The workers here a performing a mitzvah to the world by sharing this with the rest of us. The…read moreservice was top-notch, the samples were aplenty (and massive), and most importantly, the ice cream was out of this world. 11/10

Ice Cream Cafe is never a wrong answer. There's a reason for the lines in the summer -- the ice…read morecream is solid, period. Got a handmade ice cream sandwich -- to be honest, the cookies from the nearby bakery that made up the "bun" were disappointing (hence the somewhat-unfair mere 4 stars), but the coffee ice cream in the middle was amazing. Others I sampled were also delish. Advice: you can manage the line length with your arrival time, but it's worth it regardless. Enjoy...

Best peppermint stick ice cream I've ever had! They have a huge selection of flavors are happy to…read morelet you taste anything you want and really friendly staff. Really clean, nice space.

This is such a cute little hole-in-the-wall ice cream parlor. They have a great variety of flavors…read moreto choose from, and it makes it fun to try something new each time. The decor is also really nice and gives the place a cozy, welcoming feel. Overall, it's a simple but charming spot to grab a sweet treat, and I'd definitely come back again.

What a hidden gem in South Chatham! We stayed at a Cape house just down the block from Short N'…read moreSweet, and I am so glad we did. This ice cream is awesome! We visited twice. The first time was a Sunday night in May and the line was literally out of the door! And I quickly understood why. Their ice cream is soooo good. Like seriously AMAZING. And even better? The bang for your buck! This is some of the most price favorable and high quality ice cream I've ever tried. Their XXL, which is 6 scoops and huge, is $8.90. I am shocked! Staff is also super nice and explained all of the flavors we had questions about to us. I tried their chocolate, strawberry, raspberry chocolate chip, s'mores, and phantom berry ice cream. All were amazing. My favorites were definitely the chocolate, s'mores, and phantom berry ice creams. All amazing options, I would seriously recommend this place!

First time trying this ice cream spot in my 23 years on the Cape- so glad I did! My mom and I…read morewalked, which I recommend with how busy the parking area can get. Also be sure to bring cash, or use the ATM inside. I love the flavor selection and the amount of different areas you can order from. Service was very fast even with a line! The school house interior was super cute, but I really enjoyed the outdoor seating areas! Plenty of room to sit and enjoy your ice cream! The coffee khalua brownie is something I'd definitely come back for!

Worth it!! The ice cream here tastes so so good. I've gone…read moreto the Burlington and now Dennis Port locations and Holy Cow has such great ice cream. I've had the corner piece and the salted caramel brownie, (highly recommend!!). Staff are very friendly and the inside smells delicious and looks really cool! **Only flaw is that it is pretty pricey so be prepared for that.

I have been following Holy Cow on Instagram for years and finally got the chance to go last night!…read more My favorite part was the warm waffle cone (which I actually didn't order at first but once I realized they were being made on the spot and served right away I had to get one) The flavor I had was Lunch Lady - it was really good- but I do wish they had some more traditional flavors, especially for my kids- they were having a hard time deciding because they like chocolate based flavors and there wasn't a lot of options. The line was long but moved quickly, the shop was clean but the bathroom was out of soap and toilet paper. Overall I would say if you haven't tried Holy Cow I would try it and make sure to get a waffle cone!

My family visited schoolhouse ice cream for the first time. I read the reviews beforehand so I knew…read moreI had to bring cash as it's cash only. I had the Harwich mud pie and it was the best flavor I have had. Others had the mint chip and birthday cake and it was equally as delicious. I can't wait to return again before we leave the cape for home.

No bueno. Workers were great, hustling & kind to the customers…read more But the ice cream was not great & the owner should take a long look at the tubs and freezer, yuk !! Huge line, no parking, super dark out. Just an overall miss for us. Again, the staff was great, doing their best.

Excellent parking facility! The parking process is efficient and convenient…read more I have visited this location twice so far, with the first visit being notably smooth and the second being quite crowded. The outdoor seating arrangement requires navigating take-out ordering and finding a suitable spot. However, the covered area provides a pleasant ambiance. The ice cream is exceptionally delicious, and we particularly enjoyed the Bass River Mud flavor, which prompted us to try it both times. The service was prompt on both occasions, even during peak hours. I highly recommend this establishment and anticipate a potential return visit before my vacation ends.

I used to love Sundae School and have come at least once every trip to the cape. But, there are a…read morefew reasons why I'm hesitant to return. At this point, lines after dinner hours are close to thirty minutes. The staff do their absolute best and really work quickly with customers, but it's still quite a long wait for ice cream. The price is also getting pretty steep for the size cup you get. Lastly, this trip was not the first time either myself or someone in my party has had stomach issues after having their ice cream. At this point, I think I'll be taking my business elsewhere.

If you order a frappe at the Brewster Scoop, you will be disappointed. They have drastically…read morechanged their recipe this year. Mine today, and those I ordered for my two grandchildren, were mostly milk. I'm not kidding.

One of the highlights of my trip to the Cape. The cashier with the curly brown hair was so sweet…read moreand helpful. The ice cream is delicious and reasonably priced- highly recommend Graham Central Station!!

I genuinely cannot emphasize enough how insanely good this ice cream is. I'm not kidding when I say…read morethis is one of the best ice creams I've ever had in my entire life. The ice cream itself is unbelievably creamy, and the toppings are just as good. They don't skimp on the mix-ins either--the way they load the ice cream with toppings is honestly insane. Every bite is packed with something delicious. My two favorite flavors were Shark's Tooth, which is a blackberry-based ice cream with white chocolate chips, and Sweet Cream & Nuts, which is a sweet cream-based ice cream with walnuts. Both were AMAZING. I would genuinely do anything to go back and have those two again. We also tried a couple of the cookie dough and Oreo-based flavors, and those were incredible too. I especially don't know what they do with their cookie dough, but it is so decadent, soft, and delicious. It almost melts into the ice cream. I seriously don't know how they make their ice cream, but whatever they're doing needs to be studied lol. This place is SO good, and if you're in the area, you absolutely have to try it. They also have two locations, which makes it even better!

It seems like this is THE spot for ice cream in the area because we showed up 15 minutes before…read moreclosing, and there was a line of cars waiting to go in and 30 or so people waiting in a line outside. The line inside goes by so much faster, so I definitely recommend going there instead of waiting outside. I was pleased to see many nondairy flavors and not just fruit sorbets. I got the chocolate pudding which was quite creamy and satisfying. About $7 for a scoop. Plenty of seating inside and outside. The staff here work hard--there were still people in line even 45 minutes after closing when we left. I'll definitely be back if I'm in the area again!