I've been going to this place for 40 years and they've always been incredibly kind to me and the pizza is actually my favorite in the city. I was a pizza driver for 20 years and every driver knew that these guys had the bravest and most knowledgeable drivers around. Truly awesome to see a small business survive this long. read more

Ordered pizza and her delivery driver never showed up. Manager stated that she didn't care and would not refund me my money. Still waiting . read more

Can't beat it. They let us know ahead of time, it would be longer than usual for delivery. They made it within the quoted time. Pizza and bread sticks were fresh and the onion rings still crispy! Can't wait to enjoy again soon. read more

Aunt Polly's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Awesome neighborhood pizza joint! Quality is consistent and pizza is always tasty. Highly recommend!

This was the worst Pizza I have ever seen or tasted when they were on Michigan Street back in the early 2000 they were the bomb I went to the one on East Street last night I had asked for ground beef pepperoni and mushroom right tell me why I had eight chunks of ground beef the pepperoni was only around the crust one slice per slice of pizza when I lifted my cheese there was no pepperoni up under none of the middle of the pie it was just horrible I wish I can get my $28 that I spent back but we all know that's not going to happen they straight trash my dog wouldn't even eat the pizza we took a bite through the whole thing on thing away he was so mad I was trying to take a picture he said not just throwing in the trash cuz this is just crazy he was pissed read more

Regularly order from here....always super polite over the phone and food is always on point....hidden secret but definitely try the biscuits and apple butter....thank me later!! read more

Pizza is always terrific. Delivery was quick and the driver was nice and friendly. We love Aunt Polly's!

Do they have an app that has a tracker on it so we can see where the driver is does anybody know that I don't see no app like other pizza places and you have to call in it shows you can't do it online to put your credit card in does anybody know how to do all that read more

Owner was EXTREMELY rude! Not welcoming AT ALL, very mean and nasty. When I first walked in the worker was VAPING while fixing food, also the place has an awful smell to it. Would NOT recommend at all. PLEASE spend your money on elsewhere. read more

Horrible greasy high in fat food if you care about yourself don't eat here disgustingly made greasy never cooked right and the disrespectful dirty stuff that they have there are disgusting just like their service and their food read more

The service was great. The guy at the front greeted me and made me feel at home in his establishment. A really good man. I appreciated that. I love that the place is open late - gives you an option to eat something other then McDonalds or Taco Bell. the food was delicious too. That said, it's expensive - extremely overpriced. It's tough times but most menu items are ten bucks - including the chicken tenders and fries. there is NO DESIGNATED PARKING. Most cars just parked on the Main Street. There is also no indoor dining option available - it's a cramped space and they have all their inventory stacked up by the entrance. With just five customers including myself waiting for our meals in there it felt a little cramped. read more

Aunt Polly's Pizza - Chicken Tenders and Fries - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

An amazing spot with incredible pizza. So glad it's so close to my home and my job! Yay read more

Aunt Polly's Pizza - Specialty Made Pizza. I LOVE Aunt Pollys! They are soooooo kind! - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This spot brings back a lot of good memories! I think I eat here mainly for that versus the food lol. Eating here keeps me grounded lol. No really this is not a bad little dive. The staff here are beyond cool and always polite even when they're swamped! They definitely make you not mind spending your money. The neighborhood looks a little sketch for sure but they will deliver almost anywhere in the city! Everything here is solid. I'd say better than what you'd expect from a divey hole in the wall. The star for me is their breadsticks with the cheese sauce and the wings! The breadsticks are always fresh and have never been even slightly overcooked. They're always super soft and seasoned just right. Everything here is always made to order and it's evident!. The wings are good as well and don't need to hide behind sauce. I'd definitely recommend them for a cool order In, Netflix no pressure kind of night! read more

Aunt Polly's Pizza - Patiently waiting for curbside service! - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

WORST PIZZA/EXPERIENCE EVER! We waited two hours for our pizza (when the place was 5 minutes from our hotel), after I had tried to cancel the order because of the wait and us being exhausted and wanting to just go to bed, but I was told she couldn't cancel the order at that point so we waited an additional 45 minutes before our cold, soggy, disgusting pizza and mushrooms were delivered.So I called a third time requesting a refund at which time I was told that she was unable to process a refund until the following day when a manager was there. I called the next day and was told that I would receive a call back. When a man who says he was an owner called me back he spoke to me about my experience, made a bunch of excuses, then said he would call the lady from the previous night and call me back. He called back hours later with more excuses (moot at this point as I was livid) and said that he couldn't process a refund to our card so he would have to mail cash. He took my address. It has now been 6 weeks and no refund. What a rediculous scam - DO NOT ORDER PIZZA HERE! Terrible business practice, terrible management, scam. read more

Great pizza and bread sticks. Kevin is the greatest!! Three generations of Aunt Polly's lovers

We were in town for Horrorhound and ordered a pizza for delivery to the hotel, like we've done 1,000 other times. We must've caught Aunt Polly on a bad day. We had to wait for an hour and 15 minutes only to get a call from the delivery person asking us to come down to the lobby to get our food. That's never happened before. I could forgive them for that if the food had been delicious. It was not. The pizza was over cooked and burnt on the bottom, our jalepeno poppers were under cooked and soggy, and our soda was warm. This was by far the worst food we've ever gotten when ordering food to our hotel. Local favorite???? Seriously??? read more

Me and my husband tried Aunt Polly's last night and I have to say one of the best pizzas we've had in awhile!!! The dough was so soft and fluffy and the breadsticks were to die for!!! read more

We ordered a chef salad and a small pep pizza. Sent my son to pick up the order and he brought back some hot wings and a large meat lovers. Person stated they were very busy and that was all they had available. WOW! Is all I can say saved 10 dollars but can't eat hot wings or all that meat on pizza. They didn't deserve any stars read more

Absolutely the worst customer service ever! The employees must all be on something! Waited 2+ hours for a pizza, never came finally had to call them just to get accused that a man ordered it and gave them the wrong address and phone number even though it was paid by card. I ordered and paid for the phone I am a female born raised and still am. Now trying to refuse monies back! So disappointed. We always try to support the small business, but this is just an example of why so many are struggling! read more

Talking about excellence, pizza at its finest. Do not forget about the breadsticks..and that nacho cheese sause is the best I ever had..Dont let the outside fool you, don't let the looks of the inside scare you...its simple..pizza made right with love and time..one thing for sure is patients. They may say 30 min and it might take longer but the proof is in the food..One of its finest, the Boss is there almost everyday greeting people..only wish is if they had seating inside and out..this place would go forever In a local hot spot..Thank You! read more

See all

The worst experience ever never will be back Dave. Your employee Angie is these absolute worst customer service I have ever received my order was wrong order wings dry with sauce on the side I actually tried a pizza week before and the sausage was tiny crumbles your cook even agreed with me saying it was different explained I was unable to eat this sausage it was spicy like Italian and not the same as last week. I understand inventory mis habs I don't understand why you would put that back on a customer regular I might add that will never be back. read more

I've ordered from here a few times. They are open super late and don't make mistakes. The quality of the food is average and I'd guess that all of the ingredients come from Gordon's Food Store. Delivery is a bit slow and the sauces are usually tepid. If they had competition in the area by a late night delivery chain I doubt they would make it. read more

Complete horrible service. I waited nearly 2 hours to get my food and when the pizza finally arrived it was cold. They were quick to run my card but not give me my food in a timely manner. I do not recommend this place To anyone. And to top it off you call to find out where your food is and they have attitude like if you are bothering them. Worst experience ever read more

I come to Aunt pollys all the time. This $%&%^2 I come to aunt pollys all the time and this is the very first time that I have been extremely disappointed! I ordered the special with the pizza,breadsticks,wings and drink. My pizza was extremely hard and had absolutely NO SAUCE when I asked for just light sauce. My breadsticks were disgusting and were not made right at all. I asked for 5 wings to be barbecue and 5 buffalo. They mixed the sauces together on all 10 of my wings!! And I called to explain to them and he was very rude telling me the was no way they messed up smh! I will not be going back after eating my 30.00!! Very unprofessional!!! read more

See all

OMG It took me 10 years living in Indy to find this family owned business. I cant stop eating from here...Staff is super friendly and always happy to see u..Amazing specials nightly and the size of their pies, wow is all i can say. If you havnt tried them, u r totally missing out..OPEN late and delivery city wide read more

I remembered Aunt Polly's being great when I was a kid. I don't think I'd had any food from there since the 90s. It was on my list of places to try ever since I came back to the Indy area. After moving back to the east side after twenty-plus years, I finally got some Aunt Polly's delivery just before the new year. It was a Friday night, and they were apparently extremely busy. I was asked to hold, and the phone was set down where I could hear several other orders being taken. I decided to hang up and called back a little later, hoping to let the rush die down. I was able to place my order right away when I called back. I ordered way too much, but I was entertaining kids. The wait was over an hour and a half. The delivery driver was nice. The food on the other hand was not so great. One of the pizzas seemed undercooked with a heavy, doughy crust and gooey cheese, while the other two spent a little too much time in the oven. They had dark, tough cheese and large charred pieces falling off the underside. The breadsticks were the worst I have ever had. Heavy, undercooked, and inedible. I even tried to bake the breadsticks longer in the oven later on, but I ultimately threw most of them away. Some of the food seemed to have sat around a while longer than the rest. Along with the cold marinara and nacho cheese that came with the breadsticks, the breaded mushrooms I got were lukewarm, soggy, and falling apart. A far cry from what I remember way back when. Their mushrooms used to be my favorite thing on the menu. I didn't try them myself, but the mozzarella sticks seemed to be a hit. They appeared to be hot and crisp. The leftover mozz sticks reheated well along with the breaded tenderloin. The tenderloin was eaten by the biggest food critic I know, so it must have been good since there were no complaints. The best thing we received was the side salad. Even though it was made with Iceberg, it was fresh and came with a lot of toppings. It was better than the side salads at most places. Of course, the cheapest thing I ordered was the star of this mess. It was highly disappointing to drop so much money and receive so little especially when most of the food was barely edible. My memories of Aunt Polly's have been permanently crushed. I doubt that I would order from here again. Such a waste. I still cringe with regret. read more

Very friendly staff. One of the few places open late night. Food is pretty good. Whenever I have the late night munchies this is my go to spot. read more

The pizza we had was very good. Ordered pizza at 5:50 was told it would be ready in 35 minutes I arrived at 6:25. Told me 6 more minutes at 7:00 I left with my pizza. It was a Friday they were busy. I will give it another shot but I think I will show up 15 minutes late. Or maybe they could call me when it is ready. If pizza was on time I would of gave them 5 stars. read more

Aunt Polly's pizza definitely deserves better than 3 stars! We ordered delivery from there tonight, and the pizza came hot, fast and reasonably priced. It was also teeming with toppings and absolutely delicious. These people don't skimp on anything! The cheese sauce and marinara that came with the breadsticks was also reasonably sized. A very solid pizza experience, this place is a good go to for pizza night! read more

Aunt Polly's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This is the worst shit I have ever eaten. I ate it multiple times because see had to eat out at my job. I haven't eaten anything that sucks more. read more

Rating is for pizza only, which is to die for! I've only ordered 2x and both times they have forgotten a sauce. Also, both times I have paid over the phone with a credit card and both times the delivery driver said payment wasn't placed and they needed to run my card again.... I will check in am to make sure I wasn't double charged. If they were more organized, this place would be 5 stars for sure! read more

The pictures on here don't do it justice. This pizza is really fire. So is the meatball sub AND their deliver...

Aunt Polly's Pizza on the surface appeared to be a good pizza place, stone oven, hand tossed!! Much to my dismay, the pizza was horrible, one of the two we ordered was under done, the crust tasted like it was frozen, the sauce out of a can, the cheese fake. Don't waste your money here, it is not worth it. read more

A long time. East side staple. Late night delivery....which rocks. Pizza is good, my friends love the wings, but their cheesy garlic bread is yummy!! Thanks for still rocking after all these years! read more

We were staying at the Baymont off 465 on Brookville. Quick overnight on the way down south. There was nothing but fast food in the area, so we took a chance on Aunt Polly's. I had a wonderful old school pizza pie and my wife had the wet wings. Seriously, this place was the bomb. Pizza cheese was just how you love it from old school neighborhood pizza joints and the wings were fantastic. You know you are taking chances getting pizza AND wings from an unknown spot out of town. No disappointments here. Can not wait for our next lay over in SE Indy. read more

Ordered from here on the recommendation from the hotel I was staying at. Called to order and it was clear the person was talking to a coworker while trying to take my order. Annoying Said oh well, supposed to be good. 1.5 hours later pizza came and was worst I have had in quite a while. Crust was hard, and pizza had no flavor. Ended up just throwing it away and a waste of $25 read more

Since I moved to Indy a few months ago, I've been looking for a really good pizza. I've tried the local Pizza hut, dominoes, and Jockamos. Aunt Polly's is my favorite so far. It's not fancy or creative like Jockamos but it's a really good solid regular pizza with generous toppings. The crust was perfect, light & airy with the right amount of crisp the outside. Seems to be wood fired. Service on the phone we helpful and delivery arrived in 40 minutes. I always expect delivery to take about an hour from a small place so that was good to me. Only thing I would have liked better would be if cheese was a little browner on top. Overall, very happy and will order again! read more

I have been eating Aunt Polly's pizza since I was a child. It's always been a favorite for me. I think the breadsticks are always a family favorite. Their pizza sauce has always been on the sweet side. I remember being 5 years old and sharing pizza subs with my dad. I had the breadsticks last week and it's still the same old wonderful taste and it takes me back. Of course they haven't always been in this location, but the food hasn't changed. I live in Franklin now and I don't get around to them very often, but they are a long standing brand in the Indianapolis food book. read more

I am not the best critic when it comes to pizza because it is not one of my favorite meals. But, I do enjoy good pizza. Aunt Polly's is okay, but not what I like. The sauce is REALLY sweet, and The pizza is crazy greasy also. But If the sauce wasn't sweet I would love this pizza. The crust was well cooked, the cheese was salty, and pepperoni was good. The bread sticks were also pretty good. It was a tad bit cold but that is to be expected in this cold weather and the distance. We will probably not order again due to the sauce. But that's because my family doesn't enjoy sweet sauce. If you enjoy a sugary sauce this is the place for you! The pizza delivery driver was very kind and sweet. We did end up tipping him $10 for driving out here in the cold. read more

A dive for sure if you looking looking for a thick sinfully cheesy and kinda greasy pizza you found it but it's like a one a month or less or you will get clogged arteries kinda place Update: we got wings for the first time they were well cooked and very well seasoned. Don't look over there onion rings, cheese sticks, and breaded mushrooms just because there a pizza place. Mmmmmm best breaded mushrooms ever! read more