I tried this place for the first time a few months ago and have ordered from them three more times since them. There are a lot of good things they are doing right. First off, the personal pizzas are great. They have a dough that is thin with the right amount of chew. I got the 4 cheese white pizza and then the eggplant with red sauce and both were excellent. Also got a plain for my son and it was fine, I just prefer the specialty pies. The grilled chicken focaccia sandwich is very good, because this place is doing the focaccia right. The homemade potato chips are great, crispy and salty, generous portioned as a side order but also comes with every sandwich. I also tried a sausage Stromboli which was huge. It was a little overloaded with cheese, but with that same excellent pizza dough and a very flavorful Marinara dipping sauce, it's a good meal. The real miss for me was the meatball sub. The meatballs were not good, somewhat mealy texture and not much flavor. Will not order again. My wife has had both subs and wraps there and really gives them high marks. I'm going to keep coming back for the personal pizzas, the homemade chips and the focaccia. read more

The salads here are enormous. Each salad can easily feed 3 people. The hot bread that comes with is really good. This is a solid go to if we are having people over. Pizza and salad. Only 4 stars because there is pizza I prefer elsewhere. Not bad but not my favorite. Normal New York slice. read more

I am a huge fan of locally owned businesses. That said the pizza is the star. We got a salad you split and a Godfather. Square traditional pie with sauce mozzarella and basil. Crust is amazing and sauce on point. We will be back!!! read more

Great flavorful cheese slice, in a cute quaint area of downtown Westfield. Received good service as well! I wanted so badly to order a large pie after the slice I ordered. read more

Casa di Pizza - a woman standing in front of a counter - Pizza Near Me - Westfield, New Jersey

Casa di Pizza has wonderful pizza and such kind workers. I went there with one of my friends over the weekend. We were helped by a staff member, Theo. He was very patient, friendly and helpful. I recommend this place for whenever you are craving pizza. It has such a classic pizza shop place look to it. read more

This so called pizzeria is worse than terrible! Their pizza is overloaded with cheap super salty cheese! Terrible!! Worse yet, if you have it delivered it will arrive with cold, salty, gelatinous cheese. If you complain about how crappy your $84 order was, they will over you a joke of a credit ($15). Do yourself a favor and hit up domino's. At least you will be expecting terrible pizza from them!! Oh and their explanation for how much cheese is on the pizza is that it is made with three kinds of shredded cheese as well as parmigiana that's why it is so cheesy. Different types of cheese has NOTHING to due with putting too much on! Idiots! read more

My favorite salads are here! They're fresh, tasty and HUGE! The pizza is good too off course))))

Pizza is good and is one of our go-tos in town. We've gotten an Italian sub, wings, pizza, garlic knots and a chicken cheesesteak. Overall, we'll definitely go here plenty and we like the pizza, sub, wings, knots. I tried the chicken cheesesteak... I wouldn't get it again. Others night enjoy it but it's just very different from what I'd consider a cheesesteak--the chicken was not diced up into small enough pieces for the cheese and chicken to really be mixed up the way a normal cheesesteak would be. I'd call it a grilled chicken grinder. Not bad just not really what I'm looking for when I get a cheesesteak read more

Some of the best pizza I have ever had. Fresh ingredients. Salads are amazing too! Quick deliveries. So good!!!

Fantastic pizza for the best price out there! Had to wait a bit for service, but they were very busy. Worth the wait!

Got a slice of pizza the other day and the crust had a small spot of green and white mold on it. It was hard and sort of gross. Hopefully i won't get sick. read more

I am very picky about my shrimp scampi and this was a winner! The sauce was perfectly lemony and the shrimp cooked to perfection and very fresh! I am looking forward to trying more dishes from this restaurant! read more

This place has a very welcoming look to it. Tables and chairs outside looks nice inside out. After doing an Uber stop I was craving for pizza, and I came across this place. I order 2 regular slices and was not impressed on how thin they were. The crust and the bottom of the pizza tasted burn as if they were sitting there for a long time. Not a fan at all did not like the pizza. Probably one of the worst one I ever had. read more

Casa di Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Westfield, New Jersey

Love love love their salads and chicken wings!! I think the pizza is also decent hot like blow your mind beat pizza in the world but a solid slice! I especially like their Buffalo chicken pizza. For me their salads are the star of the show though they give you an option to have them chopped which is a game changer for any salad. Great neighborhood spot. read more

Ordered a pie for the kids waited an hour pizza came cold and undercooked pizza . Nasty and never again. read more

Casa di Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Westfield, New Jersey

Casa di Pizza used to be my shorty but she's about to get served. Beneath the tsunami of undercooked cheese was a soggy crust that had more flop than an elderly man at a nude beach. Seriously, how hard is it to fully cook a pizza? read more

Casa di Pizza - More flop than elderly man at a nude beach. - Pizza Near Me - Westfield, New Jersey

Awesome pizza! Owner is super nice and very friendly. I order from there every time I am near Westfield.

Probably the best pizza I've had so far in New Jersey. Casual atmosphere, byob, good prices for the quality and the generous amount of toppings we got. Great location in the heart of downtown Westfield. The salad we ordered was kinda bland but other than that everything else was great. We got a pie with fresh tomatoes, mozzarella along with chicken. Many other types of pizzas I saw on other tables looked delicious too. read more

Casa di Pizza - Fresh tomatoes, chicken and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Westfield, New Jersey

We were a party of 13 people and they did an amazing job setting us, giving bread while we waited, getting our food out at a quick pace, and taken care of any needs. Vegan pizza was really good. Salad was huge. All the pizzas and wraps were enjoyed by our party. The soup looked delicious and homemade. All the employees were friendly and helpful. I read more

I'm actually shocked that this place does as well as it does. I think their success stems a lot from their location in Westfield Town center. The pizza was a little too thick and the toppings were overloaded, where it was overpowering. I had a chicken ranch slice and the quality of the chicken wasn't great. It wasn't very flavorful and the sauce was mediocre at best. Not worth going out of your way for. Really shocked this place does so well given there are so many other spots in town that have better pizza. They need to work on their flavors! read more

See all

Favorite pizza spot in downtown Westfield. My family has been ordering from Casa every week for years now and we haven't looked back. The Godfather pie is a MUST for that special occasion dinner, the perfect combo of Parmesan, fresh basil, and olive oil with a red sauce base. The kind of pizza that you can't wait to eat after pick up and finish it in a parking lot (no joke, my grandparents did this when bringing it over to our house one time). Also have great hero subs-the chicken parm being a household favorite. read more

I love this place, great pizza, excellent salads and terrific catering for business & on the go

Decent slice of pizza and a kid friendly place with some seating outside. read more

See all

My favorite place for a salad, it always fresh and the taste is always amazing. The pizza can be hit or miss but if you order a fresh pie then you can't go wrong. When I'm in the area this is def my go to spot for a quick bite. read more

Had some business in the area the day before thanksgiving. Decided to stop in for a bite. After reading the reviews about the pizza being salty I can see what they are talking about. The pizza isn't salty in the sense that it is over seasoned, it's the fact that real quality cheeses are being used. They had two types of Sicilian pizza on offer, one of which has Parmesan cheese, the other with fresh mozzarella. As the one with Parmesan was oven fresh I chose it. I was pleasantly surprised at the affordability and quality of the pizza. Yes, it had a salty note due to the parm. Yes it was saucy. But these two things made it a great slice. I can imagine it would not travel well as the sauce would soften the buttery and crispy crust. But getting it fresh and hot? Delicious! Gonna bring my kids back soon to get another slice! read more

We are visiting Westfield after a year and a half and decided to order a delivery from this great place. Ordered to arrive at specific time, delivery arrived right on time, piping hot. Our carbonara was the best we ever tried, amazing. The order girl was nice, the delivery guy was so polite, this this the place to be supported. Thank you to everyone. Once again top class. read more

Not awful, but not that great. Pizza was mediocre. We were waiting on a delivery, but after an hour called and asked if we could pick it up instead. The owner/manager or whoever he was, was not very nice. Never apologized and didn't want to return the delivery fee, but he did so reluctantly. This was our first and last time trying them out. read more

We order often from Casa as it is our favorite pizza place. We ordered a pasta dish and a Red Hawaiian. I went to pick it up, ran a quick errand on the way home and imagine my surprise when I get home to serve dinner and it's the wrong pizza! I immediately call and explained they didn't give us a Red Hawaiian, but a white Hawaiian with red blobs of sauce ( please see pic). The gentlemen who answered was very apologetic and offered to make it right by delivering the right pizza to my house. I am very pleased with the response to fix this issue immediately. Casa di Pizza really does care about customer satisfaction. They will continue to be our pizza shop for their delicious pizza and attentiveness to making sure their customers leave happy. read more

Casa di Pizza - This isn't a red Hawaiian - Pizza Near Me - Westfield, New Jersey

I am very impressed with this local pizza joint. Not much seating, but there was a delicious selection of slices available in the case. I chose Melanzane and margherita, both of which were very good. My friend got cheese Sicilian and was very happy with it. They were also very friendly, and let my young friend try a garlic knot, which she thought was delicious. Thanks, yelpers, for sending me here when I needed a slice of pizza in this area. read more

Casa di Pizza - Melanzane, lots of eggplant Parmesan goodness - Pizza Near Me - Westfield, New Jersey

See all

Excellent, relatively new pizza place is probably the best in town. Their crust is on the thinner side, but has nice crispness on the outside and the requisite tenderness within. We tried two different types, the white and the pepperoni. The white pizza is probably the most flavorful example thereof I have eaten - is that a hint of gorgonzola we tasted? The pepperoni was also quite good and not greasy at all. Service was quick and friendly. Excellent minestrone soup, as well. We went on a sleepy Sunday afternoon and seating was available, but I would imagine that this place either is or will soon be crowded. And deservedly so. read more

Casa di Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Westfield, New Jersey

In the heart of downtown Westfield New Jersey lies a gem of a restaurant and pizzeria. Reasonably priced together with friendly service all contribute to a nice atmosphere and a good time. Try a seafood and pasta dish you will not be disappointed. I recommend this restaurant. read more

Casa di Pizza - Meatball sub, Portobello Mushroom salad with goat cheese, grilled chicken and balsamic. Very good! - Pizza Near Me - Westfield, New Jersey

Favorite pizza spot in Westfield! Perfect crust finish and the sauce to cheese ratio is exactly what you want! I always choose this place over others read more

First pizza place we tried before pulling the trigger to buy a home in Westfield! We're serious about our pizza in this town! The perfect place to grab a slice post soccer practice or after playing at Mindowaskin park. A true Westfield establishment, rowdy, joyful kids and all. read more

When this place opened, I couldn't believe Westfield was getting ANOTHER pizza place. I couldn't see how they could compete. But oh boy, am I glad they defied the odds. I love this little pizza shop. Hands down, the freshest, tastiest pizza in town, with a friendly, hardworking staff. Everything I've sampled from them is fresh and worth ordering. From their salads (get the roasted vegetable salad!) to the minestrone, you can tell that attention was paid to the quality of the ingredients. read more

Just moved to the area and this has been one of the best pizza spots around. Consistently good food no matter what you order! We've gotten pizza, pasta, and sandwiches! The grilled chicken panini is my favorite and their pizza is always perfect. read more

I can't say enough about the great service (and of course food) at Casa Di Pizza. Last Saturday I went in with my four toddler boys and a girlfriend with her toddler daughter. The staff could not be more accommodating. They set up our table and when the pizza cake set it up on a different table so none of the kids could touch it and dished out each slice to us and seconds when they were needed. A+ service especially when parents are already overwhelmed taking kids out to dinner! Foods to try: garlic wings, chopped salads, pizza. The salads are my favorite in the area! read more

All the food at Casa Di Pizza is excellent. Soups are the best and they have the best pizza in town. Have eaten there on numerous occasions and the food is always cooked to order and delicious. Had them cater my GF 40th. Offsite about 30 minutes. God arrived hot and ready to go. Chicken was amazing. Everything was fresh and our family loved everything they made. read more

Got a slice here. Super fast, nice sauce. Good crunch. Good neighborhood spot.

Out of all the Italian restaurants/pizzerias in Westfield, this establishment knows how to master Italian cuisine. Without naming the others, I find the others to be flavorless, not fresh and not authentic. The appetizers at Casa di Pizza are awesome. Portobello stuffed mushroom, eggplant rollantine and baked clams are classically made and burst with flavor. Orrechette with sausage and broccoli rabe knock it out of the park. Other items on the menu never disappoint. Delivery is timely and accurate. Such lovely food. . read more

I've ordered from here several times because their pizza is tasty, however not tastier than Buona Pizza- also located in Westfield. The reason I give them 2 stars is because they don't actually start making your order until you get there, so if they say "20 minutes" that means come in 20 minutes and we'll start making your order then! I would say this was a one time deal, but it's happened about ... 5 times. It's teenagers in there on their cell phones, I get it, cheap labor that doesn't give a sh#t... but at some point maybe care about the customer because with so many other awesome italian places in westfield you'll eventually start losing business. read more