Great food people are very friendly. The new ownership is very very good and they take care of you. Any ownership actually will sit there and talk to you like a human being. It is a very nice place to go and sit and relax. Have your breakfast. read more

Lackluster bagels and $7.50 egg sandwiches. There's better places nearby for cheaper.

Our go to- the best bagels- not huge- always tasty and quickly prepared. Been going here for decades and have tried other places- always come back to this one! read more

Would never come back again. Place is old and the manager has an awful attitude. Not worth the crappy bagels they serve here. Ladies at the front counter are nice though. read more

The food is good, but the senior employees are terribly rude and do not know how to talk to people. They seem to be easily frustrated when they are busy. read more

Our favorite bagel place. Bagels always done perfectly. Very tasty. Quickly made. Have been going here for years and will do for years to come. read more

Fresh bagels and good egg sandwiches. Quick and pleasant service also. Would recommend.

I dont want to sit here and say the deli is terrible as a whole because 7/10 times i go it's delicious but on the other hand theres a young girl with glasses and bangs that consistently messes my orders up. Just this morning my sandwich was messed up 3 times and after the 3rd time i was expected to pay, this time was the cherry on top there has been multiple other instances (me and my workers take lunch here 3x a week) when the girl messed it up because i guess she dosnt know what shes doing. I payed with no issue but i cann promise to god theyll never get my business again that girl alone will run that business into the ground. If you go there to eat request someone else to take ur order/cook ur food read more

Great bagels, my favorite bagel shop! All the employees are friendly!

New owner very unfriendly never says hello or acknowledges customers. Today I asked for turkey bacon got regular turkey asked for egg whites well done came runny asked for small coffee got large terrible read more

Horrible service....didn't get my order right....the one in medford blows this one away...I wouldn't go to this place if I was starving n they offered me a free meal....im not one to write reviews because I know people make mistakes....the man Brian on the phone was so rude...im literally shaking... read more

Awful. First of all, our food was cold by the time we got it. I told them I was placing a delivery with door dash, they told me over the phone that coffee comes with an egg sandwich but when I got my delivery both our coffees were not in there and when we called back they said oh if you don't come down in person, it doesn't come with a coffee. What is the difference I'm still placing the same order whether I'm in person or through an app. The owner BRIAN was an absolute dick. So rude and unprofessional. I would never go back there and recommend it. Sad because the one in Medford is great. He hung up on us as well. read more

I've had multiple bad experiences here from the teenager workers. Uncooked bacon and home fries, bad service, idiotic statements such as "Do you need a plate?" even though I've already told them I was dining in. As if I'm going to eat my bagel on the table. The only reason I still come here is because one of the guys who work here, Mike. He's only there in the morning though. If there's any other person there, I plan on leaving now. read more

EXCEPTIONAL SERVICE!!! New to the area and I'm very HAPPY I can get GREAT SERVICE! Most importantly they have FRENCH vanilla creamer and make a PHENOMENAL bacon egg and cheese. read more

Bagels Your Way Cafe - Amazing service once again!!! - Bagels Near Me - Mount Sinai, New York

What do you say about a bagel place? They make great bagels. I really enjoy their egg everything bagel with vegetable cream cheese. It hits the spot. If you are having company, they have a great deal. For about $20 you get a dozen bagels, cream cheese, and OJ. They also feature a "Bagel of the Month." This month its pumpernickel raisin. Sounds good! The place is clean, the bagels are fresh, the staff is friendly, and most of the time you can get in and out real quick. read more

Bagels Your Way Cafe - Egg Everything Bagel with Vegetable Cream Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Mount Sinai, New York

Love this place!!! Best bagels, super clean, quick service. Love the staff and the owners are friendly.

Never Again! I went in for a couple of bagels and a cup of coffee yesterday morning. The person who took my order behind the counter opted to wear her face mask as chin guard, a young man working behind the counter didn't have one at all. Then an arrogant mask-less young man came in, ordered, sat down, drank a red bull and no one said a word. No mask? No service? Wrong. They took his order. As I waited, for far too long, as every man in the bagel store was attended to, and they made me wait, I couldn't take it anymore. I asked why they were working behind the counter without masks and serving customers without masks. The customer said, "I don't have one", not that I asked. I should have walked out, but my order was now ready and I had already paid. Insult to injury... I asked for a LIGHTLY buttered bagel... they put it on about a half inch thick. I'll be contacting the DOH, and again, I will never waste another nickel in this please! There are too many options... please enjoy your bagels elsewhere!!! read more

Bagels Your Way Cafe - Store front - Bagels Near Me - Mount Sinai, New York

See all

I have been going here for at least ten maybe fifteen years, but in the last few months (year?) the service has gone down hill incredibly. Screwed up my WRITTEN order, slow, ran out of sesame and poppy bagels on a Sunday morning. How is that possible? The quality is not as good either. They said they have new baker, well, I will be looking for a new bagel store in the area! read more

I called 4 other places as a senior looking for a delivery and received excuse after excuse. Well I called here and was greeted friendly and they delivered within the hour, just saying..... my go to now! read more

Average food bagels tasted a bit stale. Customer service was okay. Liked the selection of desserts.

This is a decent local (Brookhaven, Mt sinai) bagel shop and sligthly better than nearby Strathmore B imho. My everything bagel was hot, fresh, and tasted very good. The cream cheese was good. I thought the service could be a bit more attentive as one of the counter girls was bs ing with a customer as I stood behind ignored to get another sliced bagel. Other reviewers have also had issues here and there with the counter service. But the place makes up for it with a good local bagel. I shall return due to location and quality. read more

I'm sad to see Bagels Your Way has so little stars on Yelp. They are the nicest people, have great bagels and always give you a solid egg sandwich. I'm a frequent customer and time after time they prove to be consistent, fresh, fast and friendly. The store is always clean, there's a place to sit if you want to eat In and there's a spotless restroom. read more

Waited 20 minutes for two bagels because the girl helping us was talking on the phone and eating. The store wasn't busy. Then told us that the reason we had to wait was because the toaster was slow but we could see that it wasn't the toaster. Very poor customer service. Bagel itself was fair nothing special. read more

The food was fine, but they have prices listed that they do not honor. I was charged $5.25 for a grilled cheese despite the large sign saying it cost $4.50. Bad business. read more

I've come here many times , and at this point, I give up. Every time I walk in I pray that the person in front of me doesn't order an egg sandwich, because I'll be waiting ten minutes to get a bagel. The bagels are fine quality wise. The service is horrible. Very slow. My last check-in was the final straw. I looked in the window and saw one customer at the counter, so I figured it was safe to buy a few bagels for my family. Wrong. I actually had to ask an employee after probably close to ten minutes if I could just buy a few bagels. I'll credit the owner who must've overheard me, apologized for the wait, and helped me. I will now drive a mile down the road to another bagel store even though I can walk to this one. The horrible service overrules the convenience factor. read more

My first time there. My bagel was ok. The coffee was burnt. A note to the owner don't have your employee start moping the floor while people are still eating. The smell was so strong! We had to leave! read more

Probably the worst bagel spot ive been to on the island. 2 people on line and took over 15min to get a bagel. Then when i was rung up i was over charged for a already over priced bagel. Save your time and drive down the block. Terrible and rude service read more

Best Bagel-Deli Caterer around! Order the Party Bagel and you'll understand why 5 stars! I use Bagels Your Way for all my Corporate Luncheons and they always WOW the crowd and make me look great!!!! read more

My favorite bagel place on Long Island. I say stick it to all those bagel lovers who want size. All you get with most bagel places with larger than life bagels is a hollow inside. Nothing like a small bagel that packs taste and just enough for your CC or butter. Thats what you get at Bagels Your Way in Mount Sinai. There bagels are always fresh. They claim that they make the bagels, but i have my doubts. You really can't see where there would be ovens as it all hidden. But whatever..Every morning when i go there I get a great smile from the young and and older ladies who work there. They are always nice and love to talk. Great sitting area to eat in. There cream cheese is perfect. And they are the only bagel place that i've been to that serves cold butter with my bagel. I totally love this place. Oh you can't go wrong with a bagel that costs less than $1.75 with CC. read more

I stopped eating at bagel shops after visiting here. I ordered a bagel with cream cheese and paid for it. The woman took my cash and proceeded to make my bagel with the same gloves on. To top it off I saw her tuck her hair behing her ear and rub the area under her nose, with that same gloved hand. She continued making my bagel with that glove on. She put it in a bag and handed it too me, I had already paid. I said keep it and bounced it down on the counter. Yes, I was mad. I said something about how the gloves aren't there to protect you and what she did was disgusting. She then ran her fingers through her hair and made a sarcastic remark. I turned to walk out and she hit me with the bagel, really hard on my shoulder. I should have called the board of health or someone on her but I didn't. Its been a few years now, still can't go to bagel shops they all seem to take your money and make your bagel with the same gloved hand. read more

The ladies who work behind the counter are actually fairly nice people however they move slower then a snail. God forbid you order an egg sandwich let alone try and even get your bagel toasted. Don't even try and go on the weekend you will wait an hour no matter what for a sub par bagel. I recommend anywhere but there. read more

Nice ladies working the counter, but they move very slowly ... If u are trying to get in and out in 10 minutes in the A.M., try somewere else. read more

I agree they move slow but I call ahead for omlets and I think they make the best one around. Free bagel with omlet and free juice and coffee. read more

This bagel shop will be forever in my mind. I was born in Long Island but my family moved to Pennsylvania in 1989 when I was 7. Bagels your way was a must whenever we returned to visit family. Where I live the only bagel shop is the local Dunkin Donuts and don't get me wrong they make a good bagel but nothing like bagels your way. What I wouldn't do for a salt bagel... they don't even make them here. When I took my husband to Long Island for the first time I warned him that if he ate a bagel from there he would never be satisfied with one from anywhere else ever again. Well he and I where just saying about maybe taking a five hour bagel run. Not sure if we'll make this year but until we do my craving will remain. Thank you Bagels Your Way. read more