The food tasted good; however, we arrived at 7pm on a Friday evening and weren't served our 2 meals…read moreuntil 7:50 pm (and the restaurant wasn't particularly busy). Apparently the server and the cooks didn't communicate well and she explained that she had to place the order twice. My Reuben sandwich on rye was piled high with corned beef, a slice of Swiss cheese and sauerkraut and came out hot. On the other hand, the French fries also came out hot but were soggy in the middle. The other meal, a hamburger served with sweet bourbon sauce, also was tasty although my table mate ordered sauce on the side and instead the sauce had been spread on the bun. Our service began with oil-dipping sauce and 4 diagonally-sliced pieces of plain white bread. It lacked creativity yet snacking on it helped to pass the time while we waited for our meals to arrive.

This was a nice little place. The host and servers were very attentive. The food was good and…read morereasonable pricing. We had ribs and fish and chips. The ribs tender and the sauce was very tasty. Unfortunately I forgot to take pics before I started chowing down

7-2026 Buffet was very clean, and food was delicious I loved…read morethe cabbage casserole! My husband loved the chicken. Lots to choose from and hearty food. Good service, very crowded but it was organized and ran very well.

Used our "Amish Country Summer Package" which included dinner here…read more We got sat instantly right at 5:30, prime time. Karen greeted us right away and explained the deal to us. I got the full buffet & she got the salmon w/ sweet potato fries & salad bar. Drinks were included as well. Plus she brought wheat rolls. The hot buffet was limited but everything was always fresh & very tasty. I can't complain about any item. The salmon was pretty good as it had a nice crust on it. The sweet potato fries were perfect & the cinnamon butter was even better. Salad bar was really fresh & the local cheddar cheese was amazing. The cold prepared salads were a bit too wet but yummy. Only dessert item was jello. The full buffet w/ drink only cost $18! And Karen was the best server!

The food was amazing; service superb and we got to meet and talk with the owners. It's a small…read morelocally owned place with that welcoming feeling

We had a great lunch at the Mill Street Diner on New Year's Eve. Not much was open in Amish Country…read morethat day so we felt lucky that they were open. They were steadily busy, but the staff was friendly and upbeat. It is in an old building that made you feel you had stepped back in time. Comfortable booths and high ceilings. Very homey feel. The food was hot and flavorful and not very expensive. We'll be back when we are in Sugarcreek again!

We stopped in at Scott's Diner on a Sunday on our way home from Columbus. Cute little family run…read morediner offering home cooked goodness. We were able to find a seat at the counter amongst all the regular locals. My phone did not eat first at this place. I was too hungry I had to dig in once my food arrived! I got the French toast with a side of scrambled eggs and my husband got their classic breakfast. Wow. Although the selections were your average diner fair, everything was fresh and cooked to perfection. I think it might have been some of the best French toast I've ever had. Crispy edges and soft almost custard like center. I didn't think I was going to be able to finish but I indeed did. The hospitality mixed with great breakfast made this a wonderful stop.

1 star is generous as this place was a huge disappointment. First disappointment was the menu…read moreprices. Absolutely ridiculous prices for small town Ohio!! $20 for two very small fried eggs, 2 small chewy pieces of bacon, and a plate overflowing with soggy hashbrowns with no seasoning, and definitely not crisp! Comes with toast, which was fair. Won't be returning. Brought home the majority of hashbrowns and toast with hopes to jazz them up and try to get our money's worth. Also, very cramped seating situation. Breakfast shouldn't be as expensive as dinner!

Absolutely incredible food, the service was outstanding and the staff was so friendly. Definitely…read morewould recommend if you're in the area

This was a pleasant experience and we will be back. This entire county is a dream for middle-aged…read morewomen, but this is a place to get a reasonable meal as a guy not trying to lose their mind looking at quilts, etc. Food = Fish sandwich and noodle soup were both good at a fair price. They run out of pies throughout the day because they're not serving old pie here, but they're good and lots to choose from. Service = Very friendly. Sometimes a guy has questions, like "Why is there a log of cheese with my soup?" (even though it's awesome). But they answer in a friendly way. Restaurant = This place is busy, you will likely wait. Lots of seats, because apparently I'm not the only one that plans on going back after visiting. Clean and quick.

The best service I have ever received. The environment was so good it almost didn't matter the food…read morewas amazing. But the food was top notch

What a cute spot! Hubs loved it for the efficiency and operation logistics as they moved people…read morethrough quickly and with care! We were in the area and looking for a brunch spot and Early Birds Breakfast popped up with good reviews. The menu had so many options, decision paralysis! I ended up with the pancake, eggs, and bacon breakfast. The food was great quality. The eggs was fresh and delicious. The bacon was cooked beautifully and not just pure fat. The pancake was delightful and fluffy. Coffee was also solid here. Stop by if you're nearby!!

This is an amazing place! Definitely worth checking out. Their twist on traditional food is so…read morerefreshing and it is delicious. I had the fish and I highly recommend it. So wonderful!! Service was great as well. Our server knew a lot about the food. Check them out!!

While in for our vacation we stopped here for dinner. We were prompty sat near the kitchen and…read moremusic speaker that made it uncomfortable to dine. After asking one clueless waitress if we could move (her answering we couldn't), another (Pookie) moved us toward the front. MUCH better. The food came out promptly ad my wife's Quinoa Stir Fry was super good (I liked it too), but my Bacon Ranch pasta was *COLD*. I had to wait a bit til Pookie waited on a party of 7, but eventually the other waitress got my dish and it was fixed in 5-6 minutes. My food was eventually good, but should have been first time out. It was then much too long to get our bill after we were done. The place has potential, but they need some better staff who do better.

We were seated promptly at 1045 so I thought I missed breakfast but they were giving grace until 11…read moream. Husband got the roast beef sandwich and mashed potatoes with gravy all over. It was very good I had a bite of each. The potato were not ruiny as some make them $14.99. I had the buttermilk pancakes (2) they were plate size and 1/2 thick. Fluffy and buttery too. 1 pancake was plenty..My husband happily ate my leftovers and commented on greatness. Service was attentive and food came fast. TIP: they only take cash or checks Would definitely eat here again when in area.

So disappointed with this place. For weeks I've been looking forward to the Black Raspberry pie…read morethat I had read about in many reviews. Are you kidding me? It was like a jar of preserves had been placed between 2 sheets of mediocre pastry. Hubby had ham (yuck) and shredded home fries, that were cold and tasted like they'd been hanging out on the grill for a few hours. 2 stars instead of one as the lady at the counter was decent enough to take the pie off our bill. Obviously the locals love this place, but I was very disappointed. ChatGPT had recommended it. Try it and see what you think. We won't bother going back.

Amish Country at its best!…read more This is a gem of a restaurant. We found this place thanks to the great reviews on Yelp. We were not familiar with Baltic, Ohio, yet we were so happy we found this place. The staff was so friendly and welcoming, it felt like we were eating in someone's home. Christian, the manager, could have not done anything more to accommodate us. He really went out of his way to enhance our experience. Our waitress, Arlene, had told us she had been there for several years and you could really tell this by her ability to help us through the menu. She wanted to make sure we were completely satisfied. The menu was one like I had never seen before. Everything from a large breakfast selection to Wagyu and Prime steaks. I had the best Ruben sandwich I had ever eaten ( that is saying a lot). We also shared the Wagyu filet with hand cut fries and sweet potato fries. The steak was sautéed with fresh mushrooms and onions. The steak was seasoned to absolute perfection. You have to try this. I have posted pictures of the menu. Don't forget a side order of homemade mac & cheese. Their prices are extremely reasonable considering the quality of the food and the impeccable service. The decor is perfect. Simple yet very pretty. They even have a nice area (living room style) that we hung out in until our table was ready. This Amish restaurant is the "best of the best". I will be back in this area next year and will be sure to make this my go to restaurant. Bravo to the staff and chef, well done.

Frankly, I didn't hate or love it. I just don't see a reason to make a trip there other than a…read morelack of competition. Food = Jalapeño popper dip was good. Pork chop was cooked alright, but definitely needed a sauce to add some flavor as it was bland. Coconut mango rice was sad (my wife is filipino so she knows a bit about rice, mangoes, and coconut). I had the reuben and it was alright. I don't understand why all the steaks and fish are "market price" on the menu. This is not a fancier restaurant that serves wagyu, why can you not figure out how to price half of your meats? Service = Good with no problems. Restaurant = Stylish, Spacious, and Clean.

Long line when I walked in, but they worked through it quickly. SUPER nice staff!…read moreMy honey bee cold brew was stupendous and enjoyed my apple fritter, too. Wish I had time to sit and enjoy. Noticed some cute local gifty items for sale on my way out.

Serving delicious bakery treats and excellent coffee. I stopped at Jitters as I was passing…read morethrough Millersburg and am very grateful for Jitters being there. I ordered a fresh brewed coffee and a small cream stick donut. Jitters serves Crimson Cup coffee which is known for their award winning coffee. The donut was fluffy, fresh even in the afternoon, and delicious. I appreciate that they have a regular and half size cream stick Jitters has several different spaces to enjoy if you stay to enjoy your coffee, baked goods, or food items. They have a typical dining area and a cozy area with comfortable seating. There is also a designated area for kids. In addition to coffee I saw to go drinks and foods. Their coffee menu is typical of a coffee shop with seasonal drinks as well. I believe they have meals including handmade sandwiches. They sell crafty mugs, candles, sauces, journals, Bibles, and crafted items. A must visit if you are in the area.