This is a gorgeous little shop with a lot of unique items. (It's worth pointing out that many of…read morethese stones could be purchased for a lot less in some of the shops up in the North Carolina mountains, but then again, we're a long way from the mountains down here.) We picked out a gorgeous butterfly pendant for my wife for her birthday. She loves it, and the staff here was helpful and friendly. We will definitely return the next time we're in St Augustine.

The assistant manager, Dakota, is knowledgeable, happy to help, and very friendly and welcoming…read more She helped me find what I was looking for without pressuring me to buy anything. They have a wide variety of stones and metals and know/care about where things are sourced from. I've been in almost every jewelry store in St. Augustine looking for a very specific charm for a bracelet, and Silver Feather beat the competition in every way in my opinion.

Casa Rodriguez is a very nice, cute jewelry store in downtown St. Augustine tucked inside a…read morecharming house. It's not big, but it has high quality merchandise. I received gifts from this place and I also purchased a few nice items (silver) when in the area. It's long lasting jewelry. Very cute and nice designs. Prices are on the higher side, but they have more reasonable items, too. Great customer service, they put everything in nice gift boxes that make a festive presentation. Casa Rodriguez is a nice store to shop for a little something special gift.

Sadly this business is now closed. Replaced by a Parisian clothing store, which does have some…read morejewelry but not local.

Been to this store quite a couple of times and always pick up a couple of trinkets. The service…read morehere is pretty good and the ambiance is always good vibes. They have a wide selection of things to purchase from bathing suits to clothes to other items!

Absolutely loved this spot. The selection is seriously one of the best I've seen in St. Augustine,…read morewith a great mix of unique vintage pieces and really wearable finds. You can tell everything is curated with intention, not just thrown together. The staff was super welcoming and helpful without being pushy, which made the whole experience even better. Prices felt fair for the quality, and I ended up finding pieces I haven't seen anywhere else. If you're into vintage or just want something different from the usual retail stores, this place is definitely worth stopping by. Will 100% be coming back next time I'm in town.

Really awesome antique shop with a very large selection. You could spend a long time in here. There…read moreis something for everyone! Prices are affordable as well.

This is a super cool antique shop in St. Augustine. It was close and convenient to the hotel we…read morewere staying at as well as the religious sites we were visiting. We also were taking refuge from the badly needed monsoon rains in St. Augustine at the time. The store owner was very helpful to my wife who was checking out some of the Estate jewelry that was for sale. Lots of very cool options from art decor, to steins, sports collectibles, to coins, and to everything collectible.

Best consignment shop on the island for great value in select designers and certainly tops for St…read more Augustine. The shop is not only well organized, but bright and airy. All items appear to be in "like new" condition with many top designers and especially that Florida Coastal fav Lilly Pulitzer. I have shopped here for quite awhile for a special unique item. I recently consigned a few items and the consignment process is easy. Staff are always helpful and dressing rooms are large and bright to clearly see fit & colors.

Where to start... Whenever I need or want to buy something this is my first and, usually, only…read morestop! I shop and consign and the owner and staff are so easy to work with on both ends of the process. They have helped me rework my entire look at a fraction of the retail price. Rather than standing at the counter waiting for 'approved or rejected' clothes (both time consuming and possibly embarrassing), you just hand them a tote with your items and then follow up as to what will be resold. SO EASY!

I LOVE this jewelry store! They offer an enormous variety of affordable merchandise. Furthermore,…read morethey have some really unique styles. In the past, I've purchased two bracelets for myself and gifts for others. All of us are very content with the quality of our pieces. I am very mindful of how I store my jewelry so I keep my pieces in their perspective pouches. Needless to say, I haven't experienced any issues with discoloring, tarnishing, et cetera. The store's layout is interesting. I enjoy the massive interior case that mimics a bar as the salespeople are behind the counter. It's is very well organized with the jewelry sectioned off by color, theme, etc. (ex. dolphins, pearls, silver, and so on). In addition to the interior rectangular showcase, there are separate display cases where shoppers can peruse and touch. The staff at JR Benet are extremely friendly and accommodating. My friend and I shopped in January when we went to see the holiday lights and we spent a lot of time looking and trying on the merchandise. They were so patient and never made us feel rushed. We both left with jewelry for ourselves and others. It was a pleasant experience and I'm excited to return later this month when I'm in town. Be sure to checkout the manmaids above the counter when you checkout.

I come here every time I visit and add some firefly jewelry to my collection. I love this store! If…read moreyou appreciate artistic pieces, come here. :) got some earings this time.

I am so very pleased I found Nettle's Fine Jewelry and wanted to share our experience!!…read moreSince our very first visit, we were treated like family and felt completely confident knowing we were in honest, knowledgeable, and caring hands. The team takes the time to listen, explain every detail, and never once made me feel rushed and my emotions throughout the process were so gently respected. Their integrity, patience, and attention to detail made the entire experience stress-free and meaningful. The quality and craftsmanship of their jewelry is absolutely beautiful and was finished long before I had hoped which was a very nice surprise. We are incredibly grateful for their exceptional service of the entire team- the friendly and helpful employees - we had the pleasure to work with Clay, Darcy, Joy, Joanne, and others I can't recall their names- We absolutely recommend them without hesitation.

Shoutout to local community heroes at this amazing venue. My husband was able to surprise me a…read morebeautiful pair of Mandarin Citrine earrings. We have looked high and low for a pair this impressive and vibrant. The mandarin citrine (or "Fire Citrine") is a vibrant, orange-to-golden yellow variety of quartz known for its warm, sunny hue, often sourced from Brazil or Uruguay. Highly prized for jewelry, this durable 7-on-the-Mohs-scale stone is typically eye-clean and used in statement pieces. It is associated with prosperity, joy, and energy. I was so happy and grateful for this venue and my hubby making this special gift a reality!

Near the oldest wooden schoolhouse in the United States, this small store is packed with eye…read morecatching jewelry, cute gifts and glassware. They sell Swarovski jewelry. Their prices are expensive to some good deals, like the round Swarovski bud earrings. I bought a really pretty, unique bracelet for $11 that was made in the store. I have gotten several compliments on it. Was tempted to buy more jewelry! They also have a website. Didn't think I'd get anything out of this touristy, generally overpriced shopping street but I'm glad I passed through!

In another life I absolutely must have been a Magpie. If it shines it draws me in like a siren song…read moredraws the sailors to their deaths. For me, it draws my wallet out of my purse and makes me part with my hard earned cash. Shiny! Sparkly! Must. Look. Away. As I am inevitably drawn in..... Sunburst Crystal is almost overwhelming with the vast selection of Crystal of all types, not only my absolute favorite Swarovski but other types as well. They offer necklaces, bracelets, window prisms, you name it and they have it. So beautiful, so plentiful. My poor hubby, so patient waiting nearby waiting for me to finish my purchases. Service is OK, prices OK.... shiny things?? MORE than OK!!