They make decent breakfast sandwiches, and I do like that they use two eggs on their bagel sandwiches instead of skimping out with one. That alone makes the sandwiches more filling than a lot of other bagel spots around. My biggest issue is the everything bagel as it's a little too salty for me and on the thicker, denser side. I personally prefer a bagel that's a bit lighter and less heavy. They also offer flat bagels, which I didn't get to try, but I think I probably would've liked those better assuming they're not as salty. Overall still a solid local breakfast option. read more

Nice Freestanding Deli with quick and attentive service. Welcoming staff that take care of their customers. Smaller shop with some seating. Known for the hand rolled Bagels which are of nice size and plentiful variety; this is more than a Bagel shop. Quality wraps and sandwhiches for many tastes. The underrated Paninis are well worth it. Definitely one of the better places around. Never had a bad Bagel here. read more

I saw all of the reviews about them being rude to women so I had to see this activity for myself. My wife went to order 12 bagels and three breakfast sandwiches while I waited in the car due to limited parking. They couldn't have been more kind to my wife and we had everything in under ten minutes so I do not know what to believe about those other reviews. I have also been going here for a long time even with previous owner and I have never had an issue with this business they have fair prices prompt service and good quality food! read more

Here is the final version with your correction: Ordered a bacon and egg sandwich with no cheese. I repeated no cheese three times. Once when I placed the order, once when they read it back, and again just to be sure. I pay, leave, open the sandwich, and of course there is cheese on it. I go back, hand them the sandwich, and say I want a refund, not a remake. They say it will only take a couple of minutes. I tell them I am not letting them waste any more of my time. This happens every time. I specifically said no cheese multiple times and I want a refund. The girl behind the counter suddenly acts confused and says I paid with a card and the manager isn't there so I can't get a refund. I say I'll take cash. She gives me cash but it is short. I do not realize until I get back to the car. I walk back in and tell them they shorted me. They try to argue with me until I literally count out the change in front of them. She reluctantly hands over the rest or so I thought. She shorted me again. At that point I cut my losses and walked out. Go to Bagel Factory in Matawan instead. They are cheaper, they do not mess up your order, and they will not steal from you. Their bagels are better too. read more

Best bagels in New Jersey. They are big and taste amazing. This place is a classic bagel deli style with really good sandwiches and more. Every time I come see mom I have to stop here. read more

Deliciously fluffy bagels, nice customer service, and easy to get too right off of NJ Route 79. The bagel selection is plentiful and they all have that lovely 7 am taste to them (bagels are after all a morning food). Their sandwiches are pretty big and tasty as well. Get to it and get a good breakfast here. Sorry if this review is too short for you.... Deal with it. read more

See all

Stopped here earlier today and we got 2 bacon egg and cheese on roll sandwiches. They were average to good. Service was fine, it was busy but there was plenty of pleasant staff to take the order and prepare. I did find the interior to be adorable for a bagel store / deli. The little tables and stools are so cute. The only downside I found to our visit today was the cost. Two breakfast sandwiches and a small coffee came to $15.00 +. Not so sure they were that amazing but we will definitely return to try their bagels. I'm sure prices are in the rise all over but I did find this bill a bit much. read more

Also, all of their pricing is blocked on the boards, so you can't easily see the cost of anything. I found this strange!!!

Ordered a plain with cream cheese and came to $3.75 which seemed a little excessive for a bagel. Bagel reminded me of a day old roll more so than a bagel. Big lump of hard bread, not the fluffy dough you'd expect. Won't return. read more

Great NJ bagels, great service, lovely outdoor seating and seating inside. Don't pass it without stopping!

$11 for a Pork Roll, Bacon, Egg and Cheese. ELEVEN DOLLARS Also it was mad slimy, not greasy, slimy, and fell/slid apart immediately. read more

Prices are blocked! $26.84 for half a ham sandwich, and a breakfast sandwich. Pure robbery. Used to come here all of the time, sandwiches are great but the pricing is crazy! They are also selling expired sodas. read more

Horrible customer service & food has suffered in past few years since sold to new owners.

Wednesday morning I had a hankering for a bagel it's been a while. This place was pretty good before new owners took over. My wife had a toasted everything bagel with cream cheese and she said it was meh. I had a sesame bagel with cream cheese. My bagel was semi stale! Very disappointed. I don't like crunchy bagels. A bagel should be firm but not crunchy. There's 2 other bagel shops close by that we will try instead next time. read more

Went to buy a sub Was the only person in there. Just as The clerk was making my sub Then somebody came out with a broom and had to sweep stirring up all dust the girl had to stop making my sub until she finished sweeping the floor If I didn't pay a head of time I would have walked out who wants all that dirt and disgusting dust in your sub sandwich that costs 15 bucks that I didn't even eat. read more

I had high hopes for this place I been passing it for the last couple weeks back from my sons soccer practice. From the exterior it's very appealing. I was surprised when I went in to see a small little display of chips with only two brands and five salads to choose from to have with your sandwich. I'm assuming maybe this place specializes in breakfast ? Idk but my sandwich was weak AF. The bread first and foremost was stale. I was told the sourdough bread that they are supposed to have with this sandwich was not available fine but don't sell me a hero charge me twice the amount and give me a day old piece of bread. Not to mention I got 2 maybe 3 slices of cheese on this big hero I didn't even taste it. It was mostly bread! The avocado was also brown which completely grossed me out as the cherry on the sundae. This was 1:30 on a Saturday unacceptable....first and last time wish I came to yelp to see this place didn't have a good rating . Oh and the guy touched my cheese with his bare hands which i thought gross I probably should just leave and not take the sandwich But I was starving so I got the damn sandwich but please people go spend ur money elsewhere read more

See all

Bagel Time seems to have perfected the process for creating a bagel. They know how to make it the right size, texture, and flavor. Not every bagel is perfect, but no bagel shop even comes close to having bagels like Bagel Time's. This is the best bagel spot in the area. read more

Bagel Time & Deli - A dozen bagels - Delis Near Me - Matawan, New Jersey

See all

Last time I will be coming here was a loyal customer. found what looked like to be a burnt pieces of a wooden stick on my sandwich if I did not see it before I took a bite who know what could have happen. read more

See all

Went in for bagel sandwiches over an hour before!! closing and eyes were rolled and was told butter or cream cheese only since everything was already cleaned. This used to be the best spot in the area! Won't be returning read more

Their bagels are okay. This place is only a couple blocks from my house, so I SHOULD go here, but I don't. They've gotten my order wrong too many times. It seems they either have a high turn-over and keep hiring people who have no bagel experience, or the people who work there just don't care to learn because I've received breakfast sandwiches with lettuce on them from this place. Who puts lettuce on ANY breakfast sandwich? It's tiny inside, without room to sit. The parking lot on the outside kinda wraps around the building, so people have no idea where to park. Ordering something like "everythingn bagel with fresh lox, cream cheese, tomatoes, onions, and capers" always seems to get strange looks from the folks writing it down, as if I've invented some monstrosity they never heard of. If you ask me, there are a couple of better options for bagels within a mile of this place. read more

I've lived in the Matawan area for about 20 years and Bagel Time makes the BEST French Toast bagel Anywhere. It's like having dessert for breakfast, sure, but they say life is uncertain, so eat dessert first! For $2.40 you can purchase a cheaper bagel, but you'd be missing out. read more

The sandwiches and bagels are good for NJ (no comparison to NY). Usually hot and tasty - majority of the time. - prices are too high now with Covid as the excuse - staff is overwhelmed, not friendly, and gives inaccurate estimates for when food will be ready - no masks by staff, more patrons, and hot inside store / not a good Covid combination - owner when on-site here or across the street seems disgruntled and not wanting to speak to customers Hope that they can get the staffing and Covid controls in-place to not lose any customers..... read more

Great place to eat if you want every communicable disease that the workers have. They gather and talk over your food as they make it with unwashed and ungloved hands. I watched a worker, put her cell phone in her pocket, handle money/credit cards at the cash register and then handle food with her bare hands. I watched another go from chatting with other workers, put one glove on, and then proceed to handle my food and even dig into a vat of onions with his bare hand. If none of this bothers you in a world where monkeypox is on the rise in Middlesex county, then good luck! read more

Excellent subs. The workers are great at following instructions with food modifications and requests. The salads are very boring and bland. I ordered a grilled chicken salad once and added avocado slices in it. It costed around $15 how bizarre! If it was a slamming salad, I wouldn't mind, but geez. The coffee is pretty watered down, so it's nothing special. My huaband loves their bagels. The service is very fast and organized. My one advice is to don't order any subs from 2:30pm onward. The bread always tastes stale and old. Order in the morning or before noon and you should be good! read more

Bagel Time & Deli - Horribly boring salad. Had avocado slices added and it costed around $15. I ate barely half and threw the rest away. - Delis Near Me - Matawan, New Jersey

The food is good but the prices are super ridiculous for a bagel sandwich,Just not worth the price.

Really loved this bagel shop. Have seen a bit of a decline but still held a torch for them- today marked the breaking point. Dry, sad, burnt bagel sandwich. (I did not ask for it toasted) read more

Bagel Time & Deli - Delis Near Me - Matawan, New Jersey

You. Yes, you. Stop scrolling and read this. You haven't lived until you get a bagel from Bagel Time. That sentence should just about wrap up this review, but I'm going to elaborate on the excellence of these bagels. Let me back up and give you some background information on my bagel-eating career. I've had the legendary bagels from the city before. Black Seed, Absolute Bagels, even Barney Greengrass. Yeah, they're pretty awesome. But this is Matawan, NJ, and I don't have $15+ to take NJTransit into Manhattan... Then you gotta get a cab or take the subway... Too much of a hassle. The quality of the bagels here are incredibly Incredible. If I could name something that this place is incapable of doing it would be this: they are incapable of getting it wrong. Seriously, their egg everything bagels are on another level completely. Make it a breakfast sandwich with egg, cheese and avocado, and you'll thank me for the rest of your life. The service is fast, polite, and efficient. You make your own coffee, but who knows how you take your coffee better than you anyway? Speaking of coffee, they have the staples you know and love like regular and decaf, hazelnut, French vanilla, plus a nice change in the form of their Sumatra. They've also got really good pastries. My knees go weak when I see those blueberry danishes on deck. What's the moral of this review? Stop reading this and pick yourself up some bagels. Don't let your dreams be dreams. Yesterday you said you'd go tomorrow. Just do it. You'll remember the day you first went to Bagel Time as a close second to your wedding day or your kid's birthday, or that one time driving to work where you hit all greens. read more

Bagel Time & Deli - ACE on an egg everything is on deck all day. #respect - Delis Near Me - Matawan, New Jersey

This place is right near my house. The Food is consistent and pretty solid. No matter what time of the day I go it's always fresh. They have a huge selection and will even make you custom items if you ask. My problem is with the counter help. If you call In, it is a huge clusterfuck. I don't know if the people who answer the phone don't understand English or if it's just too loud in there but it's really a pain in the ass when you're trying to order food on a Saturday and it takes 20 minutes and your order is still wrong. I'm not gonna stop coming here because the food is good but they really need to get it together when it comes to the counter help! read more

They literally mess up my order every single time to the point where I actually think it's done on purpose now because how do you mess up a toasted bagel with butter every single time? I've been going here for years and the quality just goes down every single day. Rude staff except that one woman who is an angel on earth read more

Stopped in for a bagel sandwich because I knew I'd have a long period between meals. I ordered a 2 egg whites with sliced tomatoes on wheat bagel. Not the best value compared to just egg, pork roll, and cheese on a bagel, but I thought it was delicious! The wheat bagel was so good,I didn't feel like I was eating one! I always cringe when I hear wheat anything! It tasted better than the one I had last time, and I'm glad I tried Bagel Time again! The only issues were, the 2 egg white on a bagel was $2.50, but my sandwich was closer to $4 after the tomatoes and tax. I guess that's the price to pay trying to eat healthy. Also, the egg whites didn't really fill up the sandwich. Still, I'd get it again and make the occasional pitstop here for a sandwich run. read more

See all

Always busy because it's so good! Very clean as well. Staff are very friendly even on the busiest Saturday or Sunday mornings. The owner helps with orders to keep the line moving. We usually call ahead and place our breakfast order. Great bagels, always fresh! Full deli selection and fresh coffee. Nice variety of cream cheeses. Get egg, cheese, pork roll, and hash brown on a bagel! It's so good! read more

Paninis are delicious! They also have different cream cheese and things to take home! They are very nice here the guy who I believe owns or runs it even gave me some bagels on the house! It's convenient and service is excellent! read more

I am updating my review. In the last 6 months, The sub consistency and staff have gotten better since the new ownership. read more

New to the immediate area, Bagels are Awesome crusty on the outside soft on the inside

Hands down they have the best bagels in the area. Fresh and Delicious. Service is excellent too!

Now this is what a bagel shop should be like! Fast and friendly service with bagels and sandwiches that NEVER disappoint. I go here after church on Sundays. Hands down my favorite spot for breakfast :) Because it's such a great bagel spot, it can get packed in the mornings during the weekend. Also, their grill shuts off right before 2 on the weekends so if you're looking for a hot breakfast sandwich to fill you up, get there before then. I've gone to other bagel spots in town, but this one is the only one that makes my delicious French toast or super cinnamon bagels. I usually order that with hame, egg, and cheese with some coffee to go. Also, if you like the classic glass coke bottles, you can get those here! Small outdoor seating available during the warmer month. Overall, it's a great little gem. Go check them out! read more

Nope. Not having the experiences some of you below are. My last three trips to this bagel place always ended with regret. Last time, I waited 26 minutes for my one bagel order when I checked a text msg timestamp I sent out right after placing it. Today, I ask for turkey egg cheese with ketchup and hotsauce. No ketchup. No hot sauce. I MIGHT see turkey in there. And look at the photo for how little of anything is in my bagel. And I never leave reviews, but this experience infuriated me that much to get me to create a yelp account read more

Bagel Time & Deli - Delis Near Me - Matawan, New Jersey

Got a pork roll egg and cheese on a roll. Wish there was a little bit more porkroll because it seemed like all cheese but it was still good. Decent bagels and sandwiches, can't go wrong. read more

Bagel Time & Deli - Pork roll egg and cheese - Delis Near Me - Matawan, New Jersey

Used to go here semi frequently a couple of years ago and although they were pricey, they were good. Went there recently to get a sandwich, pastrami and swiss on a roll. Besides the fact that they skimped on the meat, they charged me 11.25! I was pissed for going there. I could have got a better sandwich at Jersey Mike's, and could have got the super size for 2 bucks more! Never again! read more

I bought 8 bagels today this morning. And gave one to my sister she just ate it this afternoon, and literally after bitting it 2 times. She saw a big bug on the bagel. It's disgusting. read more