So happy that Dover Dairy is open for the season! I opted for the classic Oreo Flurry while hubby…read moregot his traditional cookie dough flurry. What I love about their flurries, (besides the best soft serve vanilla anywhere) is that they blend your flavor choices very well so there's toppings all throughout, then top it off with ice cream and more toppings. Of course they have awesome homemade hard ice cream flavors, cakes, slushies, novelties and more. Be aware that they are a cash only establishment, so grab $$ before you head over. There is plenty of parking behind the store. In case you are hungry, the Dover Grill next door is also open. They have awesome burgers, fries and amazing comfort food. The owners have been there forever and their ice cream is the best in Morris County. They train the most professional servers who scoop with a smile. The lines may get long at times, but people are super patient because the reward is worth it. Stop in for a bit of joy, you deserve it!

Cash only establishment with no indoor seating but a few benches outside. Plenty of ice cream…read moreflavors to choose from, including soft serve flavors (so used to only chocolate or vanilla) and they're all delicious!

Another great ice cream place to add to the list! The variety of flavors and new flavors I haven't…read moreseen was really great to see. The s'mores ice cream was divine. I love how they were able to get that graham cracker taste and it not be over powered by the other notes. Service was great, the ladies were so nice and gave us great recommendations.

I've always loved Jefferson Dairy. We were headed to mini golf and stopped in before to get our…read morefavorites. I love Elephants Never Forget and it never disappoints. Hubby went for the supersized "The Jeffrey" which included Dirty Diaper (my other favorite), Elephants never forget, Lake Hopatcong Mud. It was topped off w/ chocolate cream cookies, whipped cream and of course a cherry on top. They are always super nice and let you sample any flavors you wish. When it's nice out, they have chairs and picnic tables for you to sit, relax and enjoy!

I ordered a salted caramel on a cone and really enjoyed my experience. The shop itself is average…read more There is no indoor space, and you order outside via a service window. The seating outside the shop leaves a bit to be desired, there are just a bunch of benches on the pavement and cars speed by. We actually almost got hit by one that accidentally drove through the seating area. My cone itself was good but nothing super special. They have a great range of flavors, including some soft serve, too. I am only giving this four stars, as opposed to a more average rating, because the location on the lake is unbeatable. On a nice summer day I would highly recommend grabbing a scoop and heading down to Lake Mohawk Boardwalk for a walk. It's one of the only ice cream places around and makes for a perfect end of the day treat.

Had a vanilla caramel small cone and a pumpkin small cup. We both loved the flavors…read more $6 each but we were given a decent amount of ice cream. Cash only.

A great family business that supports our kids with all sports. Their ice cream and cakes are…read moredelicious.

This is the best ice cream I've had in my entire life and will be gladly driving an hour for it!read more

What a great little "self-serve" ice cream stand in Newton (closer to Stillwater). Cash only, pay…read moreand fill your own cup or cone. Today's special flavors were "maple creme" and "honey". Or you could select vanilla, chocolate or strawberry. Nice clean well kept area with picnic benches to sit and relax. What a treat.

The sugar shack is an awesome little self serve ice cream trailer located in a scenic country…read moresetting. You can choose between a cone or a cup and they always have chocolate, vanilla, chocolate/vanilla twist and usually two seasonal flavors to offer. Sometimes it's maple creame, strawberry, pumpkin, mint or even sweet corn. Their ice cream is amazing and the concept of being a self service ice cream trailer is so cool! The people that own it are super nice and it's the perfect treat after a long hike or a hot day doing chores around the farm!

Delish! Great choice in flavors & the ice cream is so good! I loved the pistachio! The area…read moreoutside has some benches for you to sit on but other than that that, there is no place to really enjoy it.

It's close to my house and the prices are cheaper than a similar place down the road. However, the…read moreice cream just doesn't taste that good. Last time I went they had coffee sugar free ice cream, but not regular coffee. My father in law got a pineapple sundae and said there was only a few pieces of pineapple. Their ice cream cakes though are amazing.

best ice cream place in the area. i live in mount bethel and have tried places in bangor, nj, and…read moreanywhere near and this beats all of them. me and my boyfriend always go here and love it. (and he's picky). the service is amazing, they get your ice cream out in no longer than a minute always, it's cheap, and there's a lot of variety. the ice cream is also very very good. love this place i could not think of any cons!

I cannot lie, we only been in Blairstown since the first of July. We been going to this place…read morealmost everyday. The customer service is great. Liam is great he gets to know the customers and makes the ice cream just as you like it. The ice cream is amazing, well it's ice cream and ice cream is always great. You can go inside to order and sit outside with your tasty treat, or roll through the drive through and get it to go. Blairstown Dairy is in a great location and the setup is perfect. You will not go wrong with stopping in and grabbing some ice cream. I prefer the blenders and my wife loves the chocolate peanut butter. He occasionally has specialties like his campfire which was great as well. You need to just check it out.

There's nothing like a small vanilla cone to make it feel like summer! I got mine with a new peanut…read morecrunch topping and hubby got the chocolate dip. We were driving by and couldn't resist since the lines weren't long and it was just the vibe. Plenty of parking and places to sit and enjoy your sweet, delicious cones, blizzards or whatever makes you smile. I always love their ice cream cakes because they let you pick other flavors besides chocolate or vanilla. Friendly service with a smile. Stop in and treat yourself.

It is Always delicious ice cream whenever we come. Drive-thru or a pick-up window and plenty of…read moreseating. Always fits our group to sit together. Always plentiful in the cup and always a treat. ( fun lightening inside- and some couldn't wait for a pic )