I had to drag myself all the way out to Port Jefferson, which is about a million miles away on the darn Long Island Railroad from Forest Hills, to go to a friend's father's wake. Wakes always depress the hell out of me anyway, but afterward we ended up at this bar restaurant. It's a totally regular, blue-collar joint. Nothing fancy or phony about it at all. They had the usual stuff sitting out as the wake crowd shuffled in. Trays of wraps, wings, pasta, Caesar salad, sausage and peppers, that whole routine. Average food, really, but it got the job done. Everybody was feeling pretty happy as the drinks came in and went down celebrating this mans life on this depressing planet. It wasn't great or anything, but it didn't pretend to be, which I respect. If you really want to know the truth about the dining area, the whole setup in there was funny as hell. On one wall, they had all these cartoon posters, or whatever the hell they were, like Artificial Intelligence Smurfs and Angry Birds and all those childish pictures hanging up like it was a damn nursery. But then right on the other wall, they've got pictures of Marilyn Monroe and Frank Sinatra, like they're trying to act all classy and sophisticated, which just killed me. It's such a strange contrast that it almost breaks your heart. ​And then over on the bar side, it was just this huge square bar where a bunch of locals were sitting around watching the Mets lose on TV, some old bar fly playing a version of compacted nine pins. They were all staring at me like I had two heads or something just for wearing an expensive suit, which depressed me as well. read more

See all

Wow found my new favorite spot to grab some food. The hamburger was delicious. The pretzels with the warm cheese is amazing as well. Great atmosphere, service was fantastic. Also tried the chicken wings. They were crispy and cooked perfectly. So much flavor. Highly recommend going for a great time out. read more

Place felt dingy, it was over priced, food tasted old or frozen. I had the AC above my head dripping on me and my food the whole time. Waitress was unfriendly. Will not be returning. read more

It is a bar. The food is, at best, bar food (overcooked, flavorless, and makes you feel sick unless you have been drinking). The crowd at this place is questionable, and there is no such thing as ambience here. The staff is fairly inconsistent (leaning towards friendly but slow and ignores you). If you love watching an hour of My Pillow commercials while you wait for burnt hamburgers, by all means check it out. read more

Delicious appetizers, reasonably priced drinks, and most definitely the Best wings in the business!

Just a dirty bar with bar food. Nothing more, nothing less. Bar is always busy, the restaurant is just ok

Fun menu, reasonable prices and very pleasant service. Steak bits were tasty and tender, fried fish platter was fresh. Sports bar vibe with dining in a separate room so you can have a conversation. read more

This place is a complete dive bar. It was dirty, food was good but overpriced (eg. A simple veggie burger with LTO was $20). Our waitress was one of the rudest servers I have ever encountered. I will never return. Zero stars if possible. read more

My daughter was craving french dip and the reviews suggested here. Review was right. My daughter was very happy. My husband and I got the steak tidbits and they were delicious. The onion rings were thin and crispy and also really good. I loved the horseradish sauce on the side of the tidbits. Somehow my daughter actually had room for dessert and got the "famous" skillet cookie. read more

Benchwarmer's - Sports Bars Near Me - Mount Sinai, New York

I recommend this restaurant, their service is prompt and their staff is very friendly. The food is amazing.Stop by anytime and enjoy the games. read more

AMAZING FOOD! The marinated burger was so flavorful. great service and the server Patricia was super friendly. I would recommend this place and will definitely be back soon! read more

I love this place the food is excellent, the prices are reasonable. Service is great. I do want to say they changed the burgers, and it's a little disappointing because the burgers they use to have adult and kids menu ones where great and the ones they serve now are not. Hope they go back to the old burgers because that was the reason I fell in love with that place!!! But I've never had a complaint about any of the other food! read more

Walked in at 7:30. Totally packed for happy hour in the bar area so we sat in the dinning area where there were plenty of seats. Had mozz sticks, pretzel sticks, a Greek salad, and fish and chips split between 2 people. Mozz sticks- just ok Pretzel sticks- awesome. Light, slaty, buttery delicious. With cheese dipping sauce Greek salad- great fora bar salad! Lots of fixins in it Fish and chips- needed salt but very good. Decent beer selection as well. Bar area had a great TV set up. Lots of big ones. Just grab a table before the happy hour rush. At 830 when we went to leave definitely opened up in there read more

Never has any vegan options, I think all they have is a veggie burger and veggie sandwich. It's also really over priced for BAR food , something that is cheap and easy to make read more

Would have been nice to be told that soda refills were not free. Ended up spending $9.15 on 3 sodas. Also wasn't told of the up charge for waffle fries. Not coming back. read more

27.16 for 2 drinks that didn't have any alcohol in it. What a joke. We weren't regulars so I guess we had to wait for a second round. That's when we decided to leave. We were also looking for a dinner but when no one else was having food it didn't seem like a good idea. Not very busy for a Friday night. This place is a easy skip read more

Best food, great atmosphere and Excellent cocktails and beer. Always something to do. Great for family and business events . Professional and knowledgeable bartenders. Best place to go. Great karaoke. The place to go to see your favorite sport. read more

Love the atmosphere! They did such a great job renovating. The bar area is modern looking. The bar staff are friendly and attentive. The food is very tasty, fresh, made to order and consistently good. The food has been so good that I ordered a bunch of dishes for a holiday party this year. Everyone loved the catered food. The kitchen staff do such a fantastic job. read more

The food is always fresh and consistent and the staff is so friendly! We like the warm decor and the drinks are always how we like them! read more

Benchwarmer's - Great drinks! - Sports Bars Near Me - Mount Sinai, New York

Bartenders are great! The burgers are so good and a decent beer selection. My favorite is Patty Melt with sweet potato fries (they are waffle style ). There is a shuffle board, but the bar is usually pretty crowded. Fun local hangout. read more

The place is nice, however if you are a fan of pumpkin beer, be careful of cinnamon rim. My first sip was followed with me spitting out pieces of glass!!! Yes, you heard me right piece of glass! When I brought it to the bartenders attention, no remorse of the fact that I just spit out shards of glass from my mouth! I was very upset how they handled it....like nothing happen..I won't be returning! read more

I gave the two stars for the very nice people but the food was just not good. We were a party of 4 and none of us were happy with our meal. The bar area was nice and the tv's were adequate for sports but will go elsewhere next time. read more

Great pub, we visit at least once a week. Nice atmosphere and friendly service, with plenty of TVs for sports fans. The food is good and very reasonably priced, as are the drinks. Happy Hour Mon-Sat 4-8pm is fantastic value. Mary is one of the best bartenders I've ever come across. read more

Went in for lunch. Great service. Delicious marinated hamburger. Will go back. Also try the soft pretzel appetizer. Very good, but a bit on the pricey side. read more

Great food and atmosphere! I had the grilled chicken panini and my husband got the blackened chicken. Both were delicious! It was our first time there but we'll be going back. Service was excellent. read more

Place has good food and good specials. Bartenders are ok. They seem a little off sometimes like I'm annoying them or they are too attentive if that makes sense and they always assume I want a 12 dollar double. Kind of annoying. Check it out. Lots of tvs and sports on too. read more

Happy hour seems to be beer or wine We go Wkly and prices for drinks r not discounted. The food is good serving ample. read more

Great happy hour specials , even in the dining room....good drinks, friendly waitstaff...excellent wings and burgers. Never got anything we didn't like. They had a great dinner with Santa on December 15 and the Santa was awesome, got to take lots of pictures and didn't feel rushed through dinner... One of our favorite local spots. read more

A great place to go to. Great atmosphere excellent staff and the food is terrific. They have a quite dining area also if you prefer. Plenty of T.V's to watch your favorite sporting event. By far the best pub & grill in the neighborhood !! read more

Would not recommend for non locals or a younger crowd. I was not treated right here. I felt like I was dealing with discrimination at this place. read more

I went there to meet friends and ordered a drink. Vodka and soda is an easy drink, however when this place has filthy lines throughout their system their soda tastes like vomit. I took a sip and informed the owner and he did nothing but emptied the drink in the sink and charged me full price. I paid and left but bottom line this place put a bad taste in my mouth (literally) and I didn't even get any food. read more

Food is great, but sometimes the bar service really sux, Ive waited 10 minutes for service because of all the chit chat and nonsense going on behind the bar. read more

Not impressed. Food was very salty. Glorified bar food. Service was amicable. Music from bar was loud and annoying. Better food at a diner.

Tues they have Prime Rib dinners. Happy hour is in dining room also. EVERYTHING was great! Finally a neighborhood pub in Port Jefferson Station that is reasonable, clean and friendly!! read more

Love this place!! Mary the bartender is awesome, so attentive to her customers. Food is amazing. Will be back :)

Benchwarmers is my favorite place to kick back and have a few beers or some food after work. The happy hour specials are great, the food is tasty, plenty of tvs with all the sports you could want. I usually kill a few hours here after work before I go home to my nagging wife. Highly recommended for anyone in the same situation. read more

Love this place. There are real good happy hour specials and the food is on point. I'm very satisfied with the service. A server named Colin took the time to talk sports with me and was very professional and friendly. I will definitely go back again. read more

excellent food and service. probably one of the best french dips I have had out in years. their cole slaw was awesome as well. (don't find many places around with a good slaw anymore) Atmosphere was great and the wait staff was a pleasure. I would def recommend checking this place out! read more

My husband and I live around the corner from benchwarmers and like the convenience of the location. We've brought our kids into the dining room and have also spent time at the bar for dinner and drinks. The pub quality food is decent and the menu and drink prices are slightly higher than nearby pubs but the establishment is very clean. The dining room decor is a little cheesey and doesn't really match the bar which has very nice stone and brick work and some nice sports memorabilia. My family has been going there for months but the couple who owns it are very standoffish and unfriendly. The last few visits we've made the wife of the owner has been drinking at the bar and on a couple of occasions we've heard her be unnecessarily nasty to patrons at her husbands establishment. We still enjoy going to benchwarmers on occasion as we find their staff to be very friendly and its close to home but we don't go nearly as often anymore. read more