Among the BEST ice cream I've ever had! Flavors were amazing, and homemade! Didn't taste artificial. Brownie Batter Swirl was 10/10! Service was friendly and samples were generous. Prices were reasonable read more

I went I. The afternoon and it was mellow. The peppermint stick ice cream was a nice throwback to a childhood favorite. So creamy! read more

Ice Cream Cafe - Peppermint stick - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orleans, Massachusetts

Ice Cream Cafe is never a wrong answer. There's a reason for the lines in the summer -- the ice cream is solid, period. Got a handmade ice cream sandwich -- to be honest, the cookies from the nearby bakery that made up the "bun" were disappointing (hence the somewhat-unfair mere 4 stars), but the coffee ice cream in the middle was amazing. Others I sampled were also delish. Advice: you can manage the line length with your arrival time, but it's worth it regardless. Enjoy... read more

Visiting from Georgia and this ice cream shop was suggested. The line was LONG... and totally worth it! Homemade ice cream was to die for and I love that they use fresh cherries! We got a small cookie dough cup and two sundaes, one with vanilla and one with snickers ice cream. Honestly, I'm tempted to skip dinner tomorrow and come back here for ice cream instead. To top it off, the staff is AMAZING! read more

A huge selection of non dairy options and my final selection was amazing. Will be back on our next visit to the Cape!

Great non dairy soft serve. The staff were welcoming and friendly. I picked this spot because the lines are always out the door.

Super cute little ice cream shop in Orleans! On a rainy day trying to find some things to do, we decided that eating ice cream was definitely a proper way to use our time. They have a nice deck for better weather, but we opted to enjoy ours in the car. We each got a kiddie cone, which in proper New England fashion, was still plenty of ice cream. I had coffee Oreo and my husband had Irish cream. The flavors were excellent, lots of cookie chunks in mine. I really liked the texture too. It was very smooth and creamy, not icy, but somehow felt lighter on the tongue than a lot of premium ice cream does. They also had quite a few dairy free/sugar free/gluten free options so they seemed very allergy friendly. Services was friendly and prompt. They're serving some of the best ice cream on the Cape! Definitely check them out. read more

Ice Cream Cafe - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orleans, Massachusetts

Fantastic ice cream. You can get it in any way you can imagine - cup, cone, sundae, milkshake, root beer float, cookie sandwich, and many more. I've been to Cape Cod about 5 times and this is the best ice cream I have had anywhere in the Cape! read more

The workers here a performing a mitzvah to the world by sharing this with the rest of us. The service was top-notch, the samples were aplenty (and massive), and most importantly, the ice cream was out of this world. 11/10 read more

Awesome list of homemade flavors to choose from. Sat outside and had a great time with the kids. Ice cream was really good and refreshing. The service was impeccable. The kids working there were really great and helped us find the flavors we wanted. read more

Long lines, service was quick! Lots of unique flavors. Parking is a bit tight. Loved the fresh cherry on top! read more

Ice Cream Cafe - Hot fudge sundae - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orleans, Massachusetts

Best ice cream ever!! And the vegan options are amazing!! Not to be missed. And the staff is lovely and friendly. They have vegan hot fudge and caramel sauce too! Often a long line but it moves quickly... gives you more time to try to figure out what you want... sooo many yummy options! read more

First time here this summer; line is very quick, servers hopping around to help each other and clear the line - well done! FYI they have online ordering with a separate pickup area. read more

Ice Cream Cafe - The sign says it all! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orleans, Massachusetts

We were looking for a place open before Memorial Day and decided to try this place! Typically, we are Sundae School people and aren't in this area for dinner, but we were so impressed and happy that we stopped here. I got the Cocamint Chip which was unreal and Orange Sherbet. They make their own ice cream and there is parking and outdoor seating. You can pay with credit card. read more

Ice Cream Cafe - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orleans, Massachusetts

See all

This ice cream is absolutely delicious! Besides, having great ice cream, the service is fantastic. Josie went above and beyond. My husband complained about his ice cream flavor. She went and got him a new scoop while hearing him bitch and moan that the flavor he got was not what he had anticipated. Thanks, Josie! read more

Wide variety of treats. Line was long but moved quickly. Scoops were generous but the shakes were a bit milky.

Pros: Tons of dairy free options Huge portions Cons: - dairy free ice cream still tasted like soymilk/dairy free, didn't really agree with the reviews - portions felt too big, you get way more than what you pay for but was only able to finish 1/4 of a small blizzard so it felt very wasteful, consider sharing read more

Ice Cream Cafe - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orleans, Massachusetts

See all

This was my first time in probably 20 years enjoying a Blizzard, and it was fantastic! This place offers non-dairy milk options, which was a game-changer for me. I had a salted caramel Blizzard with peanut butter cups and Reese's pieces, just like old times before I became lactose intolerant. The service was quick and excellent. The prices were reasonable, as I received 7 items for under $45, which I consider a great deal. The Blizzard I had was sensational. I wish more places around my area offered these options. read more

See all

Quality great tasting ice cream. A new favorite at the cape! Great service and good family fun. The line moves quickly because the servers move fast and courteously. read more

great ice cream both soft and hard. the coffee oreo among the best of its kind. service is quick and cheerful and there's a nice porch to sit on. don't miss this orleans highlight! read more

"We pulled over for this" on our way back to Hyannis from ptown. We had already stuffed our faces for lunch but we all have a little extra room for ice cream. After reading some of the other reviews, I'm pleased that there was no line during our visit on a Friday afternoon in August. Ha Ha!!! I was impressed by the pure quantity of different flavors available as well as diary free options. I struggled to make a decision but ultimately went with a small red velvet in a cone. The small is a very decent (probably too decent for the scale) portion. The red velvet was creamy with chunks of red velvet cake in there. I don't think I've even ever seen this flavor before let alone tried it and it was nice to try something off the beaten "cone" if you will. There is seating on the deck outside with umbrellas. It is a great place to take an afternoon break with a treat. read more

Ice Cream Cafe - Red velvet - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orleans, Massachusetts

It's a cute place. They have a nice non dairy selection. Good help, but why is a regular cone $6? If you work a minimum wage job at $15 that is 25 minutes of work to buy an ice cream cone for your kid. Family of 4 $24. I know everyone is doing this, but it makes no sense that an ice cream cone is this expensive. read more

It's a generic name, but this place truly has the most/best allergy-friendly and low-fat frozen treats on all of the Cape! They have really good soft serve non-fat frozen yogurt with choose-your-own mix-ins. The best combo is chocolate with strawberries and oreos! On our last visit, they had added even more dairy-free/vegan options too. Of course, there's delicious regular ice cream too (visited 5/27/22, 8/13/23, and 6/15/24, and many more times!) read more

We found this ice cream shop while staying in Brewster. We were on the hunt for some ice cream, but a few places closer to Brewster weren't open for the season, so we drove to this shop, and it did not disappoint! There was a long line on Monday night, and you know a long wait usually means it's a good spot. My favorite flavor is maple walnut, and honestly, this place has the best maple walnut I've ever had in the U.S.! I've tried that flavor everywhere from Maine to Seattle, and this place makes amazing homemade ice cream with rich flavor and fresh cream. My kids got soft serve, and it was really good too. I'd definitely recommend it and can't wait to come back next time I'm in town! read more

The ice cream is delicious and a large selection. The hot fudge is tasty without being cloying. The service fast and the outside seating comfortable. read more

Great homemade ice cream. The cake batter and red velvet were particularly tasty. Real cake mixed in. Highly recommend!

I was referred to Ice Cream Cafe from some Orleans locals and it did not disappoint! The number of flavors available was almost overwhelming. The variety is unbelievable and the ice cream tasted as home made as it gets. I was told to try the banana ice cream, which at first I said ew? The staff offered me a taste test and I understood why it was recommended. It was AMAZING. I got a scoop of banana and a scoop of coco mint chip (also delicious) on a wafer cone. Do not be intimated by the long line here. The staff is quick & efficient. I waited less than 10 minutes for a line that wrapped into the parking lot. Ice Cream Cafe is a must when on the Cape! read more

Ice Cream Cafe - Street view of the business - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orleans, Massachusetts

See all

Really good ice cream and even better service! The staff knew their stuff when it came to allergies and made me feel totally comfortable. I got a scoop of chocolate and a scoop of salted caramel -- both were awesome. Definitely recommend this place, especially if you have food allergies. read more

Went before close. Blizzard was so good and great portion! Line was long but went super fast. read more

Ice Cream Cafe - Ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orleans, Massachusetts

Brownie batter ice cream was delicious line was long but moved fast! Would definitely recommend anyone visiting the area. read more

Ice Cream Cafe - Ice cream menu - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orleans, Massachusetts

See all

We stopped here after Cape Escape Mini Golf for a little afternoon treat. This place takes covid precautions seriously (masks for all, calling customers in one at a time). I applaud their safety measures. They have only outdoor seating and it is limited. I would have given 5 stars for the ice cream but the outdoor seating wasn't kept up very well. There are so many flavors!!! My husband was bummed they were out of Key Lime but happy with his black raspberry consolation dessert. I ordered their dairy free soft serve twist and was delighted with how delicious it was. read more

See all

This is the best place for ice cream when visiting the Cape. Every year we look forward to this place for the best ice cream and soft serve varieties. Last night we got three sundaes. All were small sundaes that includes two scoops. The first was with a scoop of chocolate chip and a scoop of cookies and cream, topped with hot fudge and Reese pieces. The second was Coffee Heath and Chocolate chocolate chip topped with hot fudge, peanut butter sauce, Heath and Reese Peanut Butter Cup. The third was Soft-Serve Swirl Ice Cream with Butterfinger pieces. All of them were tasty and we ordered online to make it faster for pick up. The line is usually long, but Thursday in October would have been fine to go right up to the window. read more

See all

Outstanding every time! Chose to come mid-afternoon and wow - that's the time! No wait and plenty of seating to enjoy the fabulous creamy ice cream. Friendly service and great chill atmosphere. read more

Here's my issue: they use real cherries on top of their sundaes. That's atypical. So when I bit into the cherry on my sundae, I chomped down onto the pit. That was, of course, right in the exact spot of a dental crown. Now my crown is loose. Not what I want for my vacation or a dental bill. It really sucks. The ice cream is good. Hot fudge wax tasty. Just please warn people if you're going to do something so highly atypical that is also a hazard. Or consider removing the pit of your cherries. I could picture this being problematic to anyone who bites down on it. read more

Still the GOAT, best and most affordable option for ice cream in the area. Including vegan and dairy free options AND they are super conscientious about nut allergies!! read more

Line moves fast- don't be discouraged!! Had small dish of both peanut butter (vanilla base) and dark chocolate chip and it was a delightful combination! Creamy ice cream and large tasty chunks of peanut butter cups and chips! Worth the wait!! ! read more

Worth the lineup! Original flavours and quick, pleasant service. The kiddie cone was a hearty scoop and enough to be enjoyed without the guilt of overindulgence. I tried the dirt bomb ice cream, at the recommendation of my brother-in-law. Cinnamon flavours with muffin pieces-- I was amazed at how the muffin stays crispy when mixed in ice cream! One of the best scoops I've ever had! Not overly sweet; just the right flavour balance and very creamy. I might go a second time this week while we're visiting the Cape. read more

My go-to used to be Sundae School. Then it became Smitty's which was also good. Problem is its open for a fairly short season and usually has long lines. So I started coming to Ice Cream Cafe. The ice cream here is also very good and the lines can be long, especially in the evenings. So go during the day and the lines are shorter. They have a good amount of flavors and prices are about average for one of the better ice cream shops on the Cape. Don't waste your time at other places that don't make their ice cream on site. Basically I recommend this place and it's now my go-to on the Cape. read more

There are so many ice cream spots on the Cape but I feel like this is the one to go to in this area. There are a ton of flavors to choose from, the staff are all friendly, and there is space for large groups. Most importantly: it's ca$h only! read more

Excellent the cream and an excellent ice cream shop ! Friendly hard working employees !