Every year I go to their Easter buffet. 2026 is the worst. Not much selections. The staff was great. But the food wasn't. Desert table consisted of either small cube (one bite size) of either chocolate or carrot cake. Nothing else. Other years was worth paying the high price. The bread selection trays were always empty, unless you like rye and pumpernickle. After paying for 5 adults and one child, Over $200, plus tax and tips, I was extremely disappointed. I did, however give my waitress $30 tip for her great service. Next year, I'll still take the family to Easter brunch, but not at Caddyshack. read more

The last time I was there the food was terrible. I had a hamburger that tasted like shoe leather. Actually I am no longer impressed with any of their food. It seems to have all gone down hill. Can't anyone make a hamburger that is well done without tasting like shoe leather?? I can, perhaps I should work in the kitchen. As for service. I am so sick and tired of the same old guy waiting on me. Every time I go there it's him. How about some young blood! Get those young servers in the kitchen to come out and wait on tables. I am sure they could make a ton of tips. Have wait staff that actually engages the customers. As for the ambience I realized they just remodeled and it's an improvement, but there is room for a lot more improvement. So to some it up the place and the food is just boring! read more

Friday night Prime Rib special with a baked potato. Excellent all around, Mark was our waiter, great service! Drink specials as well. Highly recommend. read more

Great place for lunch. The Nashville hot chicken sandwich was true to its name and they had the new Tröegs IPA Graffiti on tap! Service was personal and attentive. A good time with friends read more

We used to love this place but things have really gone downhill. The wait staff is really friendly but the long wait for food can be a bit of an issue. The real problem though was the cooking and a potential health hazard. My family recently went to eat and ordered med well burgers. My son bit into the burger only to find it was completely raw. Not even rare but raw. I got the waitresses attention and she put the order in again only for another 30 minute wait for the replacement burger......only for the burger to be completely different than the original I ordered. There are a lot of good pub food places out there. Save yourself from getting sick and go somewhere else. The cool staff really needs to get it together bc our waitress was wonderful read more

Caddy Shack - a person holding a sandwich - American Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

AMAZING service and atmosphere! The bartender Michelle was so sweet and welcoming! The food here was most excellent, and the fact that there's sweet potato fries here will keep me coming back time and time again! Good job guys read more

Caddy Shack - Y'all finally got sweet potato fries and I'm here for it - American Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

For dinner I ordered ribs they were ok they were tender but not my favorite I prefer smoked ribs. The servers are great they were very nice, read more

Caddy Shack - Spare Ribs - American Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

French dip was really good. Even tho it didn't have cheese on it like it was supposed to. She had a chicken sandwich that was good, but a little dry. The crabby fries were good. I was given a lemon with my corona which was awful and the waiter wanted to try and say it was a lime that wasn't quite ripe. Lemons and limes are def not the same. Haha. The other couple that was with us had the Hawaiian wings and a burger. I had a wing. That was very good. I didn't try the burger, but how fast he ate it, I assume it was good. The waiter was nice, but not personable. read more

My time there was great! The manager told me the story of Denny Sealover and Ms. Mitchell is a great waitress and I found the most soul rendering image on the wall that scared me in my childhood and here it is!: read more

Caddy Shack - The Soul rendering Gopher that ruined my childhood! - American Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

I had the salmon salad with their vinaigrette dressing. The dressing was different from what I'm used to, but it was very good. The waiter was very nice and came back a couple of times to see if we needed anything and to refill drinks. The others that I was with, had chicken wings, that looked deli it and the waffle fries looked good, too. The ambiance, what can I say it is a bar/restaurant at a golf course, but very nice pace. read more

This place was okay. Just a typical sports bar with a decent menu. I got the bogey sandwich, which is basically just a turkey club on a pita roll. It was pretty good, but ultimately I wished that I had gotten something different. The sangria I had was alright, the fruit in it wasn't fresh, I could tell it was from a can. My fiancé very much enjoyed his meal, so overall this place was a success. read more

The last few times that we ate at the Caddy Shack was terrible. My ribs were dry and the salad was unsatisfactory. Everywhere when we go out to eat the prices and usually overpriced and the quality is not so good . read more

We had a large group of 20+ people. No worries @ Caddy Shack! We did call them a couple days ahead of time to let them know what time we would arrive. We were sat in the back part of the restaurant in a "room", but had a large door/window opening to see the TV's, etc. At our table (we had 5 of them), we started with this HUGE soft Pretzel. Oh my was it HOT, SOFT and Wicked Good! Loved the horseradish/mustard sauce. For me, I had the Fish and Chips, and she also had the Fish and Chips. Not sure who's sizing the portions, or what size fish was in the breading, but man it was BIG and Tasty! Fries were great too. Service? For a waitress who's on her "first job", she did great. small drink mixup, but she quickly fixed it. Parking is easy, as this is a golf club too. Love the movie themed plates. Noonan! haha. read more

We went here because we had won a Gift card at a benefit. We weren't sure what to expect, but we were pleasantly surprised. We were able to sit outside and watch the golfers which is quite entertaining. I have the veggie burger, which was so delicious you would've thought it was a crabcake. My husband had a salad with salmon, the salmon portion is rather large. Everything on the menu is decently priced, I would definitely go back. read more

Caddy Shack - First cut - American Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

Never been here and finally tried it. A good surprise. Was a perfect day with the weather to eat out side. We had a very good waitress. She was personable, polite, quick and attentive. The food was served surprisingly quick too. Everything tasted fine too. Had a salad with grilled chicken and it was a good portion with everything in it fresh. I recommend a visit if you haven't been. I reasonably priced spot read more

BANQUET SERVICE REVIEW - My high school class has had two reunions at Caddy Shack in the past few years. Banquet manager Karen B. is unbelievably accommodating, even willing to make sure guests with special dietary needs have the proper food. The staff handling our reunion dinner was friendly, helpful, and just plain wonderful. The food was delicious. Everyone was very pleased with the Caddy Shack food and service. I highly recommend Caddy Shack for small to medium-sized events. read more

This is a restaurant for us normal people as well as those of you that like a pint and a bite to eat after chasing a little white ball around a nicely manicured lawn while wearing cute little sun visors and shoes with thumb tacks on the bottom. Just kidding. It's a great local eatery. Food is what you'd expect from a golf course restaurant atmosphere. Family friendly, lots of after golf noshers, good selection of cold beers, and decent prices. They have daily specials for things like shrimp, clams, steaks, and wings. The wings are worth a trip. You even get to order them by a bucket that has a gopher on it (remember the movie . . . Caddy Shack . . . are you old enough to remember?). The bucket is great for use around the house when the wings are long gone. In the summer they have $1 burgers on Sundays. That's reason enough to sneak out of church early. Their best food is their "pub" food: the nachos, the wings, the beer, the artery clogging shack fries, the wings, the wings, the wings (did I mention the wings?), the burgers, the wings. All of the wing sauces are worth a try - they're all good, it just comes down to personal preference. Word of warning, you should mention that you want your wings to be well sauced. Sometimes they are served with too little and you spend your time trying to cover them before you eat them. The kid menu is great - everything except the ribs is $3.50 when I last checked and that included a drink. They have a big list of specials. People say the desserts are good, but I've never had room after food and beer. read more

Was feeling adventurous on 7/9/18 - ordered the PB&J wings. On paper they sounded good, but the product on the plate was quite horrible. So why 3-stars? I've had over 10 lunches over the last 7-8 years and they've been pretty decent. The chicken wings, if you can call it that, were full of bones where the meat is supposed to be. The quality of the wing itself was bad. The sauce is supposed to be a peanut sauce similar to a Thai satay sauce. This tasted thick, liquid peanut butter. It's supposed to be served with a raspberry vinaigrette dipping sauce. The combination of wing and dip made the dish too sweet, not in a good way. Did I mention the celery - it was good! It was happy hour. The drinks were good...perhaps a different appetizer next time! read more

The food was fine and the waitstaff was also very polite: however, in the age of coronavirus, no one was wearing a mask (not patrons or servers that were visible) and no social distancing was happening. If you have concerns about the coronavirus, I truly suggest you go elsewhere. We will not be back. While Cumberland county is green, there are still certain restrictions that are expected to be in place which was clearly not the concern at Caddy Shack. read more

Now I remember why we stopped coming here. Came back for the first time in a few years last night. I ordered the "Rocky" burger. It's a burger with salami, sautéed onion, and sharp provolone on an onion roll. So much potential. The burger came out with one of those little red plastic sticks that said "rare" on it. No idea why as I was never asked what temp I wanted my burger. It turned out to be pretty funny as the burger was hammered. Absolutely hammered. Like, it was once a piece of meat that had been chemically transformed into plastic hammered. The burger itself was carbonized on one side. The salami was magically turned into beef jerky. There was three onions on the whole thing. It was easily among the worst burgers I've ever had and I couldn't even eat it since it hurt my teeth. My daughter and hubby liked their fish and chips, so that's a plus. But dear lord, please learn how to cook a simple burger. read more

This place was fantastic. Great atmosphere and awesome food. We were part of a large party and the server was on top of things. She got all our orders, kept the drinks filled and was super friendly. We started with the Super big Pretzel, so delicious, for 4 people. It was a meal. Then had the fish and fries. The portion of fish was very large. I ate it instead of wasting time of the fries, but did have a few :) If I am ever in the area again, I will definitely go again. read more

Its been many years since I have been here. This visit the dinners were half price during the month. The food quality was ok. None of it would be worth paying full price. I'm not sure how the rest of the menu is. Our meals came out quickly and were hot.The servicer was fair. Drink refills were hard to come by. And she was not real attentive to our table. I might come back. But on this visit there was nothing that stood out. read more

One of my favorite places, the staff is phenomenal, great bartenders, great servers. Food is sports bar comfort faire, don't expect gourmet, but always fulfilling and reasonably priced. Only negative is that they're not open all year round. read more

What a difference a few weeks makes. We loved the wings on our first visit, but on our return they were different--dry with no sauce. My husband liked the steak Diane I ordered the last time, so he ordered it this time. He gave me a taste and I was shocked to taste a sweet, Marsala-type sauce--once again, entirely different and unpleasant, I might add. I ordered Chicken Oscar. The "hollandaise" was clumpy and coagulated and tasted more like a butter sauce than a hollandaise. I doubt we'll be back after this bad experience and it's a shame. Did they change cooks? I did enjoy the mango mojito though. read more

We come to the Caddy Shack for our family's annual "finalizing our thanksgiving plans while eating cheap food" dinner. We enjoy the ritual and taking advantage of the November Customer Appreciation Month 50% off dinner menu. Its usually a good crowd when we go and the menu is pretty varied with yummy things both on and off the special's menu. The service is very friendly and efficient and its just an overall good time. Usually I get the steak and although its a little fatty, its tasty and it comes with your choice of starch or vegetable and a salad which is actually quite good. They have a good selection of dressing and yummy croutons. The wings are good and crispy and the fries are good too. We also had the chicken parmesan which was a hit with everyone and the kids had pizza which was remarkable. Overall this is a fun place to go and especially fun when its customer appreciation time. read more

Caddy Shack - Half price dinner menu for November - American Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

See all

We have gotten take out a few times over the pandemic and their timing is always right, food order is always correct and easy to get safe pick-up. But what I really came to rave about is the portobello sandwich. The mushroom caps are huge! Combine that with a fresh pretzel roll that soaks in all the good juices and it is awesome. You can also customize so for veggie lovers like me adding grilled peppers and onions are right up my alley. All the meat eaters i have dined with are always envious when they see the sandwich. read more

First the good- my husband enjoyed his pretzel appetizer. It was huge and the horseradish dip was really good. He had fish and chips minus the chips and up charged for onion rings. He said if he had never had Duke's he would rate them pretty high however, there is no comparison to Duke's. Dukes gives you 3 large fish fillets and he said the onion rings are also better at Duke's. I had the little neck clams. They were served with melted margarine-yuck! The Napa chicken salad was 5 star. It was uncomfortable also hearing the kitchen staff using the f word and saying "this place is crazy"! Our waiter also wasn't very friendly. We won't be coming back. Addendum- still sitting here and kitchen staff said "instead of watching the game, I watched porno on my Firestick". Now I know there will always be talk amongst workers that may be colorful but if you are in hearing distance of customers it should be toned down quite a bit more! So far we have heard the F bomb more than we hear in a bar atmosphere. read more

Wings were average. Not very flavorful at all. Disappointing. Just an average, run of the mill place. Nothing special.

Returning customer of many years. Called this past Friday night (June 5th) for call ahead seating and had the MOST unpleasant "girl" (although she sounded in her 30s, her behavior was that of an adolescent girl) named Heather on the phone. She was extremely rude and at one point turned to a co-worker during the phone call to mumble "oh my god" because I was taking up her seemingly valuable time with a simple question about how busy they were. Having grown up in Mechanicsburg, caddy shack was always a go-to for a good time and decent food, but after that pathetic display of customer service I will not be back. Twenty year loyal customer down the drain. ...Oh and Heather, find a new line of work, sweetheart. Quite frankly, you're not cut out for any job that requires human interaction. And I have a feeling it's not the first time you've heard that. read more

This was our third time coming here. Each experience was the same. Service was great! Food.... not so much. Its mediocre, average food. Honestly youd be better off eating at home and cooking your own dinner. The atmosphere under the tent is nice and the beer pricing is comparable. We really want the food to be better so we can go here more, but we are 0-3 on visits read more

Kept seeing ads for this and finally went to try it out. Wish I hadnt. The place was swarming with flies, the food was horrible and so was the service. read more

Caddy Shack - American Near Me - Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania

This is a great local restaurant! The food is not gourmet but it's always consistently good and you can't beat the prices. The wait staff is always super friendly and they can handle big groups with separate checks without a problem. The 'shack fries', wings, burgers (even the veggie burger), nachos are all awesome!. Stop in and check out the Caddy Shack, you won't be disappointed! read more

Awesome local pub. The food is good overall, especially since the owner brought the "Cellar" collection over. Don't expect fine dining quality, it's a local bar/restaurant. It's 5stars for great service, the best bartenders in town, Johnny the manager is great, and it's just the best local place to gather with friends. Especially after playing a round at Armitage! read more

About what you would expect from a golf course restaurant.....very wide array of menu choices....sat outside on the patio.....very nice, just a bit tight and way too noisy (mainly from overzealous jerks craving female attention) I had the taco salad, and it was better than I thought for only $8.99.....Drinks are reasonable ($4 for a Mint Mojito) TALL glass read more

Great food, we got the BLT. They added more space to eat outside which is very nice. However, service was somewhat slow. read more

See all

Had dinner here with a friend today. Was my first time, may be the last. The restaurant is on the second floor but there is no sign indicating that so we had to stop a golfer and ask where to access it. (Up a flight of steps) The restaurant sign is on the first floor. We both got the NY strip, both asked for med well. Mine was right, hers was rare. We switched steaks rather than send hers back. The steaks were mostly grisly but a few good bites. The side salad and cole slaw was good as was the iced tea. Her fries were good but my onion rings were soggy with grease and had very little onion inside. If I went back to this place, I would not get a dinner and since I don't do sandwiches much, when I go out, I don't see a return visit here for some time. Hear their wings are good but I don't do wings either. When I go out, I like to have a cooked meal and I like to have something I don't make at home, like steak or seafood. This place is obviously known for more simple fare like wings and burgers. read more

Tonight, I met here with a friend for the first time & I was so happy with our server - Felicia. She was so sweet, attentive & following the guidelines! I know how hard it is during this time for the industry & I just wanted to give her props for being so wonderful! Everything was great! We appreciate you being open & accommodating! read more

We placed a curbside pickup order and when we arrived no one there, including employees or customers, were wearing masks or other protective gear and there was no social distancing. We were shocked! The food and service were good (again it was a takeout order) but we are required to wear masks in public and follow social distancing guidelines even in the green phase. We will not return to the Caddy Shack until we find out that they are follwing the appropriate guidelines, as it's not worth the risk! read more

This is a truly local hangout. Michelle, the weekday daytime bartender, is the bomb. After that, you're on your own. Food is pretty good and the daily specials rock. What else can I say. read more

I grew up within walking distance of the Caddy Shack. I have great memories throughout my life here. Many of the servers have been there since I was a kid. The people that gave it poor reviews, I recommend sticking to the original items. Come for their wings and their caddy shack fries. The Cellar menu brings more upscale items which many of them are good; but their bar food is the best. Caddy shack fries are piled high with cheese and bacon. The bacon is cut to good sized, real bacon. The caddy shack sauce is so delicious you can dip a leaf in it and it would be great. Stick with what they do best and you won't be disappointed. Ps: they have excellent holiday buffets. (Mother's Day, Father's Day, Easter) read more