It was delicious pizza. Lots of toppings. It is pricey, but for what you get, it's well worth it. They know how to make a pizza!

Brooklyn Boys has a great atmosphere overall, with cool décor, indoor and outdoor seating, and fans or heaters depending on the weather. The food is usually very flavorful with fresh ingredients, which I really appreciate. The only drawback for me is the night staff. If you arrive about 30 minutes before closing, there's an obvious feeling of annoyance and inconvenience from their tone and actions. One evening, I even overheard someone in the kitchen say, "I'm going to do this ass backwards because I don't want to be around them out there," which was concerning. Tonight I watched, a father and his children were told at 8:15 that the kitchen was closed. If Brooklyn Boys wants to stop serving at 8:15, that's their choice--but it should be clearly posted instead of advertising later hours. read more

Brooklyn Boys is ALWAYS good! I was happy to find out I could get delivery and prices are good too. The calzone I had was fresh and the veggies crunchy inside! read more

We live near Brooklyn Boys Pizza & get take out regularly for years now. Gosh how lucky we are to have such REAL food in our small community! Everything here is amazing from the Pizza to the Seafood pasta. Eating in is causal and worth the stop. read more

Atmosphere is pretty plain and our waitress was brand new but had a great attitude and worked hard to make up for her lack of experience but... went in with a party of twenty (they don't take reservations) and they seated us and got us drinks and everything came out on time and together. We all stayed with Italian even though they had sushi and Mexican etc etc. food was great! I rate places for what they are trying to be and not against other places of different categories so this is a great 5 star local small town Italian restaurant. Great food and service ! read more

This restaurant came recommended by a friend in the area. I was surprised by the looks of it. You would think that it isn't an Italian restaurant, but when you eat the food. It's simply amazing. My wife always judges an Italian restaurant by its sauce. And she loved it. So we knew the food was going to be great. We had a really good talk with the stepson of the owner as he was our server, and we learned a little bit about the restaurant . supporting local business is important. Are food came out hot tasty, with more of the tasty sauce for dipping. I know next month. Where will we take a large party to this restaurant after our event. If you're in the keys, don't area or passing through. It's definitely worth a stop. They've got some really cool signage inside and out read more

See all

I'm incredibly disappointed in the service provided by the restaurant tonight. The waitress was fine, but they literally closed down around us, turning off the games in tv, mopping and stacking chairs as we were trying to enjoy our food. Whoever came to speak with us was rude. We would've never come in at 8 pm except the website stated that they close at 9:00. Fortunately, I don't live in Keystone, where there are literally three restaurants to choose from. However, the family we were here visiting does- as does their large extended family, and they won't be back. What a shame. The food was good, but the attitude of everyone who worked there was absolutely atrocious. If I could give less than a one star I would! read more

Food. Spaghetti had oily sauce that didn't stick to noodles. Canzone, spinach and roasted red pepper; crust was good, baked perfectly, the filling was a strip of mozzarella next to, not on top of, a strip of ricotta, with 2-3 thin strips of red pepper and a too small amount of spinach pulled in the middle. Service. The staff was prompt, polite, and helpful, though a little too casual in addressing customers, especially we somewhat older folks. They were clearly ready to go home. Slamming glasses, plates and silverware when cleaning of a table. That cacophony coupled with the country music played through tinny speakers made the meal one to be tolerated vs enjoyed. Ambiance. While the waitstaff brought the food , iced tea and silverware out correctly, the general feeling in the place was I Don't Care, and customers being taken for granted. Zero effort in ensuring customer satisfaction and return business. There are better places in this small town. read more

Been in KH for a year and finally have this place a shot. Decor is defo as described by others as Politically Incorrect, but I don't base my food options on politics, so not bothered. Mama and I both had a stromboli, hers was steak and mine was the Garbage. Both were good, but the garlic knots were the real star. Swimming in garlic butter, hit and fresh, and super tasty. They come with marinara but you don't really need it. Service was passable, with nothing to set it apart or give me a reason to complain. They also charge a fee for all card transactions, so just be aware. read more

See all

Food takes too long. We can make one at home and have it eaten before one even makes it to our table at this establishment. Last time it took 45 minutes to get a large pizza brought to our table and it wasn't even good enough to wait for! No thank you. We would rather make the trip to Starke and be treated right at Tony's Italian Restaurant where their pizza is amazing! read more

Pretty good ! We ate that all up so fast. Great flavors. Food came out hot and fast. Every time we finished one dish the next just about came out right after. Not pictured are the medium wings. Could've been a bit saucier but the ranch was good. read more

See all

fed 5 adults & 2 littles pizza, sub, wings, stromboli, and beverages outdoor dining perfect for these FL wannabees :) read more

Brooklyn Boys - Brooklyn Boys F L O R I D A - Pizza Near Me - Keystone Heights, Florida

Awesome food. Friendly staff. Great atmosphere. Husband enjoyed as well. Would eat there again. Over and over again.

Waitress seemed annoyed we came in an hour before they closed and didn't even greet us. Just grumbled under her breath. Bar tender came and took our order but at that point it was kind of awkward. Pizza was just ok. Wings at the table next to us looked legit...wish we would have ordered that instead. read more

Food was good. Had Stromboli. Kudos to cooks. Greek salad came late. Never ate it so can't review. Looked like a standard Greek so I'm sure it was fine. Group of 8 of us. No complaints from anyone regarding food. Waitress was new. Very sweet but obvious she was new. Despite our experience, we tipped her 20%. If future of this place has anything to do with service & attitude, don't expect it stay open for more than a year. Can't imagine people in that community putting up with it no matter how good the food is. Bartender was very rude. Some other guy working in there was a jerk as well. Spoke to manager & he could less if we were happy or not. Based on actions of employees, can't help but think owner must be similar or they wouldn't act like that. Bottom line is this- We don't live there. Might visit once a year. The other 6 people who we were with do actually live in that community. They've eaten there numerous times. Said food was usually good, but service was usually bad. According to them, this was worse ever treated. They won't be back. Avoid this place. read more

Best Pizza we have had in Florida. We got a large pizza. Called in order, was ready when we arrived at the Pick up entrance , so no need to enter. If we were staying in the area longer we would try their other items on menu and Dine in. read more

Only been twice and the food has been very good both times. First visit they had smoked and then flavored chicken wings which were excellent. A month later the waitress informed me they are no longer smoked. Disappointed about this since I liked to get the smoked chicken wings and antipasto salad. I'll still be back to try their other food. Service is somewhat slow do to how busy they generally are. Don't expect to come in and out in 30 minutes. Atmosphere is relaxed and light. Overall great little place in Keystone Heights. read more

Great food! The atmosphere is.. not the best. The wings can be a little hit or miss here, but their pizza and calzones are always great! Could've used just a bit more garlic today, though. The fries and garlic knots are always top tier! A little secret is that they have sushi night on Wednesdays! I know it sounds crazy, but the sushi here is actually fantastic! read more

Food was really good. I was pleasantly surprised for being in a small town. We just had pepperoni pizza and garlic knots but was really good. Definitely going back! Decor is interesting also! Prices are very reasonable. Casual atmosphere. If you are a smoker It looks like there is seating outside with ashtrays. Separate entrance for take out. Service was good also. She was on the ball! read more

Brooklyn Boys - Garlic knots - Pizza Near Me - Keystone Heights, Florida

See all

The online reviews said this was the best pizza in town. If this is true, Keystone Heights has a problem. The Domino's had better pizza, even though it received a worse overall review. We ordered a pizza to-go; 1/2 pepperoni and onion and ham and mushrooms on the other 1/2. The pepperoni and onion 1/2 was ok, but the pepperoni used was very spicy/hot, which was not to my liking. The onion was stringy and seemed like there was onion skins in the mix. The other 1/2 was terrible! The ham and mushroom side looked like the had dumped Spam on it. The toppings were not recognizable, because it was very finely chopped up. My husband said it was the worst pizza he'd ever had, and we've traveled the world, getting pizza in every county. Needless to say, we will not return. read more

Highly Highly Recommend! We tore into the pizza before I could take photos, but it was delicious. The pizza crust was crispy and toppings were top notch! Already looking forward to coming back next weekend read more

Brooklyn Boys - Chicken Pesto Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Keystone Heights, Florida

See all

Third time we've been to Brooklyn Boy's Pizza/ The P.IG. In the last 2 months. The waitress's are great, love the atmosphere but the pizza is garbage. So soggy and full of water it falls right off the crust, have to eat it with a fork it's so bad. Very little flavor unless you have sausage or pepperoni. We thought maybe it was a fluke...$50 bucks later, no it's the way it's made, same way all three times, three different pizzas. Won't be back.... read more

Things have definitely improved and we are now fans of Brooklyn Boys! Their pizza is very good & their meat lasagna is some of the best around! So glad they have improved not only their food but their service! read more

Great pizza, cooked perfect. Reasonable price and very friendly folks. Got a deluxe pizza 14" perfect for two with leftovers for tommorow. Crust was thin and tasty. read more

Good pizza, good seafood, good wine, good beer, relaxed atmosphere, plenty of TVs to watch the games, and a covered patio for the nice days. It's one of my favorite places in the area. Very friendly staff and good service. read more

Brooklyn Boys - Shrimp, scallops, and andouie over totellini. - Pizza Near Me - Keystone Heights, Florida

Worst customer service ever. The waitress was so nasty; cursing at us because check was incorrect. There is a sign on the wall that states they are "politically incorrect," but what they actually are is classless. I wouldn't eat there again if they had the last morsel of food on the planet. read more

Brooklyn Boys - Pizza Near Me - Keystone Heights, Florida

See all

Amazing food and great service too! Decent beer selection. Try the calzone! We have also had the toasted ravioli and pizza. Everything was good so far! read more

Our first time ordering. Pizza and sides were decent. Felt it way too expensive for an o.k. dinner. Would have given a better review if they delivered. Had to also order from Dominos to be able to afford feeding all. read more

Not real impressed with attitude of employees in here. More concerned with chatting with each other than getting hot food out to customer. Food is not that special either, read more

Standing in line to order, you don't tell me to wait and take a bunch of orders on the phone to be put in before mine. Tell them to hold. Then when I ask to have my order put before theirs I get to listen to smart mouth comments from the back. It's a reasonable request and I'm not your bro, I'm a customer supporting your local business instead of patronizing a chain. Y'all must racking up the disappointed local residents, it'll all catch up. read more

Had a great first experience at Brooklyn Boy's in Keystone Heights. Hunter is a great bartender amd recommended everything I ordered. Definitely will be back. They also have an AMI Jukebox to play your favorite hits. read more

See all

The best Pizza in town, very nice bar. Daily specials really good. Service amazing, great people cold beer, asked for Margaritas!!

got the philly cheese steak sub and it was really gross. Not sure what kind of meat that was!!

Great food and a good atmosphere! They had a wide bar of beers on tap too and service was fast! We will be back. read more

Brooklyn Boys - Pizza Near Me - Keystone Heights, Florida

Hit up this place on Christmas Eve for my first time to try it. They were closing early which is reasonable. They had the "To Go" area open and some folks eating outside on the picnic tables but their dining room was closed. Their menu look lovely and had Stromboli, lasagna, pizza and all the usual Italian foods. In addition they an extensive list for Salads, Subs, Hero's, Pasta, etc. A seriously good menu selection. We were barely greeted at the pickup area by a young girl with a graphic t-shirt. There was one other customer there and it seems she was challenged in the multi-tasker part of her job. Being new, no idea what was going on but I found the menu myself and looked at it for quite a while as she had a personal phone call, talked to the cooks and pretty much ignored us. She finally asked me what we wanted and she seemed annoyed with my order, had to talk to the pizza dough throwing guy for a solution but caught the whole vibe as very inconvenienced that we were there at all. All I wanted was a supreme pizza with some extra veggies added to the other side. We added an appetizer and, again, felt like we annoyed her. Asked for a beer or wine (aka alcoholic beverage) and she flatly replied that they could but we couldn't drink in the premises. What? Not at the picnic tables? Just really not understanding this because we wanted to give you more money but she wasn't helpful with the menu, conversation, explaining, etc. We paid and sat outside and joked that we would be lucky if she didn't come out and throw the food at us and you could bet there would be no napkins. She didn't actually throw it was abruptly sat it in the table and left immediately. Guess what? No napkins, no dipping sauce for the fried mushrooms. Pizza was good, mushrooms were eh. A guy at another table must have overheard us because he went to his truck and brought us back some paper towels. Overall, on a normal day, probably would be better service. As an employer myself, I would never allow someone to face my customers like this. The food was good, I will go back to try the other items on the menu but this visit left us annoyed simply because of this one employee. read more

I have always had good food here from the pasta to the salads. Their pizzas are good. Stick to the Italian things on the menu because I think that's what they do best. I really like their salads they have good service and good takeout. It's a bar style atmosphere but they have outside tables as well. read more

Great pizza place I recommend the Philly pizza great service takes only fifteen minutes

This was supposed to be extra cheese. I'm seeing barely ANY CHEESE. I am really trying to give this local business some business and they are making it really difficult. read more

Brooklyn Boys - Pizza Near Me - Keystone Heights, Florida

I highly recommend their garlic parmesan wings...their chicken bacon ranch pizza and their buffalo chicken pizza are also the absolute BOMB. We went there because I've been telling my buddies about them for absolutely ever and since we were pretty close, we did. While it wasn't a cheap bill, everybody LOVED the wings and pizzas we brought home. One person kept asking "where did you get this from?". Needless to say, I certainly WILL BE back, simply because of the wonderful flavors everyone enjoyed. If you're looking for cheap and quick, look elsewhere, but for great flavored pizza and some of the most banging wings out there, you pay for what you get. I've eaten inside a few times with my husband and he had calzone or stromboni and didn't like it because the innards weren't cooked at all, but I'll stick with my pizza and wings. Both are out of this world. They also have some amazing craft beers on tap so I hafta give major kudos for that simple fact. read more

Love there salads. The pizza is very good also and the Italian fries for appetizer. They also have really good boiled shrimp.