1 of the 2 reasons I even go to the beaver valley mall! its such a gem! I was raised on this pizza. Nice and thin with a light sauce! So Bomb read more

I'm sad to see the mall and Antony's couldn't negotiate on their space, effectively closing this establishment. Hopefully the owner can find a new space to get up and running again. read more

One of the most extravagant, godly, supranatural single slices of pizza in the entire cosmos was found, by me, in of all places, The Beaver Valley Mall's food court. Hidden in a land of suburban mediocrity is a taste of the New York street, and this pizza is so very STREET. It's so street, each slice struts and swaggers its way into the oven and onto your paper plate, pointing and nodding at a few people each way. It knows everybody. Even your cousin. This pizza has cred for weeks. Each slice is larger than life. I got a slice of the Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza which was dressed to the nines in bacon, ground chuck, cheddar cheese, and perhaps American cheese (?). The crust is like a soft, toasty cracker, the meat is tender, the cheese ooozing... I was almost depressed when I finished the gigacut. I was left wanting more, which is what a quality slice of pizza always does to you. And you'll get rolled if you look at it funny. But, if you're cool, it has your back. read more

I've been eating this pizza since the late-80s at BVM and it's just as good now as it was then. Some of the best pizza I've ever eaten, and trust me, I've eaten a lot. read more

I like pizza - all styles of pizza. New York, Chicago, New Haven, Greek, Sicilian, California Pizza Kitchen, and even Italian style (for those of you who have ordered a pizza in Italy or Sardinia you know what I am talking about). So I found my self in Monaca, PA to meetup with some friends. None of us are from Monaca but it was centrally located. Jonesing for some pizza I walked to the Beaver Valley Mall because the receptionist at the hotel I was staying at recommended Antony's Pizzeria in the mall. Ok mall pizza ... what comes to kind is Sbarro's. Let me tell you that the pizza at Antony's is superb and rivals the pizzeria that pioneered the New Haven-style. It has a nicely crispy and thin crust and the sauce is exceptional. Not to sweat and not to tangy. 2 New York size slices and a large drink came in at under $7! Quite the deal! If you find yourself in Monaca, PA and want to know what New Haven style pizza tastes like you can't beat Antony's Pizzeria! read more

See all

Longtime staple at the Beaver Valley Mall. They may outlast the Beaver Valley Mall. Real good pizza. Always do a decent business and is a big favorite around here. Nice treat when shopping to get a slice ( or two) and a drink. Sassy staff that makes ordering fun. Definitely worth a go. read more

Highly disappointed .. long time customer and always get pepperoni pizza .. tonight I ordered a large pepperoni for my mom and it was so greasy that the crust was soggy ... now I know it's pepperoni so it's going to be greasy but this was rediculous..when we called about it we was told there's nothing they can do about it.. not even bring it back we will make you a new one.. wasn't trying to get free stuff just wanted to eat actually edible food.. I won't be getting pizza from here for a long time.. I'm sorry but poor customer service skills.. if you want to be sick after eating a meal I recommend this place!!! read more

See all

There's really not a lot to say about this place. The pizza's heavenly. The end. You'll want to dim the lights, put on some music and touch yourself while eating this pizza. I could eat it every day. Try it. read more

Very quality pizza by the slice. Not easy to find such places in the area. Pizza is thin tasty and crisp on the bottom how it shoyld be. Definitely New York street style. Pepperoni rolls are my son in laws favorite of all time, and he buys one everytime he is near the mall! Friendly guys working as well, the lady, not so happy but professional enough... Also good to order ahead and takeout read more

Best Ny pizza . I've ate it many times. Very traditional Ny style pizza. The slices are great and the whole pizza is awesome. They hand toss it in front of you. The sauce is very tasty. I highly recommend this restaurant. Staff is friendly and restaurant is clean read more

Best pizza I've had in the Beaver Valley and I've had a lot - amazing Sicilian style as well. Having lived in NY I'm very picky about my pie and Antony's gets 5 stars from me. Very friendly ownership and staff as well. read more

Best pizza in Beaver County. Hands down. Always friendly. The sauce is the best I've had!

Really people.... who paid for these reviews? Less than mediocre pizza in a defunct mall food court. Drove 10 miles out of my way to try this "highly rated " pizza and was sooo disappointed- not to mention the grief I had to endure from the 4 people I had with me. YUCK!!!! read more

Love this place. For a quick and excellent tasting slice of pizza, this is my number one go to location.

Best street style pizza ever. Never gets old. Customer service 10/10. The gentleman that runs it remembers your face and your taste. I've been eating here for over 10 years and the price is more than fair. read more

I wanted to start off by saying I read the reviews and the few people who gave the one star review are clearly the idiot customers that local restaurants can't get ahead because of... literally the owner could be a saint who gives free food to homeless, donates money to 3rd world countries and offers a kidney to child in need and these people would still bitch about something...with that being said....I have had there pizza and it was delicious! Today I stopped in because I have been told there subs are amazing.... by god one of the best subs around!!! Huge portion, price is even better and the staff is very friendly... Highly recommend!!!!! read more

I have been eating pizza here for about 15 years, and it never disappoints. The menu has (thankfully) never changed, because their vegetarian pizza is one of the best slices I've ever eaten. The crust is chewy and the perfect amount of thickness, and the veggies are fresh and flavorful. One slice is sufficient for lunch, and for $3.50, it's quite the bargain! read more

I have come here for the past 20 years growing up in beaver county. Called to order slices when I was back in town recently. Prices have raised drastically while quality has declined. Also, there was a hair in one of my slices. I used to love Anthony's pizza, it is likely I will never come here again. read more

Always great pizza and subs. Went here weekly in college and the staff is always friendly.

There aren't many good pizza places around but I do enjoy Antony's. They guys who work there are nice and the food is delicious. My only complaint is that they are a little pricey. read more

Had pizza lunch for 30 construction hands and made the right choice. Service was 4star and pizza was great. Great crust and sauce wasn't over spiced I'll be back. Thx read more

Lived in that area for the first 20 years of my life and the pizza was awesome. Stopped back to Anthony's today because I was in the area for business and had two slices of the cheeseburger pie.. It is even better than I remembered. The guys that work there are the same people and are as awesome as they were decades ago. Will need to get back there more often. read more

My favorite pizza of all time, and I've eaten pizza everywhere. Turns out the best is located in the food court of a mall.