One star -- and only because zero isn't an option. We made a long drive specifically to visit this place and arrived at 9:47 PM, ten minutes before closing. We were told a "last in line" pass had already been given out, meaning they had effectively shut down early with no notice. Fine -- I can accept that policy. What I can't accept is the way the staff handled it. No apology, no warmth, just a dismissive attitude that made us feel like an inconvenience. If your actual cutoff is earlier than your posted hours, update your hours. Your customers' time is valuable too read more

I just got out of a Yelp event and was craving for something sweet (as I always do after any savory food). My friend said Blacksmith Ice Cream is her favorite, but she's never been to the this location in Bountiful. I was so excited to try it! My excitement was 100% matched by my experience here! There was a line out the door, and I see why. I believe this is their original location, as they did originate from Bountiful, UT. They have a lot of unique flavors. After sampling a few, I went with Fresh Raspberries and Honeybud. I REALLY loved both flavors. Truly, the fresh raspberry flavor was immensely fresh, from the cream to the fruit. Honeybud has a lavender base flavored ice cream. Some people say it tastes too soap-like, but I did not have that issue. It tasted like a subtle flower with delicious honey on it. I truly enjoyed every bite. Next time, I'll be sure to get a bigger size. So delicious and so fresh. The vibe is soo cute too. Very farmhouse and welcoming. read more

See all

My husband and I stopped here for our date night and we each got a sampler flight. We thought our favorite ice cream was going to be the Cookie Butter Chip ice cream, but it ended up being the Pumpkin Cookie Butter and the Black Web. The Pumpkin Cookie butter was booming with flavor! I wish it wasn't a seasonal flavor because I'd order it every time. I think it would be even better if they'd add chocolate chips to it! The Black Web was a black licorice ice cream and it had little pieces of licorice in it. This is a must try for anyone who likes black licorice. I hope they bring this one back too! I also had the Salted Cookie Dough. It was good, but I was searching for the salt. I really wanted a little bit of that saltiness in my ice cream. The only flavor that we both didn't like (but we thought we'd love), was the Campfire S'mores ice cream. It tasted burnt with a propane flavor. When I saw them post a video on social media about them making the ice cream, I saw the problem. They burnt the marshmallows instead of lightly toasting them with a propane torch (and maybe that normally works well, but it didn't work for our batch of ice cream) :( Hopefully we'll be back for more pumpkin ice cream before fall is over....and if they still have black web, we'll grab that too! read more

See all

Oh, so so so good! Some of the best in Utah. I've had Leatherby's, Handel's, Brooker's and this beats them all. Such creamy ice cream, you can see the difference in its texture and flavor. I had the Caramel Cashew and the Honeybud. Both were outstanding. Honeybud is a lavender ice cream with pockets or swirls of honey with some bits of honey comb. Wow, so good! The lavender is not overwhelming and the honey perfectly balances the flavor with the slightly crunchy bits of honey comb adding to the texture. Wonderful. I went at 8:00 on a Friday night and they were slammed with no end in sight. Two lines takes care of everyone pretty efficiently, though. Whole families with kids, senior couples, those just picking up prepacks...a wide variety of ice cream lovers in line at the only business in old downtown Bountiful that's open. Run, do not walk. Get at least two flavors. Enjoy. Go to ice cream heaven. 5* = A top favorite. Mind-blowing good. I will definitely return and I will go out of my way to go here. Worth every dime of my money. 4* = Outstanding. Top-tier. Some elements not quite as good as it gets, but it still is worthy of my regular business. 3* = Good experience. I might do repeat business if it is convenient, the only option, the only one in its category, or on a whim, but would not be among the first thing to come to mind. Would definitely recommend you trying it to get your own take on it. 2* = Not so good. Would not recommend at all. Waste of money. 1* = How are they still in business? Stay away at all costs! read more

Blacksmith Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bountiful, Utah

See all

The best ice cream in the state. Finally came and tried it and was very impressed. The service was great and the line moved quick for how busy they were. The cookie butter flavor was so creamy and had such amazing flavor. The chocolate chips were a nice addition. The dough Oreo flavor was very yummy as well. Can't wait to come back - please put a location in AF! read more

Took my 4 kids with me this time and it was nice and easy! There is a sign that says only 2 taste tests per person but they were very patient with my kids and let them try a few before they decided on their flavors. I love the complimentary cone slice in the icecream. I like to crumble mine into the icecream. I got s'mores today based off of a recommendation and it was absolutely amazing. Tasted like a true campfire smore! Had an amazing Smokey taste. read more

Blacksmith Ice Cream - Single cup 2 scoop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bountiful, Utah

See all

Wow! What a busy and bustling place, but it makes sense considering how fantastic their local ice cream tastes! The line was out the door on the Friday night we visited and we had a great time chit chatting with the people in line with us about all the different flavors. When it was our turn to order the girls who helped us were very sweet and friendly, offered samples of a few flavors and helped us decide on the flavors for our sampler. We ultimately decided on the Honey Lavender, Campfire, Butter Cake, and Cookie Dough Batter. They even gave us a few pieces of their homemade waffle cone to try! I think the sampler is a great choice for first timers! read more

Honeybud and peanut butter cup - separate scoops, not together - are our go to flavors. Tasty every time! Service was quick and friendly. Dining area was clean, but we sat at their bistro tables outside. We always come back. read more

Blacksmith Ice Cream - Mother's Day dessert outing at Blacksmith! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bountiful, Utah

Blacksmith Ice Cream is one of those places that makes you understand why people are willing to line up out the door. The moment you step inside, you're greeted by the smell of freshly made waffle cones, and the whole space has that charming, small-batch feel. It's a cute, welcoming shop where you can actually see the creativity and care that goes into every flavor. The ice cream itself is incredible: creamy, fresh, and full of unique twists. I tried the banana Nutella, which was rich and perfectly balanced, and the cookie butter chip, which came loaded with extra chocolate chips for the perfect crunch. I also had to grab a scoop of their mint chocolate chip, and it was clear why it's such a favorite (refreshing, flavorful, and not overly sweet). Each creation feels thoughtfully crafted rather than just mixed together, and you can taste the quality in every bite. Between the smell of the cones, the variety of flavors, and the attention to detail in the mix-ins and texture, it's easy to see why Blacksmith has the hype it does. Yes, there's a line, but once you're holding a cone of their fresh, small-batch ice cream, you realize it's absolutely worth it. read more

See all

This is some of the best ice cream I've ever had. I know the menu rotates but if you can get the HoneyBud it's a must try. Everything we had was good, but that was our favorite. read more

Blacksmith Ice Cream - Honeybud (left) Smores (right) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bountiful, Utah

Amazing ice cream and flavors. amazing service! And an upper seating area that's fun. read more

First off I want to say I LOVE Blacksmiths ice cream. However, we arrived tonight at 9:40 to get some ice cream and at the end of the line the customer was holding a sign that said "last in line"The employees said that they do that because if they don't then they can close at 10:00. But was only 9:40. I would think that the sign would or should be given to the last person in line at 10:00. What is the point in having a closing time posted if you don't allow customers who arrive 20 mins before closing to get ice cream. read more

Make sure you get there before 9:30 pm- even though the closing time says 10:00 pm. They will turn you away on a Saturday night to make sure their workers go home at 10. They actually made a customer hold a sign that said "Last In Line" and turn other customers away. I love this place, but was seriously disappointed. We watched them turn away at least four other groups after us. read more

Love ice cream places that offer flights so you can try several different flavors! Berry cheesecake and lavender honeybud were soooo good, I also enjoyed their hot honey seasonal flavor. They always come out with fun creative flavors that rotate! read more

Blacksmith Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bountiful, Utah

So yummy! Fresh ice cream and fun seasonal flavors. I love the addition of the pumpkin cookie butter flavor for fall! Wish they would bring back banana Nutella. It actually tasted like legit banana...not fake laffy taffy banana lol. Their customer service has gotten so much better, thank you! I love coming here and I look forward to their new flavors every season/holiday. The added dairy free flavors are just as delicious too. I will happily eat my weight in the strawberry basil diary free ice cream. Clean and inviting environment..it always smells so delicious when you walk in. For the quality I think the pricing is fair. It's so fresh and delicious and they use actual, real ingredients. You get what you pay for which is quality. The whole family loves it here! read more

Blacksmith Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bountiful, Utah

See all

I got Spider web (black licorice) and Honey bud (lavender n honey) and they are sooooo good! I wish I took a photo but I scarfed it down. The workers in there are easygoing and willing to communicate with phone (we are deaf people and using notes on the phone to communicate with them.) read more

Walking into Blacksmith you are hit with the smell of sugary local ice cream goodness. The smell of waffle cones fresh off the press. You know it's going to be great. At the risk of the lines getting longer... I will die on this hill that this is the best ice cream in Utah. The raspberry is INCREDIBLE! I have never had a flavor that disappoints. I recently tried the Mango sticky rice which was such a new inventive flavor. The staff is always patient and a delight. read more

Blacksmith Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bountiful, Utah

All dressed up on a Friday night, we joined the line going out the door for some local ice cream. It moved fast and everyone was in a good mood because... ice cream. Original and familiar flavors in a cute setting is hard to beat. The girls behind the counter were efficient and allowed us each two samples to make our decision. We went with chocolate brownie and mint chip. Both quite tasty. Good texture and full of flavor. I don't think you can go wrong with any choice. I would have preferred another chocolate option, but I ate every bite. I'm not sure I would drive to Bountiful for it, Salt Lake and Provo have some tough competitors (and my personal favorite). But, I might stop by again on my way through town for a treat. read more

Blacksmith Ice Cream - Cute exterior - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bountiful, Utah

We have friends in South Ogden who have raves about Blacksmith Ice Cream, so I decided to take a trip down to Bountiful to give it a try. The first time, I ordered the fresh raspberry and passion fruit flavors (recommended by the employee behind the counter) in a waffle cone, and the second time, I ordered the berry cheesecake and cashew caramel flavors (also recommended to me). Thank you to both employees who recommended me the flavors -- my indecisive Libra in me could not fathom deciding between all the flavors. The verdict: it's good ice cream and at a great price! It's not my favorite ice cream place I've tried in Utah, but it's certainly a good one. I docked a star from them for not offering sorbet flavors which my husband loves. The ice cream is creamy and sweet, and out of the four flavors I tried, I think the berry cheesecake is my favorite. read more

Blacksmith Ice Cream - Fresh raspberry and passion fruit ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bountiful, Utah

See all

Blacksmith Ice Cream is the BEST Ice cream in all of Utah. Just wish they would move up into Davis County or Weber County. So creamy and the flavors are AMAZING! read more

I heard this place was good and I had other plans in the area so it was finally time to give it a shot. I easily found parking on a weekday afternoon. I appreciated the list of common allergens and which flavors contain them. You get two samples so I tried the mango sticky rice (which had hard pieces of rice in it and mango that didn't taste ripe so definitely a no) and the milk and honey which was super good! I wanted a more vanilla-y one and a more chocolate-y one but there wasn't a chocolate flavor that was gluten-free, darn it. So, after making sure the banana was not artificially flavored, I went with that without tasting it because I had run out of tasting chances. Luckily, it was very good! That banana ice cream tasted homemade- nothing artificial there! read more

Blacksmith Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bountiful, Utah

I moved out of the area around the time this charming ice cream shop moved in, so this is my first visit--but it won't be the last. The Dough n Cookies ice cream was good, but the burnt marshmallow flavor of Campfire S'mores was out of this world! The water dispenser and little wafer in the ice cream were nice touches, too. Pretty much, I liked everything about my experience. Even the location on historic Main Street makes it a great place to visit during a stroll! read more

Blacksmith Ice Cream - Campfire S'mores and Dough n Cookies - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bountiful, Utah

Service was incredibly friendly, warm, and welcoming. We LOVED the honey lavender ice cream and the fresh raspberry ice cream that was recommended. They said "this is the best ice cream in Utah" and I have to agree! read more

Blacksmith Ice Cream - Raspberry Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bountiful, Utah

Oh my goodness I do not have enough delicious and kind words to say about Blacksmith Ice Cream. My son wanted to try a lot of flavors and the staff was so kind and patient while he made up his mind. My family loves to try different dessert places and I was so happy that they did indeed also have just plain vanilla for my four year old who is as basic as can be We cannot wait to return for more! read more

It was 31 degrees outside and we had to go drive down to get a scoop of delicious ice cream each. Best ice cream I've eaten thus far. Enjoyed the mocha cold brew. The place was packed. read more

Blacksmith Ice Cream - Dessert. Enjoying ice cream in 31 degree temps. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bountiful, Utah

Excellent ice cream with some eclectic flavors. The waffle cones are really good. I'd you want two great flavors for the price of one get the split single. read more

Great ice cream, haven't had better ice cream anywhere. Highly recommend the raspberry ice cream.

Blacksmith is our favorite local ice cream place! Fresh changing flavors for each season, and every one is so good! Love the atmosphere, and friendly scoopers, definitely our go to spot! read more

Blacksmith Ice Cream - Best I've cream around! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bountiful, Utah

Unique flavors such as Honeybud (Lavender) and Cookie Butter Chip (Biscoff). I also enjoy the Campfire S'mores.

Delicious ice cream and fast service on a busy night. Friendly servers. I nice treat for the family. Could use more outside seating. read more

Rating (maximum points = 5) Value for money: 4.5 Cleanliness: 4 Food Quality: 5 Customer Service: 5 Look and Feel (Ambiance): 4.5 Thank you, Come Again?: 5 The interior of the shop reminds me of another ice cream place called 'Salt and Straw' that is based in PDX. I'm so glad to see we are getting more local ice cream shops. Small local shops allow for more flavor creative freedom. Sampler Ice cream flight - $8.90 - this includes 4 scoops of any flavor you would like. 1/Campfire s'mores (Smokey toasted marshmallow flavor was authentic of a campfire flavor). 2/Honeybud (Lavender and honey, this could be a little soapy for some people but I personally liked it) 3/Berry Cheesecake (Hands down my absolutley favorite. Real cheesecake flavor with fresh balckberries) 4/Golden Passionfruit (Tangy and fruity. This was very refreshing and bright). All flavors were really potent and tasty. Overall I would definitely return and try more flavors. The only recommendation is to allow more than 2 samples per person. I completely understand why there is a sample count restriction because of the long lines but personally would have loved to try more options. I also appreciate the fact that they clearly communicated which ice creams had ingredients that were common food allergies. (e.g., tree nuts and gluten). Blacksmith ice cream is thoughtful of their customers and is clearly communicating their menu ingredients. Would you go? Let me know. Follow me for all the Salt City sips and trips. read more

See all

I just want to add to my review because we love Blacksmith! My parents live in California but come here multiple times every time they visit. It's become their thing with my kids. My dad even met someone from Bountiful who was visiting CA and they bonded over their love of Blacksmith. It's in the perfect location to spend a warm summer night out on Main Street, but also has enough seating that you can visit and stay warm in the winter. No matter what flavor we get, it's amazing! The employees are always smiling and loving their job. And it's a fun, busy place with a fun atmosphere, yet quick service! read more

Every time I fly back to Utah this is one of the first places to visit. Always a new seasonal flavor to enjoy and the Lemon bar flavor did not disappoint in the least! However, I still always migrate back to the Banana Nutella and the Backberry Cheesecake. And all of my family members have their own options that they swear is the best. You'll find options for any friend or family member to enjoy here! read more

Blacksmith Ice Cream - Banana Nutella ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bountiful, Utah

See all

While visiting my daughter and her ohana they took us to this wonderful little shop. The ice cream was absolutely amazing so creamy and fresh you could tell it was made with the finest ingredient's. The girl that helped us was very nice and patient as we sampled a few different kinds. The place was busy but we did find a table. The artwork on the walls was tied into the theme of the shop. It will definitely be on our list of places to visit. read more

Blacksmith Ice Cream - Half&Half scoop Berry Cheesecake and Campfire S'mores super tasty. My daughter had the milk and honey it to was also wonderful. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bountiful, Utah

Love the unique flavors. My favorites are the Honeybud and the Campfire S'mores. Also tasty is the Dough and Cookies. This place is always a good choice. read more

What great flavors and service. The grilled pineapple and fresh raspberry were my favorites.

They have alot of flavors. I ended up getting a Vanilla Bean cone and I enjoyed every bite. The service was great. The staff was very nice and let me try a few flavors before getting what I wanted. The place is very clean, and super nice. read more

Blacksmith Ice Cream - Vanilla Bean Cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Bountiful, Utah

See all

By far the best ice cream place in Bountiful! Located on Main St. makes it a nice little visit as you can eat it and walk around. Hand made ice cream with fresh ingredients makes this a great stop. read more

Five stars without a doubt! Fantastic ice cream. We got honey bud and caramel cashew. Both were creamy and sweet. The honey bud is a lavender with honey comb pieces. The caramel used in the caramel cashew is addicting with the sweet and salty combo. If you are in the area and you're buying your ice cream anywhere else, you're making a mistake read more

I've heard so many good things about Blacksmith ice cream and was excited to try it. I was absolutely blown away by how delicious it was! The texture was absolutely incredible! It was creamy, flavorful, and so amazing! They have so many great flavors! I like how the flavors are unique but not too over the top. The ladies working there when we came in were super nice and let us sample what we wanted to. It was a little crazy for me because I had all my young kids with me but they were patient as we tried to decide which flavors we wanted. I got the s'mores ice cream and could not believe how good it was! Seriously one of the best ice cream flavors I've had in my life! My kids got the cookie dough and fudge brownie and liked it so much! I highly recommend this place! We will certainly be back! read more

See all