Excellent fresh seafood Love the lobster roll. Stuffed with lobster. Also have good Stromboli in the freezer case

Great pre prepared food. Prices are honestly way too high. Great service. Deli ambiance.

I love the variety of crab cakes here. I was craving for crab cakes so my boyfriend went and got me some. We tried different ones, some we liked more than others. Overall it was interesting to taste the different ones. Still my favorite is a plain crab cake not battered and without any fillers that is nicely seared. Capt'n Chucky's Crab Cake is a nice addition to the area. read more

Seafood is the best. Prices are reasonable. Yum is all I can say. Very helpful when picking out your meal. Thank you ! read more

Finally tried this place and am annoyed I hadn't done so earlier! I did not catch that you actually cook your own food so it is not a takeout place or you're going to grab food and go eat real quick. That was my bad. You get seafood options already made and the quick directions to heat them up. It didn't take long. We got a crab cake, a shrimp cake, a crab and shrimp roll, and a clam chowder. All suuuuper yummy. read more

Everything we have purchased has been first rate quality. The new owners are as delightful as the previous owners. read more

best customer service! i have to come back this is the best crab cake i have ever had. i love you guys and this is my first try!!! keep it up cutest restaurant ever. read more

Good frozen seafood selection and tasty seafood. We've been buying seafood here for over two years. The former owner had nice positive things to about the new owners. read more

Went to Captain Chucky's in Colmar today and found the BEST shrimp for shrimp cocktail; they are large, delicious, snappy shrimp for a surprisingly good price. I also bought the macaroni and cheese because it looked so good. My son said it might be the best he's ever tasted. I'll be going back soon! read more

Captain Chucky's is usually good. Yesterday, 02/14/2023, not so much. I called to see if they had two Smith Islands. CC Yes, we have plenty. Five minutes later I got there and asked for two, the guy asked what else, and I said that's all. He went in the back for a couple minutes. Meanwhile the woman up front started ringing me out. When I handed her my credit card for the $18.00 charge, she asked if I had cash, I said no. Why? CC we don't like to take a card for charges under $20.00. She took it anyway. Just a strange interaction, but then came my dinner. The crabcake was tasteless and dry. I know what a crabcake is supposed to be, and this wasn,t it. Maybe because I didn't want something more, he threw some crap together. I gave this two stars because it was edible, whatever it was. read more

Great food at very reasonable prices. Everything I've tried has been great so far. Also the staff is very friendly.

Best crab cake ever...no filling just pure lumps! It's darn shame that yelp requires me to type more because the only thing you need is the image to go along! Nice job Capt'n Chucky! read more

Capt'n Chucky's Crab Cake Co, Colmar - crab cake and crab cake - Seafood Near Me - Colmar, Pennsylvania

i dont have the most sophisticated pallette but when you compare the crab cakes here with the ones at wegmans, it blows wegmans away. i love wegmans too and was surprised at the margin. just get their signature one which i can't recall the name. there's one with old bay seasoning and i do not endorse that one. just get their signature crab cake and thank me later. oh also the guy in charge, i believe his name is frank, he has had the COOLEST past career in his life. ask him sometime. so damn cool. read more

See all

First time ordering from Capt'n Chucky's and I would absolutely do it again. The woman and man I spoke with on the phone to place my order had outstanding customer service. I ordered a little bit of everything. King crab legs, crab cakes, fish fillets, sides, and dessert. Everything was outstanding!! Everyone who ate couldn't stop saying how good everything was. Overall experience was top notch and look forward to ordering again. Thank you Capt'n Chucky's! read more

This place is the epitome of fresh and delicious seafood. Period. The crab cakes are really something to behold - especially the Smith Island and Signature varieties. But regardless of your particular tastes and preferences, they actually have a crab cake for you. Breaded, not breaded, lump, imperial, zero filler, or even stuffed into a big portobello... I assure you, Capt'n Chucky's has a crab cake for you. There are amazing "grab-and-go" specials each and every week, and lots of frozen options to choose from to satisfy every taste. Even their coleslaw is something special. This weekend, I had the distinct opportunity to purchase FRESH (never frozen) Alaskan King Crab flow in directly from Dutch Harbor, AK. It's been my experience that obtaining such a rare treat has normally been limited to folks residing IN Alaska or at least the Pacific Northwest. Oh boy, did the family-run Capt'n Chucky's deliver!!!! King Crab is sweet and delicious even when flash-frozen at the docks, but this fresh delivery was so very special. I'm talking the sweetest melt-in-your-mouth thing you've ever tasted. I'll be a rather frequent visitor to this little gem in Colmar! Thank you Terri and family!! read more

Capt'n Chucky's Crab Cake Co, Colmar - crab legs in a sink - Seafood Near Me - Colmar, Pennsylvania

The people that own this business are absolutely amazing! I always buy my seafood from them for Christmas Eve. They made a small mistake on my order today. Nothing that couldn't be fixed. And they gave me something free for my trouble. Totally unnecessary, but thanks! Awesome customer service and great seafood! read more

Wow! Had this week's special, a colossal crab cake dinner, with crab critters, stuffed mushrooms, and dessert and loved it all! We were limited to celebrating our 50th anniversary at home and Terri and Al took good care of us and made our celebration great. We will certainly be back soon! Sue and Larry read more

This place is great! They have a good selection of sides, desserts, and frozen soups, but if you're going there, your focus should be the crab cakes. They're so good that it's just not even worth it to make them from scratch. I have always gotten the Signature crab cakes and have never been disappointed. The format is "cook at home" so they give you a set of clear directions on your options for cooking them. They even throw in a little container of butter you can use in their suggested cooking process. Besides the absolutely delicious crab cakes, what keeps me coming back is the incredibly friendly and knowledgeable staff. They have always been able to answer any questions I have and seem to really care that you have a positive experience. I know this is a newer store (they have several other locations in the greater Philadelphia area), so I hope people in this area will support them so they stick around (and so I don't have to commute to buy my crab cakes). read more

Lobster roll was ok not great. I thought it was a little expensive for small pieces of lobster. It was bland and seemed to be made the night before. read more

I love this place! I've been three or four times now and am thrilled that there is a location in Colmar. The seafood is without peer in the area. I have had almost the entire menu and nothing has disappointed. Obviously for a first visit you have to start with the crab cakes but the soups are delicious as well. The service is quick and effective, you don't waste a lot of time in line or for the food, it's extremely fast and extremely fresh. The place doesn't pretend to be anything other than what it is - fresh seafood. The owners are the best part of the experience. They are so knowledgeable, passionate, and will do absolutely anything they can to make your visit a great one! They have a true sense of joy behind the counter and you can't help but walk out of there with a smile on your face! I would absolutely go back and plan to use them for parties and all my seafood needs! read more

I've lived in the area for 10 years and finally gave this place a try. I was a bit skeptical given its location, seafood place next to flooring warehouse. I was pleasantly surprised. First, love the online ordering app!! So easy to order and pay. Pick up experience easy and fast. Now for the food. Wild caught steamed shrimp were amazing, meaty and fresh and steamed just right. The shrimp were well cleaned, no vein. Price point reasonable, better than Whole Foods and Wegmans. Captains mega colossal crab cakes had lots of lump crab meat, sweet and no bits of shell! Decided to try one of their sauces for the crab cake and got the Sabi sauce, great sauce for dipping anything, crab, fish, shrimp, or chicken. The wasabi crab spread was fresh and creamy and delicious. There are a lot of seafood options on the menu and I will be returning soon. Food is fresh and the store is clean, no fishy smell. Prices are reasonable. read more

I recently held my annual Cousins Party. For a change I included Smith Island Crab Cakes as one of the two dinner entrees. Just 15 minutes from box, to oven, to table. It was a huge hit! Jumbo lump crabmeat with a bare minimum of filler, and a distinct taste of Imperial. I highly recommend. read more

Absolutely the best crab cakes. Our first visit we tried 4 different crab cakes and shrimp salad. Yum! Smith Island was our favorite, but they were all delicious. Going back this week to pick up crab cakes and scallops for a very special birthday dinner! read more

I am beyond disappointed! I called Saturday to order 60 Shrimp to pickup up Christmas eve and was told they were not taking anymore orders. I called back and was told I should come to the store when they open and there would be plenty of shrimp. Got up early, made the trip and was told I was limited to 1 pound of shrimp. Eleven guests splitting 18 shrimp doesn't cut it. Not a very good way to do business. read more

I had the misfortune of my wife bringing home a cream of crab soup from this place. The soup was, without a doubt, the most disgusting soup I have ever had in my mouth. It was totally bland (zero taste!) and had the consistency of wall paste. I asked her if she bought it at Home Depot. She tried it and started laughing out loud...and simply took the container and threw it in the trash. Next up...the crab cakes, which were OK, at best. Certainly nothing to rave about and a far cry from a quality crab cake product. Look, the only people who could find anything good about the food in this place would be folks who simply have absolutely no idea what decent seafood is supposed to taste like. Quite frankly, Red Lobster has better quality seafood and that place is beyond horrific. Avoid this place at all costs...just hit the drive thru at McDonald's and grab a filet o fish sandwich instead. read more

WOW usually when an order is placed in plenty of time you can count on it to be ready??? NOT HERE!!!! Maybe the owners should train their employees to properly handle speaking to customers with some knowledge of the product. Very disappointed... read more

Excellent local seafood shop. I've been here a couple of times and I'm a fan and will keep coming back. The crab cakes are the main event however the other items they have are also very good. And the Sami sauce is great. I'd recommend the Smith Island crab cakes of all the types they offer but you can't go wrong. read more

I am picky with seafood. Decided to stop in for a pound of shrimp to give them a try. Not only did they look great and were huge, they were very fresh. I will be going back soon! read more

Good place to grab some seafood to go. Whether is crab cakes, lobster tail or a frozen meal. The owner is friendly.

Have eaten their crab cakes and shrimp. Really really good! If you are in the area of Colmar this should be a destination.

This place is fantastic! It is a hidden gem. The seafood is fresh. Prices are extremely reasonable and food is delicious. I can't wait to go back! read more

I had gotten manhattan clam chowder a good while ago and was very disappointed that it was not very good. So I thought let me try them again-big mistake! I will say the crab cake was good. however the lobster cake was awful and smelled funny-threw it out. I had also gotten some frozen wild flounder-awful smelled funny-threw it out. Never again-wasted money. read more

I love this store! The crab cakes are the best ever. I have been told I am a 'shrimp snob' and this place has the best deep sea wild caught shrimp I have ever tasted. I am hooked! You can get live or cooked crabs from Maryland in the summer and no need to drive to Maryland for them... read more

Fresh and delicious seafood. Best shrimp cocktail around too!! The staff is very friendly too.

I love the crab cakes and shrimp. My opinion is the shrimp is the best you can get. Everything I have had there was awesome. I like the fact that I can get a complete meal and they even have the meal of the week. Every week a new meal for a great price $6.99. You just cant beat it - I met the owner, Scott, and he is very pleasant and happy to help. read more

Best Seafood ever. I have eaten seafood from Mass. to the gulf coast and there is no better place for crab cakes or shrimp. I have purchased many seafood items and loved them all. Highly recommend. read more