Customer service. I ordered a large pizza and they gave me a small. I questioned the size and they didn't do anything. They rather me leave with a small pizza instead of making more money for a large one. read more

This pizza is . I come here 1-2x per week. For years now. If you want to have a spectacular slice of pizza, buy 2 slices of GRANDMA pizza. I promise you, it will not disappoint. Owner and staff are nice, easy to order, walk in and walk out 5 min later with a toasty pizza in hand. read more

Great pizza. Personal sized (10in) with pepperoni and ricotta - tons of cheese, very tasty. I like a crispy crust, which it had. read more

Atlantis Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atlantis, Florida

Live around the corner from this restaurant. Nice little local pizza shop. Staff is super friendly but only when the boss/owner is there. Food is inconsistent at times. Good for a quick bite but not impressive. read more

Order spaghetti and meatballs to be delivered came promptly with a small salad dressing and some garlic rolls. Spaghetti was a huge portion with three large meatballs and tasted delicious. I asked for extra sauce and they certainly accommodated me. Great job Atlantis my go to for spaghetti for sure. read more

Best NY style pizza. Made fresh while you wait. Crust was amazing. Dough is made fresh on site every day.

Do Not go through Uber eats with this place! You will get missing items constantly and quality will be thoroughly lacking! Uber Eats no longer has a customer service number that answers so If you're missing items, you're out of luck. Shameful. read more

Always keep making pizza of all kinds all day long. If you sell out keep fresh dough on hand to keep making pizza . Very sad read more

See all

Cheese Pizza. DECENT. Had a cheese slice which had a pretty good taste to it with the cheesiness factor being adequate. A small slice which was cut wide costing $2.50 a slice. This place is basically a takeout establishment with limited dine in seating. ATLANTIS PIZZERIA is located across the street from the Lantana Airport and I don't consider this area to be in Atlantis. The city of Atlantis is a Country Club with it's own municipality. While the pizza here was alright it wouldn't be my go to place for pizza. read more

We had this pizza from a group purchase and loved it. We went back and got individual pizzas. Get the full size because the crust didn't seem the same to us. read more

This is not Keto friendly and I don't give one delicious crust about it! Was stuck at work a few extra hours and starving. At the inkling of a coworker we call up this place. Cheerful service over the phone and average deliver time. The pizza did arrive piping hot and delicious. Taste was pretty balanced with sauce, crust, and cheese though I found it pretty greasy. Went back a few months later to pick up an order. Again great food and great service but noticeable hostile patrons were pacing waiting on orders. I got my White Veggie quick and was downing a slice by the first red light out the door. You gotta indulge in your local joint every so often. read more

Ordered eggplant parm with spaghetti. Could hardly find the eggplant. Literally 2 bites of eggplant and a pound of spaghetti. So disappointing. read more

Atlantis Pizza - Atlantis Pizza Eggplant Parmigiana with Pasta Dinner - Pizza Near Me - Atlantis, Florida

Amazing food and service, I recommend this place for locals but it's kinda pricey though. I recommend getting a Veggie Pizza or the meat lovers pizza and their Stromboli's are to die for. And service was good but nothing extraordinarily. So if you're in the area this is a good spot. read more

This place has tasty pizza. Not too greasy and the meat lovers option is great. The sizes are descent. Service took a descent time.

Wanted to try a different pizza place in the area and I'm happy I did! Ordered a Sicilian for pick up ( which was considerably less expensive then the other pizza shops in the area). But it was 100 delish the sauce was super fresh and had nice pieces of basil and garlic and the crust held up perfectly and was golden and crispy. This will be my new go to!! And the staff was also super kind and patient! read more

What a disappointing experience. I wanted to enjoy pizza with my parents and was told the original pizza had a burnt crust. When my parents called to complain about the quality, they were told only a small amount was burnt and the pizza is ok. Are you kidding me? Paying premium for a burnt pizza? A new pizza was delivered. Too bad the center was soggy. read more

Atlantis Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atlantis, Florida

We just ordered a margarita pizza form there and it was raw and under done! Asked to to be crispy lol! Called to express our disappointment and the owner screams at me and asked "if I know what a margarita pizza looks like? REALLY?! NEVER AGAIN!!! Extremely rude and unprofessional. read more

Atlantis Pizza - Does this even look like a real margarita pizza? Not! Burnt basil and diced tomatoes! Go back to culinarily school!!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Atlantis, Florida

I spill pizza sauce on my shirt every time and I don't even care. The pizza is so good. I enjoy all types of pizza and appreciate each for what they are. If you are looking flaky/fluffy/crispy crust, and a sauce like fresh tomato sweet, not too acidic or overpowering so I can eat a whole veggie pizza and my heartburn doesn't strangle me at 5am. The base is crispy on the bottom and smooth top below the cheese that is just right. I've been in south Florida 20 years now, this is in my top 5 including miami. Whew. I love this funing pizza. This is the pizza if you want pizza tonight. I have to restart whatever I'm watching 3x unless it's Seinfeld and i can just let it run. Sue me read more

The food is decent and I've been ordering takeout and delivery quite a bit from them recently. The last time I ordered delivery, my son answered the door and brought in the food. About 20 minutes later, I received a call from Atlantis telling me they will never deliver to me again because my son didn't write in a tip! He didn't know to do anything other than write my initials because I was on an urgent phone call and did not think to tell him how to write in the tip. Regardless, this was a one time misunderstanding and it clearly was not an adult answering the door. For them to call back and threaten me was extremely unprofessional and borderline stalkerish. I've always tipped 20% and clearly they keep tabs on their customers tipping history. Their food is far from good enough to order from them again after that very strange incident. There is another pizzeria that I just tried that has free delivery (higher tip for the driver) and better food. ETA: they've made several errors in my past orders, nothing huge. I just brushed that under the rug until now. read more

Cook Chaz and new guy ( Grant I believe) it was his first day, did an amazing job!!!! I had specific instructions for my food allergies and they acted like it was not problem at all!!! 10 stars out of 5, absolutley amazing!!!!! I was planning on going to Rosalita's but after a bad experience took a chance and came here, I am SOOOO SOOOO SOOO glad that I did!!! I will be a full time regular customer!!!! read more

I loved this place so much! It had a good bite and it was very juicy, the flavor was amazing. Cant wait to try different things from this place. read more

See all

Excellent pizza and always nice people to deal with I really love if the crust, not greasy Definitely one of my go to pizza places read more

Steak & cheese sub is a go to always fresh n good quality cut up peppers soft fresh bread. I Order here at least 3 times a week delivery is always accurate timing ! read more

Had the Atlantis pizza. It was really delicious; had artichoke hearts and broccoli . Ordered the Roma salad and the guy forgot about it =\ but made another one right on the spot. Salad was delicious, cheese tasted really fresh. read more

Atlantis Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atlantis, Florida

See all

Rudy and the rest of the team at Atlantis pizza are not only extremely friendly, but they make THE BEST pizza in the state of Florida. I am not exaggerating. I have had Dominic's, Boynton Pizza, Bronx Tale pizza, Jimmy's Brooklyn Pizza, Dominos, Papa Johns, Little Caesar's, Pizza Hut, Danny's Pizza, Chicago Uno pizza (Orlando), Downtown pizza (a close second), etc... this place completely blows them away. Eat here and you will 110% not be disappointed. If you are, you're part of the problem. Eat here NOW! read more

The customer service here is horrible, I placed and order , and I ordered all the time , literally 6 seconds later I called and changed order , so order came wrong , I called and asked for them to fix it and they refused , saying that I was wrong !! The owner is horrible and provides the worst customer service, I will never order again !!! read more

Ordered 3 different pizzas, plain, veggie, and pepperoni. All were very good but I personally like a crispier crust. read more

Atlantis Pizza - Atlantis Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Atlantis, Florida

One of my favorite pizza places in town. Sicilian is great. Stromboli is great. Gyros are great. Calzones are great. Pizza is pretty good too. read more

This is my go to pizza place after trying so many other pizza places , this is a great family owned and ran place

Good pizza, reminds me of pizza upstate. Costumer service and atmosphere is really homey

A thin crust ricotta and mazorella cheese with green peppers and black olives and pepperoni and some olive oil its the best I've ever had yet!! Totally recommended !!! read more

Atlantis Pizza - This pizza was absolutely delicious and it was my first time trying white pizza it was to die for! It felt like New York City!! - Pizza Near Me - Atlantis, Florida

Absolutely delicious food! I eat here about 3x per week! I work close by and always have a great meal! The owner and his staff are very personable and friendly! They go out of their way for me and I love it! read more

Our goto pizza place! The food is scrumptious (The Pasta Faggioli soup is to die for!) and they pay attention to any special requests we make. The owners and staff have always been incredibly nice, and when we order delivery it has always been earlier than the timeframe they give us and more importantly piping hot. If they have a problem or are out of something they call very quickly to see if you'd like a replacement or credit. The delivery service they partner with Slice, has a handy app and clearly state their rewards program. Overall I love our experience with them so far & have no desire to get from someone else. Thank you for great customer service and quality food guys! My full time work/college student self appreciates it! read more

We've ordered take out/delivery here a number of times. There are a couple tables, but I think they are more for waiting on an order than actually dining there. We usually order a couple pasta dishes and there is always enough for lunch the next day. Note: if you get anything baked it will be smothered in a ton of cheese. The pasta dinners come with a salad and garlic rolls. I'm not a fan of the garlic rolls as they come across hard, greasy, and with too much garlic. The salad that comes with it is a good size and the Large Salad is a great deal because it is enough for 3 or 4 people to eat along with a pizza. The pizza is good - not great, but good. Delivery is generally ahead of the promised time so the food is still nice and hot. read more

Not crazy about their pizza...tasted like frozen pizza bought at a grocery store....had 2 sliced of the 12 inch and didn't feel like going back for more..but nice staff. read more

Atlantis Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Atlantis, Florida

This is my favorite pizza place in the whole area! The sauce and cheese ratio is amazing! I really recommend coming here it's a nice family place and has amazing Stromboli and chicken wings! read more

It's a decent little place to swing In for a slice. Decent Pie fast friendly with a nice Sunday 5 dollar special

Walked into Atlantis around 9 on a Thursday and ordered a 16 inch pepperoni to go. Pizza was ready in a couple minutes and took it home. Pretty good! Quality ingredients, thin crust NYC style pizza. Pie was just slightly undercooked but can't quibble too much. Just wish they did an 18 incher, 16 is their largest size. Would return for more. read more

I had a bad experience the week they were changing management. The new owner / manager did contact me about it and attempted to make it right. I'm not sure if I will return, but I am satisfied with the outcome. read more

This place has good food and many of my fiends and I frequent a couple of times a week. The problem I have is that although they list a "must wear mask" on the window the cooks refuse to wear a mask when making the food. I have asked several times but they don't care. We will not be returning. They are looking to be shut down. read more