I HIGHLY recommend this place! Don't expect fancy surroundings, white tablecloths or vested waiters at this under the radar fabulous Italian like find Situated on the corner of turbulent Thompson and Bleecker streets , where it is a Mecca of dining establishments, this one blends in with the rest but trust me it's superior Staff could not be friendlier or more highly efficient. It's a young happy vibe! We started with the Burrata which is served with the thinnest of freshly baked crisps. Awesome The arugula salad was huge! Enough for two infact probably enough for 3 or 4 The linguine with clams ... never had better i I was shocked considering how inexpensive it was .. I mean I've had this dish at 30 dollars no better than this one at a mere 19!! The best part is that it arrived piping hot , and truly Al dente The salmon was also a hit. Served with freshly sauté spinach and delicious roasted potatoes.. The food absolutely does not disappoint The only soft point was desserts. Limited to the point where we choose to abstain The best part is his reasonable this food was Go! read more

Carrol's Place is a great spot for a special occasion, especially if ambience matters to you. We hosted a private birthday party and had the upstairs to ourselves, which made the night feel intimate and elevated without being stuffy. The food was *excellent* and served coursed, family-style -- perfect for a group. Standouts included the calamari, wings, bolognese, rigatoni, salmon, French fries, and dessert. Everything came out well-paced and consistently delicious, and it was clear the kitchen knows what it's doing. We didn't opt for the alcohol package, and unfortunately drink service was the weakest part of the experience. It was very slow, and drinks often came out tasting different from one another. That said, our server was fantastic and did everything possible to make up for it, which we really appreciated. Overall, the food and ambience more than made up for the drink issues. I'd absolutely recommend Carrol's Place for a private event or celebration! read more

Carrol Place has been New York's most unproblematic, no frills and 'gets the job done' bottomless brunch for as long as I can remember- so when my friend opted to come by here for a quick meal for her birthday I knew exactly what to expect. I ordered the steak and eggs and added avocado. Everything came out good. I do wish there was more steak in my plate and the eggs were seasoned a bit more, but this was still a good plate of food. Everybody on our table went for the bottomless drinks option so they generously sent us decanters of mimosas and sangria which we got very tipsy off of. The drinks here definitely hit and are not watered down. My friends and I are always a riot and our server was such a good sport when he knew we were in the mood to get turnt. He played all the songs, took requests, even curtained off the dining area after everyone left and let us have our moment till our uber picked us up to take us to our next destination. The bathrooms were clean and I was able to easily change in my next outfit in there. It really felt like we visited nana's house and kept our day pushing. So grateful for restaurants like these that exist and facilitate life!! read more

Carroll Place - Brunch Steak and Eggs - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

This place is fine. Open seats at Saturday at 7 pm, so you understand what I mean. Worst espresso martini I have ever had, should have stuck with beer. The pizza and kale caesar were very good, so hence the 3 stars. The Amatriciana pizza is amazing. Otherwise, nothing to write home about. read more

See all

Spacious and chill spot for brunch! We got a couple of drinks and for food we shared the calamari, prosciutto and arugula pizza, sliders and fries. Overall good spot for brunch and plenty of seating! Also saw a lot of birthday parties so great for groups! read more

Carroll Place - Calamari and sliders - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Oh man, it was colder than a witch's (expletive deleted) because it started to hail when Jamie W and I were strolling in Washington Square Park. Yes, hail. Ouch. We were still determined to find some lunch and stumbled into this busy village tavern. Surprisingly, while the back dining room was full, the bar still had open seats, so we took them. Now here's a shocker. We didn't have any booze to warm our bones and went right for the hot food, sharing three plates. First up was the $19 Pugliese Pizza, a bigger-than-average pie for two with a nicely charred crust topped with Italian sausage, chopped broccoli rabe, cherry tomatoes, and fresh melted mozzarella (Photo 8). We thought they could've been a bit more generous with the toppings, but it hit the spot. Pasta sounded good, so we went for the $20 Orecchiette which was mixed with pork & fennel sausage, broccoli rabe, basil, and pesto (Photo 9). Topped with grated Parmesan, it was straight-up homestyle comfort food and fortunately delicious. Our last dish was a side, the pan-roasted $10 Brussels Sprouts with Pancetta (Photo 10). They sure know how to char the sprouts. Savory good stuff. FOOD - 4 stars...delicious Italian comfort food away from the hailstorm AMBIANCE - 3.5 stars...more spacious at the bar than you'd expect SERVICE - 3 stars...a bit slowish TOTAL - 4 stars...it's about satisfying our bellies RELATED - Hungry in NYC? Here's my collection of bars and restaurants l've patronized and reviewed: https://bit.ly/2YS9ELS read more

See all

Some friends and I had dinner here before a show in the area. We arrived early in the evening and the place was packed. The decor was nice and the vibe was energetic. The seating area was a bit small and you were sitting right next to another party. We ordered meatball parm sliders as an appetizer for the table that came in two and each of us were able to eat one. For dinner, I ordered the lasagna and two other friends ordered the penne alla vodka with chicken and the other had sausages. We all enjoyed our meals with no complaints. None of us ordered cocktails agreeing we would be nodding at the show we were going to see shortly after dinner. lol Our server was sweet and friendly. The bathrooms were clean and the attendant in the bathroom had everything you needed when you finished in the restroom so take some dollars for a small tip. lol Overall we had a great time and I would definitely return to check out some menu items. read more

See all

Located in the heart of Greenwich Village (a.k.a. NYU territory), Carroll Place is a big, lively restaurant that's fun for a weekend brunch. I went with a few friends on a weekend and we started with drinks at the bar before sitting down for their prix-fixe brunch, which includes 90 minutes of unlimited brunch cocktails for around $38. The food was pretty solid, my omelette was fresh. As for drinks, the mimosas were just okay, and I wasn't a fan of the sangria. But the overall energy was great, the place was packed, the music was loud (in a fun way), and the playlist was solid.Our server was friendly, and there was good service. I'd recommend Carroll Place more for the scene, location, and group brunch vibes than for standout food or cocktails. read more

Carroll Place - Brunch omelette - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Food: Came here for some unlimited boozy brunch deal! Ended up ordering the burger with the mimosa deal and I could not have been any happier- the burger was delicious and the addition of the unlimited option was one of the better deals I have seen in the city! Cost: Approximately around $40 for unlimited drinks + burger option (I do know it was a slight upcharge for the burger choice out of the entree options). Environment: Fairly large establishment! Was able to have a party of 7-8 fit and be accommodated without any issue. Service: The service was great! Our waitress was always keeping an eye out and making sure our mimosa pitcher was alway full and ready for us to demolish haha Uniqueness: Great place for brunch, especially if you want a boozy brunch with a fun atmosphere and plenty of room for large groups! read more

See all

Overall: I went here on a Saturday night with my girlfriend. We had a reservation for 8:30. When we arrived, the entry way was packed and several groups with 8:00 reservations hadn't been seated yet and were told to hang out at the bar. We were actually seated right away, but in the upstairs dining room. The food was good, but the upstairs area was basically forgotten by the wait staff and was dominated by another bar area. The food was good, but probably won't be back based on the overall experience. Food: 4 Drinks: 3 Service: 1 Value: 3 Atmosphere: 2 Food: The food was very good, easily the highlight of the night. We got the meatball parm sliders, the lasagna, and the pappardelle. The sliders were pretty unique, with a crushed meatball and a slab of parmesan cheese between a soft bun. The lasagna was very savory and cheesy and came out hot (took an extra 20 minutes, which we were warned about). Drinks: We each got a cocktail. I got the 'You Must Chill' (mix of run and several liqueurs) and my girlfriend got the 'Ding Ding Ding' (spicy marg). They were fine, but nothing special. We each thought they were lacking overall flavor. Service: This part was dreadful. We were seated quickly and had our drink orders taken, but then we were basically forgotten. We had to make a point of flagging down a waiter to order food, get refills, and pay our bill. Even then, they got distracted and needed to be reminded. The point-of-sale software they were using failed at some point, which caused another delay while the waiter tried to fix it. The table next to us took over an hour to order their food. Maybe the issue was that we were in the upstairs area, but it was pretty frustrating. Value: I thought the food prices were reasonable: $15 for the meatball sliders, $22 for lasagna, and $21 for the pappardelle. The cocktails were $15-16 each, which was kind of a lot for how small they were. Atmosphere: The restaurant was dimly lit and decorated with lots of holiday themed touches. It looked promising going in. Again, I think the issue may have been sitting upstairs. The upstairs part seemed like they couldn't decide between being a nice Italian restaurant or a cheap college bar. Our table was half booth; my girlfriend said the bench she was seated on was covered in dirt, as if it was common for people to stand on it to dance. Our specific table was nearest to the bar and we were regularly dealing with people throwing their coats next to us and shouting. The upstairs bathroom door was broken so it didn't latch properly. Lots of potential, but overall not a great experience. read more

See all

Stop in for dinner before an event. Really nice atmosphere and nicely decorated. The staff were great. The drinks were good. Had grilled Salmon & Calamari. The Salmon was excellent. The Calamari was a little greasy if it wasn't for that I would have gave them 5 stars. read more

Went for brunch on a Sunday at 11:30am. Not crowded at all which was great. Food was decent and servers were pleasant. Overall, nothing amazing but not bad place to go if you didn't make a brunch reservation elsewhere. read more

Carroll Place - French Toast Brunch Eggs Benedict - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Same owners as Ainslie in Williamsburg so very similar menu/style. The brunch special was the same with $32 unlimited drinks INCLUDING entree which is great. However service was not great, we were seated for 30 minutes before anyone came and greeted us or anything. We had to ask a busser who our server was and he went to go grab someone. It was good they left carafes for us but food was decent. read more

Carroll Place - Brunch Pappardelle - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

As a dinner spot, there are probably better options out there. As a bar spot to go hang out on a weekend night with drinks and music, this might be the place for you. As for the dinner, the food was ok and service was just blah. The pizzas we ordered were charred all over and soggy. Picking up a slice resulted in the whole thing slipping off and turning into a pile of greasy soggy dough with random pizza ingredients sprinkled all around. The pasta dishes were good but barely enough to call a complete meal for one person. Service was not memorable. We asked for any recommendations and got a dismissive answer. We didn't want to order drinks or appetizers at the time so the waiter got annoyed. He barely showed up to check in on us and just didn't seem welcoming. The best was when he came and gave us the check so we could pay and finally leave this place to get a second meal elsewhere cause this place just did not cut it. read more

See all

We went to this place for a friend's birthday dinner . Upon walking in, the place was really cute! The service started off, shaky. We had a party of 18 and the tables that they gave us was just not picking up to suit our party. We asked to be moved to a different area, but they said they had a bigger party. However, they ended up moving us to that place, which was interesting because I thought they said they had a party. It ended up that they did have a party. We just got there first. I'm glad they moved us because it was definitely more comfortable. The bottom is option was all or nothing but that's pretty typical for a restaurant in the city. We got the some appetizers: - Caesar salad was made out of spinach. Spinach leave the weird taste in my mouth which has nothing to do with the restaurant. The salad was good. -The Meatballs were so good. Not dry and very flavorful. -The Fries were incredible. They had a hint of truffle flavor. They also had a nice bite to them. - The brussels sprouts were cooked well. I wish they were more saucy. - The pizza was floppy but decent. I'm overall not a huge pizza fan but I liked the thinness of the crust. - The penne alla vodka lacked a decent amount of sauce for me. I needed more of that creamy tomato sauce. - The chicken was kind of dry but okay. After like 10pm, the place turned into a club vibe. The music was bumping and it was a nice mix between current and oldies songs. I would recommend! read more

See all

Fun place, nice ambiance, cool interior. Gets very crowded as it gets closer to noon for brunch. They have large bar area with high top tables, a large back dining room, an upstairs dining room And a covered outdoor seating area. It's a fun environment, but it does get loud, so if you want a quiet place, to have a conversation, this is NOT it! There is a bathroom Downstairs but also a single bathroom on main floor. Menu is larger than it looks and all dishes were nicely presented, good portions and tasty. Lots of vegetarian options. I had the eggs with tomato sauce and polenta which was excellent . Other dishes were good as well, no pics Unfortunately. They have a bottomless brunch, I think for $30, which def seemed worth it. read more

See all

The fourth star is definitely for the bottomless mimosa brunch that you can choose mimosas bloodies or sangria. The food was legitimately good though as well. But the Pride can't be beat. $30 includes your brunch entree (which can include pizzas and can also include some other things at an upcharge). I got the eggs Benedict which were a little small but came with fries and a nice looking salad. Girlfriend got an omelette that came with toast, fries and a salad (even though these weren't listed on the menu so it is a full plate you get). Food was good. Mimosas were also good. read more

Carroll Place - Eggs Benedict - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Good spot for chill drinks at the bar - wines are around $12 per glass and if you sit at the bar you can watch them make pizzas in the wood fired oven. We snacked on the 3 for $18 cheeses - Gorgonzola / Manchego / Pecorino di toscano, which came with bread. Would like to come back for happy hour! read more

Carroll Place - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

This place makes me nostalgic. The food is well, pretty bad, but if you're coming for that bottomless brunch price, it's perfect. I ALWAYS have fun here - it is my "broke but want to brunch" spot with my friends, but yeah, gonna drill it in, the food is unimpressive. I've only ever been for brunch, so maybe other menus are a bit tastier! read more

I came here with a big group and we had a $40 per person family style meal. All was fairly good, and the highlights to me were the parpadelle Ragu (the pasta tasted so fresh) and the burrata. The chicken was also well done. The Nutella pizza (really calzone) was interesting with ricotta cheese inside but it could have a bit more Nutella drizzle on top. Other things we had were: Meatballs, fries (wish it was fried a little bit more crispy), Broccoli Rabe, Margherita pizza, penne vodka, and arugula salad. We had vegetarians so our dishes skewed that way. read more

See all

A great spot for a cheap bottomless brunch. For $30, you get an entree AND unlimited mimosas, sangria, or bloody marys. You can switch between drinks whenever you want. Be mindful that the 90-minute seating time starts exactly at your reservation time, even if the whole party isn't there yet. If you're doing bottomless, I'd suggest ordering the drinks right when you sit down to get your money's worth! They have a pretty extensive selection of entree options, from pizza to pasta to burgers to traditional eggs benedict. There really is something for everyone. I got the eggs benedict, and I have to say it was the smallest eggs benedict I've ever had. I feel like with most benedict plates, the eggs are the shining star, but the salad and fries on the plate basically swallowed it up. Although small, it was tasty. I wish there was more prosciutto than the measly see-through slice that was on there. The fries were done really well and were probably my favorite part of the meal. Overall, this is a good place if you're looking for a cheap brunch. The drinks were on the weaker side (heavy on the OJ), but once they started flowing, it did the trick. It's also a good place for large parties as they have a lot of large tables. read more

Carroll Place - Tartufo Pizza - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Came here for bottomless brunch and you can get the mimosa and sangria non-stop with an entree of your choice (but limited). I got the shakshuka and wasn't blown away - probably the worst shakshuka I've had which was much more egg whitey than it was eggs bathed in tomato sauce. Like that it was clearly put in the oven and had a nice broil around it, but def be careful as it's super hot when first handed to you. The sangria didn't really taste like sangria and the mimosa was very sour/harsh and not the best but I will say that this is a GREAT deal for bottomless brunch if that's what you're looking for. You have an hour and half to go as hard as you can with the drinks so just be mindful of that. The bathroom is super nice though and very clean. read more

Carroll Place - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

An amazing family style deal! $65 menu and unlimited wine, beer, and sangria for 2 hours! Located in the heart of Greenwich Village, this is a steal. Arancini was crispy. Chicken wings were cooked perfect. Meatballs were very good and burrata was the best appetizer. Loved the mix of Italian and American classics! Dinner consisted of free range wood fire chicken, penne alla vodka, and the blank angus hanger steak was cooked perfectly. And you can't leave without trying the Nutella pizza for dessert! Perfect for a girls night out or family dinner. Check out their schedule for live performances. read more

Carroll Place - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Refuse to give you a cup of water when you need it at 2 am when your friends are paying patrons

Had the rucola pizza, it was okay. My friends hated their pastas so would maybe stick to the pizza if anything! Decent ambiance, the pizza tasted okay but it was so insanely soggy I had to hold my fork beneath it and slide it back as I took a bite so it wouldn't just flop over and lose all of the toppings. read more

Carroll Place - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

I'm not sure if you necessarily have to make reservations on a weeknight as there's plenty of seating in the back. They have different nights, but the night that I went with my friends it was karaoke night. But didn't stay for that as it was at 9pm and it was a Wednesday night. I'm not trying to stay out late and take the train back late at night. I did see a stage setup with instruments on it. I guess it is a live acoustic set that people sing songs with? Unto the food items, everything was great. The pizza, the shrimp scampi, the burrata were good and it came out altogether to start the dinner off with. Afterwards, came the entrees which were the orecchiette and pappardelle (I think was handmade as it said fresh pasta). It was all great and we finished everything off. The only thing that I didn't like was how there was only one server for the entire back area. So service was a bit slow moving. But otherwise there were no complaints. read more

See all

Came here for brunch. I order the good morning pizza with prosciutto and eggs. and a burger with Gonzalo cheese and Truffle fries. We did the Unlimited brunch for $30 per person. because it is cheaper than ordering a drink and food. The portion size is generous. The food was good. Love the ambiance, very quaint and cozy. The service was fast. I recommend this place for a fun time. Like a Birthday party. read more

I was here for a friend's birthday dinner and she made a reservation for 18 people a couple months ago. When we arrived, we were seated at a table that was too small for our party. We asked if we could be moved and at first they said no because they had another big party coming in. Eventually they did move us to a larger table and it was much better. We had the family style dinner and we also opted to do the unlimited wine, beer and soda option. I felt like the unlimited drinks were not brought out quickly enough for it to feel like it was worth it. The waitress would come over every so often to ask if we wanted more wine or we would have to ask for more. We were a large party and went through the two bottles she would drop off fairly quickly. I think it would be more efficient if the wine bottles came more often without having to ask. The food was really good! The truffle fries were so delicious- the perfect amount of crunch and flavor. The Brussels sprouts were cooked well. The meatballs were juicy, and had the right amount of sauce. The Penne Alla vodka could've used more sauce but it was still good. I didn't care for the wood-fired Nutella pizza that we had for dessert. My piece tasted burnt and dry. More variety for desserts would be nice. At the end of our dinner, a waiter brought us all a round a free vodka sodas which was a nice touch! After 10pm the whole restaurant turned into. Bar/ club scene. The DJ was playing hit after hit, and I almost didn't want to leave. Overall, I had a good time here and I would return! read more

See all

The food here is good and what you would expect for the price point. We had the margarita pizza, ceaser salad and truffle fries. It's very cosy inside, great lighting and clean but the musical selection had much to be desired. Minus one star for that. It's a romantic little spot but the club music bumping wasn't necessary. Server was nice and we didn't feel rushed. read more

The bar tenders lost my card, blamed it on me, were really rude when they finally found my card after me having to tell them it's at their register. Then, they added their own tip which is technically larceny!! I saw multiple dollars added to the charge when it cleared. You've been warned!! read more

Nice ambiance but the prices on the menu are a couple bucks lower than what they will charge you so... read more

Carroll Place - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

On the positive side, the ambiance of Carroll Place is pretty nice - well furnished with a cozy vibe. Though we didn't stay for it, I thought it was cool to see open mic karaoke with a live band being setup as we were finishing our meal. The spot is spacious too - easily able to accommodate slightly larger party sizes via seating at the back but also having a decently sized bar for a more casual setting at the front. The food and drinks however was a bit of a let down.... they were watery and bland. I got the Love Season cocktail and one of my friends got the You Must Chill. Both sounded good on paper, but tasted watered down and frankly.... bland! The Calamari was ok - decent size portion too. The Brussel Sprouts were unevenly cooked - some were a done nicely, others were raw or even overcooked and burnt! The dish was pretty oily and didn't have much taste. The Cauliflower was very similar to the Brussel sprouts in terms of inconsistency (see how some have a dark char yet others look a little raw in my photo). The Amatriciana I got was probably the best thing I had - the dough was soft and bouncy despite being thin. The sauce/toppings was pretty salty though. Though not pictured, I did try the Free Range Chicken which my friend ordered, and this was by far the worse item of the night. The chicken was flavorless and so overcooked it was basically dehydrated, the broccoli rabe was bathing in oil and the mashed potatoes were so incredibly salty. I tried eating it by having a mouthful of each element as well as eating each element separately... both were bad. Pretty disappointing visit. I'd come back for drinks at the bar but won't be getting food. read more

See all

Went here for dinner on a Saturday night. We had a variety of different dishes. Pasta, pizza, truffle oil fries, etc. The food was pretty good. The service was pretty attentive. The place had a rustic chic vibe to it. All in all, a good experience. I would go back again for dinner. I've also been here for drinks and it's a fun crowd for that as well. read more

Dinner plans? Look no further than carroll place, an Italian American Gem with Gastropub twist. From Happy hour specials to Live Music nights ( after 9 PM ) , it's a perfect blend of delicious dishes and vibrant vibes. A must go-to-spot for creating unforgettable memories. featured Meatball in Pomodoro Margherita Pizza Endive salad with Salmon Grilled Hanger Steak Linguini Vongole Chocolate Cake Strawberry Sorbet All the food was excellent, we really enjoyed the dinner with live music . read more

See all

Good for parties and events. Staff is accommodating for the most part. Quality of food is great for price.

Amazing! Amazing! Amazing! This was such a charming dinner experience, aside from the Uber soft and warming interior, the staff provided the most unbelievably welcoming service. The entire place was full of smiles and laughter from happy diners. I had an unforgettable dinner with some friends where we opted for Carroll Place's new family style dinner menu which offers an array of appetizers and entrees to choose from, and dessert plus a bottomless beverage add-on. We got to select 4 appetizers and 3 entrees, and all decided to sip on endless rose. Our starter choices were Arancini, Calamari, Rosemary Wings and a Cheese and Meat Charcuterie board served with honey and soft bread. Our shared entrees were Margherita Pizza, Hanger Steak and Penne a la Vodka alongside Truffle Fries and Broccolini as sides! The huge sweeping meal then wrapped up with a Nutella Calzone Pizza, would definitely recommend for an intimate group celebrating something special or just looking to have a great time over a delicious feast. Thank you Carroll Place! read more

See all

Absolutely loved this place, great service, music and food. Worth every dollar highly recommended it read more

Carroll Place - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Carroll Place is a no-nonsense place to get cheap bottomless brunch, and that's about it. The food is alright but nothing special - in fact, I would've given this place 3 stars for food alone but their bottomless brunch drink prices are very affordable. For that alone, try coming here if that's what you're looking for. Just don't expect mind blowing gastronomy. FOOD: Penne (4/5) - the pasta was good and the sauce was flavorful. Nothing special or out of this world, but a safe option! Buon Giotto Pizza (3/5) - the pizza actually added a few dollars to my brunch prix fixe total and it was basically a flatbread with egg on top. Solid meal with protein and carbs to absorb the alcohol, but not that good. read more

Carroll Place - Penne Piselli - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Brunch : crowd is very young. Like 20s...which is okay off your okay with the age range. Maybe it isn't like this all the time but it is also in Greenwich which is a pretty young area. The ambiance is dark and dark lol we sat in the back which is dark and a lot of wood. It was a nice day outside, so I really wanted to get back outside and enjoy the daylight, but we came for brunch so we stayed for the entire hour and a half bottomless time limit. So about the bottomless : awful. Like legit AWFUL. The drinks are terrible. Prob the worst mimosa I've ever had, and the whole table agreed. They are pre batched and taste like the frozen Minute Maid orange juice mixed with the cheapest champagne. So so bad. The Bloody Mary was tolerable. I suggest you add hot sauce to it, it's still bad, but I drank it because we were paying to drink them. I will say the steak and eggs was really good, so that def saved the day. I ordered the steak med rare and it was cooked perfectly. I did add some salt to it, but I wasn't disappointed in the food. On that note, if they made the bottomless drinks better it would be a great place for brunch. read more

I came in for a couple of drinks. I had 2 tequilas neat. I was charged an extra $4 neat charge. The music was good but I wouldn't come back. I wonder if that is a thing now. read more

Carroll Place - My NEAT charge. - Italian Near Me - New York, New York