We stayed at the Skaneateles Boutique hotel and had a great stay! Check in and check out was super…read moreeasy, the staff was very friendly, and the location was perfect. I would definitely stay there again!

Very nice boutique hotel - home like feeling. We knew we were in for something special when we…read morearrived late and found note in the mailbox as to how to "check-in" - just like a European bread and breakfast. Not many rooms so I got the room with the jacuzzi (but no champagne ?!). Nice room that was well taken care off. Also found a note encouraging us to indulge in all the goodies in the room (sorry only orange juice - no adult drinks but chips, nuts, and sorts). Free wifi and since we checked out early AM - once again, missed meeting any hotel staff. Nice, central location that is close to all the happening places.

Growing up in Upstate NY, I've always heard about Mirbeau as being a top option for a fancy spa…read moregetaway in the Finger Lakes, so I didn't bother to look at reviews first. Sadly our experience didn't live up to Mirbeau's supposed good reputation. The gap between the price and the value of service was the size of the Grand Canyon. Our room was about $450 a night, closer to $500 after taxes. The rooms are pretty, even in the winter the view of the garden was nice. The bathrooms in the cottage rooms are spacious. Things went downhill at dinner in the attached restaurant. We were one of about 4 tables so it was a slow night. Our server did an adequate job, but the food was extremely disappointing. My fiance reported that there were bits of shell in all of his oysters. The cheese board wasn't very inspiring, for $24 I could have made the same thing myself at home after a stop at Wegmans. My filet was cooked wrong twice, after the second time where it came out still slightly overcooked I had it taken off the bill. My fiance finished half of his wagyu as it also fell very flat for him. Mind you, this was a $140 dollar steak entree, and the chef didn't even bother to salt the meat. We ended up having about half our meal comped and it was still over $300 to eat one of the worst fine dining meals we've ever had. The spa itself, like the rooms, were also just okay. The locker rooms are spacious and well stocked, and kept clean. One place that's lacking is that there's not enough waiting space for everyone. The "tranquility" waiting room with the foot pool is not enough room for people who are trying to lounge/meditate AND for people to congregate waiting for their spa services. It was awkward not really having somewhere to sit. My massage was ok, it felt more like a Swedish massage than it did a deep tissue. There wasn't any opportunity to request more attention be paid to certain areas with more tension (I told her my right arm is usually more sore and she kind of just ignored me and didn't touch that area at all). My masseuse said I was breathing incorrectly so I was too distracted by my breathing to enjoy my massage. We ended up cancelling our second night. I will never recommend Mirbeau to anyone.

From start to finish the day was amazing. The amenities for the spa were clean and relaxing. We…read morespent the entire day there, eating lunch and dinner. Lunch was top, with the steak sandwich and truffle fries. The steak was cooked medium rare and the leek and herb chimichurri was delightful, frwsh, and delicious. Dinner was absolutely superb. The lamb tenderloin was one of the best appetizers I have had in the area. The pickled mushrooms and pea purée complimented the lamb, which was perfectly cooked. You don't often see lamb tenderloin on menus and this was a treat. My partner loved the tuna tartare special and the steak frites. We sat at the bar and had great conversations with the bartender, Ed, rounded off with great drinks and desserts. The food was memorable and we will be back.

Service was other worldly. I felt like a treasure by the way the staff coddled me. This place was…read moreso appropriate to the setting In Skaneateles.

Quaint Christmas town in upstate ny on the finger-lakes. Highly recommend. We had lunch in the…read moreHotel. I recommend the wedge salad. Rooms are cute. Very old school boutique. And I'm sorry, but the water has an aftertaste.

This place was like home away from home , we stayed in the lakeside suite 1 beautiful loft , fully…read morefurnished , AMAZING views of the Skaneateles Lake , very quiet, serene, relaxing ( home away from home ) right on the lake ! I HIGHLY recommend staying here if you want to enjoy your time in Skaneateles I would definitely stay there again . My husband and I enjoyed our time here , it's right in the middle of everything the beautiful town of Skaneateles has to offer , food , shopping , coffee houses , bakery's etc .... The shower in the bathroom is to die for and the loft had a full kitchen so if you don't feel like eating out you can stay in and cook and enjoy your meal at the table right by the doors looking out at the lake , can't wait to plan our vacation for the summer time and bring the kids with us this time , they would love it just as much as we did ! Definitely going back , prices are perfect for such a great location , staff are amazing and attentive if you need anything they are there for you ! WAY better than staying in a hotel if your in the area you should definitely book a room here ! Also I can't leave out how AMAZING The beds are with cozy sheets and comforters , bed is so nice makes you not want to get out of it ( no joke ) they even provide you with cozy robes for your stay !

Absolutely loved this loft! Posted a few pictures and had tonsss of people asking where I was! It…read morewas by far the cleanest and most serene stay I've had in the U.S. and I hope to be back soon!

I can't imagine a better place to stay in Skaneateles. We were absolutely thrilled with our…read moreexperience here. It was like being back in time with all of the current amenities. Our hostess left us a list of instructions and tips and was very quiet and respectful of our privacy. We could call her if anything went wrong, but otherwise, I didn't actually see her. I wouldn't have been opposed to this though because I wanted to thank her! Katie, our host, created an incredible breakfast bar. There was Oui yogurt, hard boiled eggs, fresh fruit, cheese, a variety of cereal, oatmeal, milk, orange juice, coffee, and tea. She had also generously stocked cookies from a bakery, granola bars, bags of nuts, biscotti, and other easy-to-grab snacks. Our suite was beautiful. My pictures don't really do it justice, but there were two chairs, a drawer, table, and a TV in one side, and everything we needed for a bedroom on the other. Katie also provided luxurious bathrobes and luxury shampoo and conditioner (TeaTree). We also had access to the dining room and living room, which made it feel like we had a home away from home. One of my favorite parts of the house though was the front porch, which contained two swings and two chairs. I loved starting my morning on the covered porch and will have a hard time leaving that behind. The location is incredible, allowing us to walk to the lake, restaurants, and any shops we wanted to visit. Katie was the perfect host. The decor was stunning and our experience couldn't have been better.

I wish our schedule would have allowed us to spend more time at this beautiful Historic Suite. I…read moredon't wish to call it a B&B, as it really feels, as if your stay was in a family members home without all the drama that brings, lol! We were on a fast trip for a wedding and allowed us only to spend two nights at 34 State. We so appreciated Katie & Jack's kindness, hospitality and helpfulness. Not to mention getting kisses from their beautiful lab, Oakley. We stayed in the elegant Barrow Suite. It's on the second floor as is their other suite, but they are working on a suite on the first floor for those with problems walking up stairs. Continental breakfast awaited us every morning as a fridge stocked with yogurt, fresh fruit, beer and many more items. I commented they were out of water and upon our return, not only was the fridge fully restocked, but a note with a special touch was provided. It is within walking distance to downtown Skaneateles without staying right in the middle of the main road. There is a big dinning room and living room, along with a beautiful porch with a swing to spend the afternoons drinking a cocktail. They attend to every need you may have i.e. reservations to restaurants and will follow up with restaurant to make sure you had a great experience and the best table. We look forward to our next trip and without a doubt where we will stay!

My husband and I appreciated Clark's wonderful hospitality, his beautiful Victorian home appointed…read morewith lovely furniture, art and accessories. Our pretty room had a good bed with high quality linens and had everything we needed. Clark is very knowledgeable and enthusiastic about the area and provides a great breakfast. We would not hesitate to return. Clark and Harvey are a good team.

This review is long over due. My husband and I stayed here for our Covid-moon. I'm sure for…read moreeveryone last year was a doozy but when our wedding couldn't happen as we had planned, we decided to at least get married at our town hall and head to Skaneateles. Clark was so warm, welcoming and accommodating. He really made it a special time in the midst of all the craziness. The breakfast every morning was delicious and so thoughtful since he went out of his way to make it vegetarian for us. I cannot say enough good things about our experience and this B&B. We cannot wait to visit again!!

We stayed here for a wedding and boy, were we disappointed. The packwood house is the rooms only…read moreaddition to the Sherwood inn but they are separated by two blocks on the same street. As indicated above, the packwood house is literally, a rooms only space. There is absolutely nothing on site. Guests who want coffee or to just check in/out must do so at the Sherwood inn up the road. This might be ok in most seasons, but in the middle of February when the city is having a polar vortex and the wind chills are -40, it's not ok at all. The rooms are old and not at all worth the per night price point (and there is a two night stay minimum). The bedding is not soft, towels are thin and scratchy. Toilet paper is single ply. You only get two coffee k cups even though they know you're staying a minimum of two night. No complimentary water bottles. The TV is as old as the furniture and no premium channels. It's a big ol NOPE for me. I'd recommend a cute Airbnb or even a holiday inn express room over this place. Save your money this is not the vibe.

Our favorite place to stay when in Skaneateles! The rooms are big, clean, and many enjoy a view of…read morethe Skaneateles Lake. It is the perfect location and walking distance to everything in the village. Check-in is at the Sherwood Inn and an incredible breakfast is included in the price on the front porch at the Sherwood Inn. My wife and I really love this place and it is our first choice to stay when in Skaneateles!

Newly renovated rooms with beautiful interior design. Large space with living room, kitchen and…read morefull sized refrigerator. Spacious bedrooms with extremely comfortable beds. Can't wait to come back, want to spend an extended stay here!

This newly renovated modern boutique hotel has charming and spacious living areas and rooms. Every…read moredesire of a guest is met with an array of artful and functional amenities. Its location is incredibly convenient for those wanting to explore the winsome village of Skaneateles. Hosts Seth and Lynn felt like long-time friends when arraigning our family' two night stay. They made sure everything was perfectly clean and organized before our arrival. They were extremely responsive to questions about the property or if we needed any recommendations. We also enjoyed the convenience of having food delivered by a nearby pizzeria. The Inn at the Gate truly is a gem. We can't wait to book another stay.

This Inn is a quaint little Inn with only 4 rooms and within walking distance of the heart of the…read moretown. Our room has a cozy fire place and jet tub for your relaxing bubble bath after a long day of shopping in town at all the boutiques and cute bakery delites. The lake is in walking distance also. Great little town to visit!

We loved it! We spent our vacation at the Village Inn and…read morestayed for 4 nights. Not only is it a great location, right in the center of town, but Skaneateles is a great home base for an upstate vacation. We stayed in the French Country room. It was large and clean. The windows were new, so the noise from the street below didn't bother us at all. I loved how secluded we felt in the 4 room Inn. Breakfast is served only a block away at the Sherwood Inn and it is amazing. Great breakfast every morning with a great view of the lake. I recommend this to everyone and we will be back.

Highest marks to this winsome inn, well-located to the "main drag" of Skaneateles. The warm &…read morefriendly proprietor provides a great low-key breakfast & a beautiful home filled to the brim with clever furnishings, wall hangings, kitsch & comfort. We spent a happy & indulgent couple of days here & would recommend it to anyone who enjoys old-world style & warmth with modern conveniences.

My husband and I have stayed at the Gray House four times now, and we just love it! Each time I…read morelook forward to going there, and coming back again the next time. It is a beautiful, comfortable-yet-elegant house, with a wonderful and thoughtful hostess. It is just a short walk to the center of the super-charming town of Skaneateles - yet, it is very peacefully quiet at the Gray House, at all times. I highly recommend this lovely, friendly place.