The BEST wood-fired pizza in Wyoming! Our favorite is the Margherita. The sauce is perfect and the…read morebalsamic drizzle and fresh basil take it over the top. The salad specials never disappoint and the portion is generous enough to share. A must experience!

Saw this place on triple D and had to make the stop. A relatively small restaurant with huge taste…read more Meatballs on the pizza were amazing and the chicken was cooked to perfection along with the home made pasta. Everyone we interacted with was helpful and friendly. Will be back!!!

Quick friendly service, lunch buffet was fresh and kept full! Will definitely be returning when in…read morebuffalo!

We ordered delivery to our hotel and the pizza arrived hot and delicious. Really hit the spot after…read morea long day of driving.

Excellent service, great flavor, awesome crust and the best: amazing price! We had a 3 toppings…read morecustom large pizza for $9.50! They have a bunch of deals too! We need more businesses like this. Great job!!

Interesting ... Mr Jim's is a takeout pizza place. Didn't see that on the website or in the…read morereviews I scanned. Taking the pizza to our accommodations ... WOW, what a pizza! Had the chicken premier and it's unique (and great tasting) white sauce! The standouts were the veggies (white onions, green peppers, etc.) we're crisp! FIRST TIME EVER FOR THAT! It was incredibly tasty!!! Great pizza and prepped (including baking) in under 15 minutes!!! Perhaps they're not ready for a sit down site and they would need to get a liquor license (pizza without beer? C'mon man...). Perhaps not in Sheridan but this pizza is absolutely legit!!!!!

Way tasty pizza and sammich's …read more But the hidden gem out in Bighorn is the foodies dreaM Calzones that she bakes up in the cool ass spinning oven. 2 thumbs up. Definitely in the too ten of all Wyoming.

Review Update:…read more Sadly, our last 3 pizzas were very mediocre. We kept going back hoping it was just a mistake only to be disappointed again. I can't justify going back unless something changes for the better. For years the Big Horn Pizza Mercantile Pizza has been our families go to for deliciously consistent pizza and something we have always counted on! One day we discovered the manager and the familiar faces were no longer there. Since the new manager took over several months ago nothing has been quite the same or tasted as good. - Not as fresh or flavorful - Crust changed - Sour and hard pineapple - Skimping on toppings and sauce - Much wider crust border That manager left a lot to be desired. If there was one thing she had been very consistent on is her excuses, apathy, and unapologetic attitude. She listened and shook her head and without apology insisted the pizza is exactly the same as it's always been. This is simply not true. The pizza since her running things is nothing special and certainly no better than Powder River Pizza. I just remembered there was an another time after we decided to take a break a long break from them... we had come down the mountain with friends late one evening and because of the time went ahead and stopped in for pizza. What a mistake. We spent money on brew while we waited. It took them over 1 hour to get 1of 2 pizzas on the table and somehow they forgot the other pizza. Our friends had to wait another 25 min. for their order. Hungry, tired, and regret of the situation. I wish the owner would take notice and go back to what this establishment had done for many years and what gave it such a great reputation. I sincerely hope they resume the previous way and make their customers happy again by going back to their original way of doing pizza. Back to when their pizza really was the best! And also, the previous manager was very pleasant, ran a good crew, and always made excellent pizza.

Everything there is amazing the service is spectacular the food is even better, and the beer is…read moreamazing. I highly recommend going out of your way to stop here it is well worth your time . The prices are great I dont believe anything is over priced especially for the quality of the food. My personal favorite os the Philly cheese steak pizza, but I haven't had one w i didn't like, and the wings are all amazing!!!

My favorite pizza spot--hands down the best crust anywhere. This time I tried their root beer, and…read moreit's definitely not your granpappy's brew, but wow, it was good. Pizza and service are consistently excellent, and the atmosphere is warm and family-friendly. A place that never disappoints.

Pizza was delicious- wood fired perfectly! Plenty of beers on tap and specialty drinks-read more

Just had lunch the pepperoni and the pickle both very good and the service was nice. Would…read morecertainly recommend it and head back again another day

[Review is based on camping experience] Ten Sleep Brewing Co…read morehas a really nice vibe and very picturesque. We camped here for one night on our way to Mount Rushmore. It was $18 + tax for a tent site which came out to be $23.79. $3 per person per showers which are located behind the brewery. Drinking water inside brewery available for fill ups and only during business hours. There are 2 port-a-potties by the tent sites, 4 port-a-potties outside the brewery and 2 bathroom stalls inside the brewery. Located outside is a dishwashing and charging station. We bought two beers for $7.50/pint. We didn't try the food here, but was told it's just basic "last ditch" frozen pizza and pretzels. The brewery hosts events on certain nights and have food trucks some times. We just happened to stay here when nothing was going on. We would've liked this spot more if the tent spots were further apart. People in the tent spot next to us came in around midnight and woke us up for almost an hour with their loud whispering while unpacking and barking dog which woke up our dogs. The tent spots were close enough that we can hear neighbors move around in their tents. Unfortunately, that whole thing put a damper on our experience.

Steve and I got to try Ten Sleep Brewing Company quite recently and we liked the beer we had here…read moreconsiderably! The name of the beer was Speed Goat. This was a Blonde/Golden Ale. This was a very pleasant and drinkable beer. Flavors and highlights to be on the lookout for with this beer are crispness ,clean and sweet. The beer is smooth yet is light bodied which makes this ale so very drinkable!

We ate here Thursday night minutes before they closed. We did not realize it was as tight as it…read morewas. They close at 9 o'clock and we walked in at 8:58 and they happily served us. My wife ordered the chicken salad sandwich with fries I ordered the three-piece chicken dinner came with gravy and mashed potatoes and coleslaw. I received a chicken leg chicken breast and a chicken thigh. Both meals were delicious. The ambience of this place is more of a I would say 50s 60s Berger place. The people in there were very very nice especially for that time of night and getting ready to close. I would definitely recommend In Buffalo, Wy that you give them a try. Our bill came to $31 for both meals, which is a deal anywhere. sorry for not getting pictures other than the fries. I will do better on our next visit.

Pretty run of the mill local butter joint, although the hysteria a bit more variety than you might…read moreexpected. Fries were pretty good, and the best part of the meal. The bacon dashburger was a liter underwhelming, Small with an amazing unimpressive amount of bacon. I'd prefer it over a fast food burger, but definitely on the low side of medium compared to your average local burger.

My experience started off at roughly 7:00pm on the 27th of January 2026. I entered the restaurant…read moreand was "greeted" by... one of the friendliest servers I have ever met. I sat at the bar and he was quick to help me out. I asked what his favorite pizza was. With no hesitation he said the popper. His confidence was to outstanding to not believe him. So, I ordered it.. and holy smokes. It was... delicious. It was perfectly cooked and the service was top notch! I got my bill.. and realized it was appropriately priced for what I ordered. So I gave this guy.. a pretty decent tip and told him to have a good night! People like him... Will have me coming back! I'd honestly give this place five stars out of one.

Service and food are good but prices are crazy. $18 mozzarella sticks, $18 for 8 chicken wings. 2…read moreother people there for lunch on a Friday should tell you something. Pricing yourselves out