Bagel Lady Cafe

Bagels are fresh, delicious and the service was amazing. The ambiance is very welcoming.read more

The bagels aren't actual bagels, but just regular buns with a brush of fake honey on top. I ordered…read morea ham sandwich, and it arrived with a side of macaroni salad. The sandwich wasn't fresh, and they didn't include any napkins or a fork for the macaroni salad!!! Definitely not recommended!

Inside

Egg Everything Bagel

See all

Bagels

Brooklyn Bagels & Cafe

3.0(30 reviews)

2.5 mi

Fresh bagel. Bagels in Long Island are not as in Queens but this place has good bagels.read more

Awful bagels. Ordered a bagel toasted with butter & cream cheese & a bagel toasted with cream…read morecheese & lettuce tomato onion...the bagel was literally RAW, raw dough in the middle!! Disgusting, never going back

See all

Better On A Bagel - Miller Place

4.0(64 reviews)

5.1 mi

Absolutely the best bagels -- soft, fresh, and perfectly chewy! You can really taste the quality…read more Easily my new go-to spot for breakfast!

Always fresh and soft bagels! Reasonable pricing. Friendly staff that's always on the move to get…read moreyour order and keeps the line moving. Great egg sandwiches too! The only bagel shop I'll go to

Everything bagel with cream cheese

Business closed

See all

Zona Out East

3.4(143 reviews)

2.4 mi

The turkey burger and sweet potato fries do not disappoint. Excellent price to plate ratio. My…read morewife loved her Greek salad with salmon. Another great price to plate ratio. From the moment you step in the door you feel at home, the decore is festive, the person that accompanies you to your table, and the waiters and waitresses are equally as welcoming, not to mention attentive to the patron's needs. Parking is excellent.

Food is always great. Service is inconsistent now. Sometimes you wait a long while for your meal if…read moreyour party is more than 2 people. Still, the portions are generous and food always good. I have never had a bad meal here. Typical diner ambiance. One room is booths, some tables and a counter to eat at, other room is large dining area where groups of any size can be accommodated. Sign up for their text alerts, and you get 15% off coupons. The one thing that really disappoints me is their side salads now. They used to be amazing with carrots, cucumbers, onions and roasted peppers. Now its a pile of lettuce with some onion. Understanding costs are rising, but customers notice chintzy. You can cut back without cutting out. Just my opinion. I love salad. All in all, good community diner. We are here about once a month, sometimes more

Greek salad and salmon.

See all

The Bigger Bagel & Deli

3.7(29 reviews)

4.4 mi

I ordered a sausage egg and cheese on a hero and they used ONE sausage patty, cut in half with half…read moreof it on each half of the hero. The thing was 90% bread! One patty on a roll is pretty bad, on a hero is just criminal. First and last time trying this place

I absolutely love The Bigger Bagel! Keith, the owner, and his staff are so friendly. The food is…read moregreat! Just added delicious waffles with fresh fruit to the menu. The establishment is very clean as well. Highly recommended.

Sunflower seed Bagel with Lox & Scallion Cream Cheese and tomato

See all

Dunkin Donuts & Baskin Robbins

2.1(21 reviews)

4.2 mi

This is probably my favorite Dunkin in the area. Much better than the Mt Sinai one. This place…read morealways makes my drink perfectly and the staff are very friendly every time I come in.

Hm, well. It's dunkin donuts. Customers were getting there orders BEFORE me that came in AFTER me…read more Even a customer with no shoes was served her order before me. So much for no shirt, no shoes, no service. Hm. However, the manger (I think he was the manager) did make it up to me by giving me 6 free donuts and apologized to me and thanked me for my patience.

So much for no shirt, no shoes, no service...

See all

Crappy chocolate "glazed" donut

Flying Pig Cafe

3.3(272 reviews)

4.0 mi

First time there a year ago and the food was fantastic... Not sure if the chef changed but they got…read morereally created with certain items and it was a bit lack luster sadly. Orders a chorizo and eggs dish and the chorizo was made it's this sloppy hash like things that tasted nothing like any chorizo I ever had. Staff is still friendly and the space is still adorable but just stick to the regular solid breakfast menu items that are not messed with on the menu.

Came here for breakfast on a Thursday. The waitress was friendly. The restaurant wasn't too busy…read more The food did take a while to come out. I had eggs with corn beef hash. It was good. Very standard. Hubby got a skillet. The flank steak was seasoned very well. We wish it was cut up into slightly smaller size. He wished his egg was a little more under cooked. By the time he got his dish the yolk was no longer runny. Overall the meal was good and we would come back if we were in the area.

Cinnamon Swirl Pancakes

Interior

See all

Interior

Tuscany Gourmet Market

3.3(71 reviews)

4.4 mi

•$$$

It was on the expensive side for a sandwich but well worth it when servicng size and quality come…read moreinto play . Great bread . Great service . Lots of good products in the store . Definitely coming back to try this one or another in the near future.

Please look at the one star reviews. Everything I ordered was of poor quality. I bought two types…read moreof chicken salad and if I hadn't known I wouldn't even have known it was "chicken"salad. I also bought potato salad, macaroni salad, and a fresh Italian bread. Meanwhile, the bread wasn't fresh and the salads were below par. I was planning on returning the salads, but chose not to instead I won't be returning. Lesson learned.

Overstuffed hero's ??? I don't think so !!!

See all

Outside

Maggie’s Eatery And Take Away

4.9(42 reviews)

4.7 mi

Maggie's would fit right in on the beach in Brighton as a seaside eatery. It is bright, airy,…read morecheery, and colorful. It is a very welcoming environment. The epoxy counter is a comic book lover's delight from which to order. My wife and I entered for an early dinner. We walked up to the counter and ordered our entrees. I had the fish and chips, my wife ordered a burger. Not being beer conoscenti, we left the choice to the waiter/chef. Within fifteen minutes our orders were ready. The cod and French fries I ordered were delicious! My wife also found her entree excellent. The beer was cold, dark gold, and tasty. The portion to price aspect was a bit lacking: the entree could have contained a fourth piece of cod instead of three. The Takeaway: 1. Excellent food 2. Pricy 3. Great beach vibes for ambiance 4. Good beer 5. Excellent parking 6. No reservations needed I would have given four and a half stars if the program permitted.

We decided last minute to do lunch and I remembered someone talking about this place. It was our…read morefirst time here. It's adorable. Small but spacious and bright and cheerful vibe. We were greeted upon arrival. I had the chopped cheese with fries and it was SO GOOD. My husband had the double cheeseburger with bacon and he's a burger snob and loved it! We will definitely be back!

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

11 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Vanessa K.

104

3 years ago

The previous owner was great, ran a great business. The new owner and the worker are very slow and have no clue how to run this business. I was waiting for over five minutes while two people diddled around in the back. I asked some woman if I could order and she started barking at me, basically making some unknown words, not being able TO SPEAK ENGLISH, grunting, AND SHE WAS DOWN RIGHT RUDE, she should be fired. Some man waited on me and he had about as much personality as my pinky toe. This place should close. read more

Robert E.

1 year ago

I am a huge fan of this shop. The food is excellent and they offer much more than bagels. The service is incredibly friendly and professional. The owner works hard to make sure customers are satisfied. It's a wonderful part of the community and a great option for delicious foods. Highly recommend. read more

Caroline C.

2 years ago

Every time we visit New York we have to stop by and get our bagel fix! The chicken salad on a bagel is incredible as well as the breakfast sandwiches! read more

Pat S.

10 years ago

The food is good but not sure if it's worth the wait. It's priced reasonably and it's very clean but you should definitely call your order in. read more

Jennifer R.

246

4 years ago

Delicious bacon egg cheese sandwich. Nice to see a newspaper in the table to browse while you wait. Courteous staff.

Marie M.

4 years ago

saw the boss scream at employees and it was bad. who would want to work here. those poor kids! they need a new job!

J T.

522

107

4 years ago

Good cinnamon raisin bagel. Walnut raisin cream cheese too thin - needs to be thick. Pleasant staff.

Robert L.

1 year ago

Service was fast and friendly and the food was outstanding. Absolutely love this place, a MUST TRY

Theresa R.

4 years ago

Terrible! New ownership is terrible the employees are terrible. The food is disgusting!

Laura G.

15 years ago

Bagels are good. Service is slow.

Reynold Gerard M.

12 years ago

Great sevices and great cookie

Bagel Lady Cafe - bagels - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Shoreham, New York Restaurants near Bagel Lady Cafe

BEST of Shoreham, New York Desserts near Bagel Lady Cafe

BEST of Shoreham, New York Cocktail Bars near Bagel Lady Cafe

BEST of Shoreham, New York Breakfast near Bagel Lady Cafe

BEST of Shoreham, New York Things to Do near Bagel Lady Cafe

BEST of Shoreham, New York Coffee near Bagel Lady Cafe

BEST of Shoreham, New York Parking near Bagel Lady Cafe

BEST of Shoreham, New York Pizza near Bagel Lady Cafe

BEST of Shoreham, New York Shopping near Bagel Lady Cafe

BEST of Shoreham, New York Thrift Stores near Bagel Lady Cafe

Best of Shoreham

Things to do in Shoreham

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Bagel Lady Cafe also viewed

Better On A Bagel

3.6

(55 reviews)

Great bagels and great prices. We love all their different breakfast meals. May be an odd…read morecomparison but our teenage boys love the breakfast here over the popular Toast restaurant. I prefer toast but hard to beat great breakfast food with great prices and no 2 hour wait time. Very consistent quality. Great fast service. Been going here for over a decade now

Starting eating here in high school in the early 2000s and it is still my favorite bagel place in…read morethe whole world. The bagels are huge, like the biggest I've ever seen. They are so soft and fluffy and stay that way for days. I love an egg everything bagel but their bialy is top notch. So soft and so much chunks of onion.

Bagels and Company

3.2

(31 reviews)

This is one of my sisters favorite breakfast sandwiches spots that she's blesses me with when I…read morecome into town! And I must say they do have the best bacon egg and cheese rolls!! If you're from New York you know, nothing beats B.E.C from New York! 10/10

Something seems off here, this bagel spot has been extremely busy for years…read more Today I walked in at 8:30 am and only two people on line and staff is sparse. Something felt completely different. The was NO cream cheese in the display case and staff seemed confused on what they should be doing. I ordered egg whites and bacon on a roll. When the server went to ring me up I asked if it included a juice or coffee or tea, she replied yes. It's a pet peeve of mine that if something is included in the price the server should offer it to you. Bad business in my opinion. The sandwich was ok, definitely smaller portions than before but still ok, the coffee on the other hand was horrible. Tasted like a dirty pot of grinds. Not sure when I will be back to try again.

Better On A Bagel Express

4.1

(44 reviews)

Food is yummy!! Large sized portions!! Raphael, Ellie, Dion, and Chris are super friendly and…read moreprepare your orders very fast. The best bagel place in the area!!! Check it out ASAP. You wont be disappointed!!! Fran R.

Best way to start your Football Sunday. So happy to find this place because the bagels were very…read moregood. We also had egg sandwiches and they were delicious and filling. I am excited to try their chopped cheese sandwiches for lunch.

Bagel Buddies Deli

3.0

(31 reviews)

•$$$

Best bagels in town…read more Yelp is making me write more words down. Buy a bacon egg and cheese on a toasted poppy or egg bagel.

sorry i cant say much there bagels are awful and under cooked , i real bklyn bagel is dark and…read morecrunchy on the outside and soft on the inside and i found that the new owners serve the same spongie bagels and the woman behind the counter dosent speak very good english........is ther anyone in long island that can make a real bklyn bagel thats dark and crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside just like 1970.........im sill looking but good luck to them

Bagel Lovers

3.8

(31 reviews)

I love this place. The people were great! Bagles are really nice. I love this place!!read more

Great little breakfast spot. Friendly service and a comfortable atmosphere. Menu has all the…read moreclassics. Bagel sandwiches are excellent. Fair prices as well.

Blvd Bagels

3.6

(64 reviews)

Blvd Bagels has been part of my weekend routine ever since I was a kid, so coming back for a visit…read morehome always means making a stop here, no questions asked. It's just a genuine local staple in the neighborhood. As usual, there was a line out the door when I showed up, but honestly, that's half the charm. It moves quickly enough, and, to me, it just means the place is doing something right. The staff are always super friendly, greeting you by name if you're a regular, and keeping things light with quick jokes or small talk while they work their bagel magic. This time I went with my go to: a sesame bagel piled high with cream cheese, and my dad went for a whole wheat everything with butter, and he absolutely crushed it within seconds. We both agreed the bagels are just as good as they were years ago. Fresh, flavorful, and warm. What I love about Blvd Bagels is their variety. If you're not in a bagel mood (does that happen?!), they've got a full menu of special from omelets, hot breakfast sandwiches, and some legit cold sandwich options for later in the day. Everything feels homemade and delicious. It's just a great classic bagel shop that's kept our neighborhood happy and well fed for years. Whether you're a local or popping in on a visit home like I did, it's totally worth waiting in that line!

Overpriced, Small, Hard Bagels Bought 6 Bagels and was so…read moredisappointed in the quality and price. Once never twice

Joels Bagels

4.3

(56 reviews)

Stopped here on a Saturday to get a Sausage, Egg, and Cheese on an Everything Bagel. The line was…read morelong, but that normally means you're at the right place. Service was friendly and I don't feel like I had to wait too long. My bagel sandwich was tasty! I feel like it was a good size and cooked well. Great place to grab a bagel and will go back if I'm in the area.

Second time here today …read more The first time I came here I got a dozen bagels to bring to Florida with me. My cousin described them as euphoric. They were very good. I don't know why I haven't been back in so long. I decided to stop in today for an egg sandwich. I got BEC with hot sauce on an everything bagel. It was so delicious. My fiancé had SECSPK on a seedless roll. He said it was really good. Staff was very friendly this morning (7/11/25 around 830am) too. Service with a smile. Definitely coming here more often and driving the extra few minutes from my apartment to do so.

Bagel Patch

3.7

(40 reviews)

Not sure if I would call this a hidden gem. It is a very small bagel shop in a strip mall located…read moreoff the side of Rt. 112. The longish sort of line seemed promising, but the hold up wasn't because everyone needed a bagel from here, it was only because of a discrepancy of some sort. The staff was hustling, and eggs were being flipped right behind the counter and everything looked like it was kept clean. The service is a bit subpar. I was skipped over, which seemed to be an honest mistake so I didn't fuss. More pissed at the dude that speak up to say I was next. I guess chivalry is dying. The bagel itself was also subpar. I ordered an everything flagel with olive cream cheese. It wasn't bad by any means it just wasn't anything special. The star of the show was the cream cheese. Wasn't too olivey and you can tell it was pretty fresh. Nothing was labeled so I couldn't tell you what other cream cheeses they had. The menu was digital and was hung on the wall behind the counter. It didn't have much besides the list of bagels and before I could try to read more it would flash off. This place is fine in a pinch, but I'm not running back any time soon.

The twists and all the Bagels they make our real New York style crispy yet soft to the touch bagels…read morethe girls that work the counter are always smiling and I think it's been the same Baker for years making these great bagels hats off to them. Whether it's summertime and it's

Your Bagel Cafe

3.7

(30 reviews)

bagels weren't that fresh at all or good. egg sandwich was $10 and not tasty. simple bacon egg…read morecheese. the bagel was what made it not that good

Ordered a BLT, see if you can find the lettuce cause I couldn't until I had to open the sandwich…read more Ordered a Blue Monster with Zero sugar, they gave me a low carb one and no pickle. I called and there excuse was there's a new kid. If the kid is new then why isn't there someone to make sure the orders are correct. This store has gone down hill. This was my go to spot for bagels in Shirley but the last few times I've gone it's not as good as it was. Always seems to be an issue with my order for the last few times I've gone.

Patchogue Bagel Deli

3.5

(42 reviews)