Female at the register was not really paying attention. More interested in chatting with a guy in the "dining room." Always so darn cold in here. 4 tables of 4 is what you get with mismatched chairs. Bennett's is one of our regular spots, and we keep coming back for a reason! The food is always good, the sandwiches are delicious, and they rarely disappoint. The grilled cheese with bacon and tomatoes is one of my favorites, and the chicken cheesesteak with grilled onions, mushrooms, and American cheese is so good too. Great food, decent prices, and always a solid choice when we don't feel like cooking. Tonight the chicken sandwich was very dry and the onion pieces had some of the skin. We do like this place but this was an off night. Definitely one of our go-to places! read more

Bennett's Sandwich Shop - Check. - Sandwiches Near Me - Salem, New Hampshire

See all

Sorry! I bit into it before the photo! It smelled great! Bread - very soft and good. I now wonder if they bake it in house Steak - Decently good. Been craving a steak and cheese. Toppings - Hot. Fresh. Good. -peppers-onion-mushrooms Almost added salami Wishing I had Cheese - I almost asked for provolone as well. Wishing I had. Overall, decent. Hot. Fresh. I had it door dashed cause I couldn't leave my desk and live close enough that it didn't lose temp read more

Bennett's Sandwich Shop - Steak and Cheese - mushroom / peppers / onion - Sandwiches Near Me - Salem, New Hampshire

The hubby and I stopped here for lunch. We both had the famous Italian sandwich. The bread was very soft. The ingredients were very fresh. The price for this huge sandwich was very reasonable. The service was very friendly. The atmosphere was bright, small but clean and simple. We will definitely come back to try something else. read more

Bennett's Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Salem, New Hampshire

See all

Had a veggie sub and a falafel bowl. Canned mushrooms and too much lettuce for the sub; mostly lettuce, onion and salad dressing for the falafel bowl. A big disappointment for over $30. read more

Ordered a veggie sub. Asked for only tomatoes, lettuce, peppers and onions. Order screen also only listed what I wanted. Bit into my sub and found an odd taste. It was cheese. 2 kinds of cheese. I'm allergic to cheese!! Spent $12 on a sub I had to toss and spent the rest of my Sunday on the couch in agony!! Can almost see forgetting an item the customer wanted, but to add something takes extra effort. They obviously don't care. So disappointing. read more

Stop going to Jersey Mikes. This spot is legit. Calm vibe, got met with great, friendly people. Sandwhich quality is just awesome! You can taste the huge difference in every bite! read more

Steak tastes like its been marinating in water for a month. Zero flavor and too much cartilage. I dont enjoy crunchy cartilage in my subs. Owner needs to stop being so cheap and invest in better product. Some of the staff there are also extremely rude. I wont be back read more

Subs are decent but the bread is like styrofoam. If they could change the bread to something that's not all chemicals and preservatives they'd be 5 star read more

George cooked up a mean cheesesteak! Very clean place as well. Would recommend for a good meal.

I stopped in at the new Bennett's Sandwich Shop located in Tuscan Village. It was lunchtime and needed a sandwich. I went with a tuna melt. Which came with tuna, cheese, lettuce and tomato. It was grilled or toasted but the cheese was not melted and was not warm inside. It was a good amount of tuna, but was kind of bland. I would probally go with something else next time. Service was friendly and pleasant. read more

Sub shops are really hard to come by... ones that are really good and clean inside. Such a good spot, love love the wicked steak & cheese! In a sub roll extra toasted or in a bowl just as is 10/10 the best bold flavor you'll ever try! Also have chicken cheese steaks. Service is always quick and they have indoor and outdoor seating! read more

See all

Bennett's Sandwich Shop opened in April 2023 at Tuscan Village next to Chipotle and across from Chick Fil-A. This regional sandwich shop offers a variety of hot & cold sandwiches/subs, melts, cheesesteaks, lobster sandwiches/rolls, breakfast sandwiches/subs (all day), breakfast bowls, fries, hash browns, chips, salads, smoothies, and cold drinks. I've been by the locations at the Burlington Mall (MA) and Downtown Portsmouth. I saw mixed reviews for this location and since I was already at Tuscan Village, I decided to place an online order for Bennett's Sandwich Shop. I was hungry for a cheesesteak sub and at the same time for an egg & cheese sub, They offer a Wicked Steak Egg & Cheese Sub served all day. I ordered a 12" Wicked Steak Egg & Cheese Sub ($11.99 plus tax) on a signature sub roll with steak, provolone cheese, hots, Sriracha aioli, ketchup and added green peppers, onions, and mushrooms (another $1 plus tax). The online ToastTab order would be ready in approximately 25 minutes. I arrive around 6pm, but they were closing early due to the holiday and the doors were locked. I wave to a staff member who unlocks the door and I point out my online order on the shelf, ready to go and handed to me. The bagged and wrapped sub was heavy and very hot which was a good sign that it was freshly made. I unwrap the sub when I arrive home, which is still very hot. The bread was very soft and a bit soggy from the generous amounts of fillings and ingredients. The sub tasted very good which had a slight spiciness with plenty of grilled steak, hots, onions, peppers, & mushrooms, flatgrilled egg, sriracha aioli & ketchup. I enjoyed my hot cheesesteak/egg sub with a bag of chips and an iced coffee. If the sub roll used was instead a firm & chewy rosemary parmesan sub roll from Jers-y M!ke's filled with Bennett's ingredients, this cheesesteak/egg sub would be wicked awesome. read more

The employees were very welcoming and nice. Dya, (one of the chefs)made sure I got everything I wanted on my sandwich and it turned out great. The large sandwich is also very filling, better than a sub from like Subway or something. Can't wait to come again! read more

Ordered my usually order I get at the other location and it was above and beyond great service from Kelly and the crew thank you

Bread is dried out. Half of the wrapping paper was pressed inside the sandwich with all the meat. I picked it up for bite #1 and the whole sandwich exploded onto the table from dried bread. Should have just ordered it in a bowl for same result read more

Bennett's Sandwich Shop - Sandwiches Near Me - Salem, New Hampshire

Ok, the good: quick, pretty cheap, service people were nice, bright, reasonably clean location. The bad- the rest of it. You know the difference between a wonder-type of white bread and a quality, local Italian or Scali? This is white bread folks. The whitest white bread. No form, no taste, too soft and gets nasty quickly based on the water from the veggies. Tomatoes were mealy and mushy. Me: "do you have hot peppers?" Them: "yes." Me "could I please get hots on my sandwich, too?" Them: "sure." Upon receiving my sandwich, i learned: They do NOT have hot peppers, they have pickled banana peppers. NOT THE SAME, FOLKS. not even close. Like if tomatoes were tomatillos. Not the quality I would expect anywhere, let alone the Tuscan Village area. I can't recommend the place. Sorry. read more

My name is Craig and I am addicted to Bennet's Sandwiches. The famous steak and cheese and Italian are simply amazing. The meat is cooked perfect and all of the toppings are incredibly fresh and literally look like they were just picked from the farm and added to the sandwich. Also, I don't even want to get started on the fries as thinking of the this potato perfection makes me hungry. I am not kidding, these thick fries are always perfectly cooked with nice crispy outside and perfect texture in the center. I just polished off a large steak and cheese with fries and was so pleased with the meal I had to write this review. Give them a try as you will not be disappointed. Good work Bennett team! read more

I agree with the other reviews that say there's nothing wrong with it, but the portions are small and prices high for what amounts to little more than a wrap. It's small inside with just a few seats and the wait for the food is the worst part. They take forever. read more

they have the freshest bread and vegetables any where!! my favorite place to go!! And order is always ready when I go to pick it up I never wait read more

The Food was very good .. very clean spot and the employees very nice . Deginstrly going back

The sandwiches are so good . Everything was fresh . Staff was very friendly. Store was very clean read more

Very tasty sandwiches and friendly service! Great variety of options, freshly baked bread and fresh ingredients. We will be back!

So glad I found this place. Their steak and cheese melt is awesome. Staff have always been very friendly. Excellent service!

Been twice done the last fiasco and glad I did . It's the best subs in the area and only place I'll go on my 1-2 subs a month

Excellent cuts of meat and even better bread. Also, they do a great breakfast sub! Oh yes, and what other sub shop has fries?!

Fries and sandwiches were really good, they were cooked perfectly. Workers were nice. Dood decor too.

Delicious and fresh sandwiches! The portions are really big two so you can get two meals out of one (I love that!). This place is awesome

Highly recommend. Great steak and cheese. Hash browns are top tier. Service was excellent.

Food was hot & fresh.. service was great & my order was done in no time.. highly recommend..

We thought we'd try the "award winning" sandwiches at Bennetts located at Tuscan Village. VERY DISAPPOINTING. I gave it 2 stars one for the pleasant employee, and the other for the bread. We ordered 3 large subs, and 3 small fries. Total? $61.00. The Bennett steak was lean but even with peppers, onions, and cheese it was flavorless. The tuna was fair. The Mediterranean falafel was terrible. Made with falafel that you get at Market Basket. Summing up, we could have saved $20.00 and had Romanos deliver. More food for less cash. And what makes it worse, is the horrid way the area is so congested in that parking lot. Very poor design read more