I was blown away by the quality here. Despite keeping at least 30 flavors available, there were no…read moreice crystals interrupting the cream-forward spoonfuls of peanut butter Oreo that I went with. And wow, what a combination - the smooth peanut butter brought almost caramel overtones to the vanilla, while the Oreo cookies gave a softened crunch. They do offer samples, which is great since there are plenty of house flavors to choose from. Vibes-wise I definitely got that The Dairy is a family-run business. On an only mildly warm late spring day in April, there was still a steady trickle of to-go and dine-in customers. The Dairy feels like Americana.

They have the best soft serve ice cream in town! It's homemade and they even use their soft serve…read moreice cream to make their ice cream cakes, ice cream sandwiches, as well as ice cream cones you buy to take home

My family and I were in the area and were craving some cold ice cream on a warm summer night. We…read moresaw that Cliff's wasn't far from where we were having dinner so we decided to check it out. When we arrived, the line was out to the highway. The long line bought me some time to decide which flavor to select out of the 60+ different options. I decided to go with the Graham Central Station after reading some other Yelp reviews and articles about their most popular flavors. It was an excellent choice. The texture was amazing and the cinnamon flavor was so delicious. For a "small" cup, the portion was huge. There's a few picnic benches behind the storefront to sit and eat your ice cream. Parking looks like it can be tough on busier nights. I wish it was closer to home but I'm sure I will be back if I am in the area again. Graham Central Station: 5/5

Sure the Indigenous peoples of Ledgewood didn't really have an ice cream totem pole but the current…read moreinhabitants sure do! Quick service and an ever expanding flavor menu... you'll need the check that board every trip. Now I broke protocol and opted for a soft serve vanilla and it did not disappoint! Creamy & smooth, that cone really hit the spot! And oh yeah, the expansive grounds and crowds are perfect for people watching...and there are some real characters here!

Located right next to Hapgoods, Corner Creamery serves around 22 ice cream flavors. The proprietors…read moretold me they're all made in-house, but for the dairy- and sugar-free flavors, which they're still perfecting. When I stumbled in on a lazy Wednesday, I found them in the middle of making homemade sugar cones dipped in chocolate and coated with sprinkles. Awesome. After sampling, I went with a mint chip milkshake. The ice cream is definitely sweet forward, rather than cream forward. I'm glad to have more options in the area.

A cute ice cream place located in Mountain Lakes. Reserved parking for customers in front plus…read moreplenty of other parking. The staff was very Nice and they have Homemade flavors that change every week. Enjoy

Delicious! I'm not usually a gelato guy but this place is great!…read more I tried the chocolate hazelnut and the salted caramel and both were excellent. The flavor is so well blended into the gelato and the creamy, air free texture make it a great dessert experience. Looking forward to trying some of their other flavors.

Still serving housemade original flavors from outstanding ingredients, year round. The owner's…read moreInsta game is excellent and a great way to learn what flavors are available that day and when they'll be open. Don't forget to grab a punch card, which is good for a free cup or cone on every seventh visit. I love to stop here as a quick detour off of 46, and I'm proud to have something this excellent near my house. Even the mini can have two flavors, which is super generous. And they really pack the cup!

They make the best cappuccino- with or without flavors. I like mine with cinnamon. The staff is so…read morefriendly and helpful. You can sit and relax while enjoying seasonal decorations. They make cakes and have a huge assortment of ice creams.

Cute little ice cream shop that I wanted to give a try. The parking lot is small, enough to fit…read moremaybe 3 cars but there is street parking. When we walked in, there was a man there with his daughter, who was deciding on which flavor she wanted. He was kind enough to let us go in front of him while his daughter debated. There were very unique flavors, like guava, sweet corn & soursop to name a few, so we wanted to sample some before fulling committing. I asked the woman behind the counter if they allowed tasting and she said no. Since a couple of people in my party already knew what they wanted, they went ahead and ordered while the rest of us continued looking over the flavors. As I looked around the shop, I noticed the man and his daughter each had several sample spoons in their hands. To make sure I wasn't mistaken, I asked him if the employee had given them samples, and he confirmed that she had. The man appeared to be of Latin descent, as was the employee. My party was not. While I can't say for sure why we were treated differently, I was disappointed that we were told samples weren't available when another customer had clearly been allowed to try several flavors. Rather than confront the employee, I paid for the two orders that had already been placed and we left. Had I realized beforehand that samples were being offered to other customers and not us, I would not have placed an order at all. One person in my party ordered one scoop each of passionfruit, black cherry, and mango. After they started eating, they realized the mango scoop was missing from the cup. They did enjoy the passionfruit and black cherry flavors though. The person ordered the cappuccino flavor but did not enjoy it at all. Overall, my experience left me feeling unwelcome and disappointed. The inconsistent treatment between customers, combined with the incorrect order, means I won't be returning. I hope this was simply a misunderstanding, but based on my experience, I cannot recommend this shop.

Summertime Must! At least one trip to Curly's, if not 5. My favorite stop for ice cream for any…read moreseason.

I am honestly the kind of person who is nothing but polite and I literally never leave bad reviews,…read morebut the customer service here tonight was so unbelievably poor that I felt I had to say something. For context, I'm only in my 30s--not old by any stretch--so it's wild to be treated like an inconvenience. ​I already knew exactly what I wanted and asked if they had peanut butter. The male employee completely brushed me off, curtly telling me "we have nut flavors over there," totally ignoring the fact that I had asked for a specific flavor. ​It didn't get any better from there. The employee who scooped my ice cream stood there holding it right in her hands, laughing and chatting with her coworkers while completely ignoring me and letting it melt. Just a group of young, completely unprofessional Gen Z workers who clearly don't care about their customers. Completely dismissive and a total waste of time and money. I won't be coming back.

I've always loved Jefferson Dairy. We were headed to mini golf and stopped in before to get our…read morefavorites. I love Elephants Never Forget and it never disappoints. Hubby went for the supersized "The Jeffrey" which included Dirty Diaper (my other favorite), Elephants never forget, Lake Hopatcong Mud. It was topped off w/ chocolate cream cookies, whipped cream and of course a cherry on top. They are always super nice and let you sample any flavors you wish. When it's nice out, they have chairs and picnic tables for you to sit, relax and enjoy!

Was not a fan. Friends and I went there had milkshakes and they tasted like milk! No flavor at…read moreall-so very disappointed

Scoop Theory in Livingston is awesome. Friendly service in a pleasant setting. Really interesting…read moreflavors and options to add to your ice cream. They also have pints to go. I tried the Tuscan Fig in a waffle cone. Fantastic and I wish it was a regular flavor on their menu. My Wife had a cup of Tiramisu with rainbow sprinkles which she enjoyed. We got a pint of strawberry lychee. I liked it but felt it needed more lychee. Definitely check this place out as the quality of the ice cream is top notch.

Amazing, amazing spot. No boring ice cream flavors. They're all interesting and different. Very…read morefriendly service, fresh ice cream, insane bubble cones, and great drinks. Love the place