I created a cookie box with 3 flavors from Caroline's Cookies, and overall it was a really enjoyable experience. The facility itself was very clean and bright, and the smell of vanilla and sugar in the air was such a nice touch as soon as you walked in. The staff was extremely friendly and welcoming, which made the visit even better.
The cookies & cream cookie was decadent and very rich -- so rich that I couldn't finish it on my own and had to share. Definitely indulgent and satisfying.
The lemon blackberry sugar cookie sandwich was my favorite. The poppy seeds added a beautiful crunch, and the blackberry jam paired perfectly with the creamy filling. It was sweet, but not overly sugary, which made it really well balanced and enjoyable.
The only one that didn't quite hit for me was the chocolate chip cookie slice, which tasted a bit too doughy -- almost like raw cookie dough -- and just wasn't my preference.
The packaging was clean, sturdy, and nicely presented, and everything held up well. Overall, a great experience with standout flavors, a welcoming atmosphere, and excellent customer service. I'd definitely be open to trying more flavors in the future. read more