Came to this location with a girlfriend for a 4/20 lunch. It took about 5 mins before we were able to be seated. But once we were our sever came and introduced himself quickly. We decided to order a few things so we got the Asian zing cauliflower and onion rings as apps. We got boneless Teriyaki, lemon pepper (sauce not dry) and the original boned chicken as honey bbq and Parmesan garlic. We also decided to share fries. Delicious and food came out faster then we thought. The waiter was a bit clumsy and kept asking we we could wait a min (when we ordered refills for our Shirley temples).... like if i had a choice . There was even a guy who did the spicy wing challengers eat 10 bone in wings with the hottest flavor (California pepper). He did it and won $150 BWW gift card. What a show that was I also have the app so i was able to check in (for reward points) and had 50% off my order. read more

Amazing food and service! The chicken Caesar salad was so yummy! Highly recommend this place to others! read more

Buffalo Wild Wings - Chicken Caesar Salad - American Near Me - Hicksville, New York

I firmly believe that Buffalo Wild wings is a hit or miss place. Sometimes the wings are excellent, hot, fresh and crispy. Sometimes the service is excellent. Sometimes the vibe is great. Other times they really struggle. I pick up food from here and I feel like the amount of customers being served impacts the experience. I happened to go the opening night of football season and they were a mess. I had to wait for like 20 minutes for my pick up order. It was supposed to be ready at 8:00 and I didn't arrive until 8:10 and I didn't get my order until 8:25. This was rough. The staff was super busy and from my perspective, they looked understaffed. The food was good. read more

It is the slowest one I've ever been to. And the service is sooooo slow. Not busy and waiting 40 minutes for appetizers. Never again. And the people who work here seem very unhappy. read more

Enjoying the Tuesday wing special. Very good chicken wings. Plenty of sauces to choose from, from mild to spicy. Very good service from the bartender. Happy Hour specials are good. Specials on beer, alcoholic beverages, appetizers. The best chicken wing special is during Monday Night Football with 50 cent wings. Even better than the buy one get one free specials on Tuesdays and Thursdays. Regular prices for the chicken wings are around $1.30/wing. Would definitely recommend for the Happy Hour specials. read more

See all

Wings are delicious, but only when they deliver the correct order, which is probably 40% of the time. There is a literal checklist on the receipt, but they can't seem to handle it. read more

Food was awful...cold...obviously reheated...really disappointing experience...I won't be returning

Worst wings ever,dried out from being old and previously frozen. If thats not bad enough they were very small as were the fries which were also previouly frozen. I will never go there again. Bartender(heavy with beard) was bad as well. Stay away. read more

Wings were dried out and very small seems like they were frozen and then recooked fries came out cold and from frozen. No wonder place was empty food was bad here. read more

I went here with my friends on sat Aug 23 party of 9 the service was awesome our waiter LJ was outstanding he not only was friendly fast and awesome he also offer us refills even after we paid our bill I come here very often always get great service for a party of 9 we will definitely returning thanks Buffalo Wild Wings for awesome food and service I definitely recommend this one for sure read more

Definitely stepping up their game with some of their food. Got a chicken sandwich, and it was so good! The chicken was juicy and tender, with just the right amount of seasoning. The bun was fresh and soft, and the toppings were perfect. Can't wait to try more items from their menu! read more

Buffalo Wild Wings - Chicken sandwich - American Near Me - Hicksville, New York

Nice looking establishment in a dying mall. Found staff to be welcoming and attentive. Not really impressed with the wings. Seems small and not worth the effort. Flavors are nice but so messy. Onion rings were good but don't think I need a return visit. A bit pricey for fast food. They do have more televisions than most other restaurants. read more

Incredibly slow wait on the takeout side of things. Had to ask a busy server myself about the order after the people working takeout just up and left. Then I waited some more by the takeout area until a different busy server asked what I was picking up. Would give one star if it wasn't for that nice server who saw me hopelessly waiting and finally brought out the food. read more

1. Food was ok. The service was horrible. We waited over 20 minutes for our check. Seemed like once you got your food that was it. Will not be going back. Mentioned something to the manager and they didn't even seem to care. read more

I sat and waited for my food for too long an hour at most just took to long and pissed me off

How is this place still open? I live locally and have watched this place go downhill for years. I believe it's hit rock bottom.. Shame because nice place to watch a game. My last few visits were just to pick up an online order to go and today will be my last one. When I arrived for my 7pm pick-up I was met by 10 customers waiting for take out. The dinning room was about 1/4 full. Not an employee in sight. At 7:10 I approached the bartender and asked her to check on my order. She disappeared into the kitchen for a couple minutes and came out and explained that there were a few orders ahead of mine, and they were 'bagging up' orders now. Huh? 7:20 arrives and I just want to ask for a refund but still no employee to be found besides the bartender. 7:21 a young man emerges from the kitchen and approaches a few tables so I'll assume he was a server. FINALLY, 7:28 a young lady emerges from the kitchen with a slew of plastic bags on each arm. She approaches the waiting area and begins to sing out names to the waiting customers. All 10. What a miracle! Ten orders all prepared at once! Of course mine was the last to be handed off. No mind, just wanted to get home and dig in. Guess what? The 20 wings and fries that I ordered were ice cold and barely and I mean barely edible (spit most of them out). Bye bye BBW hello Wingstop.. read more

Good service and food; I always enjoy stopping by here for dinner, (love the tall beers for $5.00 and t/Tuesday night BOGO special,) thanks Bill and Caitland for doing a great job at the bar. Thank you Kevin and Stacy for always taking the time to come over to me to say hi and see how things are going, very much appreciated. read more

Buffalo Wild Wings - American Near Me - Hicksville, New York

See all

Was in the mood for wings, and it was Thursday. Thursday BBW does bogo on boneless wings. Although boneless wings aren't "real" wings, it still helped my craving. The way their bogo works is if you order 6, you get 6, 10 you get 20, and so on. I opted for 6 (12). For my sauce/flavor I chose 6 with parm garlic and 6 with Caribbean jerk. Garlic parm was good. Caribbean jerk was a bit spicer than I expected, but still delish. I also ordered cheese curds. They were so delish. The breading had a great flavor and was seasoned well. It was severed with southwestern ranch, which paired very well. My server was Cassandra, she was great and continued to check in. read more

VERY POOR CUSTOMER SERVICE! Walked in nobody was in the front to greet so I continued walking towards the waiters and noone cared to acknowledge if we needed seats. Decided to just walk out. Not worth dining. read more

Finally had the opportunity to eat at this spot. This particular location is much larger than it looks from the outside entrance in the mall. The menu had a lot to offer and they had discounts such as $5 mozzarella sticks and $1 pint Blue Moon to celebrate the winter solstice. And yes the beer was cheaper than the soda which coats over $3!! In addition they have a variety of seasonings and sauces organized according to spice level/scale. Since this was a wings place we went with the combo: traditional and boneless wings with fries and Cole slaw. For the traditional wings we went with the lemon pepper seasoning and the boneless wings we went with limited edition of the bourbon honey mustard sauce. We also ordered the mozzarella sticks. The mozzarella sticks were on point, standard. The combo definitely feeds two people. The lemon pepper wings were better than the bourbon honey mustard wings. The bourbon honey mustard wings definitely had a spice kick which should be placed on a higher level. Fries were well seasoned. Coleslaw was not really coleslaw it was julienned vegetables with different dressing. I would definitely return to another location and try out other wings. read more

Buffalo Wild Wings - Traditional and boneless wings combo with $1 Blue Moon for the Winter Solstice. - American Near Me - Hicksville, New York

My granddaughter wanted Buffalo wild wings. We went there as a big family big group about 10 people overall the food was OK. Service was OK. Nothing great. I reviewed this place several years ago and it's improved. read more

Food was good. Kind of spicy, but I really liked it. It's sport related and I love sports. Went there a couple times. The last time with my dad. It is amazing. read more

When we came in we we're greeted by the host and seated quickly. Was a rather empty night (Tuesday). We came for the BOGO wings which only apply to the 6/10 piece combos. We selected the 10 piece and got to choose up to 4 flavors. Parma garlic, chipotle bbq, mango hab, and lemon pepper. All of these flavors we're so good I couldn't pick a favorite. Beer; I was trying to try something new but the server suggested the light sky blue moon. I've tried blue moon countless amount of times and didn't want to try the light sky version but decided to give it a shot. I've got to say it was quite refreshing that I had to get myself a second one. Service was great, the other reviews really set my standards low but the tall guy with a stash and beard was very attentive and didn't seem annoyed about his job at all. read more

See all

They just taste weird to me, like they've been microwaved. Should be renamed Buffalo Weird Wings. The company is from Minnesota by the way, not from Buffalo. Just as an FYI. I have to be honest, these are some of the worst Wings I've had and I'm not a fan are all. I've never been a fan of Buffalo Wild Wings especially not in Buffalo, but at any given location such as this Long Island spot, a lot of the time they're just not fresh and I can see why they get such bad reviews. Their attitude isn't great either. What they are good for is watching sports and hanging out and drinking and stuff and that is what a lot of people come here for - just try to skip the food because you really don't need to be eating this food - it's just not a good example of anything that it has. read more

I came here on a Sunday evening my husband and two children (ages 2 and 5). We walked in from the mall entrance and did not see a hostess so we made our way to the front entrance. A few servers passed us by but they seemed preoccupied with waiting tables. One told us to go to the lady sitting in the food pickup section... she pointed us to the hostess podium which did not have anyone. Finally after awkwardly standing there and waiting a few minutes someone finally came by. A young man with light colored longish hair. I requested booth seatings. I was mid-sentenced and he said he'll check if they have any and walked away. He came back a minute later and l said there were none in the back, but we cannot be seated in the front booths because there are no servers there (yet there were customers sitting in the area already). For a split second I was wondering if I went blind because I passed the entire restaurant and saw several booths in the back and even told him so. He suggested we can walk back together and see. And so we did. Of course there were two open booths and that was where we sat. After we sat down he said it may be a while before someone comes to us and walked away. So this is where I'm confused. There were obviously open booths in the back and he personally walked back there, yet denied any available seats. Not only that, but we're not allowed to sit in the front booths because "there is no staff"?! Can a staff not walk an extra few feet to wait the tables there? Or who the heck is serving the tables already seated there then?! The saving grace was our waitress was Victoria who was very pleasant and good at what she does. She brought this review up by a star. The food was exactly like what you would expect. Typical bar food. And I don't mean that in a bad way. It was decent. Traditional wings are large. No extra charge for celery and carrots. Prices were fair. Likely would never come back by choice. But I'm sure the workers here won't be upset about losing a customer anyway - I mean, less work for them! We certainly did not feel welcome. read more

Incredibly depressing cuz they tint all the windows by the front. I guess so you can watch the million TVs. They had a $3 gigantic beer special though, so that's all that got me through the meal. Got the southwestern chicken sandwich, which was fine. Crap ton of soggy fries. The back room where the bathrooms are has a ton of arcade games (and leads to the rest of the mall). read more

After my happy hour visit yesterday, I probably won't be returning unless there's a big game on, cheap wing deal, or some other compelling reason. With so many other similar, yet better food places nearby (Hurricane Wings, On The Border, Fanatico, Boulder Creek), this place is way too average to deserve your business. We rolled in around 5:30 on a Friday afternoon, in search of a few pints and some light food. Although there couldn't have been more than 20 patrons inside their warehouse-sized restaurant, service was insanely slow and we had to practically throw stuff at the bartenders to get them to even acknowledge our existence. Despite being told on the phone that almost all the apps (and WINGS) were half-priced for happy hour, the bartender told us that there were only four discounted appetizers. They have no printed happy hour menu, so she just told me the included items: chips & salsa ($2), Southwestern bites ($4), mozzarella sticks ($4), chili con queso ($4). Not to nitpick (well, I'm going to anyway) but the items were regularly priced at $1-$2 more, so the "discount" really wasn't a great deal. We ordered the chili con queso, took three dunks into the forgettable dip, and sent it back for the Southwestern bites. After being asked, the bartender removed the chili con queso from our bill. The Southwestern bites were much better, but nothing spectacular. OK, on to the drinks - domestics were $2, imports $3, and "crafts" were $4 for happy hour. After attempting to order two different types of beer from the menu, I was told by the bartender that "we don't offer that beer at this location." Oh really? Then WHY THE $#&% IS IT ON THE MENU? Her response was that it's a corporate menu, which is the dumbest thing I ever heard in my life. Either order the kegs, or at least place a sticker or something over the menu stuff you never intend on stocking or serving. To add to my humorous experience with the menu, Bud Light Lime was on the "craft" list....really? OK, they have a lot of TVs, but the entire place is way too open. There's an area of high-top tables, and a (presumably lower-key) area with booths, but no real partition between the two. The whole space felt very cold and desolate, although we were there during a slow Friday afternoon so I'm sure the vibe changes on busy nights. As LARGE sports restaurants/bars go, I think Miller's Ale House in Levittown really got it right, balancing the restaurant with the bar, having an open space, while also having enough privacy between the different areas so the entire place isn't too insane. Perhaps Buffalo Wild Wings could take some notes from Miller's playbook... read more

Place was pretty crowded, a 40 min wait, Wings and food was hot and fresh but the service was lacking. read more

Terrible service, no manners, never coming back to this shit hole ever again. Genuinely fucking pissed waited for 2 hours just to get seated, waited 40 mins just my mf food. read more

Ordered the teriyaki and honey BBQ, I liked the honey BBQ better. Wings were fresh and satisfied my craving for wings. We also ordered jumbo crispy shrimp as apps, it was good, they are sort of fried. Needed a sauce though read more

See all

I wanted to give this place 5 stars, but my friend said the food was cold, and that was his singular metric for a restaurant. Me and my friends come here every year read more

The only reason we stopped here was because my fiance was extremely hungry. I've been to a different Buffalo Wild Wings in the past, but there are definitely much better wings places on Long Island. The food is just okay. Its edible but not the best quality chicken you can get if you are going for the wings. This visit we ordered wings and side of cheese curds. We did like the chipolte sauce that was given with the cheese curds. It had a kick and went well with the cheese curds. Wings can be ordered boneless or traditional or a mix. If I'm too lazy to use my hands to eat off the bone, then I would do boneless, but of course traditional is the better way to go for chicken flavor. I always find that the sauces/ dry rubs here can be a hit or miss depending what you choose with the wings. I got the buffalo dry rub (which I usually order here) and decided to try the Caribbean jerk which I never tried before. The buffalo was pretty standard same flavor of buffalo sauce just not so messy as the wet sauce. I wasn't a fan of. I though that the sauce was way to sweet for a jerk sauce flavor. For drinks I got the strawberry lemonade which was served in a tall glass and did enough to refresh my palate. Service was good here. Our waitress made sure we had everything we needed and even told us about their rewards program that you can sign up for for free and discounted offers for future visits. read more

My girlfriend went out to eat with her team. Waitress seemed a bit slow, but she looked new so it didn't really bother anyone. She approached us very quickly and took our order for drinks, she forgot our straws tho. After a few she came by and took our orders. Food came out very quick, wings were tasty, but when asked for blue cheese she never gave it to me so that was kinda annoying. Overall the experience was okay, typical bar food. Typical vibe. Wish they had more tvs and more selections of drinks but overall decent. read more

Buffalo Wild Wings - American Near Me - Hicksville, New York

I have been pretty rough on this place. I think it is due for an updated review. Accidentally I have been finding myself coming here for lunch, dinner, happy hour and football Sunday. It has been growing on me and the wings as long I tell them how to make them it comes out as expected. I don't expect 5 star food here but it is not bad. I have had some bad experiences but if I come here when they are not that busy the food is not that bad. So give them a try and happy hour 4-7. read more

Buffalo Wild Wings - American Near Me - Hicksville, New York

Food was mediocre. We did go at like 3 in the afternoon so that could be it. Fried pickles and French fries were good. Nachos were bland we paid to add chili there was barely any. Mild was def spicier than most other places but it was fine. Mango habanero was tasty, too spicy for me I only had a bite but my fiancé loved them. We got honey bbq and sweet bbq boneless wings also couldn't taste the difference truthfully. Coleslaw was good too. There was only one waiter who also acted like the bartender. Would try again maybe at night instead to see if there is a difference. read more

Great local spot to go to watch the games and have some wings with beers. Usually always go to this location and the reason I'm giving it 3 stars is because of how inconsistent the food is. Often we go and order the same flavor wings and each time the wings come out a little different, sometimes a tad bit undercooked or not saucy enough or crispy enough (which is the way we always order it.) The staff is always amazing and extremely friendly and accommodating but the food unfortunately not always the same. Will still come back because wings are life but sometimes it's better to get a small order of wings for the table with a bunch of appetizers. read more

See all

Ordered take out online but they messed up the order and gave me the lemon pepper dry rub instead of chipotle bbq. The seasoning wasn't even distributed properly. Just big chucks of seasonings on some and none on others. Head to the other chains like in Farmingdale instead. read more

This review seems to be a trend with the location. Came in on Sunday evening for dinner. Restaurant is very light with customers. The first thing that gets your attention is the awful smell in the air in the whole restaurant. Hard to describe but just smells damp and unsanitary. Should have just walked out at that point but decided to stay anyway. Walked to the host stand in the front of the restaurant and waited a while to be greeted & then had to wait while the hostess checked the nearly empty restaurant for any available seats. Ended up getting seated right next to hostess station My wife asked for a cocktail recommendation, something not too strong and was told that ALL the drinks are pre made and can't be changed. We looked over to see a fully stocked bar which must just be for show. Passed on the cocktail. All this time we could not get over the awful smell in the air and the generally dirty appearance of EVERYTHING. Order our wings and the disappointments continued. We asked for extra crispy but ended up with what can best be described as very stale tasting wings. And the fries were no better tasting like they were fried in very old oil. Our carrots used to be large sliced pieces but this location served a handful of baby carrots, like the ones you can buy at Costco. Overall a very unpleasant dining experience and we will NEVER be back. Not sure what's going on with BWW...the brand new location nearest me stayed open for about 3 years then suddenly closed. Quality seems to be going very downhill. Manager was on duty but seemed oblivious to the issues in the restaurant; sat at the bar while a long line of customers waited to be seated at the hostess stand as we waited for our bill. read more

If I could leave no stars I would. Walked in and walked right out. There was literally no one in this place. Host asked if we wanted a table or booth; we asked for a booth. After walking to the back of the restaurant and passed 1927383 open booths, we were told we had to sit at a table in front of the busy kitchen because he "couldn't skip one of the servers sections". Are you kidding me? I can't sit where I want to sit as a paying customer because you need to accommodate the next server who is up to get a table? Now you get no customer. read more

Extremely good, now I'm not trying to over exaggerate but we ordered a few apps the beers were nice and cold and the food didn't taste like it was sitting, I think sitting at the bar is the best idea read more