I stopped here over the blisteringly hot weekend to get some ice cream because why not?…read moreYou order from a window, then your ice cream is handed to you in short order. I was excited to see that they had black raspberry ice cream, one of my favorites that is usually pretty hard to find outside of New England. I got a small size, which was he perfect amount. I was able to eat it all before it melted! There are benches on the side of the building beneath a cool mural. If you're looking for good ice cream in Lancaster, give this place a try.

Cute little ice cream shop downtown. Right on the corner of the street. They only do a walk up…read morewindow to order, no going inside. One kid working inside. We were the only customer on a cold Friday night but I could see them get busy during the summer. The ice cream was great. They even sell soup to take home and heat up yourself. Pricing was very reasonable.

We love rolled cold creamery! We have been here numerous times. Normally I dock them points for the…read moresmall space and limited seating, but now they definitely score a 5 star with the new location! Tons of seating, tons of space! You get a great bang for your buck here with 3 toppings and a sauce. We got the Peanut Butter Cup and Cheesecake! DELICIOUS! Staff is always friendly and very nice. They definitely give the customer a great product. Can't wait to go back!

You won't find many establishments opened late in Lancaster, but Rolled Cold Creamery is one of…read morethem. Located within the heart of downtown, this creamery was packed with college students, enjoying their purchases in their small rear seating area. The young staff members work hard, creating the artistry that I've never seen before. They take your order, create it on their frozen counter, and roll up the ice cream. Every roll was smooth, creamy, and the cookies and cream topping was the perfect selection to combine with the coffee ice cream. Thank you Rolled Cold Creamery, for having late hours and for making lots of customers very happy.

Always a 5 stat trip when you go to Nikki's Custard! Tonight's specials were Peanut Butter…read moreMarshmallow.....so good.... they are also serving up a Cold Brew Float that was incredible! If you haven't been to Nikki's they are right there with the best of the best in Lancaster County. Great service, their workers definitely care and put effort into making their ice cream products look great! The shop is small, outside seating only. Great designs and design throughout the place!

This may be the best custard in the known universe!!! Do not ever go out for ice cream again -…read morego here and try these handmade custards and you'll be hooked like I am. Be sure to take note of how personable and helpful the staff is. And if you meet the owner - you'll get why you're having a great experience. Go here - you must go here! (If they have the Snickers flavor - my wife says you can't have it cause she's on her way to get it )

What a hit for our daughter's wedding at the Stoltfus Homestead and gardens! Barb was amazing to…read morework with! So accommodating, willing and able to serve our guests! It was the perfect addition to our reception ! Our guests RAVED about having the ice cream truck available! It really brought the whole vision of a fun, relaxing reception together! The ice cream was so delicious too! Creamy and flavorful! Two full scoops in a cone or a cup! Impressive all the way around! If you're in the fence...JUST DO It! You'll seriously regret it if you don't!!!

We hired Penny's for our wedding and we would hire them a million times more if we could. Not only…read moreis the ice cream super delicious, but the service was excellent as well. My wedding guests continue to compliment us on the ice cream cart 4 months after. We were so extremely happy with Penny's and we recommend them to anyone looking to add a little fun to their event!

Good ice cream Service was quick…read more Prices have increased from the menu I found online though. Inside and outside seating Single stall, handicap-accessible bathrooms

The staff was very friendly, but not at all informed about the business. We were doing the…read moreLancaster Ice Cream Trail where this location was listed. The staff behaved as though they had to think a minute, then one staffer said she'd check to see if they still had it on their register from last year, which they did not. There is no true ice cream sundae listed on their menu, nor is there the option of just getting ice cream and a topping. We had to ask for that option. We both had butter pecan ice cream, only to discover that the ice cream is just flavored. There were no nuts in it at all, and it was pure white, not butter colored like a true butter pecan ice cream. Worst of all, the portions were TINY. We'd visited River Street Sweets at the Tanger Mall a few nights before, and their single scoop cup was the size of the Good Life double scoop cup, for the same price! The place looked dirty, the tables were dirty, the glass on the cases were dirty, and two staffers were just hanging out chatting and cracking jokes. Again, super friendly staff, but definitely not worth the money.

Came in here after our lovely dinner at Pizzeria Luca. Seriously, go there for lunch/dinner and…read morewalk across the street to Menchie's for dessert. It's a small spot, but has all the froyo yums your heart desires! Many different flavors and lots and lots of toppings. We're from California, where we have many froyo shops. We had to ask for samples here which is fine. It's just not what we're used to. I got plain tart, cold brew and Dole Pineapple. All were solid. Would definitely return!

Out of all the frozen yogurt shops I've visited across the country Menchie's is the creamiest,…read moretastiest and has a large selection of toppings. I love this place so much I would love to have one!!! The service is always friendly and they do a great job of keeping it clean. I've never had a problem finding parking. It's located in same shopping place as Wegman's and next door to Reels cinemas.

Stopped by just before closing to satisfy a after dinner dessert craving!…read more The cupcakes were absolutely adorable and tasted just as good as they looked. Unfortunately, their most popular flavor had already sold out, but we ended up trying a few of the vegan options along with the Minion-themed cupcake. The designs were super fun, and the flavors didn't disappoint Since it was right before closing, the service was pretty much what I expected. The staff was still friendly, and we tried to be mindful not to keep them too long The cupcakes are a little on the pricey side for their size, but they're well-made, delicious, and beautifully decorated. Overall, it was a great experience, and I'd definitely recommend stopping by if you're in the mood for a sweet treat!

This is a lovely shop, and the employees are always friendly. They have a nice selection of…read moredelicious flavors, and new flavors rotating in monthly. The cupcakes are beautifully decorated and are fresh and delicious. They seem appropriately priced for the quality. The milkshakes and jar cakes are also delicious. They offer a selection of coffee beverages, but I haven't tried any of those yet. There's both indoor and outdoor seating if you want to enjoy your treat right away. Be sure to sign up for their rewards program so you can earn free cupcakes!

SOOO GOOD. Just go…read more That's the review lol. Super kind people and service, good vibes, unique flavors and spot on quality icecream. Yum

Ice cream flavors were delicious The service was friendly…read moreand the to go bags are super nice , keep your ice cream cold on the way home