Got a sampling of bagels and muffins from this Fishers location after a friend brought some from the Avon location. Good quality. We got French toast, blueberry and cinnamon bagels. Nice and fresh. We got Boston cream pie and deep dish apple muffins. My son liked the apple one so much he stole part of mine. Do wish they would put their menu online so we know what is available before heading up. Will definitely go again. read more

The customer service is very poor here. I ordered a large latte. It came out at the same time as another customer's medium latte and the barista switched our drinks when she handed them too us. She realized her mistake and asked to have them back. She dumped the large drijnk into a medium cup and threw out the rest (the other customer wondered why she didn't just let him keep the large instead of wasting a cup and throwing out the extra). As bad as that was, I had it worse. She dumped the medium drink into a cup and just handed it to me. I asked her to top it off (after all, I ordered a large), and she said it was almost to the top of the large cup. I asked her again to top it off. She took it back and instead of topping it off with espresso, she foamed some milk and topped it off with that instead. read more

Big Apple Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Food was good in fact I went there six times this week but today the girl wanted to charge me more money for the same thing I've been paying 489 for she wants to pay 539. I asked why and she said a tax I said is there a weekend tax and then she got smart ass unfortunately you just lost a customer my name is Kevin. Last name is Dalton. This is the location by Highway 37 . read more

Don't go to this location!!! They are so slow and every single time we order there they mess the order up. Wrong bagel, wrong cheese, something is left off, and sometimes the wrong sandwich. The location at Olio and 116th street is way better!! read more

I'm literally only giving the two start for the two very friendly employees I encountered but that was the driest bagel I've ever had in my life. Not to be mean but :/ was not for me. I started picking through the sandwich and ditching the bagel:/ read more

See all

Love stopping in here, they are always so friendly. Someone was about to buy out all of one flavor of bagel and she was going to steal one for me. I got the American sunrise with ham on jalapeno toasted. Delicious as always! read more

Big Apple Bagels - American sunrise with ham - Bagels Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Had this place bookmarked for a while and finally checked it out. It has good food and ok prices but it's not particularly memorable. My friend and I went for brunch, an ok crowd of regulars seemed to be present. I knew it was a bagel place but thought they'd have some other things, they don't really aside from some baked goods. Food, flavors are ok but serving size could be bigger and drink selection could be better. It's an ok place but not somewhere I'd frequent regularly. read more

Big Apple Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

This place is the most unorganized business model I have ever seen. No less than 10 staff on a Saturday morning at 10 am and I had to wait 15 over minutes just for a plain begal. read more

The bagels offered by this establishment was of satisfactory quality, however, it is worth noting that the ambiance and service were somewhat lacking. read more

Big Apple Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

*MOLD REVIEW* Absolutely disappointing. It was my first time visiting BAB after a quick google search for a local bagel place and reading the first top 3 4-5 star reviews convinced me to go and try them out as I read that they not only have bagels but have great muffins too. I decided to give it a shot and I don't believe I will again. I ordered a Start Fresh breakfast sandwich on a honey oat bagel which is egg whites, tomatoes and turkey sausage. I substituted the tomatoes for red onion. As I was eating it, I kept thinking this tastes kind of funky and with every bite I took I continued to have this feeling. When I inspected the sandwich, I noticed the egg white is MOLDY and very clearly showing a green/gray/blue colour on the egg white as you can see in my photo. I was absolutely disgusted and am feeling rather sick at this moment due to that. I called the store and spoke to the manager at the time and her name was Jane (not native english speaker it seemed like). I let her know that her egg whites that I got were moldy. She did not once apologize for this, she instead decided to plead her case that "No, our egg whites are fresh, not moldy, but we can make you a new sandwich if you like". I did not appreciate her response to my having just ingested their moldy egg white that is making me feel sick. Did not offer a refund, only a new sandwich. I will be bringing whatever is left of the sandwich to the store today and showing them as it seems as though they did not believe me. I will also be contacting the general manager as these are franchised owned business and there was no indication that they would take off the egg whites from being sold. I can only hope that after the call, they checked on their egg whites and disposed of them. I also tried their mini muffins. At the time of writing this review, I tried the cookies and cream and it was tasty. I don't expect to have a mold related issue with their muffins. Please be wary. read more

Big Apple Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

I left here very pissed off this morning. I was ready to redeem my free dozen bagels, but the manager (who thought he was a total hard ass), denied what I rightfully earned. He told me to redeem it I'd have to go to the other location read more

Not just a bagel shop but also muffins and pastries! I love all the different cream cheese flavors they offer. We tried the bacon cheddar cream cheese which I feel is a game changer for bagels. The bagel itself was decent but could probably use a bit more toasting as you can see in the color. Didn't grab a picture but also got the cinnamon muffin. That was delicious and very moist! They have a bunch of mini muffins as well so you can try different flavors all in one. Pretty decent bagel spot around fishers! read more

Big Apple Bagels - Cinnamon crumb cake - Bagels Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

This place had such great reviews I couldn't wait to try it...hard to find quality bagels in Indy (except Broad Ripple). I'm obsessed with Bloomington Bagel shop down south- homemade bagels and cream cheese. I don't know why I was expecting something like that. I was nearby and came for lunch. Looked at the website to view the menu and was surprised that it was a small chain. Hmm. Went in and the man working was so friendly and nice!! He gets 5 stars. The food get -4 stars, hence how we reached one star. I ordered the bagel and lox sandwich. This is my standard order at any bagel place. Well. I took a bite and it did not taste good. The cream cheese was meh and the smoked salmon was terrible. Like seriously bottom of the barrel. If I pay $10 for this, you can at least give me middle-tier smoked salmon. Also they put onions on it when I saw no. I honestly couldn't finish more than a quarter of it. The bagel itself tasted good so I gnawed off the top of it that wasn't touching the cream cheese. A sad waste of money on an blah place. Boo. read more

Big Apple Bagels - Lox and bagel sandwich - Bagels Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

My wife and I stopped here this weekend for a quick breakfast stop after an early morning at Jupiter flights at Conner prairie. I originally was just going to grab a muffin because that's usually what I get, but they had a sign for a French toast egg sandwich and it looked very good. Overall, I thought it was a great breakfast sandwich. They always have great bagels. This sandwich was a French toast bagel, egg, sausage and syrup. Definitely may be too sweet for some but was right up my alley. I would definitely order it again. read more

Big Apple Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

I think this picture says it all! I've tried bagels from all over Indy and I have to say this place is my favorite. Even if you don't get a bagel sandwich the bagels alone are fantastic. They serve both breakfast sandwiches and lunch sandwiches both are equally as good. I will say though, the egg is microwaved that they use for the breakfast sandwich making the texture a little different but personally that does not bother me. This trip I did not get a muffin but I have in the past and they have always been fresh and moist, and they have a pretty good selection of different flavored, both jumbo and mini. This place can get pretty busy on the weekend but they do a decent job of getting the sandwiches out pretty quick. read more

Big Apple Bagels - Southern tradition - Bagels Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

This visit wasn't as good as the ones I've had in the past. I ordered a BLT bagel and first of all the person helping me was not super friendly at all, and almost seem to put out. Second of all there was only like three pieces of bacon on the sandwich and when they cut it in half all the bacon was on one side of the bagel I was disappointed in this visit, but will give it a second chance read more

Good place. I wish the toasting and adding cream cheese was quicker but their bagels are good. They are friendly and their coffee is good too. Good selection and easy to jump into from 126th. read more

Big Apple Bagels - a cup of coffee - Bagels Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Don't order online and expect your order to be ready and waiting at your expected time! They don't even care when you ask why the order isn't ready when I'm 10 mins late too! People have tight schedules and order for convenience. This has happened three times. Maybe get a new online order system! read more

I liked my breakfast sandwich (not hard to mess that up!); however, we ordered ahead with a 20 minute wait period. Once there, food wasn't ready and actually took another 15 minutes, but it wasn't even communicated that they didn't actually have anymore everything bagels baked and that's what actually kept delaying it (no option given to change bread type until we checked on food status and asked to change the type of bagel). Overall, it's a good option to have nearby, but need better expediting processes during busy times! Or just don't offer ordering ahead if not able to handle it. read more

Went in at 10 am with my daughter for a quick bite. Cashier was distracted to a point that I asked a question and he walked away. He forgot to give me my cup for coffee. I waited a few min thinking I would get it and didn't so I got one from the counter, That he noticed and asked me "you ordered coffee?" YEA!!! Anyway so sad that the service sucks here. Bagels were good not great. Coffee area had most carafes empty. Table I had to wipe down myself. Didn't see anyone clean or wipe down any other table while I was there. Took 1/2 hour to get 2 bagels with cream cheese. I checked in and tried to redeem the free mini muffin offer and the cashier had no idea what that was and did not honor it. I think next time I'll grab a bite somewhere else. read more

Big Apple Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Solid lunch experience and the bagel joke of the day make this stop . Great variety of bagels, spreads, sandwiches and beverages. Love the lox sandwich for lunch read more

I love the food here but the service is almost always lacking. None of the staff are welcoming when you arrive and more often than not they mess up something with your order. I will be finding a new location for team breakfast. One too many chances and it hasn't improved. read more

Great food good service no problems with my order and got it fast!!! Best bagel place I know!!

We went this morning and had the coffee/bagel with cream cheese I think it was $4.49. They have a good coffee selection, I had blueberry! He had the everything bagel with chive cream cheese & I had Asiago with veggie cream cheese. Only complaint was we asked for them toasted and they didn't seem toasted at all.. so maybe next time I'll ask for them extra toasted. read more

See all

Always a great place to visit. Location wise it is pretty easy to access even though it is off Hwy 37. Plenty of space inside to meet your friend. Bagels and muffins are always fresh and avaliable in various types. read more

Big Apple Bagels - Flava of the month. - Bagels Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

This is a nice place for a bagel type sandwich or pastry. I can't say that I think that they were the real deal bagels though. If you're going to call yourself Big Apple Bagels, people are going to have big expectations. It's certainly a step up from Dunkin' Donuts. The food is made to order, no premade packaged and microwaved items like the big chain coffee shops. I wasn't bowled over but I would give them another try if I'm in the area again. read more

I love Big Apple! This location in particular has been around for quite awhile. I used to frequent it in high school as I graduated from Fishers and it was very close by! They also used to donate all of their leftover bagels to the food pantry at the end of each day--not sure if they still do that, but my mom used to be one of the folks who would drive there, pick them up and deliver them to the food pantry. Love that they did that. My one and only suggestion/question: do they ever have the sun dried tomato cream cheese? One of the recent times I visited, they had it listed where the to-go containers are so I asked for it; and the cashier showed me the list of cream cheeses they had available. Well, sun dried tomato was on that list as well so I asked for it again. Long story short, they didn't have that flavor. So I'm wondering if it's ever available or if they just don't sell it anymore? And if it's the latter, I would suggest taking it off of the list. But I hope that's not the case! Xoxo, Is this thing on? read more

I like this place, yes, it's a chain but who cares?! It's clean, service is friendly, bagels are ok, and the muffins are grand. Every time I come here, I'm greeted with a smile. My 4 year gives it 5/5 for sure, very kid friendly, easy parking, clean bathroom, quiet space to work or just enjoy some peace. I will continue to enjoy these muffins and the Bagel BLT. read more

Love the bagel sandwiches here. Staff are super friendly. I ordered the California club, which is a triple decker with turkey, cheese, guacamole, cucumber, tomato. Yum! read more

Good morning spot to grab some coffee and a bagel or muffin. Good quality sandwiches. I cannot comment on lunch items read more

I love this place. So glad it's around the corner from where I live. Their bagel sandwiches are delicious!

If I could give them more than 5 stars I would. Not only are there bagels always delicious but when I left my purse and they had already closed they graciously told me I could still come and get it and they'd open the door for me. They even gave us some bagels! Thank you Big Apple Bagels! read more

I think my favorite place for a fresh bagel. If you're coming from the west, you have to drive by it and use a round about. As I mentioned fresh, but if you ask for it toasted with butter, they toast AND put the butter on it. None of this, here's your plastic knife and a small container of butter. Easy grab drive and eat! They also have coffee, various cream cheese spreads, and muffins. They also have breakfast and deli sandwiches, on a bagel of course. No seating inside during Covid. read more

This has to be one of the worst place get bagels - everytime we come here - we'd wait and wait and wait get our food . Other people would get food before us - poor service .... We will not be coming back here again. read more

We really enjoy BAB. My husband goes all the time and me not so much, but I always enjoy my meal when I'm there. I'm also always surprised at ALL we get for the money! Today we got a coffee, two sandwiches, two muffins, a banana, and a smoothie and it was only $15. That is soooo affordable! The smoothie was really good and big enough for kids to split. The coffee was really good and I'm picky. The double chocolate muffins were delish but almost so thick you needed a cup of milk with them. And I love their bagels... so our sandwiches were delish too! Be ready to wait though... they sometimes have a line out the door! read more

Big Apple Bagels - Bagels Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Me : I would like a plain bagel toasted with Apple Cinnamon Cream Cheese. Cashier: What type of bagel? Me: I would like a plain bagel toasted with Apple Cinnamon Cream Cheese. Cashier : So a plain bagel. Me : I would like a plain bagel with Apple Cinnamon Cream Cheese. Cashier: Would you like that toasted? Sigh. Someone left their listening skills at home today. Decent bagel, poor order taking skills and my green smoothie had a big chunk of ice in the bottom and when it was given to me smoothie was on the cup. This was on a not so busy Saturday afternoon. I wouldn't go out of my way to visit again. read more

See all

I 11/10 recommend this place! Their bagels and their muffins are the absolute best!! The customer service is perfect, as well! Love this place so much!! read more

The food was delicious and had great texture staff were nice got an everything bagel with cream cheese loved it. Place felt very warm and everyone was very nice. read more

The bagels are very good including the bagel sandwiches. They have a good selection of bagels and coffees.

When I found out that Big Apple Bagels (BAB) has two locations not too far from where I now live, I was ecstatic! Growing up I remember always having BAB when I would visit family in Michigan. So I eagerly went in to order my fave, chocolate chip bagel with, get this...chocolate chip cream cheese! BAB is the only place I know of to have chocolate chip cream cheese. And let me tell you, it's a game changer! I might also be known to eat that cream cheese by itself, but who can say! BAB has everything you might look for in a bagel shop. There are sweet and savory options. Another great thing about BAB is My Little Muffin. Does this place get any better!? Honestly I don't know how there aren't more locations. There are muffins and mini muffins. I personally enjoy the double chocolate cheesecake muffin. It is so moist and delicious. There are also smoothie options. What more do you need to convince you!? Go ahead and check this place out. With all those options there's got to be something for everyone! read more