Great portion size for a good price. Stopped in on the way back from Shades state park. Service was attentive and a nice calm vibe.

Came on Mother's Day on the way to the casino. The food and service is alway wonderful. Our server was so patient and very kind.

This spot is definitely a rural small town eatery; that lots of older locals frequent. Service was friendly but very casual & relaxed. The food is decent, nothing spectacular, you will get full the portion sizes are huge, but the food is a little bland. The noodles in my fettuccini were severely overcooked. read more

See all

Was heading to Beef House and they were unfortunately closed. Found this GEM and decided to give it a try and SO GLAD we did! Great atmosphere, great value and the best waitstaff. My wife loved the catfish, the Creamy chicken soup was amazing and my daughter loved the spaghetti. My daughter spilled her water and the wait staff all chipped in to clean it up and get it handled quickly and with smiles on their faces. A waitress (that wasn't even ours) came over and was showing my girl a trick for drawing flowers. So cool that she did that when she didn't need to. She even gave her the advice, "If you ever want to do something in life, just try!" Would highly recommend giving this local, family-owned restaurant a try if you're passing through like we were. read more

Benjamin's Family Dining - Coloring and advice from kind waitress. - American Near Me - Covington, Indiana

This is worth the 11 miles off the highway drive. Diner food, done well and our server Ada was delightful. This is small town at its best.

The food is always delicious and u get plenty of food for the price of the meal. The service is very good always checking to see if you need anything. Love both the Benjamins in Rockville, Indiana as in Covington,Indiana. All time favorite is Rockville, Indiana just because they sweet tater fries.. The atmosphere of the restaurant is very nice lots of tables it's a very busy restaurant. read more

We stopped in here on our way from Illinois back home to Kokomo based on the Yelp reviews. We're so glad we did! We had the catfish and the spaghetti. Our food was delicious and the portions were generous. We both took leftovers home and they were enough for another meal. Our server was very personable and helpful. If we pass through the area again we will definitely make it a point to eat here again! read more

What a great place! Hubby and I are on our way home from Peoria, IL (more reviews on that later) and we made a snap decision to stop and grab some breakfast! Hopped on Yelp and what do you know - Benjamin's popped right up. Easy drive off I-74, headed in and was surprised to see there weren't more people dining considering the cars in the parking lot. All the staff was near the kitchen and after being "checked out", we were seated after being asked if a table was ok, which it was. Our waitress came over, we ordered our waters, then looked over the menus - skillets, omelettes, French toast, pancakes, sausage, bacon all your typical breakfast fare was there. The skillets and omelettes all sounded so good! The better half decided on the Hawaiian omelette and I, the Italian. All omelettes come with hashbrowns and your choice of toast with butter and jelly. I asked for homefries and wheat toast and the better half asked for a half order (2 slices) of the French toast. No problem at all! Within 15 minutes, we were digging in. Huge omelettes filled with gooey cheese, homefries that were cooked just right (though they could have used a little more seasoning) and perfect French toast (hubby thought it needed cinnamon but I thought it was fine as it was!). Loved the vibe of the place, kinda like Mel's diner minus Mel. Everyone chatting, catching up on the neighborhood gossip, you can tell this is the gathering spot. It was fairly clean, food was good, prices were excellent... ...and I saw the fried chicken!! Next time Benjamin's, next time!! read more

See all

The menu is as thick as the World Book for Q-R-P. Lita of choices. Good at many things, but not great at any. Everyone in your group can find something to their liking. read more

Great waitress, good food, big servings and the bathrooms were immaculate. We'll put it in the road atlas for a future return visit.

Delicious! Stopped by on the way from Crown Point to Bloomington. Followed the Yelp reviews and glad we did. Parking lot was almost full on Father's Day Sunday around 11am. Breakfast ALL day, which always makes me happy. Sign said "seat yourself" and so we found a nice corner booth. A lot of families of all ages. Waitress was quick with the coffee, water, iced tea and menus. We ordered eggs, bacon, hash browns, biscuit and short stack of pancakes. Eggs were perfectly cooked, over easy. Tasted fresh. Hash browns could have been more crisp but they were okay. Bacon was disappointing, limp even though I asked for crisp. (why can't short order cooks get this right?) Bacon was also very thin cut, which would have been okay if it wasn't so limp. Biscuit and pancakes were the star of the show. Biscuit was very good. Not too big and tasted like homemade. The pancakes (and I only had one bite since my partner is the one who ordered them) were some of the best I have ever had. Not stupid huge plate sized pancakes, these were like you would make at home. Fluffy without being overly cake-like. I would order them next time. Coffee was way better than I expected for an Indiana diner. Not weak and good, fresh flavor. Will definitely make this a regular stop when traveling in this part of the state. read more

Always fast, hot, & plentiful! Wide variety menu choices. I love the Turkey club with fries, but usually get a side of fried pickles too!

Not a fan...the mashed potato's taste like generic from a box, no seasoning on any food and under fried catfish. Great for the elderly crowd who can't handle salt or seasoning, or have no teeth. The service is great though!!!!! read more

Service was amazing! And food was delicious. Stopped in for lunch on a Thursday. We were passing through. Wish we had a reason to get back to Covington so we could stop back in! read more

The menu selection was great! The quality of food was A+ and the service was prompt and friendly. I highly recommend this restaurant for a wonderful home cooked meal! read more

Stopped in for lunch while in town for a meeting. The food was good and the service was great. They have a very large menu. Everyone was very friendly read more

Very good quality for what it is, a local family style restaurant. The chicken and dumpling soup was one of the absolute best I've ever had. read more

See all

We are traveling from Iowa and happened on this small town gem. We were looking for a little cafe and we won in spades. Friday nights they have specials of all you can eat Walleye and they have a surf and turf special also. We ordered both. They started by bringing us our sides of coleslaw which was more like 3 serving at any other restaurant. Then they brought our entrees. The steak was cooked to perfection and nearly melted in your mouth, it also ​came with a second side of potato choice and my wife chose baked potato, it also came with green beans cooked with onion and bacon, my other side was hash browns and was a huge serving, oh but the walleye was the best we have ever had. The staff was exceptional from start to finish, in fact we would give 10 stars if we could! read more

The staple of Covington. Not sure how they can cook so fast but we can pick up any order in 10 minutes. read more

Benjamin's Family Dining - Deep fried pickles - American Near Me - Covington, Indiana

Traveling through on our family road trip, we stopped here and were not disappointed! I highly recommend the Eiffel Tower. Cole slaw was also good. Friendly fast service. And the menu is incredibly extensive! read more

Was driving to Indianapolis, and got hungry, just as I breached the state line, between Illinois & Indiana. When I pulled into the parking lot, I figured someone was doing something right, because there wasn't one parking space, available. As I walked inside, I really didn't expect to get a table, right away, but to my surprise, there was one table, not being used. I still can't figure out, how they got all those people, in that small building. I was greeted immediately, and less than 30 seconds later, the waitress showed up and took my order. I knew what I wanted, and I was so hungry, my stomach thought my throat had been slit. I no sooner ordered, and my food was sitting, in front of me. I must've had an incredulous look, because the waitress smiled at me. Well, when I took that first bite, I was the one, smiling. Best ham & cheese omelet, I have ever eaten, PERIOD, bar none. The home fries, were equally good. I try not to eat at the corporate chains, for breakfast, and my loyalty to the mom & pop smorgasbord, paid off, again. I also met several of the locals, and I was impressed with the friendliness, of this little town. I love Middle America. Thank you, Covington, Indiana. I feel like I was family, for a couple hours, today. read more

Benjamin's Family Dining - American Near Me - Covington, Indiana

We were traveling and needed a place to stop for supper. We tried Benjamin's and were impressed. The staff was friendly, the restaurant was clean, and the food was delicious! We will definitely stop again on our next trip through town. read more

So glad we stopped here on a long cross-country drive. We like to stop at local diners along the way and this was one of the best. So clean and excellent service. Lots of elderly folks, which makes sense (they know good value!). We tried the special: beef tips on noodles with lots of gravy. Totally hit the spot. Our children enjoyed the hotdogs with fries and our lovely server even refilled their milks. We don't do a lot of Yelp reviews, but Benjamin's stood out for us and we wanted to be sure others knew this place is worth the stop. Added to our favorites for the next time we're in the area. read more

Great service and even better food! I wish we would have taken pictures of the generous portions. I had the Philly steak & fries, husband had beef Manhattan and both were delicious. Will make it a regular stop on my way to and from Peoria each year. read more

Very good home cooking type of food at a good price. Clean & friendly and not terribly far off the interstate. Our waitress was very kind to us and gave my grandpa a sample of the hot beef he was considering. read more

Benjamin's is one of our family favs! A huge selection of all kinds of food for all meals. We love the fried chicken on Thursdays and the fish on Fridays. The chicken bacon ranch wrap and the Philly cheesesteak are some of our favorites as well. Prices are reasonable and the wait staff is attentive. Gets a little slower with a packed house, but there's a reason it gets busy! Hard to not find something you'll like. read more

With the high reviews, we thought this place would be a great diner....not so much. The staff was friendly enough, although she kept forgetting things and our order. The menu is a typical diner, with breakfast served all-day. We got breakfast (eggs, bacon, toast, and hash brown) and fried cod with mashed potatoes, gravy, mixed vegetables (carrots and peas), and some other side. Everything was ok. The eggs were not good quality, and the mashed potatoes were luke warm, but just very average. read more

Superb service (Kelly is a gem!). The food was hot, cooked perfectly - precisely as ordered - and the option to order breakfast all day is sure to please any diners. A terrific choice for travelers along I-74; pass on any fast food or truck stops. This family diner is just minutes off the highway, you'll get good food, plus get it hot, fast, and right - and at very good prices. read more

The food is fantastic and good sized portions. Staff is friendly, food is reasonably priced and service is quick. What's not to love?! The fried pork tenderloin sandwich and French fries are the best! read more

Great food. The workers are friendly. Great service. It's in a small county, but the food is the best.

I don't know how many family members littered this restaurant with positive results.... it's Friday, I ordered the cod, OUT CAME LITTLE SQUARES OF FISH, still frozen on the inside, the fish squares on a McDonalds sandwich were better. Never ever again. read more

We were trying to meet my in laws at the Beef House but they were closed. A quick search on Yelp led us to Benjamins. We were pleasantly surprised with the food. 3 of the 4 of us had the tenderloin sandwich and it was absolutely delicious. Nicely breaded, fried and not dry at all. Yum! I had the rib eye sandwich which I would definitely recommend. It was cooked to order (I had medium rare) and huge. All the portions were really big and the food was inexpensive. I have a feeling we'll definitely be back. If you are in the area, definitely stop by! read more

Like another reviewer, we stumbled on Benjamin's by mistake while antiquing in western Indiana. We knew it must be good based on the parking lot being full. It was fantastic! I had 3 big pieces of walleye, fries, corn, and a side salad. Friend had all you can eat fried chicken, corn, mashed potatoes and side salaed. Neither of us could finish it all and the bill was only $17 for both of us! Waitress was also friendly and attentive. Can't wait to hea back! read more

We were waited on promptly. We both tried a bacon and mushroom soup that was very delicious and filling. I got the chicken breast sandwich on croissant and it was very large and good. My hubby got fish and fries. Although nothing special it was satisfying. They have a very large menu. We would definitely come back. read more

Best place to eat in Indiana everybody should go there good chicken all my God and Fridays fish

We stopped here after a long day of driving and were greeted by a very friendly staff!! Molly was amazing! We were offered and served our beverages immediately, our delicious salads came quickly as well. Two of us had never had catfish, and we found it delicious, as was the walleye. Molly checked on us frequently to make sure we had everything we need. It was a great end to a long day. read more

Found Benjamin's by accident when traveling thru Indiana on the way back from a wedding. The outside of the building could use some work, as does the inside. Don't be scared off though as the food is good. We stopped on a Sunday where they advertise no smoking between 11 and 3 PM. Ordered steak & eggs, fried eggs, hash browns and pancakes. Reasonably priced - whole bill came to $19.52. Recommended read more

Benjamin's is your basic family diner. We've been dining here 20+ years and they've gone through some very positive changes over the past few years. They serve a good breakfast (that's available all day) and have a large menu with something for everyone. The long tables are great for going out in groups & the staff is usually friendly and attentive. read more

They're menu is huge, but they make it so fast! Quality is pretty good especially when you consider the price. Breakfast all day. Omelettes are almost as good as the pancakes. My favorite is the walleye sandwich or turkey with dressing. read more

My girlfriend to Benjamin's at least once a week. They open at six a.m. and you get a breakfast ribeye, 2 eggs, hash browns or fries, and toast for $9.99. They mostly have what I'd call customer comfort foods. Al ays great service and usually fairly quick for sit down. They also have carry out. read more