I contacted Kaitlin at the last minute and she was able to make it happen without missing a beat. I simply gave her our school's logo, and she turned it into the most beautiful custom cookies. Not only were they stunning, but they were absolutely delicious too. Our guests couldn't stop talking about them, and I loved having something so special to give as a parting gift. I even shared some with friends and family who weren't able to attend the party, and they absolutely loved them as well! Kaitlin is incredibly talented, creative, and easy to work with. If you're looking for custom cookies that are both gorgeous and delicious, I can't recommend Bakin Me Crazy Cookies enough! read more

This was my first time ordering a cake from Katelyn and she was fantastic! Accommodating, easy to communicate with, and worked with me to bring my vision to life on very short notice. Most importantly, the cake was delicious and looked amazing! Highly recommend her! read more

I cannot say enough good things about Katelyn! I've ordered from her multiple times, and every single experience has been amazing. She's made beautifully detailed themed royal icing cookies for me on several occasions, and they always come out absolutely perfect -- not just visually, but they taste great too. She's also made cupcakes for me, including more unique and different flavor combinations, and they were delicious. On top of that, she created a custom birthday cake for me based on inspiration photos I sent, and once again, she nailed it. Everything I've ever ordered has turned out exactly as I envisioned (if not better). Katelyn is incredibly friendly, professional, and easy to work with. She's gone above and beyond to accommodate requests, including helping me out with last-minute orders, and she's even delivered to me, which I truly appreciate. You can tell she genuinely cares about her work and her clients. If you're looking for someone who is talented, reliable, creative, and a joy to work with, I highly recommend Katelyn. She's amazing, and I will absolutely continue ordering from her in the future. read more

Bakin Me Crazy Creations - Gorgeous cake she made me for my birthday! - Desserts Near Me

Absolutely recommend!! I stumbled upon on instagram and she is AMAZING to work with. Extremely responsive and the cakes/cookies quality is fantastic. I reached out last minute on my first order and she was able to get it done and ready in time for the Bridal shower. I reached out again for another party and she was there!! Great customer service and delicious dessert. Highly recommend! read more

See all

I contacted Katelyn VERY last minute to make cookies for my husband's promotion. She graciously agreed to take my order and I could not be happier! It was very easy to communicate with her and the cookies came out better than the inspiration photos I sent to her!! So thankful that she agreed to do this for us. I would highly recommend her and will order from her again if we need custom cookies. I believe she does cupcakes and cakes too so will keep her in mind for future orders. read more

Bakin Me Crazy Creations - Coast Guard Cookies - Desserts Near Me

Not only were the cookies delicious, Katelyn was so quick to respond and was easy to talk through with what I wanted. Pick up was easy and her turn around time is so quick. Definitely going to order again read more

Bakin Me Crazy Creations - Desserts Near Me

Katelyn is so creative! She made cookies for a bridal shower that were adorable and tasted great! And I loved her so much, we had her do our wedding cake! Which was delicious!!! She is the best, I will use her for all our party needs!! read more

Bakin Me Crazy Creations - Cookies - Desserts Near Me

See all

I wanted to share my wonderful experience with Bakin Me Crazy. They made cookies for my daughter's bridal shower, and the results were even better than the inspiration pictures we provided. Katelyn is a truly talented and gifted baker. If you have any special occasions coming up or are just looking for an amazing sweet treat, I highly recommend contacting Bakin Me Crazy. We now go to her for all our baking needs. read more

Bakin Me Crazy Creations - Custom Cookies - Desserts Near Me

See all

The cake was the best cake I've ever had custom made. The frosting was not too sweet, the cake was the perfect texture, and Katelyn made the cake look so perfect! I sent her an inspiration picture and explained it was for my 30th birthday with the theme of "tying up my 20s" and she made exactly what I wanted. She is also reasonably priced and very good on communication. All my friends kept asking where the cake was from because it was so good! I definitely recommend her! read more

Bakin Me Crazy Creations - Desserts Near Me

I love this small business and their creativity! It's so great to have a place like this in the community that can customize cookies to exactly what I need for my events. You can tell that there is a lot of time taken with each delicacy and they are definitely made with love. Keep up the good work and many blessings to your business! read more

I have ordered from Katelyn several times. Cookies and various desserts for a couple of orders and we also used her for my nieces's baby shower. All of her baked goods turned out beautifully and tasted amazing. She did such a great job at capturing the theme for the baby shower. I don't have pictures but the cakes and cupcakes were so cute! I ordered seasonal orders from Katelyn several times and they were so good, especially the apple pie cookies! They were a big hit. Ordering and picking up were easy to manage. I highly recommend Katelyn and Bakin Me Crazy Creations. Check her out on Tik Tok and Instagram to see the photos of her work! read more

We love all the goodies that Bakin Me Crazy Creations has made for us! The cookies are delicious my husband absolutely devours them! The cupcakes and cakes are delicious my fav is def Red velvet. Katelyn is attentive to details and has come through for me on all my last minute requests. You can't go wrong with this friendly and responsive small business owner! read more

Cookies were beautiful. Taste was okay. Customer service could have been improved. When I placed my order, I shared that I was on a tight budget and asked if any discounts were available. I was told there were none, so I proceeded with my purchase. Exactly one week later, a 10% discount was posted on Instagram. I reached out to ask if the promotion could be applied to my order, but was informed it only applied to orders placed after the post. Suggestion for improvement: If a promotion is planned soon, it may be helpful to let customers know so they can choose to place their order during the discount period. read more

I have been ordering here since they opened ! Why have I taken so long to write a review? I started ordering cookies just for the house. They were delish. Then as my younger kids birthday parties came around I ordered for those events. I even ordered some AMAZING cupcakes for a huge family reunion and they were the talk of the party. I LOVED those! I have sent orders to my clients as thank you gifts over the years as well. Customer service is always amazing, fast, professional, and thorough. Highly recommend! read more

Katelyn makes the best cookies! Her sugar cookies are the perfect balance of flavor and she is my go to for when I need decorated cookies for events such as bridal showers or birthday parties. Her speciality cookies are also amazing. She knows how to make a delicious cookie that isn't too sweet. She's creative with her flavors and will try new and exciting things! She offers different flavors throughout the year which keeps things interesting :) Aside from her amazing cookies, she is an overall very talented baker who also makes cupcakes, cinnamon roles, regular cakes, and more. Highly recommend Katelyn! read more

See all

Katelyn is amazing! She answered my call and was able to fulfill my request with a short turn around time. The custom cookies with my corporate logo were amazing and she was incredible to work with! Would highly recommend to anyone! read more

This review is long over due! She was recommended by a friend and I'm glad I went with her! I got a cake for my bridal shower and engagement party and both were super delicious and beautiful! I showed her some inspo pics and she delivered! Super happy with everything. When I need another cake (which will be soon) I will only order from her! Ordering is very easy too. She replies right away. If you need a cute tasty cake, she's the one. read more

See all

Delicious and beautiful cakes and cupcakes. I have ordered from her multiple of times and will continue for all my special occasions.

The cookies were beautifully decorated and delicious! The owner was easy to work with and did an excellent job. I will definitely be using this company again and recommended her to everyone at my party! Thank you so much!! read more

Bakin Me Crazy Creations - Cookies for my husbands retirement party!! - Desserts Near Me

Had a great experience with the small business. I ordered SF Giants logo cookies for my FIL's Celebration of Life event. Ordering the cookies was very easy. My ordered was confirmed. My order was ready as promise. The cookies were beautiful. The cookie was a basic sugar cookies. The best thing was that the cookies were not overly sweet. Communication between Katelyn and me was very smooth. I would highly recommend this cookie business if you need custom cookies. Sorry. I don't have pictures because they were eaten. read more

Cookies made by Katelyn! I have had Katelyn make cookies for a few different events & they have been amazing every time, both in flavor and decoration! Highly recommend using her for your next event :) read more

Bakin Me Crazy Creations - Desserts Near Me

Katelyn created beautiful and delicious cookies for my husband's 50th birthday! They matched the theme perfectly and everyone loved them. She's a true artist and the order and pick up was a breeze. I will definitely order from Bakin Me Crazy Creations again! read more

Bakin Me Crazy Creations - Desserts Near Me

Katelyn made beautiful and delicious cookies! Thanks so much for the cookies and definitely recommend reaching out to her for your next occasion. Thanks again 5 stars and amazing customer service!!! read more

Bakin Me Crazy Creations - a box of decorated cookies - Desserts Near Me

Katelyn does amazing work! Her baked goods are as delicious as they are beautiful! From Brown Butter Chocolate Chip cookies, vanilla scones, cupcakes in many flavors, red velvet cake, and her amazing sugar cookies to the lemon gooey butter cake her creations are Devine! read more

Bakin Me Crazy Creations - Custom ballet cookies for my nieces recital - Desserts Near Me

See all