    See all

    Side soup served with any entree

    Prime 94 SteakHouse and Grill - Steak

    Prime 94 SteakHouse and Grill

    4.3(411 reviews)
    26.8 mi
    $$$

    This was about my 7th time here and I can honestly say, I have never had anything that wasn't…read moredelicious . The food is always perfect from start to finish. Very quaint place. Not flashy, just very nice. You feel comfortable. Great food with no pretentiousness. Lastly, the service is always outstanding. Everyone you deal with from the people busing the tables to the wait staff are great. This is a definite must try!

    Prime 94 SteakHouse is a great neighborhood steakhouse…read more I'm attending a conference for the week, just passing thru New Jersey. My coworkers are content with eating Five Guys for dinner, I'm craving a glass of Caymus and a good steak. After some research, I came across Prime 94 SteakHouse and Grill. Walking in, the large neighborhood bar is to the left and the dining rooms are to the right. I'm solo so I'm escorted to a small, corner two top table. The waiter starts telling me about the specials. After he was finished, I told him a want a 16oz Ribeye and a glass of Caymus. No bread basked needed. Also, can you throw on one or two long hots? Yes sir! Now this is what I would eat at home. I'd buy a nice steak with a good glass of wine. Did I just describe my last meal before I head up to the pearly gates? Yeah.. Prime 94 SteakHouse makes a good steak. The cook was perfect, it was a little fatty but that's the flavor! The french fries are something similar to a diner fry, they were really good as well. I took a piece of steak, a small slice of the long hot, mmm mm! Prime 94 SteakHouse isn't a fancy steakhouse. There was a large table in front of me, I'm assuming it was grandma and her sisters along with a family of four. The aunts were asking, I'm assuming an 19 year old girl about her college, she was giving one word answers. Prime 94 SteakHouse, it's a neighborhood spot that's serving up some good food. If I lived here, this restaurant would be in my dining rotation.

    Photos
    Prime 94 SteakHouse and Grill - The bar

    The bar

    Prime 94 SteakHouse and Grill - Ribeye 16oz

    Ribeye 16oz

    Prime 94 SteakHouse and Grill - Caymus wine

    See all

    Caymus wine

    Casa Rustica - steak - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...