Blue Line has to be my favorite pizza spot. I love that they keep honey out on the tables -- now I ask for honey every time I order pizza anywhere. The staff is always friendly, and the ambience is cool, open, and lively. My personal favorite is the prosciutto arugula pizza. A must-try! read more

This place is pretty good. As someone with celiac as I always feel safe whenever I go to a blue line restaurant. For gf pizza, blue line is definitely one of my go to places... My favorite things in the menu are: 1. The mix salad 2. The chicken wings 3. Gf Italian combo pizza 4. Ginger Beer However, any of their pizzas are very yummy and the gluten free crust is pretty good. This time we got the mix salad and the gluten chicken pesto pizza, it was very yummy! read more

Blue Line Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Carlos, California

See all

We finally tried this place out because they did a fundraiser for the Museum of San Carlos History (good on them)! Inside has a lot of different seating and good lighting around dinner time. Our waiters were very nice and attentive; I saw one waitress offer more food to a table beside us after they accidentally dropped a slice of pizza in the floor! That's great service. The prices are pretty fair for the portions too' The meatballs were pretty good and there was a lot of them. We came during happy hour so they were $10 and worth it! The pizza we got was great! You can split the flavor for no extra cost which is great. The wild mushroom was my favorite. The harvest blend was really loaded with veggies. The deep dish crust was perfect thickness but too dry....hence the 4 stars. I like a more oily crust haha. Overall, a solid pizza place downtown (although I have yet to try others). We want to come back and try the thin crust here! read more

Blue Line Pizza - Homemade Meatballs - Pizza Near Me - San Carlos, California

See all

This is based off a pick up order but man Blue Line is loud inside! I felt like I had to yell to even tell the guy helping me my name! But anyways, pickup was really accurate and the pizzas stayed hot on the walk home which was lovely. The BBQ chicken pizza is really good, I was pleasantly surprised. Also their butternut squash salad was YUMMMM and had a lot of toppings, I just wish the spinach was actually in smaller pieces because some were insanely large read more

Ordered 2 pizzas for family dinner on 12/23. Pros: Website easy to navigate and placed order Pizzas ready by promised time Thin crust options Pizzas are kept warm in lockers for easy pickup upon arrival and no need to wait for a staff member to assist Restaurant was clean and staff were friendly and greeted us upon arrival and pointed us towards the lockers after confirming it was an online order Cheesy spinach dip with bread was good and plenty of garlic Cons: Taste was just okay read more

Solid pizzas (we tried the mushroom one and another one that was tomato based). Definitely get the honey on the side and mike's hot honey. The mushroom one was a favorite and delicious -- the mushroom flavor was strong in a good way. Apps: Spinach artichoke dip was decent -- very creamy and not too much artichoke. 6.5/10 The pretzel was a miss, not too soft. 5/10 read more

See all

Went in for dinner on a Monday. The restaurant was empty but decided to stay anyway. Had the sliders and the tequila lime wings. We received three sliders. They were pretty small. They were served on a small King Hawaiian style bun. Flavor was good, sadly the meat didn't cover the bun and not much else on the plate. Tequila wings had good flavor but weren't crispy at all, Maybe they were baked? Restaurant looked clean well set up as we walked in. Staff was very friendly greeting us and invite us in. As we sat we over heard one staff member dealing with a friendly but very challenging customer. They could not have handled that situation better. So friendly, so patient. great job! We always have a good experience here tonight it was not the food. It was the staff. Well done guys! We will be back. read more

Delivery through Uber Eats was quick, however I was a bit disappointed that the pizza box didn't have any security seal or tape on it. For delivery, it would feel a lot safer knowing the box is properly sealed to ensure nothing was tampered with during transit. The quality and taste were great, just hoping they add security seals in the future for extra peace of mind! read more

Blue Line Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Carlos, California

See all

I love Little Star - polenta crust makes everything better. That pizza plus a bacon & blue salad is not cheap meal but it is absolutely delicious!! read more

Picked up takeout late on a Friday evening. The server was very friendly and helpful. I inquired about the gluten-free crust, and she suggested the cauliflower crust as another option. She mentioned it was one of her favorite and preferred crusts so I went with it. I really enjoyed the pizza! I ordered the Little Star on cauliflower crust. It came out hot, and quickly. The flavors were good (strong onion but I like that). The crust was crispy. Indoors was spacious; pretty quiet and empty but it almost 9PM. I've been to Blue Line sparsely over the years and it's always been a hit for me. The cost for a small was around $30 which was on the pricey side so this is not a regular stop for me but an ocasional treat. read more

Blue Line Pizza - Bi Blue Line (Aka Little Star) - Pizza Near Me - San Carlos, California

See all

Ordered delivery and got a large half and half (8 slices) (Brass Monkey and Chicago Chop). Both were tasty and I slightly preferred the Brass Monkey as it was a bit more interesting. The crust was solid, but I wished there was a bit more cheese. 2 slices was sufficient for most adults. Would order from here again. read more

Slightly on the pricey side, but really solid pizza and has some nice happy hour deals. I'd recommend the pesto. Deep dish is excellent. Pictured is some vegetarian deep dish pizza, I think it might have been called fall harvest? Bottom left option of the specialty pizzas. Really good. I always assumed deep dish was best with lots of meat but the best two I've had now were vegetarian with caramelized onions and feta read more

Blue Line Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Carlos, California

I love this place! They are always so attentive and nice when we come in. The food is always delicious and comes out at a reasonable time. The deep dish is always a good choice! Beer is good and honestly prices are great! Definitive give it a try. read more

Blue Line Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Carlos, California

Not the best service, but the pizza was ok. I ordered feta in my pizza and when it was brought out there was no feta. When I pointed this out to the server he said that there was feta and that it melted into the cheese which was a lie. The tables were large and there is plenty of space to sit and not feel closed in. Parking was also easy to find on the street. I would've enjoyed the meal more with better service and if I recieved what I ordered. read more

The last time I ate at Blue Line was pre-pandemic. No idea what to expect with the passage of so much time since my last visit. Only a couple of tables were occupied and post-COVID, there were a lot less tables in general and plenty of open area. We were seated right away--our choice of table. Our server, Robbie greeted us and was so friendly. We talked about the different pizzas and whether to go for deep dish or thin crust. I love a white sauce pizza but I'm also a big fan of their meatball pizza with the scoops of ricotta cheese on top and cornmeal crust. We eventually settled for the meatball pizza. Once our pizza was served, I asked for some honey to dip my cornmeal crust and Robbie agreed with me--we bonded immediately over the honey. The first thing I noticed about the pizza was the ricotta cheese--it was small dollops; I remember it with generous scoops--times have changed. The crust was crisp and delicious when eaten dipped in honey--you need to enjoy the salty/sweet combo--it's not a taste for everyone. The pizza was tasty; just enough sauce with tiny sized meatballs scattered about the pizza. The small pizza was enough for 2 of us--we each get 3 slices or about half a pizza. Overall, a very tasty pizza and I would return. read more

See all

I love how the guy calls me sir here . I always get large because I love the pizza that much and i always get the thin crust so I can really taste everything. read more

I previously gave Blue Line Pizza a less than favorable review for showing a 9:00 PM closing time online when they actually closed at 8:00 PM. Driving down there and arriving at 8:20 PM and being told they were closed was quite annoying. I am updating the review because of the speed of Blue Line Pizza's response. The employee at the restaurant apologized profusely and immediately called her manager to point out the error on the website. A day or so later, I received a response from the District Manager again apologizing for the mistake. We all make mistakes. What counts is that they owned up to the mistake and acknowledged the inconvenience the mistake caused. I have been back several times since and have had no problems whatsoever. The food is good and the employees are friendly. read more

The chicken wings were SEASONED and spicy! We got a deep-dish pizza--half pesto chicken and half Chicago chop. I would definitely recommend the pesto chicken. The chicken was nicely chopped, and the flavors mixed so well. We added spicy honey to the Chicago chop! Also, the waiters were super kind and helpful. This is definitely a place to go yap in peace environment { if you get a corner table hehe } read more

Blue Line Pizza - Spicy Chicken Wings - Pizza Near Me - San Carlos, California

See all

We ordered take out. This is my first time ordering here. My daughter likes chicken so I ordered chicken and garlic deep dish pizza. That was a mistake because it had nothing else (no peppers or basil or anytning else). I didn't realize by saying chicken and garlic I was ordering a build our own pizza. I should have ordered the new chicken and bacon with cheese, bell peppers, etc. or any of the other prepared pizzas on the menu. (Don't make the mistake I made) The large serves 4-5 but at about 14" I was surprised how small it was. It helps that it's pre-sliced. It depends on your appetite but if each person eats 2 slices then it would only feed 4. Just keep that in mind. I almost forgot to take a picture -until we were halfway eating it (thus the pic shows only half a pizza). We enjoyed the pizza. P.S. There is a huge bar presence when you walk in, pic is on their website too - in fact I had to ask I was at the right place. read more

Blue Line Pizza - chicken and garlic - Pizza Near Me - San Carlos, California

Lunch 2/26/23 We are on the quest for the best Chicago Deep Dish Pizza in the Bay and ended up at Blue Line Pizza today. After getting our veggie intake for the day via the Arugula Salad with Mozzarella, Walnuts in a Strawberry Balsamic Dressing, we devoured the Chicago Chopped Deep Dish Pizza. Pepperoni, sausage, bacon and salami with cheese...how can you go wrong? We only had 2 slices each and were stuffed. The cornmeal crust was different than any deep dish I've ever had. It was good but the search continues for the best! read more

Blue Line Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Carlos, California

See all

I love the thin crust pizza. We add sausage, pepperoni, onions, black olives & extra cheese. The crust never soggy or falling apart. The sauce is so good too! Not boring at all - has some zip to it. I want to try this pizza particularly baked so I can finish it off at home. If we do take out, the first thing we do when we get home is pop it in the oven anyway! Give it a try... read more

Omg! Tried calling the restaurant so many times and they kept hanging up. Even tried calling from 2 different phones just in case it was a problem on my end. Literally they pick up, I hear talking, then click. They used to be so great with service. Now when you dine there, you don't get water, dishes, utensils unless you ask for it. I don't know why I tipped the last time I was there. I kept having to flag them down because I had nothing to eat with. All the while, there's plenty of staff working but they are having side conversations. Now I try to call for take out and just get hung up on. read more

You can't go wrong with delicious deep dish pizza on a cold and rainy night. Blue Line couldn't have been a better choice. We ordered over the phone and being 2 counties away, we were really anticipating what Blue Line had to offer. We arrived in perfect timing and a small box of Classic pizza and garlic bread were served hot and fresh, which was devoured when we got home. For two, we ordered the Classic deep dish and the garlic bread. The deep dish was the right amount of thickness (you could order thin crust or cornbread deep dish). The warm garlic bread was money, incomparable to any other garlic bread I've ever had. The marinara sauce provided gave it an extra kick of perfection. My pictures do not actually represent the hot and yummy experience had before the entire order was devoured. You'd actually have to order to go or dine in for the experience. P.S. Blue Line apparently has a full bar when you walk in (to your left). This location we went to in San Carlos had a good amount of customers dining in and the establishment is conveniently situated in the corner of downtown San Carlos. Come by when you get the chance! read more

See all

This review is just for the food as we ordered take out. We ordered the Garlic bread with cheese & The Chicago Chop, deep dish style. I'm a huge deep dish lover & this pizza was only okay. One, the marinara is way too chunky for my liking and two, this specific type of pizza brought red peppers but I can't say that I tasted any. Unlike myself though, my boyfriend had no complaints & enjoyed his slice. read more

Blue Line Pizza - Garlic Bread w/ cheese - Pizza Near Me - San Carlos, California

See all

I ordered the meatballs. Don't order the meat balls because I immediately got bubble guts and then diarrhea. They tasted like the restaurant got them from the frozen food isle in a grocery store, wait... I'm sure there were some in that isle that taste better than these. I think they were left out for a long time too! Had I known this experience would happen, I would have went the local grocery store and got the meatballs there. read more

Been coming here for a while and time to update my review. After ordering a number of their pizzas our favorites are the Classic and BlueLine with the deep dish crust (sans shrooms). Both are pretty damn good. Since we like variety we like to order the large with half of each one. The ones that we tried and are not ordering again are the Chicago Chop (a little too much meat for me), Typsy Pig (got a little bored of this after a few slices), and Aphrodite (just okay). read more

Came here last week during one of the recent heatwaves. We ordered the arugula strawberry balsamic salad and deep dish Italian combo pizza. Both were delicious! I liked the salad the most! It also had caramelized onions on top. Servers were all friendly & attentive! Thanks Guys & Gal! Ambiance is casual. They have indoor and outdoor seating. We sat inside next to this cute family with their kid! Fun experience! We'll be back! read more

Got the vegetable deep dish pizza.. Terrible pizza- bland, the vegetables had no taste. There was way too much marinara and the base was quite oily. I enjoy Zachary's deep dish pizza but this was nothing like that. read more

Blue Line Pizza - Vegetarian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - San Carlos, California

Man.. I was thoroughly excited for this pizza. We crossed over the bay for pick up because we wanted something new. Unfortunately, it was just meh. Round table, Mr. Mikes would've been better. The spice on the wings will knock you out lol. We didn't even freeze the leftovers, we tossed it all. read more

Blue Line Pizza - Pizza n chicken - Pizza Near Me - San Carlos, California

Happy Hour visit on a Wednesday afternoon. Had the wings and artichoke dip, everything came out piping hot and in a timely manner. Service was great. I was well attended too. Bella was especially helpful with checking in and making sure I was doing good throughout my visit. Thank you Bella. read more

The thin crust pizza was actually pretty good, as were the hot wings. However I just can't give that great a review when we went there for the deep dish - and at 7:30pm they were already out of the deep dish! Like, you are named after a Chicago subway line and you run out of deep dishes? How is that possible? Really disappointing. read more

Very good pizza. We got the Chicago Chopped pizza and it was pretty good. The corn meal crust and the thick tomato sauce on top was very tasty. I took off a star because it lacked the level of cheese and meat toppings of other Chicago pizzas I've had for similar pricing. read more

Ordered a large Tipsy Pig for take out and it was ready within 20 mins. Each pizza box has a quality assurance sticker on it. First time having Blue Line since shelter in place started so we decided to try something on the menu we don't normally order. The Tipsy Pig has marinated pork, tequila lime crema, red onion, fresh jalapeno, and cilantro. You can get subtle hints of the tequila and the pork was well seasoned. The crust is always the best part of blue line. It has a nice crunch and the pizza slice is never floppy. Tipsy Pig did not disappoint! read more

Blue Line Pizza - Tipsy Pig - Pizza Near Me - San Carlos, California

Ever since Windy City Pizza closed I've hesitated going to any other deep-dish pizza place. I placed a pick-up ordered for a a large deep dish Chicago Chop pizza and a small regular crust cheese, sausage and pepperoni. I also ordered a pound of chicken wings. It's convenient that they will deliver to your car so you don't need to search for parking. I wish the menu specified how many ounces of each pizza topping was included to set a reasonable expectation. There absolutely was some of every meat listed in the Chicago Chop, maybe I just expected a little more meat and cheese and less tomato/sauce. My bad for not checking ahead. The small pepperoni/sausage was fine - adequate really. Unfortunately, the pound of wings I received were tough and dry. They seemed pretty busy so probably just an oversight on cook time. I'm sure if I had been dining in, they would have re-made the batch. It was just too much effort going back with take-out. If you like saucy deep dish pizza this is the place for you! read more

Yes, we're all stuck at home and gyms aren't open and we miss our friends. The pandemic sucks and it's scary. But you know what will make you feel better? Deep.Dish.Pizza. I love Blue Line. I get their classic deep dish. With the ricotta. Oh my goodness, it's amazing!! Just pair with a couple of homemade Long Island Iced Teas and some trashy reality-show TV (Netflix Too Hot to Handle anyone?) and you'll be feeling better in no time! read more

We ordered a bunch of pizzas for take out from Blue Line to eat at the park and this pizza was so good! My brother, sister and two nephews all eat GF so this was a great place to grab something everyone could eat. The food held well together getting it to go and brining it in a car and to the park. I know it's only pizza but some places don't do to-go very well. The pizzas were a great size to split between 4 adults and 2 children. My brother told me they come here often when needing a quick bite to eat and I can see why. It was so good and there were no leftovers. I would totally come back here when I am in town or recommend it to anyone looking for delicious pizza in the area. read more

GREAT EXPERIENCE. There was 7 of us for dinner, a few weeks ago. We took up about 1/2 the indoor seating capacity. This wonderful little spot is quite unassuming. The singular Host/Server/Bartender was charming, knowledgeable and capable. The food was outstanding. We had pizzas, pastas, appies, wine & beer. I wish I had taken more photos of the food. (Personally, I could do without the SPORTS TV playing above the bar... But the people seated on the stools seemed to enjoy it.) read more

Came for lunch outside dine-in! You look at the menu virtually and order at the front before you sit We ordered the Caprese Salad and Small Italian Pizza; it fed the two of us nicely with 2 slices leftover. Both tasted great, service was prompt, and the atmosphere outside was lovely too. No complaints! Update: Came again and ordered the exact same thing, but this time the caprese salad had the tiniest tomato slices. I guess a star off on consistency since it definitely wasn't as enjoyable as last time. read more

Blue Line Pizza - caprese salad - Pizza Near Me - San Carlos, California

See all

The food is good. And therein lies the problem. What hurts this restaurant is the poor, indifferent service. They sat us and then nothing. I had to walk up and grab menus. I had to flag the waitress down to put in our order. I know a deep dish pizza is going to take a little longer than a thin crust. But even our salad took around 20 min to come out. I had to grab a busser to tell our waitress to go check in the salad. I sat in a spot where I could see the entire floor. Only 10 tables were occupied. There were 4 servers and two bartenders. Most patrons still looked unserved. Worse is that not a single worker seemed to care. Not one smile. The bartender looked like she hates her job, hates making drinks, hates serving customers. I read a number of recent reviews and they all mention this poor service. If the owner cared at all, they would have addressed this. I guess we'll only take out from this location from now on. read more

Pretty good we ordered a deep dish and and it was very good but ofc very rich and the Zoddle salad which was great read more

Blue Line Pizza - lol this is the only photo I have from there but this is what it looks like there - Pizza Near Me - San Carlos, California