We all thoroughly enjoyed what we ate. The salty Oreo was by far a fan favorite for our crew! I got it as a sundae with whipped cream, fudge, and a cherry. The staff seemed nice as well and it was not crowded when we went (after dinner on a Thursday in September). Also, this place is cash only but there is an ATM in the store! There's a good amount of seating inside as well and it is a clean place. read more

Ice Cream Smuggler - Salty Oreo sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - South Dennis, Massachusetts

I always enjoy an ice cream shop and compare the many flavors offered. This shop did not disappoint. I had a hot fudge sundae with coffee heath bar. Oh so delicious, creamy, and very flavorful with bits of crunchy heath candy. The shop is very clean and the crew are all so friendly. I highly recommend Smuggler's and the shop is right on scenic 6a. read more

Ice Cream Smuggler - Hot fudge sundae with coffee heath ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - South Dennis, Massachusetts

What is a 4 star Cape Cod homemade ice cream shop? We had an inconclusive discussion of 4 stars versus 5 stars for the genre. Ice Cream Smuggler is what you would expect. A mixture of traditional and unusual ice cream flavors. Salty Oreo is an unusual flavor and it was quite good. The line tends to move quickly as there are many servers. There are multiple areas to sit outside. read more

Ice Cream Smuggler - Menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - South Dennis, Massachusetts

See all

Ice creams are amazing and so tasty! The service is okay but not very friendly. However, the interior of the restaurant is very clean. They do a good job keeping it tidy. The ambiance is acceptable, but the restaurant is not a comfortable environment due to the lack of tables and seating. There are only three tables, but many seats. It seems designed primarily for pickup, allowing customers to eat their ice cream in their cars. If you don't mind picking up ice cream only, there are great choices available for you. However, if you want to stay inside the restaurant, that might not be ideal for you. There aren't any outdoor tables either. Additionally, there are no high chairs for babies, which is quite disappointing for an ice cream restaurant. I can imagine that many people would want to go inside for a cool break from a day at the beach. I really enjoy their ice creams, but I am not fond of the restaurant itself. read more

We visited many ice cream shops during our most recent trip to the Cape, and this one took the cake! Loved it - so delicious and can't wait to go back next summer! read more

Ice cream is always delicious here! By far my favorite ice cream place! The staff are super sweet. Whenever I go i always make sure to leave a tip considering it helps towards staffs college tuition!! read more

Ice Cream Smuggler - Salty oreo in a dipped cone! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - South Dennis, Massachusetts

Absolutely delicious! And such amazingly different ice cream flavors. I went with a standard chocolate peanut butter, but it didn't taste standard at all - it was divine. My husband loved his black raspberry and Clouds in my Coffee flavors. All this ice cream is served by a polite and happy staff. So easy to recommend! read more

Delicious ice cream. There were 8 of us and the server was able to get everyone what he or she wanted. Don't be alarmed by the line, it moves quickly. read more

So good we came here a few times during our 5 day visit on the cape. A perfect location to stop in when going to and from different towns. This pregnant gal did not let it disappoint her at all. So many flavors and combos and choices to choose from - shakes, cones, cups, cakes! I loved the raspberry chocolate flavor, it hit the spot in a hot day and also raspberries were my number one craving. Thinking this might be my favorite ice cream spot on the cape! Don't miss out! read more

See all

Ice cream is excellent. Service with a smile and humor, even when slammed! Atmosphere is: Inside just right for sweltering, hot days, clean tables and chairs. Outside: Nice as a tailgate spot on the cooler days. Large parking lot with lots of trees around. We highly recommend this business! read more

Ice Cream Smuggler - Butter Pecan - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - South Dennis, Massachusetts

Fresh homemade creamy ice cream that hits the spot on a hot day. While it doesn't have a more modern and fun look like some of the other more popular spots on the Cape, the ice cream is among the best that you can find. Prices are reasonable and plenty of inside seating. It is cash only but they have an atm inside. read more

Ice Cream Smuggler - Scoop of mocha chip - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - South Dennis, Massachusetts

See all

Great service! Friendly welcome! Cute, clean place. Ice cream choices were great. I loved that they offered a One Scoop sundae- just the right size! Real whipped cream- fabulous hot fudge! Got a doggie pre made ice cream cup. (No complaints there). Affordable and fair prices. Wont "break the bank" Planning our next trip and can't wait read more

Paid for an extra thick coffee frappe with extra syrup and got zero syrup.....very disappointing

Absolutely delicious hot fudge sundae. Overpriced? Sure, but so good. Vanilla did have some ice chips in it Solid service and expected ambiance/decor. read more

The ice cream was good. Wish samples were allowed, was curious about the cinnamon, but settled with a flavor I knew would be good.

It's a go to place in Cape Cod! Expect long lines but it's it's worth the trip as the ice cream is amazing! Plenty of seats to eat your ice cream before it melts. Enjoy! read more

See all

We came here to try a classic hot fudge sundae after seeing it on a Best Thing I Ever Ate episode. It was delish but $44 for our family of 6 to get one each. Their ice cream was great and their hot food was amazing and generous! The hot fudge is dark,rich and wonderfully chocolatey Do yourself a favor a drive to Greys beach, Ahhhmazing read more

Ice Cream Smuggler - Hot fudge sundaes! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - South Dennis, Massachusetts

In looking for a spot nearby to get ice cream, I'm so glad we found Smuggler's! As many reviews already said, they were on Food Network's "Best Thing I Ever Ate" for their infamous ice cream sundae. So naturally, that's what we had to try. Your choice of homemade ice cream topped with hot fudge, peanuts, whipped cream and a cherry. The magic touch was they put hot fudge on the bottom of the cup too.. perfection. I debated for much too long on what flavor ice cream to get, and ultimately landed on Black Raspberry which I thought was a perfect choice. The hubs went with Grasshopper which he raved about. Definitely hit the spot after dinner - I'm glad Yelp helped us find this spot! read more

Ice Cream Smuggler - best ever ice cream sundaes! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - South Dennis, Massachusetts

Stopped in for the first time and was impressed by all the flavors options that they had as well as choices and sizes of treats.. Ordered a large hot fudge sundae with rum raisin and frozen pudding. They actually put a dollop of hot fudge at the bottom of the cup before the ice cream goes on. It's great because you get to finish with hot fudge rather than running out. Both ice creams were about the best I've had in a long time. The rum raisin had loads of raisins and incredible rum flavoring. The frozen pudding was loaded with fruit and, again, the flavor was superior to any other frozen pudding I've had. Both ice creams were super smooth and creamy. We also ordered a pistachio cone and there was no disappointment with this ice cream either. Great pistachio flavor and plenty of pistachios. Service was quick and friendly. Tip jars are labeled with all the colleges the staff is attending with the tips helping them out. Plenty of seating in and outdoors with a large parking lot. Overall a great visit and will be going back to try more flavors the next time we're in the area. read more

Great, delicious ice cream with a wide variety of flavor options. Plenty of seating inside and outside. Friendly and helpful staff. One star off for being cash only, though there is an ATM inside. read more

Ice cream is great but the staff is lacking. Not that friendly. Early in the day the girl was not friendly and had an attitude. The evening the girl was nice and friendly to my kiddo. Staff matters, train and hire better. .. Price is way too much and they skimp on the ice cream. It's worth going to Nauset to see light house and hitting up Nauset ice cream instead. 3 dollars cheaper and portions of their kiddie is bigger than one scoop at Smugglers. Also the cash only crap is ridiculous in this day and age. What's the reason for it? Gee I wonder.... read more

Ice cream is average I hate cash only places No jimmys No tasting Small servings My least favorite ice cream place read more

Love love love this place! I have been going here before their new location. They have fantastic ice cream and great prices. Their seasonal flavors are amazing! I personally always get the Cookie Monster Flavor. Next favorite is frozen yogurt flavor Raspberry Chip! Highly recommend coming here. cash only ! read more

Ice Cream Smuggler - Mint Chocolate Chip and Seasonal Flavor Cookie Monster - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - South Dennis, Massachusetts

See all

Luckily came right before the closing rush. Walked into the front room and you can smell the ice cream aroma. Couldn't really pin point what I wanted to get but went with a banana split. Wanted marshmallow sauce on top but none to be found. Nice spot to come to when in the area. read more

Really really amazing ice cream, probably some of the best ice cream I have ever had. They have a very stretchy consistency and the flavor is rich. The atompsphere is very honey and all the pictures from the last 30 years on the way adds great character. The only thing I disliked is the fact they only take cash (tax evaders?) and there ice cream runs a little pricey. Also be sure to know what you want (no samples). read more

It started out strange. Too many signs telling me the rules of the place. I mean come on. I just want some home made ice cream. I don't need a sign telling me not to walk behind the service area. Then I asked for a taste of one flavor. No problem there. I saw another one I wanted to try. Nope not allowed. Only one taste per person. Apparently some guests come in and ask for multiple and then leave. Well as an owner of my own business I suck that up and make everyone else I serve happy. Not lose guests because of a certain few who beat the system. Owner: call orange octopus in siesta key Florida. They have amazing flavors and let you and your kids try as much as they want. That's called guest service. read more

Ice Cream Smuggler - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - South Dennis, Massachusetts

Super fast and friendly service...super disappointed they don't have sprinkles and no toppings if you get a cone. Ice cream was good, but nothing above the other places around. read more

What a bummer! With probably the most expensive ice cream on the Cape you'd think they would extend greater customer courtesy. Now I've been a patron since 1979, and as I was purchasing 2 pints (the second visit in 2 weeks) I asked for a sample of the Big Green Monstah as I never had it. I was very curtly told they do not give samples. Please, it was a late weekday afternoon with one other patron in the store. No sample? So I'd have to spend $9.00 just to see if I like it. Give me a break. This is not the Smugglers I remember that was customer friendly. read more

Really delicious ice cream hits the spot on ANY day. Just make sure you have cash on you as they don't accept credit cards. I had black raspberry with chocolate peanut butter in the in the chocolate dipped waffle bowl. It hit the spot. There's lots of places to sit & eat outside. Highly recommend this place if you're near Corporation Beach or Mayflower. We went off season so check their hours read more

The grasshopper was delicious and the black raspberry was amazing. I'd highly recommend this location.

Best ice cream on the Cape! The Smuggler is a Cape Cod tradition for my family. Favorite homemade flavors include orange pineapple and pistachio, but there's a full menu of classic and interesting flavors to choose from. For someone with celiac, like myself, they will scoop from a fresh tub for you to avoid cross contamination. They also offer gluten free cones, which I've never tried. During COVID, they have an outdoor window for ordering. Cash or Venmo only! read more

I've been going to smugglers since I was a child. It's something you crave when you're away from cape. Their ice cream selection is great and even better is their quality of it. Their staff is always so friendly and the inside is so cute. They're one of my favorite places on cape read more

I went here a little before closing because I was craving Oreo ice cream. I love that the Ice Cream Smuggler actually makes their ice cream! It was creamy and had plenty of Oreo chunks. I wish they had smaller batches of the vegan ice cream available, instead of just the pints, but they are on it! During these times, they are accepting cash and Venmo for payment. read more

Cape Cod may have more ice cream places per capita than any other place on earth. You can't go 5 miles without passing 2 ice cream shops! So it's tough to pick where to go, so many of them end up being pretty standard ice cream stands with the same flavors and same dull bases. We picked a spot nearby (out of the 10 close by) that had a bit more interesting options, and it worked out decently. I got Cinnamon Graham which they said tasted like Cinnamon Toast Crunch, but ended up being close to a cinnamon Teddy Graham to me, which is yummy, but definitely needed a mix-in, chocolate would have been a good addition. Em got the Apple Pie flavor, which was ok, the sugary apple chunks were a nice addition, but I would have loved some crunchy crust pieces in there to balance the sweetness and add some nice chew factor. Lauren got the Chocolate Peanut Butter, which was a chocolate base with peanut butter swirled through, and the peanut butter definitely dominates, which is a good thing as the chocolate base was just ok (it needed more of a deep bitter chocolate flavor), but overall a good flavor. And finally, Noah got the Salty Oreo, which was by far the best, salted caramel Oreo, always a good combination (thank you JP Licks for keeping this on your menu, still the best version of this!). I am always disappointed when you can't get more than one flavor in the smaller size especially when sampling is on hiatus for COVID and since the small is basically 2 and half scoops it could definitely be split up. I did love that they had a ice cream cone in the shape of a bowl (with chocolate dipped edges), points for ingenuity! Overall, some good interesting flavors, and a half out of five cones. Best paired with more chocolate and Lawrence Arabia - Apple Pie Bed. read more

See all

The ice cream is very good, I usually get the grasshopper ice cream flavor, which is very good and they do a very nice job. The service is very quick, and they're very nice, and the ice cream is ready in 2 minutes. The ambiance is very cute and fun and kinda retro. 10/10 would recommend it, this place is excellent. read more

We visit the Smuggler every time we visit Cape Cod. The new location is clean and spacious and, best of all, the great home-made ice cream we love in a variety of flavors. 2 or 3 vegan varieties, a couple of yogurts, too. The hot fudge and whipped cream are simply divine and according to Chef Ming Tsai, the best hot fudge sundae he has ever eaten. We agree! So very glad that the Ice Cream Smuggler has a beautiful new home. read more

Yeah, ok. Great place. Not crazy about the outside - but I'm there for the i-scream!

Amazing ice cream - we tried cookie monster, raspberry ripple and butter peacan. The raspberry ripple won hands down. They have a kids option that isn't on the board but more than enough for us as adults. read more

If you like coffee Oreo, this place has the best coffee Oreo ice cream I've had. It's chock full of Oreo pieces. No skimping here. We came here in the late afternoon. No wait. Also had the maple walnut with cookie crumbles and it was great. There's seating inside and outside here. We went to 3 different ice cream shops mid cape and this one was our favorite. Don't forget cash only here. read more

See all

Delicious! Creative flavors. Super nice staff. And a great, efficient covid friendly ordering system. Plus they take Venmo, which is downright futuristic for Cape Cod! read more