Hidden gem! Small family restaurant with a an authentic old school Italian vibe, where everyone is treated as family. I attended a surprise party there, the service was excellent and the food delicious. The fruit tray was beautiful, the olive and cheese tray was plentiful. The pizza and wings were delicious and the blue cheese was just right! The service was excellent from the waitress, waiter, and bartender. We had an amazing time. I will definitely be back! read more

I truly cannot recommend Casa Nova enough! The food is to die for always, everything made fresh and what can come from the garden out back, does! We had a party for my boyfriend's birthday in the back room and Maria and John truly went above and beyond, to the point Maria got a ladder to help me put up a sign and balloons! 35 people and not one person had a single bad thing to say, not that I thought they would! Anytime someone asks for a dinner suggestion, casa nova is most always the first place I name! Authentic, fresh and DELICIOUS Italian, friendly service and the cleanest kitchen you'll find! Don't waste anymore time and go try for yourself, thank me later! read more

See all

I had my wife's memorial dinner here, after the funeral. It was a huge money grab for them. Owner was rude and dismissive. Shameful. The food was absolutely terrible. Tiny portions and dried out. It was like they reheated last week's leftovers. Overall, not an honorable business. Steer clear of this restaurant. I don't know what happened it used to be a nice place. read more

Delicious fish fry. We had breaded fish with parsley potatoes. Cole slaw was in a separate container and very tasty. Also included was a couple of pieces of their homemade bread,delicious also and wrapped separately. We had it in take out,our usual! read more

This place treats you like family! We had my Mother's Memorial dinner here, and couldn't have been more pleased. They prepared antipasto, pizza, wings and drinks for 50 people. The antipasto tray was a work of art! The owner, John was very accommodating, and his staff was very attentive. If you're in Niagara Falls, check out this place! read more

Casa Nova Restaurant - Casa Nova Antipasto tray - Italian Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

had a wonderful meal here. great service and food. feels like fine dining because they actually give you bread plates for your bread. home grown veggies in the salad and the waitress took our food and boxed it for us. very impressed with Casa Nova. read more

So I go to Casa Nova to pick up a half tray tonight. I ordered a few months ago and the owner tried scamming me on the price of toppings on the pizza. We got into a bit it. I tell him, you know what, keep the pizza I don't even want it. I go to pick up tonight "hey I got a pick up under Bob" the nephew of the owner replies "Bob (last name)?!" I said yup, how'd you even know the last name I didn't leave a last name. He said it came up on the caller ID. I said I didn't call off of "bobs phone". He gets my food and proceeds to tell me "my uncle wanted me to tell you don't ever order from this restaurant ever again!" We had some choice words between each other. This family is the lowest of the low. This means the nephew got in contact with his uncle who wasn't there and communicated some how that "Bob (last name) just ordered food". The uncle relayed a message to his nephew to give me a message to never order from their place ever again. Great business these guys conduct. No wonder they're only open 20 hours a week. 4 hours a night. and the parking lot is often empty. If it wasnt for their regulars, they wouldn't exist.. The entire establishment went straight downhill after the old man passed away. They have no idea how to talk to customers. They can't seem to run a business successfully. They might think they have a successful business, but I've been in the restaurant industry for 18 years, and being open 4 hours a night shows they can't run a business (yes, there are restaurants that that only need to be open 4 hours a night to pull in profits) Do yourself a favor, don't order from this place. Don't support a family that doesn't treat their customers how they should be treated. They're extremely over priced. I paid over $20 for a half tray with just half pepperoni. I also know a friend that worked there for some time, and you're not getting fresh sauce,hardly ever. . It's usually 1-3 days old (because of their hours) when they pour it on top of your raviolis or spaghetti and meatballs. Unless you catch them on the day they made new sauce. This restaurant won't last 5 more years with the family members they have running it now. It's Friday, I went in around 6 and there was maybe 5 tables with customers. Every other table empty. Bar didn't have a soul sitting on a stool. Please don't give your money to a business that goes out of their way to call the owner and tell them someone specific ordered food and then ordered his nephew to rudely tell me never order from here again. Which won't be a problem. They're 30 seconds around the corner from me and it was convenient to grab a pizza from there. I wouldn't even be surprised if they messed with my food after knowing who the order was for. IF YOUVE NEVER BEEN HERE, I DONT SUGGEST IT AT ALL. There's at least 8 different amazing Italian restaurants in the area. I highly suggest Casa Antica in Lewiston for authentic Italian. There's nothing authentic about Casa Nova. They think putting red sauce on everything makes them an Italian restaurant. read more

if you haven't tried their fish and the pizza and chicken wings this is the place to go! the fish is so fresh with such a light batter it's delicious you can break it apart with a fork and the baked fish done to perfection! the staff is excellent and the owner johnie is such a nice man and his sister Maria who prepare your food is wonderful lent will e coming in the next couple of weeks so for a hot delicious fish fry this is the place to come! read more

Would give no stars. Went there for dinner last night. Big mistake. We were seated after a short wait. The person seating us said our waitress will be with us soon. She came took our drink order and we never saw her again. Someone came over to see if anyone took our drink order, which she had. Other people came in and were waited on as we were still waiting for our drinks which never came. After 20 minutes we left......will never go back read more

Nice atmosphere & building inside. Almost no liquor. Nice bar. Serving expired beer. One IPA, the worst one. Lasagna had no meat in it. Took an hour to get our food. Servers were very nice. Owner has no clue obviously, what a shame. Neither one of has felt good since we left there yesterday. read more

This old school Italian family restaurant feels like home and serves large, home style meals. Great pizza, but also pasta, meatballs, lasagna, veal parmigiana. The classics. The warm and welcoming staff is eager to please. If you are visiting the area, go where the locals go. You will walk away contended, full, and likely carrying some leftovers. Easy choice. read more

Excellent home style Italian food. Friendly staff. Quite so you can have a conversation. read more

Yet another place that puts you back in time, about 40 years, at least. Why can't any of these places spend ANY money upgrading their dining rooms. It boggles the mind. The place has a small bar at the front with a few tables, then a good size dining room at the back. The tables are old, the decor is old, the chairs are old. But, the fish is fresh! We ordered the Friday fish fry with fries, $12.50. They served us a basket of bread, though only with two pieces in it, lol. It was sort of like homemade bread. Not bad. The fish fry entrees also came with coleslaw, which tasted a bit fishy, no thanks. The fries were dry and plain tastings, perhaps I should have gone with the boiled potatoes. The beer battered fish was cooked perfectly and the fish, Cod, was nice and flaky--yum! One thing which seemed odd here was that the servers use metal cars on wheels to deliver your entrees. That seems weird. Almost like getting your dinner at the hospital, covered in a metal tin. Would it kill these serves to just use a platter to put the entrees on?! Our server was friendly and did deliver the items in a timely manner. read more

See all

Great throwback to the traditional Italian cuisine and atmosphere of yesteryear Niagara Falls. Classic in every way, and the staff is excellent. read more

If you are looking for good food and a quaint environment this is the place for you. Not only do they grow their own seasonal veggies but their portion sizes are not a disappointment. Give this place a try. You won't regret it! read more

Incredible food! They use only the best ingredients. And the dining room and kitchen are spotless! Our "go to" place whenever we're in town. read more

Very mediocre pizza pie. You'd think places like this would make a better effort with take-out only because of the virus but not the case here. A little bit better than frozen but not much. Won't be back. read more

If you're in the mood for classic Italian and old(er) school feel, then this is the place. I've been to a handful of classic Italian places over the years and this one definitely fits the bill.... great service and a homemade meal. Pizza, Spaghetti, Wine, Cannoli's... need I say more? Service earned their 4th star. Solid place. read more

Casa Nova Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

Pre-ordered the St Patrick's day special. Corned beef, cabbage, carrots and a huge potato! Delicious! Tons of food and still hot and ready to eat when I picked it up. read more

Casa Nova is a great place if you are looking for that traditional non-chain Italian Food! It's family owned/managed and run. The pizza is hand-tossed and pasta sauce is made fresh each day. The chicken wings are a requirement to go with the pizza. You know it is true "italiano" because it is the one place in the area that still serves tripe. The smell is intense but the tripe is good! As any good family owned restaurant they do offer fish fry Fridays during Lent. There maybe a slight wait but they turn the tables pretty fast. The bartender varies between the 2 siblings and the pour is good. They do know how to make a cocktail. Keep in mind that the dining room gets oud when busy and the owners employ their own children to help serve dishes & clear tables. (Which is fine. . . add a slight cute factor.) They are not open on Sundays and Mondays & only serve dinner. Be sure to say HI to Nash - he will be sitting at the bar playing cards and probably having a cup of coffee and a huge plate of pasta. It's his restaurant and he came over from Italy to raise his family. All of his family's recipes from the old country and he is sure to keep those memories alive in the food. read more

This place was a great surprise, a hidden gem for sure. We have been in Niagara Falls and had family in town for a wedding and wanted to get everyone together for one last dinner before before everyone parted ways, well they were able to accommodate a party of 14 on a Saturday night so we ended up here. My cousin raved about their pizza, so we had a tray of pizza and 50 wings, hot and bbq, and some people ordered Italian wedding soup or beans and greens. Well, let me tell you, HIDDEN GEM. The pizza and wings were great!! The prices weren't too bad either. The Italian wedding soup was OK, nothing special. I didn't try the beans and greens soup but it looks really good and I heard no complaints about it. We absolutely devoured the pizza and wings, very good!! I've passed the place a million times and never thought about stopping in, the restaurant wasn't busy either on a Saturday so obviously others do the same. But I'd definitely recommend trying their pizza and wings!! read more

Can I give it a rating between A-OK and Yay!? This place was recommended to us by a friend and I guess it can be thought of as a "hidden gem" despite the gaudy LCD sign out front that so often has the word "TRIPE!!!" scrolling across it. I see gaudy LCD sign, I keep driving usually. And I have, for like 17 years since I've lived here. So we packed up the fam and headed there on a rainy Friday with no desire to cook at home. This reminds me of every Italian-American restaurant I visited as a kid in Central New York. The smell instantly brought me back 25 years. The decor is "updated 80's" I'd say, with cheap-o banquet chairs and fair amount of panelling. The speakers were painted the color of the walls to hide them. There's an attention to detail that amused me. You can tell they really tried to take an older place and make it nice. I've also heard that the owner grows herbs out back for use in the dishes. That's pretty cool too, because as you know, fresh herbs are wonderful. Moving on. The salad with their house balsamic was great. Everything fresh, but the dressing is awesome! Granted it was served in a small plastic bowl you'd expect to see sent from the hospital cafeteria, but it was great. The spaghetti & meatballs at the table were good. Everything big portioned. My wife's chicken parmesan was good and my veal parmesan was good. My daughters medium chicken wings were tossed in butter for the most part and were not edible. Someone got the butter/Frank's ratio wrong there, at least that night. Everything we had seemed fresh. Fresh is huge for me. The more I type, the more I want to make it a 4 star rating, but I just can't. Overall, it was quite good. Not great, not crazy good, but good and it was a nice laid back atmosphere for my family. A table next to us ordered a pizza and it looked and smelled wonderful. Next time, I'd like to try that out or maybe their fish fry. Yes, there will be a next time. However, there is no next time where I will be trying that tripe they are so pumped about. read more

Went here a few days ago and we just had some pizza and wings. Both the pizza and the wings were very good. If that is what you are looking for you will not be disappointed. The only reason for 4 stars instead of 5 was because our waitress was good, just overwhelmed. She and one other waitress had the whole dining room of about 20 tables (10 each). It wasn't my 1st time here and I will be back but management should really think about putting more staff on a Friday night. read more

Casa Nova Restaurant - Pizza with cheese and pepperoni and hot peppers and anchovies on half - Italian Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

See all

Decided to try someplace new and looked at the reviews for This place.......all are correct! It's a family owned restaurant that is definitely a step back in time! The food (gnocchi and fettuccini Alfredo for entrees and cannoli for dessert) were amazing and the wine (Pino Grigio) was perfect! Our waitress was super friendly and very knowledgeable about the menu! I highly recommend this place and will definitely return! read more

Best chicken wings and pizza in Niagara hands down!! Get the extra crispy wings - cooked in peanut oil and unlike other wings you have had! Worth the drive! You won't regret it! read more

This is a wonderful little family owned restaurant. We recently had a 90th Birthday dinner for my Dad there. The chicken Parm was delicious and the owner was extremely nice and helpful in making the arrangements. Our waitress was wonderful and extremely patient with our dinner party of 17. The dinner guests included both adults and children. They went out of their way to make this a special dinner for my Dad and we greatly appreciate it. I would highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Nice family restaurant where they will remember your name. Balsamic dressing was very good in the salad. Had pizza with sausage and peppers. Fresh sausage, pupping hot cheese and decent crust. The menu is very standard but don't let that fool you. Ever dish that came out around us looked great. I'll be back. read more

Pizza and mozzarella sticks were wonderful. Our waiter Nick was very nice and very attentive (but not annoying).

A fabulous family run Italian Restaurant! The Veal and Chicken Parm is excellent as is the Lasagna. The Owner/Chef takes two days to make the sauce and it is wonderful. The pizza is very good and the wings are the best in the area. The chef uses more expensive peanut oil for the wings and they are always crispy. They have a great fish fry on Friday too. They have a huge garden next to the parking lot and use the fresh produce in the summer and fall. You can't go wrong here. read more

Had a party of 45, and the service was awesome, food was great and we were extremely pleased with everything. Italian sausage was delicious. Would return for dinner and definitely for the home made bread! read more

My favorite here is their steak with a side order of spaghetti. Sauce is very good and the italian bread with the olives is to die for! Service is just a tad slow, but food is very good. read more

Food is good but portions small veal parm $20 very little pasta and pasta is cheap I found it to be a little over priced I have eaten there several and every time the service is awful there's just no other way to put for the price and I don't mind paying g top dollar and they want top dollar for their food you want good service it isn't here waitress are high school kids can't say enough over priced small portions BAD SERVICE waitress answering phone and taking to go orders between trips to our table yelling in the kitchen just very very bad service and over priced small portions of food read more

Went to dinner and Sheas for a girls night out. There were 6 in our party. My mom cannot have gluten so we called ahead to see if they would boil her pasta of we brought it in for her. They agreed to do so. When we got the bill they had charged her full price for a pasta and sauce meal. We asked about it and they discounted it $2.00. She paid $13.99 for them to boil her noodles, one Italian sausage and a bit of sauce. They forgot to make my dinner and I had to wait while everyone else ate. There are no refills on soda, so just know that before you drink too fast. Service is very slow and in my opinion food is very overpriced. I won't be going back. Ever. Sad, because you'd think that you would have better service at a family owned restaurant but honestly, I have had way better service with less expensive bills at chain restaurants. read more