After getting some work done on my car, I decided to stop by Milk Burger, and I'm so glad I did…read more This place absolutely lived up to the hype.
Let's start with the only real challenge. Parking in this area is tough, so give yourself a little extra time to find a spot. Once you're parked though, everything else is smooth sailing.
I had the pleasure of meeting the owner, Erik, and he was one of the highlights of my visit. Funny, personable, welcoming, and genuinely appreciative of every customer who walks through the door. You can tell he takes pride in both his restaurant and the experience he creates. He told me my food would be ready in about 10 minutes, and he was right on the money. He even wrapped everything up and set it by the window so I had a nice view while I ate. I firmly believe a good view makes food taste even better.
The restaurant itself was bright, clean, and had plenty of space to sit and enjoy your meal.
Now for the food.
I ordered the Garlic Double Smash with crinkle cut fries after seeing Johnny Novo rank Milk Burger as his number four burger out of 50 burgers he's tried across New York City. After one bite, I completely understood why.
This burger was outstanding. Juicy, perfectly seasoned, loaded with gooey melted cheese, and packed with crispy edges that every great smash burger should have. The grilled onions added the perfect touch of sweetness to balance everything out. Every bite somehow tasted even better than the last. If you're debating between a single or a double, get the double without hesitation. If they'll make you a triple, even better.
The crinkle cut fries were fresh, crispy, perfectly salted, and exactly what you want alongside a great burger.
To wash it all down, I ordered the Henny Colada, and it was delicious. Smooth, refreshing, and a fun twist on a frozen drink.
If I had to offer any critiques, the burger is a little smaller than I expected, it was slightly greasy, and I personally wouldn't complain about a little more Hennessy in the colada. Then again, maybe that's just me. None of those things took away from how fantastic the meal was.
Milk Burger earned every bit of this five star review. Great food, great service, and an owner who genuinely cares about his customers. I'll absolutely be back, and next time I'm trying the classic Milk Burger, the burger that originally put this place on the map.