Great little place with local owners and excellent food. Has a full service bar, with a good…read morechoice of draft beers. Pizza was very good Highly recommend this place.

Very cool spot, super friendly service, full bar, but Pizza is lacking: very skimpy toppings…read moreordered a sausage peppers, onions and there were so little sausage on it I thought they forgot to add it. Crust is way too thick, leaving less room for toppings Place got a lot of potential, but the star of the show doesn't perform

My wife and I ordered a large, crusty, thin crust pizza with garlic sauce & half mushroom and half…read morechicken for pick-up. After I arrived and paid with cash, the young man behind the counter handed me the change, and then tried to give me the pizza at the same time? I asked him to put the pie down because I was putting the bills away, something I thought was very obvious? Then when I got home and opened the box, I became more upset; the pizza was not thin crust, not crispy, with barely any toppings and nearly a 60% bread crust! Here is yet another pizza place that does not train their employees about common courtesy, active listening skills, or how to make a proper pie. Now if we choose to order from them again, we will have to double check everything, including the finished pizza. This is not our job! Very disappointed.

I love Romeo's pizza, it's baller and delicious every single time. It's never not been amazing and…read moreit's our favorite pizza place. We love the BOGO coupons, they get us everytime with it.

Have had food from there many times, it's great. Highly recommend…read more Has recently had some work done on the outside of the building and looks cuter than ever.

Great pizza and great selection of products!…read more Excellent family business! Frozen items available, or pick up fresh to make at home or best yet, let them make the pizza for you and bring home to enjoy! They do all the work! Always a favorite !!!!

Excellent food and it was ready for pickup as promised. We really enjoy getting food from Contessas.read more

I can't believe I have an updated my review for this place…read more We love this place. And we love their pizza, which is ironic from my previous review. Also, their fried chicken is absolutely amazing. The owners do so many amazing things for the community, they deserve even more stars. It's a small town diner, nothing fancy.

This pizza place is incredible! This is top 5 best pizza I have ever had and I have eaten a lot of…read morepizza! I got the Colossal Italian and the Primo Pepperoni. The Colossal Italian had very fresh and delicious sausage on it, especially the spicy sausage! The Primo Pepperoni had old world pepperoni and lots of cheese! The sauce is incredible here because it is a nice balanced sauce that is savory but also has a hint of sweetness to it. The fresh garlic and basil really adds something amazing! The crust is not crust you will toss aside either! The staff was very helpful and courteous in explaining the toppings to me and accommodating not putting spicy sausage on the entire pizza because my wife can't eat spicy food. The restaurant had a cool ambience and feel to it. Overall, this is a must stop for any pizza lover and if you live distance away....its worth the drive! Don't miss this pizza gem in Amish country! Incredible!

First time trying this place. It was on a Saturday afternoon. I'm guessing it was considered busy…read more We ordered a small pizza for $17. My wife also ordered a chicken sandwich. We said water for our drink and they wanted to charge for water so we decided against that. We dined in. My wife's chicken sandwich came out pretty quickly. About 40 minutes later my pizza was delivered to our table. The noise of the place was terrible. The steel chairs on the hard floors echoed throughout the dining area. The pizza was delicious! Definitely one of the best pizza pies I've had. Little soggy in the center but overall it was great! My wife liked the chicken sandwich but the dressing was a little heavy, which made it a little too salty for her taste. We're excited to try different items next time! Pros: Food was great. Cons: WAIT TIME Noise Price

Hometown pizza done right! LOVE having a buffet style lunch here with friends. Always 5-8 kinds of…read morepizza, (including a dessert style one maybe two) 2-sandwich styles, spaghetti & marinara sauce with garlic bread, & a whole salad bar selection. It's SWEET! You won't be disappointed!! Sorry I go so very often. I didn't even think to take pictures. I love it here.

The best pizza I've ever had. Would be my last meal if I had a say in the matter. My family has…read morebeen eating it for generations

Love their pizza & service is always the BEST! They always remember me & are very friendly!! We…read morenever get delivery because I always want to go in & say hello!

This location is always busy! Super busy!! But they are quick and efficient! This is one of my…read morefavorite pizza places, too! You have to try the square pizza! The crust and everything is so different than their round ones! It's so worth a try!!! I get extra cheese and it's amazing! Love this location and miss the dine in area! But still good!

I was going to dine in but decided to do take out as I found this place is a little more kid…read morefriendly than I was expecting. I got a pint of reasonably priced beer while I waited on my order. So I ordered a 9" pepperoni and mushroom pizza and some breaded deep fried mushrooms to go. My order came out within 15 minutes. The pizza was pretty good. The crust was thin and crispy. The sauce was pretty decent. There were a fair amount of toppings although they weren't spread out very evenly. The price was about right ($12) but the breaded mushrooms were a little steep ($8) for the few smallish pieces I got. The staff was friendly and they do have a reasonably priced pizza buffet that would definitely entice hungry families on a budget. Chet and Matt's is a 4 star kind of place.

Stopped by for dinner with friends. We wanted to try a local pizza place avoiding chain…read morerestaurants and something children would eat. Place appeared busy attracting tourists in the area. There also appeared to be a salad bar that we did not get a chance to try. We ordered two orders of breadsticks with cheese for the table, cheese pizza, meat lovers pizza, redskin potato pizza along with fried cauliflower. I wished the waitress would have offered some advice when we ordered that much food. The breadsticks with cheese were essentially a ticker cheese pizza and we were completely full when the actual cheese pizza arrived. The red skin pizza was good as it was something new I don't typically see around. The best part of the whole meal was the fried cauliflower which I wish we had a bigger portion as we were trying to split with the table. I'm not sure if I would come back here. The food was fine but nothing to rave over other than the fried cauliflower that I feel we didn't get enough of.

FYI - carry out only. No inside seating. Staff was friendly. No pizza place in town has seating.read more

Tried Romeo's again tonight. After much thought, I decided to give them another chance. It's been a…read morecouple of years. I ordered a half pound of wings. $9 for four little wings! They weren't even jumbo wings. Major rip off. They would be better advertising by the number of wings., 5 or 10 or whatever. The meatball sub was ok, the Italian sub was... meh. Hardly any lettuce... lots of meat. Pretty much all I could taste. I come back every few years hoping the old Romeo's would make a comeback... I guess that's just wishful thinking.

I love this place. I…read moregrew up in New York City and this is easily the closest to NYC pizza anywhere around here. And even if you don't care about NY style pizza, it is just flat out terrific pizza, with the perfect chew to the crust and top notch toppings. Good beer selection (with a chilled glass). And staff is always very friendly. My only negative is that it isn't closer to my house.

This is one my favorite pizzerias In the Cleveland area. They serve multiple crusts. All being very…read moregood. I love their sauces. Love. The wings on Tuesdays are pretty special. The meatballs and cavatelli on Wednesdays are even more special. The staff rocks. I love coming here with my girlfriend. She rocks too.