A hidden gem! WOW I've missed food like this. Full of flavor and it's served hot and fresh! Staff is polite, friendly and helpful. Clean and wholesome restaurant. I tried a few random picks from the menu and it was all excellent. I was looking forward to eating there again, before even finishing my meal! Definitely a must, if you're looking around, give this place a try, it's yummy! read more

We order pizza here every week and tonight - just not good. Yes - I knew it was going to be hour-45 but certainly not that it was going to be stone cold. Embarrassing in front of my guests that I had bragged about this place forever. We live less than 2 miles from your place - but appeared we were last stop on your drivers route . What do you do to keep your regulars ?? read more

Come here for the pizza ! We were really hungry and needed a quick bite to eat in the area. We got the garlic knots and a medium pizza with mushroom and olives. It came out quickly. We didn't really like the garlic knots since they were cold and the marinara wasn't very good, so our expectations were lowered for the pizza. To our surprise, the pizza was pretty good! We enjoyed it! read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Medium 12" Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

See all

I came here because my buddy wanted to try the place out. I always was curious about pizza here as well. The parking lot is a little small as it shares with Vision Work and At&t, I came here on a week night and there was a decent crowd here. We were seated right away. I ordered the New Yorker Pizza by the slice and a Caesar Salad. Service was good but unfortunately the Caesar salad was the highlight of my dinner. The pizza was not hot and cheese was hard and not melted. I guess I am used to having hot and melted cheese on my Pizza. There was way too much olives and not enough meats. The pizza did not taste good. I had frozen pizza from Krogers better than this. Actually the Digorno's Pizza tastes better. I probably won't be coming back for the pizza, but may try something else next time. Like I said, service and cleanliness of the restaurant was great but the pizza i got was just not good. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Small Caesar Salad - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

See all

We had a Stromboli and a Calzone. They were both good! Fresh, and hot! HUGE! The service is very friendly and knowledgeable about the menu. The feel of the place is almost like a sports bar, TVs are playing all the games. Families are there with children. It's clean and overall a good place! I will go back! read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Slice of pepperoni, Stromboli, Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

Food is amazing! My husband got the small 5 meat stromboli (which really isn't small) and I had the pesto panini (because he hates pesto and I love it). We live 20-25 minutes away and he said he wished we had one of these closer to home. We will definitely be back! read more

See all

This place was a total disappointment. Both myself and my husband were only able to take a first bite. Food quality was extremely poor and disgusting. The calamari was inedible rubber, the chicken panini was also inedible, precooked chicken breast, I have no words other than it was horrible. The Philly cheese steak was also the worst he's ever had. Again inedible. The servers were playing around and looked as if they could care less! Will not be back here and do not recommend eating here! Horrible food, mediocre service! read more

Tried this place twice now. First time I just did NOT care for the sauce on lasagna, it's different, couldn't get past it. ALSO tried the Reuben, yes very thick but not grilled much, it completely fell apart and presented to be very messy on first bite, the corned beef was hard to chew, I just couldn't eat it. I'm not picky but both dishes were nothing at all you would expect of what they should taste like. Sadly, I cannot go back. read more

Brooklyn Joe's is EXCELLENT. The portions are big and the service is excellent. Our server Topper was great. The atmosphere is pizzeria/sports bar and cozy. The establishment is clean with a great selection of beer and wine. We had mozzarella stocks and fried zucchini to start. Both were very good. For dinner, we had pizza, chicken parm, Alfredo, and wings. Everything was served hot and was delicious. We will definitely be com8ng back! read more

See all

Everyone in my family got sick after eating pizza from here 05/02/26 . I think the intentionally did something to the food because I am black !! read more

This place never disappoints! I posted reviews in the past, but today we picked up an extra large margarita pizza a slice of pepperoni, and a slice of meatball. The pizza is delicious, of course, but if you've never tried the whiskey, battered onion rings... You need to because they are phenomenal! I would skip the chipotle ranch because they are perfect all by themselves! You can actually taste the onion inside the perfect batter that has a flavor. There is nothing frozen about these. Something I've noticed is some of this staff either really likes working here, or they are family because they've been here a long time. They take pride in what they do and treat people they way you wish everyone would. read more

See all

Very disappointed with how unprofessional the manager is. We called and placed a Togo order, something came up and we decided that we were gonna eat a slice or two at the restaurant because we weren't going back home. We ask the host if we can sit and eat real quick. She says yes. Not 1 min after we sit the "manager" comes up and tells us to leave. He states Tables are reserved for customers dining in. There was no wait, there were plenty of tables. But yet, we are forced to take the walk of shame because apparently we aren't good enough to eat a slice of pizza at the place we ordered the food from. read more

I love the fact that you can one good size slice of pizza and the Greek Salad is so delicious! Staff is always so friendly and I would totally recommend this place 100% read more

The pizza, chicken parmigiana and Stromboli are legit. Sure other item follow suit.. ..... read more

I decided to give this place a try last night based on their name and their reviews. BIG MISTAKE!!! ABSOLUTELY THE WORST MARGARITA PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD!!! It's usually a safe bet at ANY pizza restaurant, plus I'm a vegetarian, but obviously Joe's is like Arby's "it's all about the meats!" My pizza was SUPER BLAND with the exception of the taste of the loads of RAW GARLIC that one of the kids making pizzas thought would be a great idea to just throw on there!! There was no salt taste, of which just a pinch would have gone a long way. There was no twang flavor that good tomatoes and cheese will give when they marry... such a disappointing experience. On a positive note, the staff were super friendly. read more

The food is always consistent at Brooklyn Joes. The white pizza is one of my favorites.

Great family friendly restaurant with good food and service. We have ordered most things on the menu and everything is good. Our favorites are the salads, chicken parm sub, pizza, chicken Marsala and chicken francese. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Greek salad - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

See all

The pizza is great but the delivery times and hours are tight. Basically order before 8 or they will not deliver. At least not where we are. We are about 7 miles away and if we don't order by 8 they tell us they can't deliver. The pizza is awesome... not to this crunchy crust with a chewy inside... lots of toppings to choose from and the flavor is fantastic! This is one of those places that I would always order from... but I really need some better delivery hours! read more

See all

Everybody's loves BJs. Best pizza in town. Never disappoints. Worth every dollar spent. If you haven't tried it yet, it will quickly become your favorite spot after you're first try! read more

Love the pizza at Brooklyn Joe's. Service is nice. Always a group of young people wanting their customers to be happy. Pizza perfection - from a Connecticut girl!!! read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

I am a picky pizza eater but I loved Brooklyn Joe's. The dough is light and soft, yet chewy- and the taste is amazing. We got a red sauce, mozzarella pizza with olives on one side and ricotta on the other. Chefs kiss. Service over the phone and with delivery was polite and friendly. I'll be continuing to order my pizzas from here. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

Love this place- back again because no one makes it better! Joes Stromboli is to die for. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Stromboli on a cold January day! - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

I like pizza here , I also like the food, the staff is always welcoming and helpful . I never had anything unpleasant, always good. read more

Brooklyn Joe's lunch specials are really good - lots of food for the price! All kinds of combinations with a drink. Garlic knots and sauce delicious with a super fresh salad! Casey was a very good and friendly server! Checked in with us multiple times to be sure everything was perfect! Clean restrooms! Enjoy! read more

See all

I am a pizza snob and this place hits every single time I order ANYTHING!! The staff is patient with me because I'm a lot to deal with when it comes to my food and ordering. read more

Based on the other reviews, I'm not sure if we just ordered the wrong thing. But our pepperoni pizza was honestly worse than a frozen pizza. Also tried an app, and a club sandwich. Both sub par. Only came here because Bobby G's was closed. Won't be doing that again. read more

I came here for lunch on a weekend and there was a good crowd inside. Parking was easy in their shared lot. We were seated right away at a booth and our super friendly server was with us immediately. he was good about recognizing that we were chatting and hadn't looked at the menu to order our food. After getting our drinks, we finally ordered and the food arrived shortly thereafter. They have some lunch specials along with the full menu available, which has everything from pizza, pasta, wings, calzones, and sandwiches. I did not order off the lunch menu and had the Italian sub, which was available hot or cold. I got it hot. It was good, but not great. The bread was the perfect amount of crunchiness, but the meat and oil and vinegar did not have the kick I have seen in other similar sandwiches. Some peppers of some sort would be a nice addition to this sandwich. read more

Really enjoyed lunch! It's rare to find grilled shrimp and grilled chicken in a penne pasta! It was delicious. Pizza looked great too! Large kids menu. I'll be back! read more

Our favorite pizza place. It's always good whether take out or dine in. Just ate here in the restaurant. Our service was fast and food delicious. Ordered a Greek salad and pepperoni pizza. read more

Love Love the cheese pizza here! We order take out pizza occasionally and its been great. Warning: The smell is so amazing it may cause you to eat a piece in the car on your way home. Tip: always have napkins ready! We've had spaghetti there in the past, its ok. Same with the sandwiches - ok, but truly enjoy the pizza the most. read more

See all

The closest you will get to NY style pizza in Alpharetta ;) The eggplant parm is also excellent. This is a no frills place in a Target parking lot but the food is good and the staff is young but they work hard and hustle. Appreciate this kind of service and the price is good for the quality. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Great causal eatery with friendly service. Roxanne rocks ! - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

Time and time again, I get a parm meatball sub and ask them to broil the cheese so it isn't a white blob on top- Today, the kid said "Do you want it kinda' burned"..."yes" So, I wait as another "white blob" is served- how frickin' hard is it to brown a bubbly cheese topping? NOT HARD !!! I'd be glad to come over there, for free, and TEACH them how to make a good sub with COOKED CHEESE ! On the other hand, this 65yr old (lived in NYC area for 35yr including one teenage stint as a pizza chef) can report if you order a pizza "thin and well-done, they do those correctly- likely, the only decent pie in the ATL metro area BUT your meatball parm SUCK. Pizza rated 8-9 out of 10 Meatball parm 3 out of 10 (meatballs good, bread good, add more sauce as requested and BROWN the cheese); pasta salas side 9 of 10. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - COOK THE CHEESE !!! - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

Excellent food, especially salads, pizzas, ziti, and eggplant Parmesan. Awesome local restaurant

2nd time visiting this location while in town visiting my daughter. Great selection of pies. Service was on top of it for a party of 8 on a Sunday lunch. Definitely will be back when we are around this way. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Philly Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

See all

We decided to try a new pizza place tonight. Ordered takeout over the phone - one extra large with pineapple, ham, and mushroom, cooked well-done. Ordering was simple, but we were horrified about the lack of social-distancing being observed inside the restaurant, especially in the bar area right by the front door. Lots of staff members had the masks on under their noses. It was unsettling to say the least. The pizza was good. The slices held up the way you want them to. However, we felt the size was a little lacking. There was so much extra room in the extra large box. It truly ate more like a traditional large. We also found the amount of crust on 2/3 of the pizza to be unacceptable. Large dough bubbles and huge areas without any "coverage" was disappointing. The quality of the toppings was good. And the flavor was quite nice. We just felt like the value for the money was way off. For $30 for one pizza, we were expecting a lot more. Especially considering the value for your money you can get from some of the local competition. Finished dinner feeling satiated-ish, but definitely not satisfied. read more

Brooklyn Joe's - Extra large, who? - Pizza Near Me - Milton, Georgia

See all

Love this restaurant. Friendly people, well paced service. Damn good food at reasonable prices.

Love this place, the pizza and everything they have to offer and also treat me like family.

I get full off of one slice, LOL but that means the quality of ingredients is there! We've ordered from here every Friday since moving to Alpharetta. They are always super sweet and very quick with the order. It's always packed in here for good reason!! read more

Ordered a Greek salad with my pizza. My wife and I started eating the salad and noticed there was no black olives we told the waitress and she ask if we would like another one made. That's where things went south the GM Flora came out and accused us of eating the salad and wanting another one for free. She was very rude and when back to her staff and pointed us out. We have been going to this restaurant for over 15yrs. There are too many pizza places in Milton to get treated like this. Probably want go back. FYI we got changed for the 1/2 eaten salad.. read more

This place has more roaches than customers. I drove over an hour because my mom insisted this was the best pizza only to be seated and have a roach crawling up my leg within a minute from arriving. I would've left, but my mom wanted to stay so we did. She ate pizza, we paid, and as we were leaving I noticed THREE roaches under the table.. one crawling on the booth, another on the wall, and one on the floor.I let the server know this and he said he would get the manager. We waited for what seemed like a long time. At this point I was standing at the front counter and could clearly see more roaches in the kitchen prep area floor. I lost my patience and left. It was so nasty. My mom eventually admitted she was very hungry and was willing to overlook it but would never return either. read more