Wife and I stopped by today after reading all the reviews. I had the banana split in a big waffle…read morecone. It had bananas and fresh juicy cherries in it. Wife had the Car 54 which was coffee ice cream with cut up chocolate donuts. Donuts and coffee, for the car 54 cop theme, get it? Very friendly employees and absolutely delicious ice cream. My wife can sometimes have stomach issues after ice cream but at this place she felt fine. Maybe it's better quality or something. Definitely worth a stop by if you are in the area like at lavender by the bay

Outstanding service, flavor selection, and delicious ice cream. I ordered the pistachio cherry and…read moredad got cherry vanilla.

Amazing ice cream and even better ice cream sandwiches. The owner Lisa was very helpful and…read morerespectful of my time and the people around. Outside reminds me of a nostalgic 2000s ice cream parkour. Would definitely come again.

OMG. The best ice cream on the North Fork. So much better than Magic Fountain which has an…read moreaftertaste on most of their flavors in my opinion.

This is an old school ice-cream-only place in Mattituck - out on the North Fork of eastern Long…read moreIsland. If you are in Riverhead or touring some of the vineyards on the North Fork, you should hit this place. We drove by on the way back from afternoon golf on a Friday. From the size of the crowd, I thought it was a Beatles Reunion Concert or something. The locals told us that it is REALLY GOOD, but evening waits can easily exceed an hour. Parking looked tough. We dropped by the next day around lunch time. No line, easy parking. The menu board has over 40 flavors, which include some intriguing ones such as honey cinnamon, honey lavender, blackberry ginger, avocado coconut. I did the cinnamon, the wife opted for the lavender. They were REALLY UNIQUE AND REALLY GOOD. My daughter has some food allergies, and we were impressed by the careful listing of potential allergens on the menu list. Next time I'm out on the east end of Long Island, I'll be going there again and getting some quarts to go. I just advise you to either go off-peak, or be prepared to hob-Nob with a lot of locals for a while in line.

By far the best ice cream on the North Fork. I'm still licking the butterfat from my lips.read more

A must do in Hampton Bays. Artisanal gelati, sorbetti and espresso. Highly recommend affogato to…read moresuit (can't go wrong with classic vanilla and espresso.) Gelato in cups is very cute, with small mini cone to adorn. Outside space is welcoming, with wide open grounds, tables, umbrellas and cornhole games. Service is friendly, and the owners tend to remember customers who come back (trust me, you will. I have been, for six years running.). Gemelli means twins in la lingua italiana. Beyond the twin brothers who run the place, the great service and superior product they dually purvey is the ultimate embodiment of a great paired package. Ca$h only. Enjoy!

My dad and I stopped by for a scoop and had a lovely experience. I misunderstood one of the topping…read moreoptions and the fantastic team at Gemelli were so accommodating in redoing my scoop. Great service and delicious gelato. The outside is so cute too, perfect for a relaxing summer night!!

OMG the peach and strawberry cream pies are incredible and completely worth the price! my family…read morewas so excited to enjoy them, I'm honestly not sure how they werent devoured in the car. staff was friendly and made recommendations - wish we lived closer to go back and get more pie!

Briermere has been one of my favorite pie spots for years, and I finally got to try the famous…read morePeach Cream Pie after always missing it. Wow...the hype is real! Now it's a tie between the Peach Cream and Raspberry Cream pies. (The peach is only available in the summer, so don't miss it.) The apple cider is still the best. If you haven't been here yet, what are you waiting for? A North Fork trip isn't complete without Briermere!

Came here for dinner and had a decent experience…read more We ordered a few appetizers (we wanted to try the pizza balls but they were out) and everything was good, especially the garlic Parmesan wings. We got the chili poutine which was more of a sauce with beans and the shrimp ceviche was very vinegary. Entrees are sizable and a lot can be prepared GF. The lasagna was decent and everything tasted good. The service was friendly all though it did take a hot minute to get our drinks despite the place having been empty. Prices are a little high but that's fine. The restaurant itself is quite nice and cozy.

Went at lunch on a Saturday and we asked to be seated outside. We chose the enclosed patio. We were…read moreseated upon arrival. Our waitress Sue was very attentive. Everything came out in a timely manner and was delicious. Burger was great, wings were crispy. We highly recommend the Banana Caramel Cheesecake.

This place is hidden on Main Street next to a little coffee shop. It seems to have all the little…read moretrendy snacks seen on social media. They have many things in the menu: ice cream, smoothies, crepes, and many other things. We chose the eloté con taki's. It was hot and fresh and everything you would expect it to be. They had Guatemala merch like bags and shirts and even some of the prepackaged snacks they offered were from Guatemala. If you're in the area and looking for a snack this place will have you taken care of. The family who operates it was very nice and friendly. They were quick and all of our order was correct. Tip: the temperature inside is warmer than most places in the area would typically be.

Fantastic ice cream with a large variety of flavors!…read more We stopped by Shock for dessert and absolutely did not regret our decision. They have sooo many different ice cream flavors that it's beyond difficult to choose! Luckily you can get more than one flavor even in their smallest size. I went with the Red Velvet Revival and S'more's. Both were perfectly sweet and creamy. I can't pick a favorite, so you're gonna have to try both!

Old school ice cream parlor. The proprietor was very friendly. My wife loved the tart Greek…read morefrozen yogurt. I had a very good banana cream pie sugar cone. Happy to support this local business.

I've been eating Carvel ice cream for over 60 years. The no frills shops take me back to getting…read moreice cream on summer evenings with my family, ice cream cakes at birthday parties and my wife's insatiable craving for flying saucers when she was pregnant. We lived near the original location in Hartsdale, NY for 25 years. It's an institution for New Yorkers. The soft serve tastes exactly the same. Carvel has been supplanted by bespoke, high end ice cream, but I still love it. It's part dessert and part time machine.

This is the 2nd time in TWO weeks I have the girl with the pink/red hair and I have to repeat…read moremyself TWICE because she can't hear me with Airpods in both ears. This is terribly rude. She is listening to music and I should have to say my order 3 times. Why is this allowed. I've been coming to Carvel for years and have never encountered this rude service. And a tip???? My tip is take the damn airpods out!!! Do better with the new hires Carvel