Busy place with parking lot and parking across the street. Friendly service and good food. My buddies had the ribeye steak with mashed potatoes and another had the Calabash Shrimp with fries. I had the blackened grouper with asparagus. The calabash shrimp is HUGE! Better be hungry or split it with someone. The steaks are on the thin side but were both cooked perfectly and was told they were delicious. They also raved about the mashed potatoes being delicious. My grouper portion was decent sized for the price and was cooked perfectly and was delicious too. Same with the asparagus. I'd recommend it for a great dinner. Expect to spend $25-$50, on the higher end if you get drinks and an appetizer. read more

New review, came by Back 2 Shuckers bc it is a staple for me and my husband. I got the coconut shrimp( almost burnt) it was pretty good, Boom Boom Shrimp, and we got wings. It was a little busy but the waitress went missing several times, she did have large parties, the person who brought out our food didn't bring ranch with chicken wings you have to have ranch. Got the grits which are always banging. I miss the aquariums they had. The interior is not what you expect. You can't really hear the music. The bar is super loud but that's to be expected. If you do come go early or later never peak times. I think it could use some updating. read more

See all

Best atmosphere, best food and you always make a new friend while there. The whole baby flounder is amazing, slaw, fries. Calabash style anything is good. Love the crap dip and boom boom shrimp! Don't miss this fun place. read more

Back 2 Shuckers - Seafood Near Me - Oak Island, North Carolina

Shuckers is back as Back 2 Shuckers. We dined in for dinner on a Wednesday night and it was slammed because it's the night for their steam specials. Luckily we had no issues being seated at the bar and parking out front. We started off with a round of drinks (a beer for me and the Dark and Stormy for him) and the crab dip. For our meals it was the coriander crusted mahi with grits and veggies for me and the grouper with potatoes and veggies for my husband. The crab dip was so good. I thought that my fish was just okay but the grouper was good. It's worth a visit if you are in OKI. read more

See all

The crab dip stole the show!!!! I wasn't too into the menu and offerings but decided to go with the dip and it was amazing. They offered good beverages. The pain killer was nice and sweet. read more

See all

Great food and low key ambience. On the weekends be prepared to wait for a table. Tonight (Wednesday) at 6 they were only moderately busy but absolutely everything was ON POINT! They really DO have THE best crab dip on the island and it's a generous portion at that!! read more

Back 2 Shuckers - Happy customers post crab dip - Seafood Near Me - Oak Island, North Carolina

This must have been a very off night for the kitchen! My Calabash-style seafood arrived to the table swimming in grease. The flounder filet, when I broke off a piece, was still saturated in fryer oil, an indication that the oil must have not been hot enough to fry properly when it was first dropped. The shrimp (definitely the miniature, frozen variety) had been pre-fried and a second trip could not revive them, nor the spongy, flavorless hush puppies. Normally, I love hush puppies enough to enjoy them cold, but even these warmed ones did not merit a second bite. My entire meal was a disappointment and not worth a take home plate, though my daughter had better luck with her tuna steak. She said it was delicious as always, even if it was served grilled rather than blackened (as ordered). The garden salad she enjoyed was also tasty and fresh, served with a cucumber-wasabi dressing made popular in this establishment and its predecessor. We also had excellent service provided by the waitstaff and kitchen, something I am always pleased to see even if the meal is lacking. Sadly, after this visit, I feel I must downgrade my previously glowing 5 star rating to a lackluster 2 stars. This hurts particularly because Back 2 Shuckers as well as its previous iteration, Turtle Island, have been the can't-miss dining experience during each of our visits to OKI. I hope that this was just an outlier, and I would love the opportunity to enjoy another lovely meal here as in years past. For now, it will need to be Back 2 Somewhere Else :-/ read more

Waited an hour for food at the bar while other parties that came after us were served and bussed around us. The waitress tried to blame it on the tourists and a large party (that had been served before we put our order in). We also overheard some racist comments (spoken in assumed confidence with a regular, but loud enough for the bar to notice), which sours my experience, the food was decent but expensive and not worth the wait. I wish I had better things to say because I truly wanted to love this little local dive-esque restaurant & bar, but this is one of the rare occasions where we were on the verge of walking out multiple times. read more

Great food and service. We have eaten there many times. Quality is always good. Oak islands best

Service was SLOW and the food was MEDIOCRE. My scallops were cold. The first boom boom shrimp had one piece celery, no ranch--pretty pathetic looking. Second order and one and one-half pieces of celery lol and and a ranch! So there is that :\ We use to come to Turtle Island and it was SOOOO much better.. so much. read more

I stopped in here tonight for dinner cause everywhere else was on a long wait. The hostess was very nice and I had a seat at the bar. The bar seating was very comfortable and I ordered a Bloody Mary (which was delicious). The bartender was very nice, too. I ordered a dozen clams and 1/2 pound of shrimp. Both were great! The side salad was also good with adds fruit on it. This is just a chill place if you are loping for something more fancy. read more

See all

Food is great! Staff is wonderful! Casual fun place! Our favorite at Oak Island! Last vacation we ate there 4 times. Love this place!

Stuffed flounder was pitiful: a few thin pieces of flounder stuck to the outside of a scoop of stove top stuffing that may or may not have have a few pieces of crab in it. Very disappointing. read more

Delicious and reasonably priced scallops. Husband who never orders flounder said it was the best ever. Great service. Comfortable atmosphere. read more

I took a party of 5 adults and 2 children,(7&4), on a Thursday evening. We had a great experience. The service was friendly and attentive. We ordered a variety of food. Oysters on the half shell, delicious and fresh. The 7 year old had his first oyster and after making a pretty funny face opted for another. My mother, 100 years old and only eats shrimp cooked "extra crispy". She was accommodated and gave the fried shrimp, kid's plate a thumbs up. The rest of our party had a variety of drinks and entrees and all was good. The atmosphere was loud but as certain groups of diners left it got quieter and more comfortable. It appeared to me that everyone was having a good experience and there were plenty of to go boxes leaving the restaurant. Portions were plenty. I would give our entire experience a 5 and read more

We ate here while on a quick few days away. It was a a regular all-you-care-to-eat seafood night. We ordered two sets of crab legs, one of which had empty legs, and the other had minimal meat in the legs at best. We ordered two more. One came to our table 20 minutes later. The claw meat peeled apart like string cheese. The leg meat was limp like spaghetti. One sniff was overpowering with spoilage... the waitress apologized when we asked her to smell the food. Had we eaten it, we would have been needing a doctor's care. I didn't eat for the next 24 hrs. We have been customers when the place was Turtle Island, but wont be going Back 2 Shuckers ever....wings weren't bad. But this was a Gordon Ramsey moment for sure. read more

First time here, there was a 45 minute wait but they communicated that very well and handled seating tables without overwhelming the servers or kitchen, which was impressive. Casual atmosphere, great service and a nice variety of dishes with an emphasis on seafood. Nice stop if you want a casual beach dinner. read more

Great Service. Best Seafood on Oki. No need to leave the island and fight traffic. Wedenesday night steamer specials have been a favorite of locals for a long time. read more

First, thanks to you and your dedicated staff for being open during TS Debby! We came for Steamers night on Wednesday, based on a recommendation from a local friend. Dinner was great! Clam chowder was flavorful, as was She Crab soup! Steamed shrimp were large and tender, perfectly cooked. We also had wings and crab legs which were yummy, esp for a great price! We can't say enough nice things about our server, Mindy! She was kind, polite, friendly and attentive! She was super quick to respond to any of our requests for extra sauces, etc and kept our drinks coming during the whole dinner! We will definitely come again next year and will recommend to others! read more

Boom Boom Shrimp Prime Rib Fish tacos Service was great, food was even better. Worth the wait! read more

Small and a bit noisy but was all delicious, reasonably priced and generous quantity. Marcus provided prompt and friendly service. I'll definitely go back. read more

When I had came in towards the back end of the night I was informed that multiple items including scallops, chicken wings, oysters were out with crab legs almost being out. I understand that it was busy with spring break going on and having fresh seafood but the chicken wings was the ridiculous. The drinks were okay nothing special was expecting more from this place from the reviews and was dissatisfied to say the least. read more

Wow! So glad we found this gem! We went in on a Saturday evening about 6:30 and although packed, we were seated quickly. Everyone was so friendly and welcoming! Crab dip was delicious, my 8 year old over took it and claimed as his. Coriander crusted mahi was so flavorful and fresh as well as the stuffed flounder. read more

See all

The food and service was so good here that we ate there two nights in a row!! We really enjoyed chatting with the amazing bartender who kindly changed the tv to let us watch our college football game! read more

Wonderful beach dive bar restaurant. Don't be fooled by the outside or inside. Great staff! Menu will hit all the hot buttons raw bar, steamed, grilled, fried - however you like it. Love the specials. Eat at the bar and listen to the locals - better than a movie. My favorite place in OKI read more

Myself and my family were the biggest fans of Turtle Island so when we found out they were changing ownership and changing their name, we were a little apprehensive. I will tell you that we were pleasantly surprised! Have no fear Tini lovers, our favorite bartender Willie is still going strong slinging the best dirty vodka martini on the island. They still have the fried baby flounder which is amazing. The scallops stayed consistent and delicious. The side salad is the same with the original Cusabi dressing (YUM). The menu has changed slightly and I was really intrigued to see a Jack Daniels Chicken dish and a Blackberry Hoisin Pork Chop added to the menu. I'm annoyed by the name they chose but overall, I think this spot will continue to be our go-to in Oak Island! read more

See all

We arrived about 7:30 on a Thursday night. They only had one large group waiting. We walked right in. Took a bit for someone to take our drink order. We ordered the crab dip. The price point is pretty high for an appetizer. It was tasty, but expensive. Love the bread thst comes with it. I had the stuffed flounder. Lots of breading and fish was a little dry. My husband had a salad and 1/2 pound peel n eat. Cooked perfectly and seasoned appropriately. He really enjoyed it. Our server was so soft spoken and the restaurant was really loud. It was hard to hear. But nice to see families enjoying themselves. read more

Found this cute little place across from the mini golf! Staff was super friendly. Food was delicious! Everyone had clean plates by the end of the meal. I had the grilled flounder, my husband had the stuffed flounder, and our boys had the prime rib and the grilled tuna. It was all so delicious! read more

Back 2 Shuckers - Flounder - Seafood Near Me - Oak Island, North Carolina

Great food and service! We had fresh seafood and the place was clean as well. Our server was knowledgeable and made some recommendations about an appetizer that was wonderful! read more

First timer. Welcomed in. Great staff and food. From looking at the plates everything looked good. I'll surely go back. Great oysters on the half shell. read more

Excellent oysters on the half shell. Typical bar ambiance. Great and attentive service.

Large portions perfectly prepared. Super friendly staff. Daily specials are great, steamed seafood Wednesdays and Prime Rib Fridays. Enjoy! read more

Will definitely be returning! I am not a seafood lover, but my guy is. He got the Calabash with three seafood choices (he got fried shrimp, fried flounder, and deviled crab). He says the shrimp and flounder were great, but the deviled crab wasn't the best he's ever had. I got the Caesar Salad with Grilled Chicken. The chicken was tender and flavorful and the Caesar dressing was good, not too much or too dry. We had Marcus as our server and he made sure our tea glasses stayed full even though he was pretty busy. The hostess was friendly and greeted us with a smile, seating us right away and even made it a point to say bye when we left! The place was clean, I loved how they had the paper towel racks on the tables. Overall, great relaxing dinner after an adventure filled day! read more

Average dinner of fried shrimp and an $8 up charge for scallops. We sat at the bar when a server came out of the kitchen, tripped, and dumped an entire pitcher of beverage down my back into my cargo shorts and well, elsewhere. I was offered two small bar towels to clean up which was impossible to do. We decided to continue on with dinner as it was late and we were tired and hungry. When the check came, I was comped two $8 drinks and required to pay for the meal. A mistake of this magnitude should have resulted in a complementary dinner. read more

Food and service were excellent! The grouper was so fresh and cooked perfectly. We will definitely go back and try other dishes.

A Locals favorite! Wednesday night steamed specials at very good prices. Friday evening prime rib!!! Mmmm Mmmm good.

Went there tonight and the food was excellent. So reasonable and amazing. We had Mindy as our waitress and she was wonderful. Bobbi the greeter could not have been nicer. The entire staff are so welcoming. Thank you Amanda for such a nice experience. Can't wait to go back. read more

I so wanted to like this place. Turtle Island was consistently good, never had a bad meal, and recommended it to everyone looking for fresh seafood. I stated this because they've been pushing Turtle Island as part of their marketing. "Same staff, same great food..." This new version of Turtle Island is absolutely not the same caliber and the prices were much higher. Raw oysters were good, but that's the only item we had that I can recommend. We also ordered steamed oysters which had the consistency of chewing gum. Not even edible. Finally, we tried a pound of steamed crab legs, absolutely the worst I've ever had. They were complete mush and tasted like they had been boiled for hours. Having been an almost weekly guest to Turtle Island, this was a serious let down. I do not see myself ever going back here, it was that bad. read more

first time being here since turtle island closed. atmosphere is very fun and social and the food is great, especially the seafood. wednesday nights are steamer nights so many things are a lot cheaper but get there early! dessert was fantastic as well. michael and willy at the bar are the best! read more

Back 2 Shuckers - key lime pie - Seafood Near Me - Oak Island, North Carolina

See all

We've been coming to Oak Island for 33 years and have enjoyed eating at Turtle Island and then Back 2 Shuckers. We are back for a week and were excited to visit our favorite restaurant. However, we were extremely disappointed in the taste and quality of the food. The crab legs ($18 per cluster) were cold and took a long time to be served. The stuffed flounder was ok but not much crab meat in the 'stove top' stuffing. The onion tangles were not crispy, but wimpy. The clam chowder had small chunks of vegetables in it that weren't fully cooked. (Bring back Annie's Clam Soup) My daughter, who is gluten sensitive, requested things to be prepared with that in mind and was told that if she ordered it that way...the entire table had to do the same (12 people) So she ordered the cold, wet, crabless crab legs. Service was just ok but the hostess was very pleasant, welcoming and helpful (much appreciated...don't lose her). We'll be looking for other restaurants to patronize in the future. Extremely disappointed! read more