I have always been a fan of the Blue Pig, but my recent visit was next level! I'm not sure if they got a new chef, but there were updates to the menu. I felt there were much more interesting dishes. It was so hard to pick one! We had reservations and were seated right away. The service was quick and efficient! We started with the ahi tuna, which was incredible. If you like sushi/raw fish, this app is a must! Then I went with the scallops for my main. It was a summer version of the scallops I've had in the past and they were amazing! I loved the potatoes, sweet corn, bacon, all of it! I can't wait to come back here. The shrimp gnocchi is next on my must try list! read more

Blue Pig Tavern - Scallops - New American Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Blue Pig Tavern is located in a glassed-in patio area adjoining and contiguous to the Congress Hotel. It is a bit hard to find as it seeming;y lacks its own outdoor signage. The odyssey to finding it was well worth the effort. We had dinner reservations but on a Monday in May, probably did not need them. We both loved our flounder almondine order, despite it being a Monday night (when one does not typically order fish and expect it to be fresh). This really was! Service was top-notch and super-friendly from Jared, who was deeply apologetic when the oyster appetizer we ordered failed to appear - he comped a beer without prompting (and insisted upon it). Even absent this gesture, his attitude and manner made our evening - the excellence of the entrees was a cherry on top. One note and not the fault of the restaurant at all - a number of families with small children were dining at other tables. This is not an especially well-suited restaurant for families with under-5 kids. Their collective noise and behavior was more akin to, well, a Chuck-E-Cheese or MacDonalds. There was nothing anyone could do, of course. read more

Blue Pig Tavern - Flounder Almondine over green beans and mashed potatoes - highly recommended - see my May 2026 review - New American Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Dear Yelp, Made reservations here a week before our stay. Arrived about 6 minutes before our reservation time and had to wait. Hostess seemed frazzled. Asked us if we minded sitting on the inside deck. We did mind and were then show to a table inside the restaurant. (If we had our kids with us, then I would have not minded eating on the deck). The table was an awesome tucked away corner table that faced the inner dining room. The decor and experience were top notch. I'm glad I said no to eating outside. The room is absolutely beautiful if you are into vintage looks. I said it looked like Gaston's Tavern. Food and waitress service was good. My sister had the short ribs and they were tasty. I had a burger well done (and it was!) with both fries and a side salad. We both thoroughly enjoyed our meals and felt it was a good value for the cost. Love, Nicole read more

Blue Pig Tavern - Cheers! - New American Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Takes its name from a mid 1800s gambling parlor once there. It's a solid brunch spot when you want something quick and reliable with outdoor seating that hits on a nice day. Food is straightforward American classics done well for what it is and they keep the place open for breakfast, lunch, and dinner using ingredients from their own farm just a couple miles away. read more

See all

When booking a vacation in Cape May, you might wonder whether making a reservation for a nicer breakfast is worth it, especially when there are plenty of pancake houses around. But I am partial to booking one nice, memorable breakfast reservation and for our family, this was it. We had a few dietary restrictions and I was very pleased to discover they had so many substitutions available. For instance, my sister and I are dairy-free but love having "milk" in our coffee. They had two non-dairy milk options and I find that to still be rare at restaurants! The home fries were so flavorful and delicious. Perfectly cooked, too. This place seems to really fill up so I would recommend making a reservation! read more

This is our go to in Cape May! Congress Hall is such a beautiful building and dinner, or lunch at the Blue Pig is a great way to get to spend time in this historic landmark. The portions are large and the service is strong. I often get the turkey club which is large enough to split. read more

We are visitors here in Cape May, friends brought us here, fancy digs, but very nice brunch, great omelette! read more

Blue Pig Tavern - New American Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

My friend and I spent a weekend in Cape May and there was a blunder with our Saturday dinner reservation. We had to find somewhere with an opening in the midst of prime dinner hours. Blue Pig Tavern had an opening within 15 minutes of us finding out our original plan was no longer an option. We walked over and had a 10 minute wait, so we went over to the bar and each order a glass of wine (Cabernet and Sauvignon). Our table was ready by the time we were looking for a seat in the lounge. We sat in a little enclosed porch area overlooking the patio.. it was a lovely area to sit in with plenty of natural light. We ordered a shrimp cocktail to share and for our main course, I ordered the prime rib (the evening special) and my friend ordered the gnocchi. The portions were generous and we had leftovers for the following day. My prime rib was perfectly cooked (medium rare) with an au jus with a side of mashed potatoes and grilled asparagus. It was so good! My friend said her gnocchi was outstanding! Our wine was a perfect match to our dishes as well. We are already talking about when we go back. read more

See all

Good service and drinks but the food was low quality. The 'medium' steak frites was so charred that the only thing I could taste was a burnt flavor and it was incredibly chewy. I love steak, hangar in particular, and I ate 2.5 pieces of it before giving up- that's how bad it was. It shouldn't have left the kitchen. Congress hall seems to be resting on its laurels these days. read more

Good food but great quality. Service is EXCELLENT. Must go place if you want to watch the sunset while enjoying your meal.

Blue Pig is tucked into the back of Congress Hall. Once we found the entrance, we asked the hostess if we needed to feed the meters since it's off-season. She had no idea (but we discovered the answer was Yes). They were doing a brisk business on a Monday afternoon in November. We all enjoyed our meals - I especially liked my turkey burger with feta and tzatziki. Servers were no-nonsense and not very friendly. Didn't care for the ambiance - it's a little old fashioned for me. At least the food was good. read more

See all

Looking for a festive meal in a historic venue? Stop by the Blue Pig Tavern in old Cape May. Located in Congress Hall, there is plenty of history dating back to the founding of the thirteen colonies. I found myself on a cool summer evening, watching tourists and locals weave in and out, whiling away the time and digging into a huge plate of fish and chips. The portions were big and the food was prepared exactly as expected. If you're looking for some historical flavor to add to your meal, powder your wig, think like a revolutionary, and stop by the Blue Pig Tavern. read more

Blue Pig Tavern - Fish & Chips - New American Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Went to reserve a table. Picked the date, party of 2, time of reservation (4pm) and the time I made the reservation(2:40). Gave my name, email address, phone number, etc. Hit the button to confirm my reservation and got a response that said reservation confirmed. So we showed up for our 4pm reservation only to be told dinner reservations don't start until 5;30. I should her the confirmation I received back. She said the reservation was for 2:30. 1 said no, that when I entered/made the reservation online but the dining reservation was for 4:00. She said well your reservation was for 2:30. I just looked at her and said "you people are fucked up!" Recommendation: Find somewhere else to eat in Cape May, NJ. If they can't get their simple administrative reservations functions done properly, I can't imagine what and/or how fucked up their must taste like. read more

Another fabulous dinning experience. The food is delicious. We sat outside and brought our Schnoodle with us. Listened to live music, relaxed and had a few drinks. Congress hall is such a beautiful place. Staff is very attentive. read more

See all

Fantastic family meal for six of us on back lawn/veranda. Service was slow at first, but Mary was great and attentive to every detail. Food was fantastic and everyone enjoyed drinks, apps (calamari), bread, braised beef short ribs were amazing, two of us got burgers, Caesar with lobster, a filet and a gnocchi pasta were all winners. Can't wait to come back! read more

The chef at the Blue Pig could care less what you want or ask for. He has his own agenda. Wouldn't pair well w Mr. Flay! Too bad, the Congress is really really nice. read more

We had a sunset dinner here outside and it was beautiful the only downside was the bugs due to the little table lamps which were needed by 8:30p. The service was great and our meals were too. Loved the pigs in a blanket, steak frites, and salad. Complimentary bread was also great - like a Parker house roll. Would absolutely come back to try more of the menu and would likely sit outside again as well despite the bugs because the vibes are great out there! read more

CAPE MAY: Blue Pig Tavern is a classy restaurant serving up elevated American cuisine and drinks amongst the historic Congress Hall, Cape May resort. Blue Pig Tavern allows leashed and friendly dogs at their seasonal outdoor seating and we really enjoyed dining under the pergola with fall decor and the backdrop of the hall. Serving up breakfast, lunch, and dinner, we savored the avocado toast, eggs benedict, a side of home fries, and a nice warm latte on a chilly morning. In the off-season, they have portable heaters to keep things cozy. (FYI, Congress Hall hotel is not dog friendly inside.) read more

Blue Pig Tavern - New American Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

This was our second trip to Blue Pig and it didn't disappoint. Our server, Buddy, was great. Even my 10 year old commented that he was a great waiter. The special was Cioppino and it was delicious read more

Blue Pig Tavern - Cioppino special - New American Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Went for breakfast after a long break in many years of coming here. The Blue Pig has gone downhill. Sad. Ordinary diner quality food.

The food was very good, and the atmosphere was exactly what we expected for a special family gathering. Unfortunately, the service fell far short of the occasion. Our party of 11 was celebrating together, and our waiter seemed completely disengaged and uninterested in making the experience enjoyable or memorable. Rather than being accommodating, he came across as inconvenienced by even the simplest requests. A prime example was when I asked to have my son's family's meal added to my check. You would have thought I was asking for a free meal instead of making a routine billing request. The response and attitude were disappointing and unnecessary. A restaurant with such good food and ambiance deserves service that matches the quality of the establishment. Sadly, our waiter turned what should have been a memorable family event into one remembered for the wrong reasons. read more

You can tell this place stays in business simply on its history and tourist business. Food is just so so, it's incredibly loud, we kept having to yell at each other or lean in to the person who was talking. Service is extremely subpar. Our waiter was like a robot but not an efficient one. No personality and hardly ever came back to our table, we ended up asking busboys for water, napkins etc. I would definitely skip Blue Pig if in the area again. read more

We had lunch at the blue pig tavern today. It was good, not great. We had blueberry muffins, which were too enormous rolls with vanilla cream, frosting, and blueberries, nice. I had poached eggs with fried potatoes and spinach on a biscuit. Also nice. My seafood chowder was below average, thickened with lots of flour and more chicken than seafood in the base. We also had a smash burger that was delicious. The vegetarian omelette was average. Service was slightly slow. read more

Blue Pig Tavern - New American Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Given the location (within a prestigious old "grande dame" hotel, the ambiance, patronage, and wine cellar, we'd expected better of this restaurant. We sat in the main room with the fireplace, and it's particularly dark and hard to read the menu by table light alone. The menu is enticing and the service prompt and food fast, but perhaps prepared with speed versus taste because everything we ordered was bland and under-seasoned. For this reason, we were disinterested in ordering dessert and overall, left feeling disappointed and underwhelmed. There's a lot of potential for improvement here, but given our meal, its cost, and the volume of other options in town, it's unlikely we'll return. read more

Blue Pig Tavern came at the recommendation of my parents as a place to try for breakfast. When traveling, I like sitting for breakfast - and after checking out the menu this seemed to fit the bill. That being said, I made a reservation for the morning of my last day before heading home. BPT is located in Congress Hall; the hotel itself has a lot of history by being one of the oldest seaside resorts in Cape May - which is the US's oldest seaside resort town. So you can say it really all started here. The hotel has a lot of history, and the theming is a mix of upscale with classic Americana. That theming spills into BPT - it has a fresh look while still paying homage to its roots. I had an 8am reservation which was right when they opened and was seated in their outdoor enclosed porch. The breakfast menu has a good selection, broken down by egg dishes/omelettes, special dishes, waffles, pancakes, and sides. It's worth noting that several of the ingredients they use in the dishes come from Beach Plum Farm in West Cape May - a nice touch. Though I love pancakes and waffles, I wanted something a little higher in protein. After browsing, I landed on the Eggs Blackstone - kind of a spin on Eggs Benedict. The dish contained poached eggs, spinach, tomato, bacon, and black pepper hollandaise sauce all sitting atop cheddar biscuits. The dish was good - despite the components it wasn't too rich, and all of the flavors complemented each other. The dish came with potatoes on the side which were solid. Service was good; food was served in an appropriate amount of time and all the staff I interacted with were friendly. Overall, I enjoyed my meal at Blue Pig Tavern - the food was a win, the service was solid, and the aesthetics were lovely. This is definitely a standout restaurant in Cape May and worth a visit. read more

Blue Pig Tavern - Eggs Blackstone - New American Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

This place has a really nice ambiance. Came here for brunch and we were right on the cusp where we could get either breakfast or lunch. This got a bit complicated when our waiter had to suddenly leave shortly after we put in our drink orders due to a family emergency (totally understandable, he's human). There was some confusion by the restaurant about who would be our replacement waiter. The food was pretty good. I got the lobster roll which was big (not the best lobster roll but still decent), my son loved his pistachio chocolate French toast and my daughter loved her pancakes. Spacious, really nice interior, one of the better restaurants in Cape May I would say. read more

See all

Really nice spot with a great vibe -- ambience is warm and service was great. The food was pretty good overall, and the mimosas were definitely strong. Only downside: the home fries came with peppers and onions, which weren't mentioned on the menu -- would've been good to know in advance. Still, a solid brunch spot we always make sure to stop at when in Cape May. read more

Blue Pig Tavern - Special- cannoli stuffed French toast with chocolate chips and pistachios - New American Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

We were able to make same day reservations for 13 which was nice. The service was friendly and quick. The food was delicious. I had the scallops and clam chowder. The clam chowder was some of the best I've ever had so I highly recommend it. There were several children in our party and at the end of the meal someone came by to give them stickers which was sweet. I only wish they had more restrooms because there was a line. We sat outside which was very nice. read more

Located near the lobby of Congress Hall. Came here for breakfast. Standard, average fare with friendly service. There's a nice patio outside for when the weather is warm. I had the avocado toast. Wasn't exactly what I was expecting - there was a little salad on top, which I thought would be on the side, but it was good. I also had a side of smoke salmon to add to the avocado toast, it was a nice sized portion. Convenient location for a quick breakfast. read more

Blue Pig Tavern - Avocado Toast - New American Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Food was good, nothing spectacular. I don't think I'd return again as I'm sure there are better places in the area. Service was okay but ambiance was nice. read more

My best friend and I visited this spot while they were decorated for the holidays, and it was stunning inside. We both ordered the salmon which was tasty. However, I will say the bread in the beginning may have been the star of the show. Our server was very thorough. Reasoning for 4 stars is because we did have to wait for seats despite having a reservation. read more

Blue Pig Tavern - New American Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

Good service and a nice staff. The food is average, nothing spectacular but nothing bad either. We felt breakfast was much better than lunch or dinner. read more

This restaurant is becoming one of our favorite spots to dine when we're in Cape May. Been here a few times and have never been disappointed. Nestled inside Congress Hall, the ambiance inside and outside is spectacular. The inside seating is warm and rustic with a fireplace, the outside could be either sitting on their lovely patio where you have a view of the people coming and going through the shopping area or sitting out in the Congress Hall courtyard, that's usually available when the weather is nice. On this occasion we came for lunch and the weather was still a little cool so we opted to sit in their front porch area which is between the indoor and patio dining area. It was wonderful. To start off, my wife and I ordered a couple of martinis to go along with a half dozen Cape May Salts Oysters from our very friendly and attentive waitress. The martinis and the oysters were on point. After this we went with a couple of bowls of New England Clam Chowder which was some the best you will have. Creamy, flavorful and loaded with fresh clams. For our mains my wife ordered the Crispy Fish Sandwich which was beer battered fried haddock, served with tartar sauce, shaved lettuce, tomato, red onion and tavern fries which was delicious. I ordered the Fish & Chips, also with beer battered haddock, tavern fries, malt vinegar and tartar sauce which was honestly one of the best fish and chips I've ever eaten. The batter was so light and fish was so flavorful and tender. After we were done we went to have a couple of drinks in the Brown Room which is adjacent to the restaurant to cap off just a wonderful experience. This place is really such a solid choice when you're visiting Cape May, we will definitely be coming here often. read more

See all

The service was good, however, I asked the waiter to have the chef cook my seafood order well! As I have seen reviews of this restaurant before and several customers had the same issue, the flounder or cod was not cooked through and it was mushy! read more

Lovely setting, great breakfast! Fresh orange juice was amazing, and I've been dreaming of the potatoes ever since! However the restaurant doesnt allow for any substitutions, and the menu was a little misleading with what they offered. If you arent staying at a B&B, this place is wonderful for breakfast, especially on a rainy day by the fire place! read more

Blue Pig Tavern - New American Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

See all

Service is very slow despite lots of empty tables, we waited 40 min to be seated and 10 to have someone offer us a drink, than another 20 for lunch. Crab cake sandwich was respectable. For the price, the lobster roll should have had a lot more lobster. Not a great value as the most expensive thing on the menu. The venue has history and charm with a wandering Blue Pig. read more

Blue Pig Tavern - The Blue Pig with us. - New American Near Me - Cape May, New Jersey

The food and atmosphere were AMAZING!!! Our server, Angelica, was horrible and rude. She wouldn't answer questions about the menu and treated us like we were stupid. Maybe she was having a bad day, but she was really a bitch. Aside from her, the place was fantastic!! read more

Lovely bistro within Congress Hall. Great for breakfast and lunch. Very attentive staff, always buzzing. Clean environment for an upscale, but not too stuffy, weekend treat. Ideal location. read more

What a great place to have lunch. We sat outside and it was a lovely outdoor area. The napkins have cute blue pigs on them. We weren't super hungry so we decided to split the lobster roll. It was really really good! I recommend it if you are considering it. We had cocktails as well and they were great. Service was on point. I would happily eat here again. read more

Any restaurant that has been in business since James Madison occupied the White House is surely review proof. The Blue Pig nestled inside Congress Hall in Cape May is just such a fixture serving American Classics to a constantly sold-out patronage. The fare can be uneven but last evening it was superb offering up flounder and an almost perfect Fish & Chips that melted in your mouth. One downer is the outside patio that used to be isolated by a tall hedgerow is now wide open to surrounding vehicular traffic and a brutal sun. I'll just have to give President Madison a piece of my mind. Five colonial stars for an enduring classic. read more