Stopped in for a quick slice, employees were nice and food was good! Definitely coming back to try…read morethe garlic knot sandwiches !!

Their pizza is super thin (and floppy, not crispy, though the crust is crispy). It's delicious. My…read moresister's grilled chicken wrap was fab. And they have excellent lunch and dinner specials. (Check the front board and their website!) The store is clean (albeit not fancy- it's a pizzeria after all), and it's a small business. What's not to like? I'm still not a fan of their wings and recommend pickup (over delivery), but they're a solid local choice. Next goal? Trying their viral garlic knot sandwich.

Always fresh, great crust, never greasy. Best pizza around and I'm so glad it's local.read more

Good Pizza, it will become a go too in the neighborhood , and they Deliver . I'll try other menu…read moreitems next time

I've witnessed the many different places that have occupied the space that is now My Bagel Cafe…read more So, I was leery to stop in the other morning for breakfast. However, I gave it a try and I'm so HAPPY I did. I can honestly say, MBC is a bright and warm place that served up some fantastic breakfast food. I opted for the country omelette that contained sausage, bacon, onion, peppers and cheese. It came with potatoes and a bagel (I chose an everything bagel). My order took maybe 10-12 mins. I was pleasantly surprised and even more shocked by the deliciousness of the breakfast overall. Thank you for a great breakfast option in Cinnaminson. Will I return, absolutely!!!

This spot was mostly intriguing based on convenience. There are quite a few bagel options in the…read morearea but none that compare to the infamous Hot Bagels chain down the shore #iykyk. This may be unpopular opinion (based on the current Yelp score), but this establishment is trying to do waaaayyyyyy too many things. You're called My Bagel Cafe, but you also do pizza.......and literally everything you could possibly imagine. First things first, not doing a pizza bagel is such a missed opportunity, but I digress. Let's talk bagels: I went with a bacon, egg, and cheese on a sesame bagel- one of my two go tos. I had this feeling that the cream cheese isn't homemade so I didn't want to completely ruin my first experience. The bagels themselves LOOK incredible. They look homemade, they're huge......until you bite into one and realize it's all a facade and literally just air. It wasn't the worst bagel I've ever had, but most definitely not the best in the area, IMO. While I feel that there is too much going on with all the available options, I would probably return and try some of the lunch/dinner options.

Best Sicilian pie! Crust is not soggy and just the right crispness. Excellent service alsoread more

Love this place!!!! The buffalo tails are the best I have ever had!!!! The counter girl is such a…read moresweetheart!!! Highly recommend!!!

I've only had pizza from here so I can only give reviews about that... My wife and I only got a…read moreslice each and both slices were delicious... She had a plain slice and I had a pepperoni slice... They also have single servings of condiments which have quite a variety of pizza seasonings... I will say that I was very impressed with the staff... They were very helpful, courteous friendly... The interior was very clean... I will come here again...

A hole in the wall with great pizza I'll definitely go back!…read moreTry it - you won't be sorry.

Pizza is consistently good. The chicken tenders and fries meal is large enough for two people. This…read moreis our go to place when we want something quick and delicious.

We love brothers pizza! The mama mia is outstanding and the family who own it is the best! The…read morecheese steaks are also very good and the Wednesday specials are the best in the area!

Ordered delivery and it didn't take too long…read more I never had a sandwich here so decided to try a pizza chicken cheesesteak with mushrooms. It's not on their menu but they'll do it. You can choose 8" or 12". I would have preferred more sauce but this was more chunky pieces of tomato. Not a thin sauce. I wanted more sauce for the flavor so will ask for some extra on the side of it next time. It was a little dry for a pizza steak!!! And a chicken steak is usually drier than beef anyway. I love a mushroom pizza steak and this is first one I've had where they chop the mushrooms with the meat and cheese. The sandwich was filled with meat. The roll was so soft and fresh. I also ordered the small tossed salad. Nice size. Got two meals out of it. Nice local place!!!!

After my last fiasco with a Ruth W.-recommended pizza establishment, I was wary to visit this…read moreplace. But, to my complete surprise, Ruth W. was valid on this one. This pizza place has very delicious slices, perfect French fries, and a homey environment. I would definitely come again! Sleep with one eye open Ruth W., I'm keeping score.

Delicious bakery also with homemade food. Friendly, helpful customer service. Hometown bakery.read more

Great local place for anything Italian!…read more They've been around for ages and every time we get takeout it's always top notch. Super friendly workers and the foods always on time! Have never had a problem and it's a great local hallmark in Cinnaminson!

We pass by here at least once a week and this is our first time trying it. When we went in we…read moredidn't know what we wanted and the lady waiting on us was very informative and gave us a menu. They had some slices out but we decided to order a large "the works" pizza. The pizza came it filled with toppings, I do wish it was cooked a little longer because it was a little floppy but overall the pizza was good. We also got a slice of pepperoni and some garlic knots for our son. The garlic knots were huge and he only managed to eat a half of slice and one garlic knot. I also overheard the lady mention they have like 3-4 homemade soups I definitely plan on going back to try that.

Two Fridays in a row I ordered boneless wings and they gave me boned wings. If you don't offer…read moreboneless wings you need but tell me as a customer so I can make an informed decision. The first time I chalked it up to people make mistakes the second time I chalk it up to we don't care about our customers With the steep competition of if I'm being Frank much better tasting food for the price in the area, I cannot in good conscience ever recommend this place not only did you give me the wrong food it didn't taste that good I see no reason to ever go back to this place ever again! The wings tasted like they were frozen not something I would actually expect from a pizzeria again just save your money and do even the smallest bit of research and within a 3 mile radius you'll find several places that are better in the Italian market!

Not at all like it use to be. Ordered chicken fingers with fries and fried eggplant. Fingers and…read morefries showed up soak and wet from the condensation in their plastic packaging. Totally inedible and awful. Fried eggplant was undercooked, tough and way to "bready". Its a shame - this place use to be really good.