We reserved our gut remodel for our master bathroom with Randy Marshalek in late October 2022. The October 22, 2022 work order noted that this was a "Rush Job - Heavy Mold." The contract we signed for financing on October 24, 2022 mentioned a "full bathroom gut, new shower, floors." The work order noted all of the fixtures in the bathroom would be replaced, all of which we would purchase separately except for the shower.
The work was scheduled to begin November 30 to December 1 and take 3 days. Until then, my family of 4 plus my two visiting parents had to share one bathroom while waiting to avoid adding more wetness to the master shower. Also, I have some serious health issues that were going to require me to use a separate bathroom so it was imperative that the remodel start and end on time.
I was very disappointed and disgusted when BathPlanet called the day of the install to say that BathPlanet did not have ANY of my bathroom fixtures for the shower so they had to postpone my gut remodel another 2 weeks. That was more time I had to keep my other bathroom fixtures in the downstairs foyer, and more time sharing the bathroom.
Once the shower pieces came in the work started. The guys who did the work were polite, but they definitely did NOT adhere to the "measure twice, cut once" adage of home improvement. However, we did encounter many issues during the installation, due to poor planning and a seat-of-the-pants, wing-it type of philosophy of installation. For example, the ceiling tray for the shower was not the right dimensions but that wasn't determined before a nice chunk of my ceiling drywall was cut out. Since the ceiling tray wouldn't work, I asked them to replace the drywall and they did, but the section doesn't match the rest of the ceiling. My ceiling is cream with a swirl pattern, and the missing/replaced chunk is white and smooth. That's more work for us.
I asked them to remove the existing medicine cabinet and fill the hole from it. They filled it with drywall but taped the perimeter, and you can still see the green backing to the drywall. The section of wall is not smooth and is unfinished which is more work I have to get corrected. It's a messy looking closure of the spot.
As for the two medicine cabinets for our double sink, there was definitely no prior planning before they took a saw to my wall. It's clear that they didn't use a pipe finder before cutting into the wall because they ran into a huge pipe behind the second medicine cabinet's hole. Oops! They said they could reroute the pipe, but I was losing confidence so I said no, just surface mount the medicine cabinets instead because they'd already attached the vanity to the wall and cut the pipe area. I didn't want new problems trying to get them to reposition the pipe, reposition the vanity, and move the medicine cabinets.
Later on, I asked Randy Marshalek, our salesman, how much it would cost for them to fix the sloppiness and paint. Even though we were already paying $32,000 for the remodel, he quoted us $1800 to fix the messes they made of the walls and paint. I was appalled and said we'd paint ourselves. I was so done with them, but we still needed to have the rest of the bathroom's larger fixtures completed. This was insulting and a further disappointment considering the price of the gut remodel.
The freestanding bathtub had a crack in it so I had to order a replacement. It was installed with an additional drain trap even though the tub came with a trap so I wasn't able to use it when I first tried because it wouldn't drain. Don't you think they should have tested the draining BEFORE saying it was fit to use? At any rate, the tub had to be uninstalled and reinstalled and we had to wait again for the adhesive to cure. That added to the time we couldn't bathe or shower in the bathroom.
I'm glad we elected to leave the shower bench out because they ordered the wrong one and we would have had to wait for it to come. The shower looked nice when installed and worked well when we finally could use it after the glass was installed January 19, 2023 and cured until January 20, 2023. The half wall they made is a light brown, a different color than the gray shower. So that's another issue that is unfixable. Also, the grout behind the sink in the double vanity is peeling ALREADY so that's yet another thing we have to get fixed.
All in all, this was an ordeal that took 3 months, between the initial wait time and the delays, NOT a three-day task. To be charged $32,000 plus I had to separately buy the vanity, lights, bathtub and toilet for this remodel at $3200 is disappointing and not a value-add to my home. A gut remodel means you replace everything and make it all nicer, better and more valuable. That doesn't mean you leave things like it was slap-dashed together and hastily done without an eye to the finishing and leaving it better than you found it. We paid for an increase in value, not for this! read more