I would not come to this restaurant until they hire more wait staff. Our waiter was working his first night by himself!!! He came back to the table 3 times and never took our orders. He then came back to the table another 3 times and couldn't figure out why my father didn't have his wine. We have only seen 2 wait staff, the new guy and a woman, for about 20 tables. We've been here for almost an hour and haven't received our food. 3 of the people at our table received, and finished, their salads before the other two of us even received ours. This restaurant was recommended to us by the front desk clerk at our hotel. I will be suggesting that he not recommend it unless people are doing take out. I will update this review once we receive our food. read more

Plenty of food on each dish authentic Italian food marina was awesome. I had the seafood raviolis. Delicious. The place was busy but the service as excellent read more

This place is the real deal. Family run, and real Italian, (not Eye-talian like so many are). Like in the summer they put fresh herbs from their garden in the salads like they would in the old country. They are famous for their pizza, even competed in Italy! I like the simple stuff like chicken tortellini soup, or the house salad which has salami and good cheeses. Get there early, or call for a reservation. It gets really busy! read more

Been going to the family restaurant for over 20 years. They do get extremely busy on the weekends which can hinder the professional service they strive for. This is only during the rush. As everyone has mentioned earlier the Tony Russo is great for people who like that type of pizza, for traditionalist the thin is not soupy and you enjoy the toppings. The hand toss has crust on the ends and thin crust towards the middle. The thick....well I never had or wanted that type, but people who do, love it. Love the pizza so much, many times get half baked pizzas and take back to FL. PLUS, MOST IMPORTANTLY, any problems, they strive to make right! One of the few, original Elkhart Pizza places left! read more

The popes chicken was great! There were multiple Orin swift wines available to enjoy.

Was disappointed that DC's Pizza was closed, but glad that we got a chance to eat at this place, which is just down the street! Calamari is fantastic - Stromboli was the best I've had in years. The Arugula salad left something to be desired, but this is partially my fault as I'm used to 'baby Arugula' and the not big leaf stuff. My son had an excellent pasta dish, and I were a local, I'd definitely look forward to coming back. Not the best Italian I've had, but it was a great meal nonetheless. read more

This is one of the best Italian restaurants you will find in Michiana. Anything you order on the menue will be outstanding. I try to order something different every time and I have never been disappointed. You have to start with the tomato, fresh mozzarella salad and any entree or pizza will make your evening one to remember. Antonio's is a must to try. read more

Nice intimate affair. I didn't care for my entrée however, it was an experiment to see of I liked it. I didn't.. But, it's a taste thing read more

Antonios - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

Great food! Very delicious. Everytime I come, I am never disappointed. I would definitely recommend to anyone.

Best Italian restaurant in Elkhart. Friendly service and delicious food. Great date night.

This was our family's first visit. We ordered the stuffed pepperoni breadsticks and they were delicious! Very crispy. My father in law ordered the antipasto and what a generous portion! The meat was pretty spicy so make sure you're ok with that. My mother in law ordered the chicken tortellini soup. I'm pretty sure it was the biggest bowl of soup I've ever seen! I tried some and it was very tasty. The main course was a regular crust pepperoni and sausage pizza. If you like a thinner crust make sure to just order the thin because the regular is pretty thick. We didn't mind! The sauce isn't too sweet and the sausage has a little kick to it. As for service? We never ran out of drinks! We will definitely be back. Salute! read more

Antonios - Anthony, Mommy, and Frankie - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

See all

The food was great, the patio was great, the prices were reasonable, and the server was quite attentive....almost too much but he was new. However, as great as he was, the wait time to get our food was long. And they ran out of lasagne....how does an Italian restaurant run out of lasagne?? read more

One of our favorite restaurants in the area! They've never let us down and are reliable and consistent. Staff is always reliable and accommodating, whether it be sitting in or take out. Their Tony Russo pizza is one of our favorites, and the salad is great! read more

This is our go-to Italian restaurant. Been customers for over 30 years. We also have a home in Arizona and have never found a place that compares. I wish we could give it ten stars!! read more

This is an amazing place for authentic home made food. The salads use fresh, local produce...the pasta is truly amazing, the pizzas (especially deep dish) is some of the best in town, the entrees are one of a kind, and the wine list is very vast. A true gem for Elkhart and our region. read more

Absolutely amazing service and food. May take a minute to get your food only because it's being freshly prepared in the kitchen. Have an extra glass of wine and enjoy the scenery and company read more

Atmosphere is great but food is just okay. I would stick to the pizza. The pizza is really good but I wasn't impressed with the other menu items. I had the black and blue salad and the flavors were off. The steak didn't taste fresh at all and the caramelized walnuts had a spice on them that did not compliment the salad AT ALL. My husband had the lasagna and it was cold and a 6/10. The spinach artichoke appetizer and the pizza ordered at the table was all very good though. If we go back, I would stick to the pizza rather than the main menu items. read more

Great! Tony Russo Pizza is delicious - cooked perfectly and tastes nothing like a greasy Domino's pizza. It was light and very good. Complimentary Rosemary bread is fresh and really good. The Traditional Antipasto is also yummy and my kids gobbled it up. Our food came out quickly and everyone just seemed happy to be there. Staff was so friendly to our entire family. The ambiance is cute and the place is clean. Check this place out - it's another great local treasure. read more

Dinner was amazing and tasty Caitlin is definitely precise at what she does‍. My server Tyler was on point and made sure my dinning experience was a great one. I had the Tuscan Tuesday lobster risotto and pork ribeye both are definitely a new favorite. Of course, Monica will always make you a delicious drink. I added pictures of my dinner to Antonio's page on Yelp . Thank you! read more

Antonios - Caitlin is definitely precise at what she does‍ My server Tyler was on point for sure! I recommend the pork ribeye for Tuscan Tuesday - Pizza Near Me - Elkhart, Indiana

See all

My pizza tonight was the Italian Stallion. The bacon and 80 pcs of pepperoni were a bit much. You really couldn't really taste much else. It was over powering. They have a great deep dish crust but you can't taste it. They would have a lot more flavor by cutting half the pepperoni and deleting the bacon. You could add mushroom, green pepper and onion and have a much better flavor to compliment the crust. Disappointing. They don't allow substitutions on it either. The pizza was swimming in grease underneath too. No wonder they have a cardboard layer between the pizza and the pan. I just expected a lot more. read more

Place looks nice but the food was a major disappointment. The white wine pasta sauce didn't have any flavor at all, and penne pasta had been cooked way too long - nowhere near al dente. However, pizzas looked good and people in our party liked them. So maybe this is a good pizza joint but not as good for enjoying other Italian meals. read more

Wow has this place improved over the years! I will happily dine here for Italian any time. Food is good, service charming and I always leave content and full! read more

Ate here this past weekend. It was a beautiful restaurant! There was a lot of staff so I never sat without a refill! Definitely a plus. The odd part was I couldn't really tell what the ordering process was because we ordered our app but we couldn't figure out when they were going to take our order. We finally just told thm we were trying to order. But it would have been nice to order all at once because we ordered a pizza so it took a little bit. Pizza was great! read more

Great Italian spot! We started off with the stuffed mushrooms and they were tasty! My dad and brother split the pizza, I snagged a slice as well, it was very good. Super thin crust (the way to go) with plenty of toppings and cheese. I had the Chicken Scarpariello, and it was delicious. Although, adding more Ravioli would be nice ;) My mom had the sphaghetti and meatballs, and that was tasty as well. The only downfall was we received our meals before our salads. My mom just boxed hers to go and I had my alongside my meal, but it would have been nice to enjoy before the meal. Definitely check them out! read more

This is our favorite place in Elkhart. We have been going there for 15 years and never had a bad meal. Everything is so fresh, and you can't beat the prices! If you go, try the lobster bisque, it is the best you will get anywhere. read more

No longer serve any gluten-free options - pasta or pizza. The kitchen is not set up to do so. They did have a lovely local salad, the staff was very nice and the wine selections were excellent. read more

We had two salads; tomato and cucumber salad, and kale salad. Both were very fresh and delicious . Josie had Chicken Marsala and I had sausage ravioli with Bolognese sauce. So good!!! read more

Very good stuffed pizza...service could be better and wine selection is poor.

Good food. Great calamari! Quant but loud. Kid's menu a bit limited.

Pizza is some of the best in town. Rest of the menu has a lot of good things. Authentic Italian. Very good. Approachable wine list. Beer is cold. Bar can fill with regulars. Fun place. read more

My fave local Italian. My reliable order is lays gnocchi and a glass of wine. Also amazing pizza, dine in or carry out.

Pizza is amazing. Would love to see them tackle new Italian. The food is reliably delish. Good service.

The only thing you need to know about Antonio's is that they have the best Deep Dish Pizza on the planet. After 16 years of working in Chicago a couple times per week, I've enjoyed practically all of the deep dish in & around Chicago. Nothing compares to Antonio's. And, visitors to my shop *from* Chicago confirm this repeatedly, as many have been made believers & come back to Elkhart now requesting that we go to Antonio's for dinner. It's THAT good. read more

It was excellent! Had the Sausage Soccottini, great fresh dish and not too heavy. Everyone was very happy with their meals. Nice small family owned place. read more

Antonio's is my very favorite Italian restaurant in Elkhart! Friendly service and the food is 2nd to none! The stuffed pizza? yum! Nice atomophere too! Vicki read more

The best Italian restaurant in the area. We eat here often, at least once a week. The food is always excellent and the wine selection is outstanding. They offer gluten free pizza and pasta, which I order often. My favorite dishes include the Tuscan Tomato Pasta, Farfalle with Pine Nuts, and the Margarita pizza. Wines you should definitely try are the Super Tuscan, Toad Hollow Merlot, or the house Riesling. Service is outstanding! This is one restaurant that does everything right!! read more

Always enjoy our trips to Antonio's. The staff is great and the food is wonderful. We frequently get carryout as well. Great local place.

Pizza pizza pizza pizza!!! I can't legitimately review anything but the pizza because it's the only thing I've had. We visit Elkhart a few times a year and we always make it a point to get Antonio's Pizza. I have never found this style of Pizza outside of this area, and compared to davinci's, Bruno's, etc - Antonio's is by far the best. Amazing quality ingredients, perfect and consistent execution. read more

Authentic one of a kind restaurant. As Italian as it gets. If you are going through the area, make an effort to drive a little out of your way and experience the place. First class service & food. Full bar. read more

Another staple in town. Yes, when they are busy, you may have to be patient....just like every place. This place is classic and family owned. So support a family and eat at this great place! read more