Cancel

Open app

Search

Caffinated New Yorker

4.4 (16 reviews)
Closed • 9:00 am - 5:00 pm

Caffinated New Yorker Photos

Business Info

CAFFINATED NEW YORKER ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

More like Caffinated New Yorker

Recommended Reviews - Caffinated New Yorker

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

blueberry scone
Amanda W.

Coffeee is good but the pastries are mid, my blueberrry scone is ehh, and the ham and cheese croissant was just ok. The service was nice and decor was good but I don't love it, its a big space and theres more seating in the back, but its very family and baby loud.

Hasti P.

Cozy little spot with quality coffee & variety of pastries. Definitely one of the nicest coffee shops on the island (although the neighborhood is not ideal) but I hope they thrive.

Fruit Croissant, latte and Egg-sausage and ham sandwich.
S G.

Excepcional place! This place is so cozy and breathtaking inside! I had breakfast and a pastry and it was so good! So fresh and delicious! The best coffee latte! I can't wait to bring my friends! They have brunch as well!

Rhea Z.

Very cute inside. Such a warm vibe for sure. This would be a great spot to do some work on a laptop or just to sip your coffee. Service was good. Barista was very nice. I quite didn't like that the food is out. They do serve lunch which I didn't get to try. Tried the blueberry coconut cold brew along with a donut. Donut was delish. So light and airy not too sweet. The cold brew wasn't really my thing. I'll be back to try more of the lunch menu and other coffees as well.

The maple cinnamon cappuccino was rich and delicious. The food was yummy, better than I anticipated for what I thought was going to be to basic coffee shop menu. The portions were decent sizes too. The chef came out to check that the orders were enjoyable. Very professional. But what I appreciated most was the excellent and attentive staff that were so understanding of my 2 year and his shenanigans. They brought us games to keep him busy, and they were very understanding about his behavior. They let us take up a 4 person table so he had space to get up and move around (within reason). Very family-friendly establishment. So grateful and will be returning!

matcha latte
nadine c.

Great cafe in the neighborhood, grilled cheese on sour dough was so good!! matcha latte perfect! lovely staff , this place is so beautiful and comfy to hang at. wish you were open later during the week we would pop by for after school coffee

See all

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Alex L.
0
29
37

4 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 month ago

I've had much better experiences here, the pastries are okay, the food is good. Overpriced, The chef is cool.....

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 2
Love this 0
Oh no 1

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 1
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of S G.
0
6
11

11 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 months ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0
Photo of Gee M.
0
12
0

10 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Caffinated New Yorker

Review Highlights - Caffinated New Yorker

“Their prices are so affordable, absolutely the cheapest of any staten island café (even their specialty lattes max out at about $5!) where as many other cafés shamelessly charge almost $10.”

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Cafes 21,758 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Cafe Juliet

Cafe Juliet

4.1(90 reviews)
2.9 mi
•$$

Meeting a friend after 7 years who actually came all the way to the island just to meet me was…read morespecial moment. I ordered my favorite French toast & he ordered a Juliet's BLT . He said it was delicious! I also had the caramel iced coffee, yummy ! Cucumber service was great! Can't wait to come back !

Ok so we were on the Island today Saturday 9/26/26 running some errands in this rainy & windy Nor'…read moreEaster; Believe it or not we stopped at Charlie's Café off of 440 we bought breakfast never ate it because my 9:00 AM appointment with Majestic auto detailer got screwed up on their behalf should've known we were gonna bat a zero today.... We were starving like Marvin !! Lol !! So we yelped this Cafe Juliet's !!! What can I say? I could barely give this place a big three stars at best !!! Let's start here; their order system you walk up to the counter and you look at these huge single menus. You pick what you want and then you give your order; then if you're staying you get a number on a stick and you go to a table and sit down and wait for them to deliver your food... but wait; if you ordered hot beverages as we did two large coffees, they'll call your name and you gotta go back up there and pick up your own coffees and bring them back to your table .. Let's start with their coffee; we found their regular coffee to be a little disappointing; my coffee would be more like some kind of a watered down tea with a hint of Cardamom in it.. I asked my wife four times this taste like tea not coffee even she agreed; she went up to the counter and asked the gentleman. What kind of coffee do you guys use ?? honestly a very disappointing cup of coffee in my opinion... So we ordered a stack of pancakes; we ordered the ones with caramel came with fruit, bananas, blueberries walnuts; we both agreed this is the star of the show order the pancakes You won't be disappointed.... Don't forget to ask for butter this place serves pancakes without butter ?? I really wanted an American breakfast. Thought I was gonna get some corn beef hash & eggs ?? Not here in fact the Girl told me she only had two kinds of omelettes on the menu ?? The Wife wanted a simple bacon, egg and cheese on something preferably a bagel; but they only had a plain bagel croissant or a brioche ??? So she opted for a BLT; she ended up getting that on a brioche; not your American BLT for sure. I guess they use some kind of high end organic bacon or something ; Sorry it was just OK.... Found the bacon to be a bit gamy tasting.. I ordered the cream cheese and lox on a bagel with a Schmear; this was also pretty good; the Bagel for me is an epic fail definitely not a real authentic Bagel definitely a commercial Bagel trust me I know I use to own a bagel store so what I did was I just slid the cream cheese and the lox to 1/2 of the bagel and ate half. Take a look at the pictures the food looks incredible; the way they plate it & present it very nice !!! After watching all the clientele that were coming in and going out, we could tell this is for the younger kids, younger generation, the millennials the yuppies and I mean no disrespect by that !! Very big coffee selection cold and hot; as far as the cold beverage selection, just take a look at the pictures; when you look in their refrigerators and you could only really identify two of the beverages by their brand names, Ya just know this spot just might not be for you.... Lol The service was great; very fast and friendly; their dining room room was very clean; just a heads up we were freezing today; mind you I had sweatpants on and a hoodie and I was cold. The door seems to stay open so I can imagine how it's gonna get in there in the colder months... tip; if you don't like to be cold while dining move as close as you can to the kitchen; we watched three tables, get up and move closer to the kitchen because they were complaining about the cold air coming in.... We've been in the food business for years and what we learned is this; KISS AND THAT STANDs STANDS FOR KEEP IT SIMPLE STUPID !! we found it works over 50 years in business, maintain consistency, and integrity. It will never fail you... Would I highly recommend this place? Honestly, no.; would I come back again yes no maybe if I was in the area. would I drive out of my way like I did today 20 minutes to get here? Definitely not. Oh, one more thing let's not forget about their prices $$$$ $58. Bucks plus a $10. Tip For semi table service we for it to be a little pricey. What can we say? Give them a try & definitely have the pancakes and sneak in your own coffee !! Lol !!! Thanks, Greg D & family

Photos
Cafe Juliet
Cafe Juliet - Avocado Burrata Toast 10/10

Avocado Burrata Toast 10/10

Cafe Juliet - Maple and caramel latte

See all

Maple and caramel latte

The Basement - Billionaire Oysters

The Basement

4.6(88 reviews)
1.0 mi•St. George

Great vibe, calm upstairs then club downstairs easy to get too. Always had security close by and…read morebartenders were moving quickly.

I want to start this review by stating that the food was wonderful, the ambience and decor was…read moreoutstanding and we just loved the overall vibe. Our waiter, Guiseppe was very attentive! We had a lovely night out with a couple who are our long time and good friends and we looked forward to this evening! However, there was a problem at the beginning of the evening that is unacceptable... my husband went to park the car, our friends were waiting at the bar for us, I walked in first. My friend ordered me an Aperol Spritz and my husband a diet coke. My husband does not drink and has been very successful with his sobriety for many years. The bartender, (I later found out her name is Maureen and apparently she is a manager there), misunderstood the drink order so my friend reiterated that we wanted a diet coke and an Aperol Spritz (two separate drinks). The "diet coke" arrived in a soda glass with a lemon wedge (just like a diet coke would) and the Aperol Spritz arrived in a cocktail glass. My husband took a sip of the "diet coke" and asked me if it tasted like there was liquor in it. Sure enough there was. We immediately returned it and the other bartender confirmed that it was a mix of Aperol Spritz with diet coke in the soda glass. My husband confronted the bartender and told her about her grievous mistaken and full disclosure, he said this is a "big f$%ken mistake you made". She took absolutely no responsibility for her error and shouted at him that she "was told to make a diet coke with Aperol Spritz". Truth be told, we clarified the drink order to her and why would she present the "diet coke" in a soda glass if it indeed was a cocktail. She went full "Karen mode" on him when she should have apologized. My request is that she re-trains in customer service and her ability to mix drinks! Like I said above, the food was excellent, the waiter was great, but this error is a serious error. People do make mistakes, but please acknowledge your mistakes and take care with serious issues. The dining experience was great, but I cannot give a 5 star due to the error.

Photos
The Basement
The Basement - Chocolate cappuccino

Chocolate cappuccino

The Basement - Hurricane

See all

Hurricane

Caffinated New Yorker - cafes - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...