I saw two other reviews that said how great the experience at buckeye cabins was. Let me tell you, my experience was a complete 180 from that. I'll start out by admitting the fault of our group, we booked a cabin with a capacity of 4 people and we had 6 in our group. We thought the cabin would fit us easily because there were 3 beds (1 queen, 2 full) and a couch, but there was an error on our part by not reading carefully enough. We were told that we had to check in between 3 and 4, so my girlfriend had to leave earlier than the rest of the group to get there in time because the rest of my friends had to work until noon that day, and we were coming from Cleveland. Once we arrived, we were told by Doug that all six of us were not going to be allowed to stay, there was a strict 4 person limit, especially because of our ages (23-25). We tried to persuade him and offer to pay more or put an extra deposit down, but he wasn't having it. We then asked for a couple minutes to decide how we were going to proceed. We decided on sending the 2 additional people to a hotel for the night and having 4 stay at the cabin. We met with Doug again who said "you have about 2 seconds to decide" even though we already made our decision and wanted to ask him about other places to stay in the area, since he claimed all his other cabins were booked (at least one other cabin did not have any other guests at it the entire time we were there). When we asked what he would do if he were in our shoes, he replied, "I wouldn't have booked this cabin with 6 people in the first place." We said we understood that but we needed a place to stay and asked the more specific question about where there might be some hotels in the area. He replied with, "There might be a Holiday Inn over by the lake, I don't know." Imagine just trying to comply with this guy's rules that only 4 people can stay in the cabin, only to be met with a snarky attitude and no help as to where we could even go. All he cared about was that we already paid for the cabin, so he was guaranteed his money either way. I will never again give that rude, uninviting, senseless man a dime of my money. Oh and when we looked in the guest book at this cabin, there were multiple occasions in which 5 or 6 people had stayed at that cabin before and had a great time.
The area was great and we meant no harm to the cabin. 4 of the 6 people who were in our group are young professionals already in their fields and I am personally in a doctoral program. The last young lady with us is a dance major who has just signed a big deal in her field as well. I'm sorry that Doug viewed us as a bunch of college kids coming to wreck the place and didn't want to be helpful, but we had a great time in the area anyways. read more