The following is not based on one visit but rather many visits over 4+ years. I only live 2 blocks from this brewery...which means I truly want to love this place. Let's face it, you can never underestimate the convenience factor! I have made the effort over the years to try and make this place work but every time I go I am reminded why I haven't been there for a while. Just so you know, this isn't after one bad experience but many.
The main man, Eric, is a fantastic bartender and this place would cease to exist if not for him. He remembers your name, the style beer you enjoy, and is always friendly. He is definitely the lone bright spot of BFB.
The food is made from cheap, inexpensive ingredients, so of course nothing you get there is very good. My wife loves soup...how do you ruin soup? Ask these guys! Crunchy veggies in the minestrone, using vegetable broth instead of chicken broth in a tortellini soup, and always missing one or two inexpensive ingredients that every other version of the soup has (like stewed tomatoes). If that wasn't enough...they charge $8.00 for half a bowl...they don't even fill the bowl! This didn't happen once, but multiple times. They used to have an "Italian" sandwich and instead of using thinly sliced Italian ham (like the other thin sliced pseudo Italian meats in the sandwich) they would put a huge thick slice of cooked ham so you couldn't even taste the other meats. It was so bad and made no sense.
During the pandemic we wanted to support as many local businesses as possible. In early May 2020 they offered the Diablo Chicken sandwich. It looked amazing in the pics posted on Facebook so we decided this would be the day we went back. I walked up, ordered 2 sandwiches with fries and my bill was $39.00 before tip and NO BEER! I looked at Eric like he had to be joking and quickly contemplated canceling the order. I still purchased because it wasn't about the price, it was about helping struggling businesses and their employees. Plus in the spring of 2020 everywhere you went was a little pricier than normal for obvious reasons. I don't mind spending more to get a quality meal. The sandwich was made of fatty, grizzly dark meat. More than half of my bites were just fat. My wife couldn't even eat half of hers because it was so bad. I choked it down because of how much it cost. $39.00 for 2 chicken sandwiches w/ fries was insane and it wasn't even as good as Wendy's...WENDY'S...I'm not setting a very high bar here.
The Beer is sub par at best. Now I know I'm a beer snob and will wear this badge with honor. I don't need the beer to be as good as Heady Topper or Pliny the Elder in order to enjoy it...just be decent! Especially if you are going to charge craft brew prices. Their 42nd Mile IPA doesn't even taste like an IPA. Their flagship beers: Amber, Pale Ale, and IPA all taste exactly the same on the back end. If you look at the color on each they almost look like the exact same beer. They must have a crazy loyal fan base that has never had anything but Miller Lite their entire lives to have just been voted "Best Brewery" in the LNP. EVERYONE I know that has gone there has the same thing to say after their first visit, "I don't need to go there again."
When BFB first opened the food wasn't very good but it was cheap. The beer wasn't great but you let it slide because it wasn't far for a happy hour meet up after work. When I left BFB in 2016 I didn't feel like I was just ripped off. They are still using the same terrible ingredients and serving the same below average micro brews, but now they're charging upwards of 400% - 500% more than they use to for some food items. This isn't a random figure...their prices literally increased that much on some food items (pork tacos and the hot dog which was actually only $1.00 in 2016).
My last trip was on 10/24/20. My wife and I didn't feel like traveling to Lititz or Lancaster so we just took a quick walk to have a beer and a snack. Our order was a soft pretzel, a half filled bowl of tasteless soup, and 2 beers...my bill was $32.00 before tip. That's more than if I go to a professional sporting event (comparing to Phillies games at Citizens Bank Park) and it's about the same quality you get at the ballpark (which isn't very good). I know if I'm going to a ballgame I'll be paying exorbitant price for food that would/should normally cost a fraction elsewhere...not if I go to the corner micro brewery in Ephrata, PA!?!
Again, I want to love this place. I love local bars that I can walk to. I love supporting local businesses. My standards really aren't that high. I enjoy St Boniface, The Pressed Plate, and The Dutchmaid when it isn't the deck. I really don't enjoy bashing small businesses...but this place just isn't good. read more