We have been using Arlington for years. Always had a great experience recommend with no issues.

I recently discovered a Jeweler that has consistently met all of my requirements and then some; that Jeweler is Arlington Jewelers on Franklin Street, Nutley. Arlington Jewelers is a family oriented business with Sal at the helm. His adult children are often seen behind the counter assisting other customers. Entering the store, your initially impressed with all of the displays; neat and orderly, organized by type and size, a banquet for the eyes making your choices stress free. Each time I visit Arlington Jewelers I am warmly greet by the Family. From a simple repair to finding that correct piece for someone special, the Family is there assisting you without your feeling rushed or compromised. There IS a difference in the manner in which Arlington Jewelers interacts with their customers all of which becomes evident with each visit. Having been to other Jewelers in the past, it's continually refreshing to do business with Arlington Jewelers as they remain highly recommended. read more

Beautiful place and Sal is still the owner from when I was a kid. This is the only place my parents would buy jewelry from. Gorgeous jewelry and the place sparkles. Quality jewelry and very nice, knowledgeable owner. read more

I have had the pleasure of working with Sal from Arlington Jewelers for nearly 45 years and referred countless friends who are as impressed as I am with their integrity. No other jeweler has ever been able to come close to their quality for their price. Today I looked for my tennis bracelet which I have not worn in years, I immediately called Sal and he said "It doesn't matter how long ago, if you left it here I have it". Sure enough it was there, I brought it in for repair in 2018! That's incredible service, that's why customers love Arlington Jewelers! read more

Arlington Jewelers - Jewelry Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

This place does cheap work while charging thousands of dollars and then LIES when they have to fix something. Absolutely despicable. My now-husband spent thousands of dollars for a custom engagement ring. It was beautiful, and they even tweaked some parts of it after we were engaged. However, not even six months after that, a small diamond fell out. Arlington replaced it for free (more to come about this). We were happy until the following year a second, larger diamond fell out!! I went to a new jeweler because I didn't trust Arlington anymore. A year after that A THIRD DIAMOND fell out. THREE LOST DIAMONDS IN THREE YEARS. (I don't do heavy work while wearing my ring. There is no reason for this, even if I did.) I'm now in the process of recreating the ring with Jared's because of their protection plan, and when they inspected my ring, they pointed out all the worn down or missing prongs, saw a cracked diamond, and discovered a CUBIC ZIRCONIA. Arlington DID NOT REPLACE the first lost diamond - they LIED TO US and gave us a fake stone instead. They cannot be trusted with your business. read more

Arlington Jewelers - Third missing stone is on bottom - Jewelry Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

My family has been going here for over 30 years. I have loved everything I got from Sal and can't wait to get my kids jewelry from Sal.

Arlington jewelers has always been there when I needed a watch battery or repair, always welcoming and helpful. Today I had the pleasure of buying a diamond anniversary ring in white gold for my spouse of 30 years and they were just as helpful and friendly as they have always been... and they gave me a great deal. It's great to be able to buy jewelry from a local merchant you can trust. Further, they were able to size the ring and have ready in a few minutes while we waited. read more

Sal and his staff were a pleasure to deal with. The quality and workmanship of the jewelry was exquisite, with some pieces being so unique I have not have seen anything close ay other jewelers.. He helped my wife and I with a beautiful ring that was breathtaking. His quality and prices and the best around. He has been at this location for over 40 years, and once you visit his store, you can understand why. Before you go elsewhere, you should do yourself a service and and stop by his store to take a look at his jewelry. You won't be disappointed. read more

I had several high end watches that I needed some links removed from. My preferred jeweler is on summer hours, so I figured I would give this place another shot, as my first time there they broke a piece on my watch (during battery replacement). I should have known... "Not today Pal! I'm busy and by myself. Come back when my son is here (the one who broke my watch last time) - try next Tuesday." A full week from the day I visited. I didn't say I needed this done on the same day, and there was zero discussion around it before he dismissed me and walked away. What awful customer service. Never again. read more

I am so pleased with the necklace Sal custom made for me based on a picture I provided. I wanted a pendant with a yellow diamond. It was more beautiful than the picture! Pleasant and welcoming family atmosphere with passion for the trade. read more

Arlington Jewelers - Yellow diamond pendant. So beautiful! - Jewelry Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

See all

Arlington Jewelers is by far the best! Very knowledgeable, friendly and welcoming staff. My experience in that establishment was a 10 out of a 10. Sal and his kids went out of their way to make sure I was happy with my diamond pendant I customized at their beautiful shop. Will definitely be going back and recommending this place to family and friends! read more

Most amazing jewelry store stocked with a huge range of selection. Sal and his children are very helpful and the prices are unbeatable. Hands down the best jewelry store. read more

Many years ago I went in to see Sal at Arlington Jewelers in Nutley with a picture of a pendant that was popular that Christmas at a national jewelry chain. I wanted to buy something similar as a present for my wife. Sal made a one of a kind piece for two thirds of the price that the national chain was charging and my wife loves her pendant. Since then we are are treated respectfully and fairly whenever we shop there. We highly recommend this local business. read more

My husband was introduced to Sal and his family when looking for the perfect engagement ring. I am so happy he got my ring at Arlington Jewelers because not only is there selection beautiful but we trust them so much. My ring is absolutely STUNNING (pear shaped ring with halo shown in images). Not only is the entire family warm and inviting, they are so helpful and genuinely honest. You can tell they are so passionate about there work/business and truly love what they do. I will be referring everyone to them because they are that good. read more

Arlington Jewelers - Thank you Sal and - Jewelry Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

Arlington Jewelers came highly recommended to me by my boyfriend's mom who has gotten several pieces of jewelry custom made here. I had fallen in love with a ring I saw at another jewelry store, however, my boyfriend and I wanted to shop around a bit more before buying it. We then went to see Sal at Arlington Jewelers and he had a ring that was SO similar to the one I had seen at the other jewelry store. The only difference was that Sal's ring had three diamonds in it instead of two diamonds and a sapphire like the other one I had seen. My boyfriend and Sal arranged to have a sapphire put into the ring I wanted and I am truly in love with it. It is so beautiful and well made, I can't stop looking at it on my finger! Sal was also a pleasure to deal with. I also purchased a sterling silver infinity necklace here, which I really like and wear all the time. I highly recommend Arlington Jewelers and definitely look forward to buying more pieces here. read more

Arlington Jewelers - My beautiful ring made by Arlington Jewelers! - Jewelry Near Me - Nutley, New Jersey

See all

Went in for watch repair. 50 yr old 18 karat gold, my father's who passed away. After receiving repair watch face fell apart. Returned for final repair. Picked it up and got it home. Realized the piece that tracks the minutes was missing. Returned for a 3rd time and asked for a refund and the missing piece. Sal(the owner) got upset and asked me to leave and never come back. This was the only thing my father left me and he demolished it. There were others in the store so I kept my cool and left. He left me no choice but to seek legal counsel. read more

Arlington Jewelers is an amazing family run business that I would highly recommend to anyone! The customer service is incredible and the entire family is kind, helpful, patient, and very knowledgeable. My engagement ring and wedding band were custom made and my husband just recently had an additional Christmas gift custom made for me. Everytime I walk in, the owners greet you as if you were a member of their family. The quality of work is impeccable and the family is meticulous when creating pieces. They make it their priority to ensure that every customer leaves with the piece of jewelry he or she envisioned. They will custom design anything you ask for and the selection in the store is beautiful as well! Make sure to visit this store! read more

Used to think highly of this place as I have had custom jewelry made here as well as my wedding rings. While shopping for our wedding rings, my mother decided to upgrade her setting for her diamond engagement ring. She picked one out, he put everything in a bag and put it away and said he'd call when it was ready. A month later she goes in, looks at the ring and says hmm this diamond looks different. Sal, the owner, insisted it was because it was a new setting. She took his word for it but was still leary so went to a gemologist to compare her original appraisal to this and found out the diamond Sal gave her was NOT the diamond she left with him. It was a piece of crap. My mother went back and confronted him and only then did he finally admit he lost it. But who tries to pass off a crummy diamond before telling the customer the truth. I suspect he didn't expect my mother to have a 40 year old appraisal and would have gotten away with it if she didn't. He did eventually replace the crummy diamond with a better one, but still nothing compared to the value of her original diamond. He is a shady businessman and I would not trust him with precious items. He has lost my business forever and many others as I have told others this incredibly crooked story. Please do yourself a favor and go elsewhere. read more

I brought my brand new watch to Arlington Jewelers to get the band adjusted. After the first day of wearing it, the buckle kept coming apart. I brought the watch back and he said it would be a couple dollars to repair. I waited a week and called to check the status. He told me that the watch was ready. I came in (on a Friday) and he stated that he didn't have the watch ready and that it would be $15 to be repaired by his watch guy. He told me to come in Monday to pick up the watch. I called that Monday (3 times) and no one answered. That Wednesday I went back to pick the watch up and it had a chrome buckle for a dark brushed aluminum watch. He told me the replacement would be from the factory but it wasn't. He told me there was nothing he can do and that he would give me my money back and that he would put the watch back in the condition that I had originally brought it. He said the watch would be ready the following week. When I went back, I received my watch back with a plastic bag filled with the buckle and all it's pieces. Keep in mind that I brought the watch there in good condition but with a buckle that would just come apart some of the time. In the end, I received back a watch that is not usable, a month of wasted time, and a ruined day. I hate to say it but the guy (I'm assuming he is the owner) is a slime ball, poor business man, and would probably sell his mother a $10 watch for $200. He will try to make it sound like he is doing you a favor but he is just looking out for himself and waiting for the next chump to walk into the store and rob blind. Considering all the religious stuff he has hanging around the store, you might have thought he was a good person. Save yourself the time and go somewhere else. read more