Excellent find. A small space, but extremely well-organized. The owner is super friendly and…read morehelpful. Almost the whole shop is back-issue comics and magazines, mostly bronze and modern age, plus a decent selection of new graphic novels and trades, old sci-fi / fantasy paperbacks, and some other collectibles. I knocked more items off my want list here than anywhere around the country in recent memory. Prices IMHO range from low to a bit high, so more than fair in the aggregate. Easy to browse despite the small space. Prices clearly marked. Easy parking. For the type of shop this is (the type I like most!), legitimately great.

Awesome selection of books and comics. The name is accurate; it's exactly what you think of when…read moreyou think of the classic comic book store. Laid back, so you can browse without feeling like the staff is helicopter-ing you, but they're accessible enough to ask if you have a question. I saw some great--if not household name--scifi on the shelves, and as a Bond geek was happy to see Ian Fleming et al. get some space on the shelves. Everything was priced pretty fairly. I'll have to drop back in from time to time.

If you are looking for comic, collectibles and/or old toys, Collectors Asylum is the place to go…read more The staff is friendly and very knowledgable. Great location on Appleton Avenue, near downtown Menomonee Falls, it is easy to get to with plenty of parking. I highly recommend it if you are looking for comics and collectibles.

This place is a great place to find new and used comics. There are some great graded/ungraded major…read moreto minor keys that are by the cash register. Their back issue selection is really great. I've been to this place many times and depending on what you're looking for. It can really be picked through if it's a hot comic book at the time. However, they have a great selection of new books as well. The staff is very helpful and friendly. They also have some old action figures mostly out of box that are behind locked glass. There's something for everyone. Great place to take the kids to find something as well. The comic books are priced comparable to the comic market so depending on where that's at prices can vary.

It was my first time stopping inside yesterday. They have soo many comics and collectibles…read moreavailable for purchase. They have a huge selection of trading cards as well! The service was great, I honestly would've been in there longer if I had more time to look around. I will definitely be back!

Great selection of comics, magazines and statues. They also have a very helpful and friendly staff…read more Will be back.

They've done a great job cleaning up the place and improving the lighting. Fantastic for back…read moreissues. They also have an array of used DVD's and video games, plus a wall full of great action figures and collectibles. Also, they participate in Free Comic Book Day.

This store I have to say is my home away from home. After walking in 6 years ago just to look…read morearound I've made friends and have been able to play a lot of really cool games. I stop in every week to pick up my comic books and I'm always greeted with a smile and a hello from the owners. Together they have both created an atmosphere of awesome for anyone who wants to learn a new game, join and ongoing game league or just to buy a few comics. I've never found a better store to get my geek on.

I'm new and an outsider to the world of comics and gaming, but I'd never know it from the way Carla…read moreand Don treated me. My boyfriend has been a regular at the store for years, and I went with him to pick up his pull list this past weekend. There were people chatting at the counter when we came in, so Carla didn't see that I was with anyone when I entered the store. She was sure to ask me if I needed help with anything, which is a first in the slew of comic and game shops I've been to recently. The shop is set up with different rooms devoted to your interest, with comics in one wing and games in another, and more general books and collectibles merchandise in the main room where you enter. If you head to the back, you'll find space for game playing and where Don is organizing his back stock of comics. The shop on the whole is bright and colorful, and I felt totally welcome to browse. Don and Carla had a nice word for everyone who came in the store, and it was pretty clear that they have a small army of loyal customers. The outside of the store isn't much to look at - it's situated in an industrial-looking strip mall - but don't let that deter you from the checking out their cozy shop. Even if you're not a full-on geek, there are still things for you here - several of their games are great for a game night with friends.

Good little place. Owner knowledgeable and cool. Good collection of old and new stuff.read more

Best comic book store ever reasonable prices. I recommend to go there for heroclix, collectibles,…read moreand comics

Hidden gem of a bookstore! You never know what you will find here- from fiction to non-fiction this…read moreplace stocks a variety of new, old and classic books. Turn it into a whole morning out by doing a public library tour and topping it off with a browse at the Bookseller. Extra bonus that all proceeds benefit the library!

From the owner: The Bookseller operates inside of the Milwaukee Central Library. The stores sells gently used…read morelibrary books and community donations to benefit the public library system. Donations are appreciated! Children receive a free book each time they come into the store!

I found Lost Wonder of Worlds while searching for Pokémon cards for my cousin's birthday after…read morestriking out at a few other stores. Online showed they might have some in stock, so I called first. The gentlemen I spoke with on the phone was really nice and answered my questions, which made me feel confident enough to stop by in person. When I walked in, though, the in-store experience felt a bit different and on the emptier side. The two employees at the front didn't seem very welcoming and gave off a slightly annoyed vibe. When I asked about the Pokémon cards, they seemed confused about what I was referring to until I mentioned I had called earlier and spoken to someone. They checked with their coworker, who clarified which ones he had told me about. I asked to see the packs they had behind the counter, and the interaction still felt a little tense. That said, I was able to grab the two packs, which ended up being the perfect gift for my cousin, so mission accomplished. Overall, they had what I needed, and I appreciate that the phone service was helpful. I'd probably come back if I really needed something specific, and I'm curious to explore more of what they carry. Just hoping for a warmer in-store customer service experience next time.

As a somewhat new collector, this place is amazing! They truly do have almost everything (besides…read moreTransformers, go to Albella for that.) including a surplus of Gundam. They have shelves upon shelves of comics, model kits, etc--I greatly recommend spending some time looking here. The cashier was extremely helpful, showing me around after I asked for some help. Obviously, the main selling point for most people--the prices are great. A figure I would've spent $40+ on Amazon for cost a mere $27.99, as most of their products are retail OR slightly above, by a very slim margin. Additionally, for those who leave low-star reviews; just because your local comic store participates in a day to give FREE product doesn't mean every business has to. You are not entitled to anything of Free Comic Day, it's just that some people offer it. Also, the cat? Why would you pet a sleeping cat? That's pure, unfiltered ignorance--let the poor thing sleep. Also, who goes to a comic store for Anime paraphernalia? What I'm trying to say is, please, don't drop a trip over here because of strange opinions, as the place is definitely worth the trip.

Living nowhere near this place, I'll most likely not be back, but I had a very positive experience…read morehere. The owner was very nice, and the wide selection of old and new video games dating back to Atari 2600 could have kept me occupied for hours. I was able to find two games I had been looking for for a while, both at prices at or better than I had seen anywhere else.

Good selection of retro video games and very fair pricing. The owner was easy to negotiate with…read morewhen selling items to him too. Definitely a place to come back to.