First day in Fort Collins and had seen good things about Austin's while trying to pick a place for an early dinner. Easy street parking, surrounded by fun shops in Old Town, it offers both indoor and outdoor seating. We arrived early and had no trouble walking in, but make a reservation if you plan to be there after 6:00pm, even on a weeknight. Ambience is quite pleasing, it was not loud and Kelly came over soon after being seated to see about drinks and apps. If you want a thoughtful, friendly server Kelly is the one! We ordered the cornbread skillet first. Mmmmm mmm. Warm in a skillet and served with whipped honey butter, could it get any better? Well....maybe. Because the beef tips were so incredible. Melt in your mouth! One of our party likes cuts of meat on the pink side, the other prefers more well done cuts. Off Kelly went with our plates, returning having divided them into two and having the beef done perfectly for both of us. Get some extra BBQ sauce/gravy with it. Perfection. Mashed potatoes were also quite good. We were stuffed. I would go back in a heartbeat. Yum. Kudos to the chef, to Kelly and to the manager, who stopped by twice.....once to serve and once to check in. read more

Had three good experiences at Austin's during a recent business trip. The restaurant has plenty of seating, a really nice patio, and attentive staff. On my first visit, I ordered the tri-tip. While it was good overall, it could use a few tweaks--the meat seemed a bit under-seasoned, and the presentation wasn't particularly appealing. That said, it was perfectly acceptable and hit the spot. My next two visits were at the bar, where both bartenders were friendly, attentive, and clearly knew their craft. Based on those experiences, I'd definitely return if I were in the area and would recommend others give it a try as well. read more

We were staying nearby this restaurant so decided to walk over and try it. We were treated and said there would be a 10 minute wait, but more like 5. Jordan was our server and she was excellent. Didn't rush us, answered our numerous questions and checked back on us every so often. I had an Old Fashion and it was excellent. Not a complaint but should have had one large ice cube vs. small ones. My husband had one of their IPAs on tap. I had the chicken pot pit, salad and corn bread. My husband had 2 pieces of chicken, Cole slaw and sweet potato fries. Jordan was great letting him exchange the potatoes for the fries. Everything was so good. read more

See all

This place is a case of fancy plating but nothing to taste. Came here for steak, got the NY strip with mashed potatoes, coconut shrimp and wings appetizers, and I don't have much to say about any of it... looked nice, I like the touch of crispy onions on the steak, but I was unloading most of the salt shaker on top of my food for any seasoning. The mash was bland, the steak was bland, the coconut strip felt like an air fryer meal, and the wings were just decent. Won't say don't try it, maybe the sandwiches are good, and the patio area was pretty nice for dinner, but I couldn't find anything to return for. read more

Austin's American Grill - New American Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

DELISH!!! I stopped in at Austin's American Grill simply out of convenience-my hotel room wasn't ready and this was walking distance. The waiter was wonderful, the staff amazing, and the salad delicious! And Cornbread Croutons?! What in the world?! More like OUT of this worked!! The restaurant FELT upscale while being welcoming and affordable. Truly enjoyable experience!! read more

Austin's American Grill - New American Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

Excellent food and wonderful service!! Highly recommend for a fun evening in Ft Collins.

Austins is consistent in it accommodation of large groups and quite agile in accommodating last minute small groups. We love how the Austin's menu evolves particularly with the inclusion of bison, and the menu variety from which some of our picky-ist eaters can make selections. When the restaurant gets busy it can get loud with background noise and it can be difficult to get needed table service, which feels like a trade off that can be accommodated by making earlier or later reservations when individuals around the table need quieter background sounds...'' read more

The workers? Sweet as pie. The food? Overpriced even at happy hour for the quality. When I say the quality of food is NOT AT ALL worth the price, I mean it. The server was a saint though. I know I won't be going there again. read more

This place is trying to be a Hillstone where Hillstone won't play. Fine. But LEARN from Hillstone. Lower the lighting 60%. Or, at the very least don't have exposed bulbs in your overhead lighting, especially at the bar. Diffuse the light at the very least. But you could also stand to lose the hospital-level brightness. Turn down the lights. Ambiance will sell more alcohol... Excellent service. read more

Austin's American Grill - Bar lighting. - New American Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

Six of us came in for lunch today and it was great! Grace was our server and she was very patient and accommodating to us. The food was excellent including the desserts we shared. The restaurant has nice atmosphere with just the right lighting. I highly recommend checking out this restaurant. We will be back soon. read more

Austin's remains a go to lunch spot with our local friends. I can see why they have a solid lineup of good American food in a convenient location. There is a wide assortment of sandwiches and entrees and sure to be something that will please even your most finicky eaters. The flavored ice teas were interesting -- basically tea with some fruit syrup added. Sandwiches and burgers seem to be the crowd favorite. BBQ chicken sandwich came in a large portion. The side, coleslaw with cranberries and apples was a favorite. Service was helpful and prompt. We sat outside on the patio and enjoyed that wonderful Colorado weather. read more

It was the PERFECT dining experience. Great food, friendly (and fast) service, and great vibes. Can't wait to go back!

I'm not a stickler for service. Servers are generally some of the hardest workers, but the service at Austins was odd. It was lackadaisical and not punctual on a not so busy Saturday night. I ordered French Onion soup. It was brought out Uber quickly, before I received my water. I wonder if I got someone else's soup? It was tiny and likely satisfied by daily intake of salt for the next week. I was surprised how much I enjoyed the salmon. Knowing it had a bbq I was worried it would be overly sweet but the sweetness was mild and the salmon was cooked well. read more

Austin's American Grill - Northwest BBQ Salmon - New American Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

See all

Service is exceptional. They are always willing to make things right. Establishments are raising their prices and this place still has affordable eats. Flavors are amazing. It will be my go to! read more

Austins American Grill is a nonnegotiable for us when we're visiting Fort Collins. The Fat Tire Beer Cheese Soups is one of the most comforting dishes of all time for me and keeps me coming back. They serve it with popcorn on the side for you to drop into your soup and it is such a fun and salty addition to an already delightful soup. Service is always wonderful and the ambiance is very comfortable. In the summer the patio is lovely and the location is hard to beat, being right in Old Town. My boyfriend got the NY Strip which came with crispy fried onions and a mountain of garlic mashed potatoes. Austins always keeps us coming back for more! read more

See all

Austins seems like one of those places that feels right whether it's just a weeknight dinner out or a special occasion. Great atmosphere and service with seating at tables, booths, or the bar. Menu offers quintessential steakhouse fare front steaks, chicken, burgers, ribs, and fish right down to classic cocktails like a frosty Blue Goose martini made with Grey Goose and blue cheese stuffed olives. The most unique aspect of the menu is the presence of bison options. I think this was my first time having a bison steak, and if it wasn't it was certainly the most memorable. Perfect cooked med rare, full of flavor, very lean with no fattiness. Other highlights include the chicken tortilla soup, spicy queso, and the croissant bread pudding for dessert. Looking forward to another visit. Highly recommend. read more

See all

Love this restaurant. The last couple of times we have eaten here the food comes out lukewarm warm. Doesn't taste as good.

Maybe the best formal date place. Imagine you're already dressed to the nines and you need a place to go! Consistently classy and tasty now for over 30 years! Always great service, atmosphere, and music. They honor your allergies or preferences as well. And again, let me stress how much we love the food. read more

Staff was very accommodating seating us at the table we wanted, service was good, food was good, and drinks were good. It happened to be a nice day so we sat outside, but there was a lot of indoor available as well. read more

Austin's American Grill is a more upscale restaurant for a good American meal. Just a note, there are two locations in Fort Collins. One in Old Town and the other being here on Harmony Road. I prefer this one because parking is easier and more accessible. There are a plethora of seating options for any occasion. First dates, meetings, celebrations, you name it, they have the perfect spot waiting for you. Our waitress was kind and helpful when it came to a booth that didn't work for us. She gladly moved us to a table without us having to ask, as she could see that it was uncomfortable for us. As for food, I was feeling something on the healthier side and you can never go wrong with a cobb salad. Loved the presentation and the portion was filling and just what I was looking for. Corn bread croutons? Yeah, they were pretty cool and complimented the meal well. The cornbread itself was fantastic! Everyone else enjoyed their meals and cleaned their plates. I'm always a fan of a place that has more expensive options, but also offers cheaper options for those who can't afford the heftier prices. Good lookin' out! Highly recommend Austin's for a great meal with awesome service. read more

See all

I came in during happy hour and ordered off the appetizer menu. I had some wings and some ribs and everything was perfectly cooked and delicious. I was sitting at the bar and the waitress took very good care of me and it was dark and quiet. I thoroughly enjoyed my experience. The only reason I'm only giving it four stars is because I didn't have anything off the regular menu. read more

Staff was so good I could cry food was so good I could cry if some one is reading this try the serloyn roast

A joke. I wrote in a while back to complain that our $80 meal was awful, the chicken haystack sandwich made of low quality meat remnants, the salad little more than ice berg lettuce with a big greasy chunk of "corn bread" on top, and the fried crab avocado a bland mushy mess. Literally the only thing that was "good" were the fries, which are hard to fuck up. Anyways I was pleased when Jenn reached out in hopes of making it right, thought maybe I could get a refund or something but this corporate robot offered us... a gift card. For Austin's. I explained I had no interest in returning and don't even live there so that wouldnt work and she offered me... another gift card. To another establishment she's affiliated with, that I ALSO don't live in the same state as and have no interest visiting. She was unwilling to offer a check and I get that, hardly anyone even has them anymore but for real lady; venmo? cash app? SOMEthing. Come up with something. Instead, she just stipped replying. More business owners who only care about "making things right" if it results in more money in their pocket book. Thanks for nothing Jenn! I'm not even typically a person who write reviews or seeks refunds, but this was that level of bad and it was a date. Highly recommend going anywhere else. This place was good 10 years ago. read more

Great place for a group lunch! Service--amazing. Nice place with plenty of room for a lot of people. Parking? No problem--lots of spots to be had. read more

A tasty pulled chicken sandwich, friendly service, sweet potato fries were hot and fresh

Great food! Great service! we had the Chicken and Ribs Combo and it was perfection. Austin's is Fort Collins restaurant icon! Try it...you'll like it. read more

Had a birthday party here recently and the whole thing was a disaster. Starting with the waitress she sat us in designated seats so she could remember our orders which didn't work out we still had to point out everyone's order. Then I ordered a simple cup of soup which was forgot. When I asked about it she lied and said it was in a window which took another 10 minutes to get. Food was mediocre at best. Would not recommend this place. BJs is across the street for a real dinning experience me and my family will not be returning read more

I had a bison burger, which was fantastic with fries. I had my order delivered and game to me at a great temperature.

This place is pretty nice! They have indoor and outdoor seating. It has a mix between an upscale aesthetic and a pub vibe. The service was attentive and the timing of the food was perfect. Overall I would recommend trying them out. We started with two drinks. One blueberry lemonade drink and one strawberry mojito mojito. The mojito was definitely better as the blueberry drink was a bit sweet and artificial tasting. The mojito was just right and I would definitely get it again. We also had the green chili corn bread (not pictured) which was good and served in a cute little cast iron. The steak was very good, the crispy onions were a nice crunch, and it paired very well with the flavorful garlic mashed potatoes. The seasonal veggies were great and seasoned very well. The Cajun Walleye was a little bland and could have had more Cajun flavor. read more

See all

I think I definitely prefer this location over the old town one for ease of access as well as busy-ness. We were seated right away in a booth in the back. The restaurant is dimly lit and very comfortable. The music wasn't too loud and very enjoyable for the atmosphere. Our server was friendly and prompt for the most part, however towards the end, she was very chatty with other tables and did not come back to ours for quite some time. For drinks, my husband had the smoked maple old fashioned and said it was delicious. I opted for the butterfly effect - a fun color and very flavorful. For food, we ordered coconut shrimp as an appetizer which was pretty tasty, especially with the sauce. My main dish was the bison burger and it was fantastic! The onion straws were crispy and delicious, I only wish there were more. For dessert, I went with key lime pie and it too was delicious! It's on the pricier side, but a very enjoyable meal. read more

Food is always great. I usually take it to go. Love their chicken and ribs. Service is always good.

Last time I was in I had a steak. It was seasoned well and cooked to order, and it was tender and juicy. We've never had a bad meal. Menu is a bit dtsle and needs some updating. read more

Austin's American Grill - Steak was cooked nicely. It was tender and juicy. - New American Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

Should be fined for false advertising. Came to get the haystack sandwich advertised on their online menu and it's not even close. SiE is considerably smaller than picture. Almost no onions. Fried are old. No meat. Stay away read more

We had a rough start to our dining experience with a long wait to be seated. One of the servers noticed we had been waiting a long time and seated us. From then on, we were taken care of and both food and service were awesome, thanks to Marcus E. We will go back. read more

Everything ordered lacked flavor. Very bland food such a disappointment. Had dinner for my brother's birthday last night. The appearance and ambiance is fabulous. However it gives a false appearance for a great meal. Waited a bit for our cocktails. We each added a small salad which was amazing. So very good. Messed up on my dressing, I didn't complain I just ate it. Server was pleasant. I ordered New York to share with my husband. Bake potato was fair. Loaded with too much cheese. Otherwise ok. My husbands part of the steak was rare, we asked for well done no pink. Didn't happen. Sis in law had white chicken and rib combo. Very unimpressive. White meat is known to be dry so you would think they would remedy that with cooking or provide a sauce. Lacked flavor as well. Ribs were so so nothing g to make you want more. Brother had prime rib where as he had to add salt and pepper for flavor. Even had to add flavor to the au jus. No horseradish. Brother had to ask for this. No bread or rolls were offered at dinner. Graciously they offered my brother a complimentary dessert. Asked for bread pudding they brought cookie dessert, sent back and received very delicious bread pudding with vanilla ice cream. That was the best thing there. Server was pleasant and so friendly. Would we return again probably not, it was our first time. Didn't really enjoy. Pricey for 4. read more

Very hit or miss. Came here twice in two weeks for work functions and got a full rack of ribs with a side of quinoa and rice palif both times. First time it was amazing-- meat was falling off the bone, absolutely delicious. I was honestly shocked at how good it was. Second time was the complete opposite. Ribs were dry and chewy (think overcooked pork chop) and the rice was undercooked. I'm not one to ever send food back, but I'm mad at myself for not. Complete hit or miss kind of restaurant. read more

Bison burgers were more than medium and not juicy or flavorful. Buns were not grilled. Plates were not hot so everything cooled too quickly. Enjoyed the single cornbread crouton on salad. Service was ok. read more

I went here with a friend while I was visiting Loveland. We started in the bar, but ended up moving to a table on the patio. We got our drinks and ordered food in the bar. The drinks were delivered to our table in the bar and food was delivered to our table on the patio. Once our food was delivered, no one really paid attention to us. The bartender stopped by once during the hour that we were there to check and see if we needed anything else. It wasn't really a problem for us, but I could see where it might become one if someone had wanted additional refreshments for dessert or...Whatever. Fortunately, we didn't. I would suggest a little more intentional way of handing off tables. Overall, the experience was quite good. Food was excellent the drinks top notch. And, the people we did encounter we're very nice. We just an encounter them often enough. I would definitely return. read more

Tried Austin's for the first time as we were visiting our kids over the 4th of July weekend. Ryan S was our server and he was outstanding. He was attentive, fast and anticipated our every need. Our choices ranged from the bison meatloaf, the haystack sandwich, the bison burger and the ale smoked pork tenderloin. Everyone was equally jealous of everyone else's choice. Everything was delicious. Well worth coming here! read more

Austin's American Grill - New American Near Me - Greeley, Colorado

Brunch was delicious and the coffee is tasty! I had the French toast with apple compote and could have licked the plate clean.